The Way Forward for India is to Join Hands with Pakistan on Nuclear Matters

Group Discussion
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
  • Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
  • Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
  • Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
  • Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
44 comments Page 1 of 5.

Sagar Dwar said:   1 decade ago
"Trust" that's what is needed for building a relationship. India has taken a few steps towards better relationships with Pakistan, but, we know how far Pakistan has justified our trust. Joining hands with a country on Nuclear basis, that too a country which has been untrustworthy, may cost India a lot. Nuclear power is a boon to people, but Pakistan has many a times transformed, what's boon, to bane. I don't want a Hiroshima or Nagasaki kind of future for my children. We can't take risks. It would be better to put off the thought of nuclear relationships with pakistan.
(77)

Meera said:   9 years ago
For any kind of agreement a trust has to be there which is certainly lacking in Indo-Pakistan relations. Whole world knows about the attitude of Pakistan towards India and the role it plays to promote terrorism.

On one hand, they conduct peace talks and on the other hand, they break ceasefires, behead our soldiers and kick their heads like a football and deny to return it back to us. This kind of attitude has made Pakistan a non-trustworthy nation as well as a back-stabber.

There is no point on making any nuclear agreement with Pakistan as you never know when can they back stab and use that power against India. For productive works like powers, Infrastructure development etc too, I don't think India has to make any ties with Pakistan. India can very well develop without Pakistan's help and support. It is Pakistan which needs India for such tie-ups.

Actions speaks louder than words which is apt in case of Pakistan. So, India should not go for such ties until and unless there is a trust relationship between both nations which I think, is never going to be.
(59)

Zara Attar said:   1 decade ago
Intense matters like the joining hands with another country in order for nuclear growth depend on a number of factors.

In case of Pakistan, we should proceed only if we can trust the pakistani government. If we can't trust them and neither can they, then there is no point in taking this matter ahead.

Our past experiences with Pakistan have also not been good. In such a scenario, making such amends can either bring the indo-pak relationship to a positive side or this can also be used by the politicians and terrorists to create further havoc.

Trust is a very essential raw material to have growth as a by product. Hence, I would suggest we should not consider this this.
(46)

Nishant Kishlay said:   10 years ago
Hello friends, we are here to discuss on the topic "The Way Forward for India is to Join Hands with Pakistan on Nuclear Matters". And as I think we shouldn't put a step forward for this issue as we are not having a stable, trustworthy relation with Pakistan. Neither we have completely trust on Pakistan nor they are having on India. And joining hands with Pakistan on nuclear matter would really be a bad decision from our side.

If we proceed with sharing the nuclear details with Pakistan and working with them and if they misused all the nuclear information provided by us then it would be a dangerous sign for India.

TRUST is the most important thing which need to be present between two nations if they are joining hands for such a issue, which is lacking between India and Pakistan.

Hence concluding with my ideas n thoughts, I would say that India shouldn't join hands with Pakistan in nuclear matters, however joining hands for strengthening our relationship is quite good and we should join hands for making our relationship good but as far as nuclear matters which is a vast topic are concerned then we shouldn't join hands with Pakistan according to the present scenario.
(38)

Bhawani said:   10 years ago
Hello friends. Good morning.

Its Bhawani I am agree with your views but wanna add my views too.

As we all know that every coin have to different faces and these both use to have values. As soon as we heard the name of nucleare our mind reaches on explosives but nuclear have a another face too energy which gives us light for daily needs power for industrial use etc. If this field pak and India wanna go then they should go without any doubt on one another because this way of use nuclear can help both countries and bring them to develop countries from developing and poor countries and by passing time and positive result we should hope for improve the relation positively and they both go with on another good ways for their citizen who are now fed up with this contention.
(34)

Pradeep said:   1 decade ago
Dear amit i am not agree with you because collaboration is right with a country which know the meaning of cooperation but pakistan is not a country on which we can trust as per our historical experience & also we are suffering today from terriorism. join the hands mean we will transfer our technology or raw material of nuclear but we should understand that they can misuse this against us because we have been a long talks with them over terriorism in kashmir & other places but i think they are pretending to the world that they are in talks with india & try to take all grants & assistence across the glob.
(29)

Surya said:   1 decade ago
Nuclear relationship with a country which is not at all trustful is like giving money bag to a thief. So, in my point of view before joining the hands we should think about the terrorism which is spreading in our country like a poisonous gas. Nuclear collaboration is right with a country which will be helpful to generate energy in future but not with a country which is well known in the world for their profession in creating terrorism.
(28)

Zeeshan said:   10 years ago
In my point of view its better to stay freeze on this matter until the conditions in pakistan gets stable. Instead of sharing our nuclear aspects why don't we focus on the basic needs of our people, we can help pakistan in their infrastructure this will bring a stable government there and then we can think of sharing our nuclear aspects. Also if pakistan gets a stable condition this will reduce terrorism in India as well.
(25)

Arjun said:   8 years ago
Hello everyone!

This topics sounds like we merge ourself with Pakistan.

Why to do so? To shake our hands with them means Merge and Merge means sharing our capabilities with them and get benefit of their capabilities.

India has enough nuclear sources than Pakistan. So in My opinion don't do that have faith in our country's resources and capabilities.

Pakistan government do not have control over terrorism activities run in Pakistan. So what is the assurance that after getting our information on nuclear they will not missuses it?

Thank you.
(22)

Ketan said:   8 years ago
I think that we ignore shaking hands with Pakistan because of its cost us a lot. Pakistan is such a coward and liar country that can do anything.

They said that we don't know about terrorism but they attacked us in an indirect way. They are untreatable.
(21)


Post your thoughts here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.