What India needs is a Dictatorship?

Before speaking about democracy or dictatorship. I would like to highlight few hypocritical mentality of we indians.

1. Who does not give their tax on time?
2. Who abuses women?
3. Who is responsible for child marriages?
4. Who buys black sims and movie dvds etc. ?
5. Who over drinks alcohol and smokes and take drugs?
6. Who gives money under-table?
7. Who becomes district officers, police officers, and officers of various public service department?
8. Who employs children in hotel or at home as servant?

To all these questions the answer is the same "it is we common people are the one who do it" and not the "government".

From where does the MLA's and MP's come from ? of course they don't come from hell but once they use to be common people like us!

And in future we will be the one who will rule the government.

Blaming or changing the government may not be a solution to our problem but changing ourselves and by giving a bit extra time for our country can develop India within 5 years! yes !I m not kidding!

The only solution to our problem is 1. Change in mentality of our people, 2. And become a bit less selfish.

THAT'S ALL IS ENOUGH TO CHANGE OUR COUNTRY!(my speech was quite long. Sorry if you all got bored).

With the current situation of our politicians and nature of politics, It is notorious to have a Dictatorship. And for sure it will push the country into a civil war situation. When the people of the nation is not cooperating or, dealing with some rebel groups, dictation is required.

Here the real culprits are the upper crest society, corporates, diplomats, politicians, and mafias. Common people are always ready to comply and even ready to adapt to new changes based on the benefits.

So if you push dictation, the full force will not touch any of the real culprits. Due to their political influence and wealth, they will receive first class treatment even in a dictatorship. Only the middle class and common people will face the crushing effects of pure dictation. And ultimately they will get even frustrated and finally end up starting a revolt.

And also our politicians are extremely selfish and crooked. So giving full control in their hands is an absolute suicide.

Even now also is not the majority people expect a dictatorship, it's a small group of people with fanatical ideas demanding a dictation.

But whatever the case, dictation will wound the country so badly. And it would never be cured under any circumstances.

India need a mix of both democracy and dictatorship. India need an honest, patriot, responsible, educated, straight-forward and strict leader. The problem will not get solved with democracy or dictatorship, it will get solved by changing our mentality. We need to change our mindset. India boasts of highest population of youth in the world. Everyone dreams of becoming a doctor, engineer, accountant, managers, professors, teachers, lawyers. Does anyone want to become a politician? Why?

India have a lots of educational institutes for doctors and engineers. But do we have any single educational institute where the people who rule us are being taught? There is no qualification to be a politician. That is the reason why we are being ruled by foolish, uneducated people in the name of democracy. Problem is with common people, who first elect the foolish, uneducated people and criminals to rule our country, and then cry of corruption and scams.

The youth needs to come up and lead the country from the front. Its high time now, more honest people need to enter politics. We need to grow up from the petty politics in the name of caste, creed and religion. We should have a feeling "COUNTRY COMES FIRST".

Hello Everyone,

I strongly feel that India needs a patriotic dictatorship. As some of you are saying that there risk of the wrong person getting the power. My dear people, we are still taking that risk in democracy & we are getting failed every time.

I just want to ask "is this democracy doing any good to you?, can your children go out in the night? Etc. I have lots of questions regarding that but I don't want to take so much of time.

Actually, we are the hurdles in full development, because we take everything for granted, Just one example, Like breaking the traffic rules. We know that it can be very much damageable for us or anybody else but we just do it. We are becoming very stubborn in not following the law & we are not going to follow the law unless of until we are afraid for our own life. For that, I think we need a dictatorship.

There is the old saying "If You want something good, you will have to lose something" & I totally believe in this.

If we want a good future than we will have to take this risk. I know it will create lots of chaos, but it will surely change for good.

Hello Everybody,

It's very good to have this type of discussion. We common man are not getting proper platform to participate in such a important issue. In my point of view India being a Multi-religion, multilingual, Multi-caste, Multi-believe Nation. So keeping in mind this social factors I can strongly recommend Democracy in India. Of course One thing here I can pull out that India have lost its luster & shining due to some anti-national intruders. This intruder are nothing but the group of people who are trying to polarize the society in the name of religion and caste and some how successful to apprehend the society in the line of hate venom and try to dictate in Indian soil, probably have forgotten the Past History of bloodshed that has brought the nation into division. As we know we have very strong laws but we are not able to implement this in our society. Our youth has become the toys in the hands of So called Saviour of Country. We have to change the attitude and understand our capabilities and then only we will be able to be governed by a popular Democratic Government.

Hi Friends, I am Shashank. This topic sounds to be a very interesting one.

I personally feel that the giving the country, especially like India, which is diversified in its every aspect, to the hands of the dictator is like nothing but inviting the problems yourself. Some of my friends think that yes the dictatorship is good as the dictator is free to take the decisions firmly and will be able to eradicate the problems like corruption, terrorism but would happen if he himself terrified the country with his acts. One can't imagine what would be the pic of India then. I do agree but that he also may be best and can take the country to zenith heights of success but then to this point I would like to quote an English proverb.

"Two heads are better than one".

So instead of choosing the dictator we should try to be a responsible citizen first and then we should also try to to elect a best candidate possible, not from selected list, i.e from list available to you, but from the list we the people of India think should be.

Only after then we can think of a glorified India.

Thank you.

Hi,

In my opinion, India definitely needs a dictatorship if it wants to become a developed country and overtake China. Most of the people in India don't respect the laws of India and our laws and judicial system are outdated it is provided by Britishers with the intent to have control over India even after providing independence. Also, the executive sector is totally messed up where officers don't respect common citizens and they feel like they are not answerable to them. Sometimes it feels like our IAS/IPS have just replaced the white people and they consider themselves superior and are totally corrupt. There is a need for discipline only then our country can progress.

Corporations fear creating industries in India because of the lack of infrastructure and an outdated, corrupt, slow system where you have to provide bribes from top to bottom and even after that there is no guarantee that they will get full cooperation.

Most of the MNCs prefer to create industries in countries where democracy is not present because of the support they get from the government and stability.

Its Good to have such discussions. But friends do notice 1 point here. It is the same "we" going to elect the person for both the cases 1) Dictatorship 2) Democracy.

Dictatorship could be more efficient one but on the other hand democracy plays a key role.

Dictatorship will lead to "progress" of country but Democracy leads to "Better" country.

Progress and Better which mean the same again ! if actually concentrate. Becoming Puppets to the political leaders is in our hands. As it is "we" who are electing them. I think what India needs is not whether it is democratic\autocratic? Rather it could be better if there exits mutual understanding between each which is almost a difficult thing to implement. First change "U" then say "society" because ultimately "Society is again U"!we can see Better India or autocratic India only when 1) Every child to old is EDUCATED with EMPLOYMENT 2) Eliminating the POVERTY which we are studying from LKG to 10 in schools but yet no one analyse it!

3) Finally stop practicing VIOLENT METHODS. Not necessary to mention as every know what they do!

Even though we take a lot of pride in saying that " India is the world's largest democracy ", the outcome of this form of government has been far from satisfactory. Inflation, scams and scandals, lower gdp, rising level of crime, all these have torn apart the country and led to the lowering of morale of the citizens.

As is said " Too many cooks spoil the broth ", the mayhem in India is a classic example in support to this. Our so called worthy democrats, the people whom we pin our hopes upon, are often unable to reach to a satisfactory decision on topics of national interest and have a divided opinion. In case of a person having an autonomous authority at least we would be served with concrete decisions which we could chew upon and would yield results. At Least he would not sit mum while our territory is being seized by our " neighbors " but would take action.

The current form of government has not yielded any positive results and we still remain a third world country. Change is the only constant and we should be more receptive to autocratic form of government too.

To all those who feel that there should be dictatorship in INDIA, friends, if there would be dictatorship, you would not be even able to express this view of yours. We can debate here only because there is FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION.

And how can we forget the efforts of all the freedom fighters who fought for our freedom and not for the rule of one. If dictatorship would have been a better option, than there was no need of struggle for freedom because there was the dictatorship of the English people.

Another point is that everything takes its own time and charity begins at home. No development can take place until unless WE make collective efforts and don't just blame the government. There has been evident growth in India. So, in my opinion, we should be proud to be a citizen of the world's largest democracy.

Yet, there are some ill- effects of democracy as well and they can be removed by the laws and our own conscience. Spitting on roads can not be fined in this largely populated country. We have to think that it is our home and we only have to keep it clean.