What India needs is a Dictatorship?

Group Discussion
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
  • Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
  • Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
  • Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
  • Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
143 comments Page 7 of 15.

Bhanu said:   1 decade ago
In My opinion, India yes do require dictatorship in a some sense. In last few years we have seen that the gov. Has failed on my fronts either it be economic, health care or defense. We really need a strong leader at the centre who can take tough decisions on every front. Democracy with a strong and tough leader is far much better than pure dictatorship.
(23)

Gowtham said:   1 decade ago
India needs dictatorship because dictator is the only person to change the law and he will suitable judgement to rapists by sentencing them to death. As you know Rajiv gandhi was assassinated. The court is still thinking to sentence them to death. The court is not able to give proper judgement to a victims who killed the prime minister. Then how can believe the law helps a common man. I am ready to become dictator but I am waiting for opportunity.
(23)

Anik Siwach said:   1 decade ago
I think, everything that is wrong in India is due to the democracy. People have a say in everything, altering the right function of the country. Yes, I agree it is nice for the people to have the power of their own country but this means no strict law can be passed.

Essentially, if India wants to become a superpower, Indian needs to reduce the crime rate and make it known to the world. This can only be done by becoming a dictatorship. Dictatorship will definitely spark a fire among the people but in the long term; a criminal can be hanged, without any socialist people acting against the government.
(23)

Chaitu said:   1 decade ago
I strongly feel believe that India require a dictator like Adolf Hitler so that the life style of the people changes and we can be witnessing a completely developed India.
(23)

Partha Jois said:   9 years ago
This a subject way out of today's Agenda. That does not mean that it has lost its importance. YES, India needs dictatorship. Leaving democracy may appear a dangerous step towards the development, but hey we know what the speed of development of this nation is. We all know India is a spectacular place, but it could be even better, with all good people. For this we need a strong autocracy, this may appear menacing, this leads to people raging against the person who has the opinion of dictatorship, but if it is given a deep thought, it appears that dictating works in India far better than what democracy does.

Contestants in elections use money and liquor as a means to tempt people to vote for them. This happens where I live. And people are attracted to them, this is not right. This happens not in front of a responsible citizen's eye, but behind him. In order to remove this, we should teach lessons not only for those contestants but also those who accepted the money or anything it might be. Punishments do not work because people who reinforce those punishments are also indulging themselves in these nasty practices For this people must be empowered. These complicated things can never be ruled out until and unless the whole system is ruled out. And yes that is the only solution for this country.

Dictatorship also has some boundaries, what the country needs is not Hitler-Dictatorship but A good dictatorship. If this does not happen, this leads to the even bad government. But, we can conclude that a Dictatorship can be the best to India, but it can also be a danger.
(23)

RJ said:   1 decade ago
Dictatorship is what India needs right now.

The present form of Government has devastated the entire nation both socially and economically. After losing the majority of the resources, its pointless to believe that substantial amendments can be made to bring the nation back to track in possible time.

Dictatorship on the other hand, if laid down, has its own benefits and cons as well. No form of governance can be explained as to be the best for current India as challenges are getting piled up one upon another.

While democracy has been around the corner for a few decades now, laying down the foundation for a new form of governance should be approached rationally fulfilling the need of the hour.

People can derive many examples of nations under stable dictatorship and also believed to be as a significant factor in their development.

Remember guys.

"Too many cooks ruin the food" whereas "All it takes is only one man to bring the necessary change".
(22)

SHIVAM CHOUDHARY said:   1 decade ago
Dictatorship will make it worse. Dictatorship will only work if a dictator wants to do something for his country but unlimited power. I don't think so dictatorship is gonna work. Government need's to change its policies. We can solve our country's problem in two ways :-

1. Our parliament should amend the constitution and give power to supreme court so that every single bill or law which is passing in parliament must be approved by supreme court both are the different systems of democracy which will limit misuse of power by the members of parliament. If there a corruption case against a minister than it is must for investigation agencies to submit report to the supreme court within 1 year and supreme court must have to take its judgment under 1 month.

2. Second there should be a minimum qualification requirement for every member of a party to fight election or a competitive examination to be eligible for taking part in election. Illiterate or uneducated people can't rule a country or state.
(22)

Anshul Gupta said:   10 years ago
Dictatorship leads to create riots in a country as we go in a flashback we saw an example of Iraq under the dictatorship of Saddam Hussain, Egypt under Gaddaffi, Germany under Hitler currently Libiya wars, Syria Crisis all these situation created due to the impact of Dictatorship.
(22)

Vikranth_bharatham said:   7 years ago
With the current situation of our politicians and nature of politics, It is notorious to have a Dictatorship. And for sure it will push the country into a civil war situation. When the people of the nation is not cooperating or, dealing with some rebel groups, dictation is required.

Here the real culprits are the upper crest society, corporates, diplomats, politicians, and mafias. Common people are always ready to comply and even ready to adapt to new changes based on the benefits.

So if you push dictation, the full force will not touch any of the real culprits. Due to their political influence and wealth, they will receive first class treatment even in a dictatorship. Only the middle class and common people will face the crushing effects of pure dictation. And ultimately they will get even frustrated and finally end up starting a revolt.

And also our politicians are extremely selfish and crooked. So giving full control in their hands is an absolute suicide.

Even now also is not the majority people expect a dictatorship, it's a small group of people with fanatical ideas demanding a dictation.

But whatever the case, dictation will wound the country so badly. And it would never be cured under any circumstances.
(22)

Nipun Chadha said:   7 years ago
India needs DICTATOCRACY. There is a huge time of facing democracy but still India has poverty, corruption, illiteracy and what not. There are around more than 2 crore people in India joined with politics.

Suppose each one of them have 1 crore then total is 2 * 10' this much money can rebuilt India again. Let the golden bird fly again.
(22)


Post your thoughts here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.