Reservations in the Private Sector

How long we want to continue this reservation? And how are we measuring if it's solving purpose or not? People will keep asking reservation irrespective of their need. It's been 70 years and if it's still not working let's abolish it and find the root cause.

How a mere job add a value or improve condition of reserved category instead let's give them facilities and chance to grow by themselves, give them extra classes, training to improve their knowledge/skills. Freebees is not going to help who gets it nor who provides it.

Yes I support Reservation,

Even today Jain, Gujju's Marwadi, Punjabi are top industrialist people from SC/ST are from Labour or worker category reservation will help them to uplift their economy. Because of caste system in India human were not treated like human their condition were worst than animal.

So I think first we should abolish caste system from our society, till the caste system and we people say I am Brahmin, I am shatriya, we are Mishra, we are Pandit, we are Iyer, till the time we won't say we are Indian reservation should remain and it constitutional right of Backward class people.

Every revolution is born out of foolish implementation of policies and suppressing people. At this rate, we are not far from seeing the jobless poor people of forward castes start a revolution and end this pseudo democracy. God bless our country filled with caste politicians who only know divide and rule policy!

Caste based reservations should go, instead reservation should be based on financial status of a person/family. This will deferentially take our country to new level.

I do not support reservation. They make genuine candidates deprived of opportunity. You will not find a skilled worker roaming free. But if reservation in private is done, then skilled people will roam free and all the idiots and stupid reserved candidates will have jobs who will go to office and sleep.

Reservation is the process/system by which the government promotes the inclusive growth. But now, it has became a family reservation rather than caste reservation. A man who became IFOS or ACP or other administrative and executive jobs in public sector, become financially rich in the society.

According to me, he should be removed from the Quota once he used the opportunity. In India its not happen. His son became educated and he also get good job using Quota, even though he is rich. Already people are agitated against this in many parts as we know.

Completely eliminating the Quota will affect the deserved. Abraham Lincoln said " Government is for the people, by the people, to the people". So It's necessary for inclusive growth. It should be there in Government Sector.

But extending it to the private sector will lead to chaos. Once the reserved people get the Quota education, government's duty is over (According to me) , because they are already empowered. Apart from that, they also have the reservation in the public sector.

Private companies nurture competitiveness, growth. Forcing them to recruit people based on reservation will collapse the system. I am not saying, reserved people are not talented. I am saying if they are talented, let them compete with others. Let them prove themselves to the society and the recruiter.

In the private enterprises point of view, their main aim is profit maximization. Everyone runs company for profit not for charity. For their part, they are doing CSR activities. They are providing employment opportunities to the society.

They are contributing to the growth of GDP. Forcing them and involving in their decision making process will make them frustrated with the system. Then they have other nations, which are ready to welcome them with the red Carpet. Our aim of 7.6% GDP growth and Make in India will vanish in the near future, if it is allowed.

I want my country to grow in a proper way which includes inclusive as well as talent oriented growth. Dear bureaucrats, please think and decide. No reservation in Public sector needed.

It's representation not reservation. I want everyone to ask themselves since how many generations general merit peoples are getting education in India. Its irrelevant to answer because since Vedic age only upper caste men were getting education. Not only sc st obc even upper caste women were not getting education in this society. Because of constitution everyone are getting education. Sc st obc are now opening their account in education field. They are may be in 2nd or 3rd generation.

Compare to you people who had 100% reservation in Vedic age. Present reservation system is null. And you people think sc st obc means only 3 castes but inside them there are 1000 of community who claim for that minimum reservation. Remaining are claimed by 25% of gm people. These 25% people claim more than they deserve in population.

And coming to private sectors. The present percentage government jobs are reduced to avoid the growth of backward communities by allowing private sectors. Almost all private sectors are owned by upper caste peoples who are giving opportunities to their communities. If reservation is not allowed here one fine day these private sectors will replace whole government sector and they'll eradicate constitutional rights.

Due to unemployment backward communities will stop their children to schools. The whole India will be in the hands of 25% people (private sectors) and rest of them will work as slaves in their hands. If opportunities are not given to backward communities its impossible to develop India.

Hi friends I think there is no need for reservation system in private sector. Because we all know that there is very much rare change for general caste person for an job in public sector due to reservation system.

So if in private sector is also reserve then there is nothing is to mean as equality for India. One side say all persons are equal in the eye of law and one side this reservation system going on.

So long I have been through this discussion.

1. Reservation system is good but depends on how it is implemented.

2. Every time whenever I take part in such discussions I always see people yelling about the 1000 years old India and system and all that, please take deep breath and ask yourself is that really good to yell about the past about which you don't even know completely.

3. We always have heard in the stories, once upon a time there was a poor brahmin, then according to that brahmins should be the poorest and lowest one but I hate to throw casteism in the reservation criteria.

4. I have been with a lot people who say all the time, why do I need to work hard when I have reserved seats and yeah that's fairly right. When non reserved candidate gain 500+ marks then still he is not able to get the admission while reserved one can even take admission below 125.

5. Private sectors demand work they take high talents. Do you know what will happen after private sectors allowing reservation in their system. The lack of job. They would pick very less number of the employees from India affecting the the non reserved ones too.

6. I am a non reserved candidate I have suffered a lot. I was alloted with below poverty level facilities like tuition fee waiver in college but then I found that the number of such candidates were higher whose family income was pretty high even greater then the upper middle class.

7. That's the spoilage of reservation system. Those who have the resources are taking advantage of the system while those who don't are getting down and down.

8. Let's put reservation at high pace for next 500 years and what will happen then. Looking in the future of India I clearly see reverse of the 70 year old situation.

9. And yeah the reservation system is the reason today that India is unable to produce even 100 of good engineers every year they just produce mass garbage of engineers.

10. India is youngest country and have almost nothing for the youth.

People who are advocating reservation in private sector. Guys first of all guys if anyone sets his own firm he pays tax in various forms. And he invest his hard earned in turn to get more profit. He is competing with global firms from Europe and USA. So why will he check on castes?

Instead of fighting for job why don't you guys ask and appeal the government fr schools with all facilities get proper education and grow. Why running behind money when base is not strong nothing can stand long. Same follow life.

Students who are in iim and IIT they get placed well if they work hard. Irrespective of caste. So if understand corporate world wants best and not caste community.