Necessity of Women Quota Bill for Women Empowerment

Group Discussion
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
  • Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
  • Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
  • Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
  • Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
116 comments Page 1 of 12.

Abhishek kumar said:   1 decade ago
Hi friends.

According to me no need of women reservation. It is wastage of government rule and regulation. Their are two types of women live in India:

1. Rural women who need only education and well respect in society.

2. Urban women who need well education system and safety.

We always say that there is an equality between men and women but today society has changed a lot of things, first thing is that people have to change their mindset so that women can feel safe in this society either in rural area or urban. Then a women can be stabilized their own identity.

There should not be any reservation to solve these kind of problem but the mindset of narrow mind people should have to be changed. There should be a respect of women then women can also prove herself that she has also potential.

But I think women reservation is not useful for urban and rural women I see in many rural area if wife is sarpanch in paper but main work is done through the mood of their husband. She is only for signature. So you give reservation for rural women then it is waste of power through its relative.
(145)

Gopikrishna said:   10 years ago
According to me, reservation for women is unnecessary. Because reservation meant for weak people like discriminated people and physically challenged (handicapped, blind). Many people who are talented &skilled will work hard to achieve their goals& aspirations. But because of this reservations they will be frustrated, disseminated of their unsatisfied goals.

In the present world, girls are giving good compact to men in every aspect of the life. They are capable of taking their decisions that they know what is good/bad for them. If govt wants do something for women provide them safety& security that we need to respect them.

Parents worried about their daughter to send out of city for job or education due to lack of security so we need to provide safe environment. They are able to do anything & have strong determination toward their goals.
(104)

Nikhila said:   10 years ago
In my opinion reservation for women would only prove that they are weak.

We observe that in every educational institution girls equally compete with the boys and many a time they are better.

Moreover, the reservation some times might do injustice to those men who would actually work better for that position.

What we must concentrate doing is proving education to those in rural areas. If the education to both the genders is equally given, I am sure that there would be equal number of men and women working in the society.
(95)

Sumit said:   10 years ago
Hi,

I'm totally against of reservation. Because the world "reservation" itself define weakness. Gov should provide reservation only for those people who really deserve it like physically challenge (handicap, blind) etc.

Not for those who are physically as well as mentally strong. Women are capable to take their decision they know what is good /bad for them because now days women's are giving good compact to men in every aspect of life. If govt want to do something really for women provide them security, feeling of safety we need to respect them.

Because most of the parents doesn't allow them to go out of city for higher education because they feel it's not safe there for her. So firstly, we need to change this mentality & this would be possible only when we provide safe environment for them, so that women can get a good platform to prove themselves. Women has great ability to do anything they have strong determination toward their goal.

Conclusion - No need f reservation, don't underestimate the capability of women, if you want to see nation develop by 2020 then empowerment of women is must.
(90)

Kritika said:   10 years ago
Hello everyone,

Most of the people here have presented the argument that reservations are for weak people and women, today, are capable enough to get a job based on their skills and talents, and hence no reservation is required.

I respect this opinion but I would like to highlight some major loopholes in this assumption. Firstly, RESERVATIONS ARE NOT FOR WEAK PEOPLE. Reservations are for the groups or communities in our system who have faced discrimination and have been a victim of unfair treatment, and hence a special platform is given to them so that they can merge in the mainstream society.

Secondly, the assumption that situation has changed and women are given equal opportunities. The real scenario is not as beautiful as being painted by most of us. In rural areas, as well as high profile urban areas, women suffer from domestic violence, rapes, partiality, typical patriarchal mentality, honour killings, dowry deaths, female foeticides and what not?

They face discrimination and lack of security at workplace in a lot of ways. Why are male actors paid 5 to 8 times the actresses even for the same role? Therefore reservations should be given to women if their status in society is to be changed.
(73)

Sahasra said:   10 years ago
Hi myself Sahasra.

Reservation for women is not mean that they are week in all aspects, it will give the support and encouragement for the women who wants to do the best. It is very helpful for rural people.
(66)

Sooraj Singh said:   9 years ago
Hi, my dear friends.

Myself Sooraj Singh.

All my friends gave their view on the necessity of women quota bill.

I like their view on this topic but I have different Point of view about it.

First of all, we need to know about reservation it means giving authorities those people who are not capable reaching at a higher level without by means.

If we give reservation to women it means they are not capable of doing this but we can see women in every field what they are doing. We need to think why women are not reaching there because.

1 - Security problem for women.

2 - Some people think women can not do this.

3 - Women have lower literacy rate than men (67% for women and 87% for men).

So these problems cause not participating women in parliament.

We can understand what is the need. Providing reservation is not the solution for women empowerment. We need to women aware through giving for free education especially backward. Then we can see women as the national leader.

But we are to give reservation give such fields like which indicate less capacity like air jet flying, combat jet flying as well as etc.

Thanks to all my unknown friends.
(61)

Alok said:   1 decade ago
According to my point of view women reservation bill is not necessary because they are no more lag behind their male counter part in terms of job quality. In all sphere of life they are doing job side by side.

But what they need this time is a safe and secure environment and respect. In recent year growing crime against women creating sense of apprehension in parents mind too and do not all their daughter to go in other cities for job or education purpose.

As per as reservation is concerned then I think, it is bad concept to give reservation on the basis of cast or gender. This creates sense of frustration, dissatisfaction, dissemination among those candidate who are better but deprived of the award for their hard work what they deserved to. There should be given only financial support to all who are poor irrespective of their cast and gender.
(52)

Ritika said:   10 years ago
Hi friends, I am Ritika.

According to me the women quota is not necessary for girls as well as women because in this era women have capability to prove herself with their skill and knowledge. If government wants to do something for women then work on women security, safety. Now women and men are in same position in everywhere. So need for women reservation.
(50)

Anji said:   1 decade ago
Hi friends.

Actually don't give reservations based on the caste and gender only reservation is required for need people become they don't have food every day. In present situation women's also working in all fields equal to gents so they don't need reservation.
(49)


Post your thoughts here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.