Necessity of Women Quota Bill for Women Empowerment

Group Discussion
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
  • Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
  • Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
  • Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
  • Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
116 comments Page 5 of 12.

Richa Bqajpai said:   9 years ago
Hi this is Richa here.

Well I reckoned that no reservation should be given to Women as they are totally equal to Men in each and every field. By giving reservation it shows that women are not up to the level of Men and reservation is helping them to make them up to that level. In today's era Women proved themselves in every field and there are many legendary examples of that such as Kalpana Chawla, Indira Noory, Neerja Bhanot etc.

Now a days what women require is safety from the society. This is how the constitution can help the women.
(11)

Sayooj said:   9 years ago
Hi, friends. Myself Sayooj. The given topic of discussion is very much relevant in this period of time. I would like to take an example of our religious belief of Ardhanareeswara. It shows the universe is formed from women and men. Men always try to dominate women. Is it a good practice? In my opinion, no women have equal right as men. But our mentality has changed and in most of the field, women are not coming forward thinking they can't dominate men. This bill will give women an opportunity to come forward and take the challenge. There are many exemplary women who broke this barrier and came forward like Sunita Williams.
(3)

Arushi said:   9 years ago
No reservation can ever help any section of the society to gain empowerment. Status of backward classes still is the example of this policy. Even after 67 years of adopting the Constitution, they are still backward classes in fact now more politics is played on their account. If you actually want to empower any section, basic ground work os required. The inclusion of and improvement in the mindset of men (particularly) is also needed. Intellectually and emotionally both genders are very similar. Care, love, empathy, nourishing nature, sensitivity, patience, resilience is there in men as well. They are just never required to explore this side of themselves as many women are asked and made to feel obligated to possess such qualities. At the time of birth, boys and girls are completely similar. Giving them similar values is necessary to develop a society where security and equality prevails.
(12)

Ritu said:   9 years ago
In my opinion women reservation should be there as in every field stress work is there so people think that the female candidates will not do these work. So they will try to first select male candidates as they will be having fear of maternity leave some physical matter related leave then how would our work will go smoothly. So if reservation will be their then compulsory they have to select male and female candidates. Though female candidates are now better in every field, reservation should be their.
(5)

Abhay Chhatrodiya said:   9 years ago
Preamble Of Indian Constitution.

"We The People OF INDIA, having solemnly resolved to constitute INDIA into a SOVEREIGN SOCIALIST SECULAR DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC and to secure to all its citizen;

JUSTICE, LIBERTY, EQUALITY, FRATERNITY"

What is my point is on the day of independence we accept the equality status for all Indian citizens and other fundamental rights for everyone without barriers of race, sex, age, etc.

So there is no sense making someone empower. But if these Bill provides security, employment and education in backward areas then it should be passed with the kind support and regards of every Indian citizen.
(29)

Navodit said:   9 years ago
What I think is that yes, we should treat both the gender equality, there shouldn't any quota for girls and even for boys. We all have the same capability to achieve what we want in our life if we are having good education for that.

But we have to take it under consideration that in our country, many poor people are there who are having daughter and they are not capable to educate them, but it might be same for a boy whose parents are not financially strong to make him educated.

Poverty doesn't look at gender.

For the welfare of our society, if our government is capable to provide some kind of reservation, then this reservation should be given to the poor families of our country.

And reservation is also not given according to the religion, if such a citizen is capable to earn his bread and butter, then there is no need to give him reservation. Same as for women.

And also I want to add one point that a girl must be educated because when she is going to have a baby, she is only the person in the world who he's responsible for his/her thinking, and it is needed for our society to have well educated mind for your future.

GOD bless.
(41)

Suraj anand said:   9 years ago
Hello everyone,

In our society, women empowerment is very necessary, but it cannot be completed by women's quota bill only. Today men and women are equal in every field either in the corporate world or defense or any other. But these girls are courage and educated by their family and society by which they can stand herself. But another hand, In our society, there are many girls, who have not seen even the book are college.

Everyone should treat girls equally, then girls will be educated and empowerment.
(5)

Mayuri Dhurjad said:   9 years ago
Hi this is Mayuri.

According to my opinion considering present situation all are say that Mens & womens are equal. But its a thing only for telling when considering whole India & situation of villages and middle class families gives the importance to boys education not girls and lot of things in which people differ girls and boys so for changing that situation reservation is the right step.
(18)

Ayush said:   9 years ago
I feel reservation in colleges is different and in elected offices is different. In elective offices I feel reservation is needed to ensure representation of women. But in colleges, I don't think there should be reserved based on gender or even caste. There reservation should be on the basis of facilities available to people to create a level playing field.
(3)

Neda Khan said:   9 years ago
Hmmmmm. So what I think is. Ya many of you people said that we have been equal. And all. I do agree.

We women can compete with you. We are growing everywhere. We dot need reservation. Our parents are sensible. They can satisfy us with our basic needs including education. We thought at this point how we live.

Everyone knows that's not the case with below the poverty line or poor people. So they may take initiative to make their male child educated. But they don't to their daughters.

Though those girl dreams to be something. To stand somewhere. She has the power to compete. But not resources.

So RESERVATION SHOULD BE GIVEN WHERE IT IS NEEDED.

SAME APPLIES TO MINORITY THING IF THEY ARE POOR. GIVE THEM SEATS. IF THEY ARE NOT DONT SPOIL SOMEONES LIFE. DREAMS.
(13)


Post your thoughts here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.