What India needs is a Dictatorship?
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
- Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
- Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
- Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
- Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
145 comments Page 14 of 15.
Raj said:
1 decade ago
No, all that India needs to be a superpower is that the educated people like you and me should understand our responsibility well and contribute to its prosperity by our deeds. Had we been realising this since we got freedom the scenario would have been quite different. We call names to the politicians and say damn things about them and escape even the most important role to be played as a citizen of a democracy - VOTING - just on the pretext that all the politicians are the same and we will not vote to any.
While saying so we do not realise that this is our vote which could make the difference because we will always be choosing a lesser evil, even if the assumption of all the politicians being evil is correct.
If we would be choosing the least evil since our independence the best evil would have come out by now to rule the country. This is we who waste most of the precious resources of the country which are not in abundance and leave the weaker section deprived of, for instance, drinking water, electricity, cooking gas, fuel etc. Etc. The bold and clear question in front of we the intellect and educated people is WHO GETS DIRTY TO CLEAN THE HOUSE OF OUR OWN. In fact the weaker and uneducated section of our society is not even aware of the responsibilities of a responsible citizen.
So how can we expect him to have less children and not increase the already burgeoning population of the country. Again this is we who can educate them at least as much as it is necessary to read and write. Do we not encounter in our everyday life at least one such illiterate person who comes across our routine life and we can educate him/her?
While saying so we do not realise that this is our vote which could make the difference because we will always be choosing a lesser evil, even if the assumption of all the politicians being evil is correct.
If we would be choosing the least evil since our independence the best evil would have come out by now to rule the country. This is we who waste most of the precious resources of the country which are not in abundance and leave the weaker section deprived of, for instance, drinking water, electricity, cooking gas, fuel etc. Etc. The bold and clear question in front of we the intellect and educated people is WHO GETS DIRTY TO CLEAN THE HOUSE OF OUR OWN. In fact the weaker and uneducated section of our society is not even aware of the responsibilities of a responsible citizen.
So how can we expect him to have less children and not increase the already burgeoning population of the country. Again this is we who can educate them at least as much as it is necessary to read and write. Do we not encounter in our everyday life at least one such illiterate person who comes across our routine life and we can educate him/her?
(6)
DEVASHIS said:
1 decade ago
INDIA NEEDS A DICTATOR.
While we talk of dictatorship we always tend to think and give examples of nazis and fascists etc but think of this, if we talk about voting a right candidate to power why can't a honest person come to power by himself and lead by example now thats a possibility. Democracy is new to India and its just few decades old and look at its condition, people have lost faith on the government entirely. We are a deadly mix of people who were never meant to remain together But all we need is a cohesive force, a force so powerful that will not only bind us with fear but peace, stability and development. The dictatorship in India should be like as follows:
1. The revised constitution will be the only holy book of law.
2. A party with nationalistic programmes and no hidden agenda.
3. No reservations but instead robust facilities and talent development.
4. Governmental participation based on education, experience and likeness of public.
5. No appeasement politics but yes the hinduism should be taught to the world as this is the only land for hindus.
6. A uniform civil code and cooperative participation from grassroot levels.
7. Everything that is anti-national should be banned.
8. Sanskrit should be made compulsory at schools.
9. A single party in which anyone can participate.
10. 5 year elections will still be conducted but with revised and best election procedures.
11. Revision of authority and simpler governance mechanisms in place.
12. Growth, prosperity and city hygiene should be first on agenda.
13. Religious and cultural organisations should be monitored and any hate propaganda should be met with strict punishment.
14. The glory days of India should be brought back with efficient and honest governance and full public participation.
I can write many such points but at the end of the day its our necessity and our desperation and frustration with the current state of affairs that has led us to find the best way to drive our nation. And last but not the least isn't it that our so called 5 year governance is actually TEMPORARY DICTATORSHIP. THINK ABOUT THAT. AND YES IF YOU HAVEN'T FIGURED OUT YET AS TO WHO DICTATES YOU NOW FIND OUT WHO YOU ARE NOT ALLOWED TO CRITICIZE.
. .PEACE. .
While we talk of dictatorship we always tend to think and give examples of nazis and fascists etc but think of this, if we talk about voting a right candidate to power why can't a honest person come to power by himself and lead by example now thats a possibility. Democracy is new to India and its just few decades old and look at its condition, people have lost faith on the government entirely. We are a deadly mix of people who were never meant to remain together But all we need is a cohesive force, a force so powerful that will not only bind us with fear but peace, stability and development. The dictatorship in India should be like as follows:
1. The revised constitution will be the only holy book of law.
2. A party with nationalistic programmes and no hidden agenda.
3. No reservations but instead robust facilities and talent development.
4. Governmental participation based on education, experience and likeness of public.
5. No appeasement politics but yes the hinduism should be taught to the world as this is the only land for hindus.
6. A uniform civil code and cooperative participation from grassroot levels.
7. Everything that is anti-national should be banned.
8. Sanskrit should be made compulsory at schools.
9. A single party in which anyone can participate.
10. 5 year elections will still be conducted but with revised and best election procedures.
11. Revision of authority and simpler governance mechanisms in place.
12. Growth, prosperity and city hygiene should be first on agenda.
13. Religious and cultural organisations should be monitored and any hate propaganda should be met with strict punishment.
14. The glory days of India should be brought back with efficient and honest governance and full public participation.
I can write many such points but at the end of the day its our necessity and our desperation and frustration with the current state of affairs that has led us to find the best way to drive our nation. And last but not the least isn't it that our so called 5 year governance is actually TEMPORARY DICTATORSHIP. THINK ABOUT THAT. AND YES IF YOU HAVEN'T FIGURED OUT YET AS TO WHO DICTATES YOU NOW FIND OUT WHO YOU ARE NOT ALLOWED TO CRITICIZE.
. .PEACE. .
(44)
Ajai said:
1 decade ago
Dictatorship is not a correct solution of India.
You seen in world every country now want democratic so how we want autocracy.
Elimination or ban anything is not a solution while changing the condition and make a system good by doing any thing is a solution.
Just like some people talks if India have power in president hand and army hand then it is good. But you think that if they are doing same thing or even worst thing then what would happens instead of that whatever system is there make it transparent better.
You seen in world every country now want democratic so how we want autocracy.
Elimination or ban anything is not a solution while changing the condition and make a system good by doing any thing is a solution.
Just like some people talks if India have power in president hand and army hand then it is good. But you think that if they are doing same thing or even worst thing then what would happens instead of that whatever system is there make it transparent better.
(9)
Bhanu said:
1 decade ago
In My opinion, India yes do require dictatorship in a some sense. In last few years we have seen that the gov. Has failed on my fronts either it be economic, health care or defense. We really need a strong leader at the centre who can take tough decisions on every front. Democracy with a strong and tough leader is far much better than pure dictatorship.
(23)
Bala said:
1 decade ago
It is very nice to read all your ideas on whether India needs a Dictator or Democracy.
First thing we should understand that Dictator can not be elected or installed. He emerges from the situation/problem and take control of the country. If he is good the country will definitely benefit from it. Otherwise like many African countries which are under different types of Dictators suffer.
One thing I failed to understand why all these posts failed to mention the current situation of Dictatorship in Africa which will provide us with many cues.
First thing we should understand that Dictator can not be elected or installed. He emerges from the situation/problem and take control of the country. If he is good the country will definitely benefit from it. Otherwise like many African countries which are under different types of Dictators suffer.
One thing I failed to understand why all these posts failed to mention the current situation of Dictatorship in Africa which will provide us with many cues.
(3)
ANIL GARG said:
1 decade ago
Hi friends, I am anil. This topic of whether India needs dictatorship is a serious one. So, we must take adequate steps regarding this matter.
In my point of view there is no use of dictatorship in India. India is a vast country and different people have different needs. So it is difficult for one person to understand the needs of all the people.
It is not right to imply dictatorship by looking at the other countries. America is developed because they are used to dictatorship and there problems are different and there population is also very less as compare to India.
Democratic government is the best for the countries like India. Only thing that is required is that the leaders which are selected should work properly and faithfully.
THANKS.
In my point of view there is no use of dictatorship in India. India is a vast country and different people have different needs. So it is difficult for one person to understand the needs of all the people.
It is not right to imply dictatorship by looking at the other countries. America is developed because they are used to dictatorship and there problems are different and there population is also very less as compare to India.
Democratic government is the best for the countries like India. Only thing that is required is that the leaders which are selected should work properly and faithfully.
THANKS.
(56)
Kshitij kumar said:
1 decade ago
Well, I see that democracy is the better alternative against dictatorship, as because.
1. A dictator, will have his own view of country's overall development, which might not suit everyone's need. Worst case scenario would be that he shall plan only for his benefits, or to implement his agenda. Beside, we shall never know whether the dictator thus installed in his/her post would actually work for the development of this great country?and he will not be accountable to anyone.
2. Even if democracy gets corrupted, it needs the support of the people in order to survive. So, even if one makes false promises in order to woo voters, he/she still must have to do something in order to get re-elected. In other way, democracy ensures the development, in spite of how fast or slow it is.
So if you any problem, choose a right representative who is honest, empathetic and can make and implement strategies to improve our lives.
If you don't find anyone, BECOME ONE.
1. A dictator, will have his own view of country's overall development, which might not suit everyone's need. Worst case scenario would be that he shall plan only for his benefits, or to implement his agenda. Beside, we shall never know whether the dictator thus installed in his/her post would actually work for the development of this great country?and he will not be accountable to anyone.
2. Even if democracy gets corrupted, it needs the support of the people in order to survive. So, even if one makes false promises in order to woo voters, he/she still must have to do something in order to get re-elected. In other way, democracy ensures the development, in spite of how fast or slow it is.
So if you any problem, choose a right representative who is honest, empathetic and can make and implement strategies to improve our lives.
If you don't find anyone, BECOME ONE.
(11)
Sudhanshu said:
1 decade ago
It is no matter that whether it is democracy and autocracy it is good government which makes the difference but if we talk about India then I must favour autocracy because I feel it can do such thing which are not done by our democracy even in 60 year I want to named then corruption, reservations, communal riot. If power goes in one hand he is allow to do one hand and for that no one claim for that, take the example of china when he see that overpopulation he implemented the one child policy at the same time India also want to implement two child policy but he could not do because of democracy but china implement because of semi autocracy, that type things I want to express, thank you.
(11)
Kushnabh said:
1 decade ago
Hello everyone.
In my opinion, the way politics is done in our country is nothing less than a dictatorship. It is like dictatorship for fixed 5 years.
In democracy, people have a say, representatives have to implement the desires and needs of people. But in the political scenario of our country that is not the case. Representatives act like anything without caring for the needs of common man.
Hence what I want to say is that dictatorship-like rule is already there which is incapable of governing our country. What we need is democracy in its true sense.
In my opinion, the way politics is done in our country is nothing less than a dictatorship. It is like dictatorship for fixed 5 years.
In democracy, people have a say, representatives have to implement the desires and needs of people. But in the political scenario of our country that is not the case. Representatives act like anything without caring for the needs of common man.
Hence what I want to say is that dictatorship-like rule is already there which is incapable of governing our country. What we need is democracy in its true sense.
(9)
Aditi Khare said:
1 decade ago
According to my views I don't see any benefits in switching from democracy to dictatorship because its not the government which is responsible for the downfall of humanity, it is we the citizens.
So in order to make our country good enough all we need is our increased responsibility and proper understanding.
So in order to make our country good enough all we need is our increased responsibility and proper understanding.
(6)
Post your thoughts here:
Quick links
Quantitative Aptitude
Verbal (English)
Reasoning
Programming
Interview
Placement Papers