The Way Forward for India is to Join Hands with Pakistan on Nuclear Matters

Group Discussion
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
  • Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
  • Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
  • Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
  • Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
44 comments Page 1 of 5.

Nishant Kishlay said:   9 years ago
Hello friends, we are here to discuss on the topic "The Way Forward for India is to Join Hands with Pakistan on Nuclear Matters". And as I think we shouldn't put a step forward for this issue as we are not having a stable, trustworthy relation with Pakistan. Neither we have completely trust on Pakistan nor they are having on India. And joining hands with Pakistan on nuclear matter would really be a bad decision from our side.

If we proceed with sharing the nuclear details with Pakistan and working with them and if they misused all the nuclear information provided by us then it would be a dangerous sign for India.

TRUST is the most important thing which need to be present between two nations if they are joining hands for such a issue, which is lacking between India and Pakistan.

Hence concluding with my ideas n thoughts, I would say that India shouldn't join hands with Pakistan in nuclear matters, however joining hands for strengthening our relationship is quite good and we should join hands for making our relationship good but as far as nuclear matters which is a vast topic are concerned then we shouldn't join hands with Pakistan according to the present scenario.
(38)

Meera said:   9 years ago
For any kind of agreement a trust has to be there which is certainly lacking in Indo-Pakistan relations. Whole world knows about the attitude of Pakistan towards India and the role it plays to promote terrorism.

On one hand, they conduct peace talks and on the other hand, they break ceasefires, behead our soldiers and kick their heads like a football and deny to return it back to us. This kind of attitude has made Pakistan a non-trustworthy nation as well as a back-stabber.

There is no point on making any nuclear agreement with Pakistan as you never know when can they back stab and use that power against India. For productive works like powers, Infrastructure development etc too, I don't think India has to make any ties with Pakistan. India can very well develop without Pakistan's help and support. It is Pakistan which needs India for such tie-ups.

Actions speaks louder than words which is apt in case of Pakistan. So, India should not go for such ties until and unless there is a trust relationship between both nations which I think, is never going to be.
(59)

Kunal C Rana said:   9 years ago
After the winning of war of 1971 Bangladesh still we have not get the good feed back from the Pakistan and still cross border terrorism and many illegal activities are done by Pakistan to destabilize the Indian economy, diplomacy, and political issue. On wars & borders we are winning but on diplomacy table we are defeated multiple times, by Pakistan as per the topic, my personal suggestion will be that to talk with any relation on any platform with Pakistan is breaking head on the stone.

Dear Mr. Amit Kumar Singh I would like to suggest to you is that Pakistan is betrayed brother & friend for India. Since 15th August 1947, so to get a ray of hope from the snake is not a good thing, its better to cut the snake head and finish the thing from the bottom of the route, and for that India must take major military action.

It is a worthless talk with Pakistan on peace, On my perspective to join hands with Pakistan on nuclear matters is not a good step for India as Pakistan is supplying the nuclear technology to North Korea & Iran.
(9)

Samyuktha said:   5 years ago
Hi this is samyuktha.
In my point of view that joining the hands with the pakistan having some advantages and disadvantages.
the advantages of joining the hands with the pakistan so that we can co-operate with each other .it can reduces the destruction of war,it inbits the peace between us.
By sharing the nuclear power matters between us we can develop our technology system .If any other country declare a war we use those weapons of highly secured.
The dis advantages of joining hands with the pakistan we make our selves as terrorist country with our hands.we should not blindly believe the terrorist country.it is not a trusting country.
There are so many terrorists are there in that country so we face so many problems by shaking hands with them.

So i conclude that we should not involve all the matters with the pakistan we should maintain a safe distance with them.
(15)

Surya said:   9 years ago
Nuclear policy is not a relation first this policy divides the world even one is who posses and does not possess through out the only five where against not non proliferation treaty south Korea India Pakistan and Israel at this position we also not supporting the treaty because our ground realities were different so we cannot do that so at this position we need a support because we have only 0.4 of uranium reserve for civil use to meet our abilities and in defense.

We have grown extraordinarily in making of nuclear we have the best Agni and Prithvi k missile family at this situation we need a support of other country to meet our needs but not Pakistan's support because every one knows about root and fertilizers of terrorist is Pakistan and there is no belief at all with them because it may go wrong hands so we should not support and we cannot support and it is not necessary for us.
(8)

Deepankan said:   8 years ago
Hello,

India should not share about nuclear power things with Pakistan because we all know the intentions of Pakistan whose main aim is destruction of India. Once India had already tried to share information about the nuclear power and all with Pakistan and to join hands together and work for the betterment of the both country but that time also Pakistan shared those information with North Korea and created a worst situation.

Because nuclear matters has all the information about the country's defence system and all the technologies which the country is implementing and Pakistan by knowing all these things will definitely try to create something big terror activities which India can't face.

So Pakistan should never be trusted over these nuclear matter issues as in such scenario our country will make a harm of themselves.

Thank you.
(14)

Bhawani said:   10 years ago
Hello friends. Good morning.

Its Bhawani I am agree with your views but wanna add my views too.

As we all know that every coin have to different faces and these both use to have values. As soon as we heard the name of nucleare our mind reaches on explosives but nuclear have a another face too energy which gives us light for daily needs power for industrial use etc. If this field pak and India wanna go then they should go without any doubt on one another because this way of use nuclear can help both countries and bring them to develop countries from developing and poor countries and by passing time and positive result we should hope for improve the relation positively and they both go with on another good ways for their citizen who are now fed up with this contention.
(34)

Tejkirat said:   8 years ago
We all are here to discuss on the topic "forwardness for India by dealing with Pakistan on nuclear matters".

According to my opinion, we should not do.

Deal with Pakistan on nuclear power because we all know that Pakistan is not a trustworthy country we have seen according to our past experience. If suppose India shake hands with Pakistan, then what is the proof that after sharing our nuclear power with Pakistan they will not misuse it. And one important thing I want to tell you is that Before joining hands with any country for any issue trust should be there. And according to the topic neither India has trust on Pakistan nor Pakistan have on India. At the end, I want to say we make deals with that country on which we have full trust.

Thank you.
(7)

Arjun said:   1 decade ago
Nuclear energy is not a matter on which the decision can be taken thinking twice or thrice, it has to be thought 1000 times. It is a sensitive matter. Pakistan is a country with which we had intense tussles, although when all this was to come at peace, Pakistan made 26/11 attacks which can't be forgotten of. Sharing nuclear power is not a right decision. Its just like cut that branch of the tree on which we're sitting. Until and unless Pakistan gains our trust, we can hand this dangerous weapon to the. As they would share our resources and weapon with us, but in near future if Pakistan shows us the thumb it would be our loss only. The possibility of something bad overrules the possibility of good.
(13)

Ronak thapliyal said:   9 years ago
"Pakistan" well we all know what kind of a nation it is. Pakistan is a country where people live with their lives on their hands every single day. The breeding ground of terrorists. Though Pakistan has never accepted their crimes. Also our relationship with Pakistan hasn't improved much since Kargil.

Though India has always tried to improve the relations. At this stage, we cannot think of discussing such issues with Pakistan. Let them first bring the culprits to us, they have to make us believe - yes they are against terrorism and not a single man who is guilty of any terrorist activity can escape. Then only we can think for joining hands with Pakistan on nuclear issue.
(7)


Post your thoughts here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.