Is Reservation in Higher Education Only Alternative for Social Equality?
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
- Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
- Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
- Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
- Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
168 comments Page 9 of 17.
Himani said:
1 decade ago
I am not supporting the reservation in education system. I increase the inequality between the cast. And I think it just increase the Caste-ism in India. I think Reservation based on intelligence not on Cast. It based on Financial condition of the student. Just because of this reservation system many of the student of upper class can not get a admission in good college while getting good marks and not able to get a good job in Government sector. It is only a agenda for increasing a vote bank of these politicians nothing except it.
(12)
Vishal gulia said:
6 years ago
Reservation is a hot topic today. From teacher to politicians, from students to employees, Every profession is affected by the reservation system. Now India is developing that's why it has to face many challenges. The reservation system is one of them. It is a pol necessity in India.
As we see that many cases are making attempts to be classified as backward to take the benefits of caste-based reservation. And they make riots to get the reservation.
So, I would like to say the government should put a ban on cast reservation.
As we see that many cases are making attempts to be classified as backward to take the benefits of caste-based reservation. And they make riots to get the reservation.
So, I would like to say the government should put a ban on cast reservation.
(14)
Akanksha said:
1 decade ago
Concluding all of the above terms I just want to say that reservation should be there but up to a certain extent the poor and the needy sections of the society must be given allowances and funds by the government for their upliftment, and as regarding the development of the country there must be no caste reservation each and everyone must be treated equally and only the weak sections must be given reservation so that corruption must be removed to a certain extent and making India a country where everyone is equally treated.
(15)
Nandini Vishist said:
1 decade ago
Hello everyone as per the topic reservation should be removed from the education system because there are many talented students who are not able to fulfill their dream of studying where hey want to just because of reservation and these can be from upper class as well as from middle class.
Each and every student should be judge from his/her knowledge what he/she is from inside, because now a days we all students are being judged by there numbers and knowledge. So reservation should be removed from the education system.
Each and every student should be judge from his/her knowledge what he/she is from inside, because now a days we all students are being judged by there numbers and knowledge. So reservation should be removed from the education system.
(17)
Mukesh Panwar said:
9 years ago
In my opinion, reservation should be on economical basis, not on class/caste and religion.
The reservation should be given to deserving one who registered by government of India under BPL.
The other concern is about reserving the peoples who lives in forest. A special reservation should be given to these peoples because they are backward.
Higher education reservation lacks the country in the backward side. If you give opportunities to deserving one, our country would be a developed country very soon.
Thanks.
The reservation should be given to deserving one who registered by government of India under BPL.
The other concern is about reserving the peoples who lives in forest. A special reservation should be given to these peoples because they are backward.
Higher education reservation lacks the country in the backward side. If you give opportunities to deserving one, our country would be a developed country very soon.
Thanks.
(23)
Anupam said:
1 decade ago
People who are well to do in society should not get reservation. If reservation has to be given to those who need it, to bring up their families (Poor people). The current form of reservation is for those who are making mock of the system.
See 50% reservation is there and those people who are well to do, they have their kids in very good education system, they avail the reservation, there by denying to those who are poor and tried reservation also but because of these selfish people, they cannot get admission.
See 50% reservation is there and those people who are well to do, they have their kids in very good education system, they avail the reservation, there by denying to those who are poor and tried reservation also but because of these selfish people, they cannot get admission.
(3)
Vijay kunar said:
1 decade ago
A general category poor but still able to enjoy a good status in society can study without social pressure on the other hand an SC/ST who got discriminated feel stressed because of this discrimination, their families had faced it for so long that they can't come up, it takes generations to get over with this discrimination how can you expect him to give 100% to studies. A SC/ST category guy/girl got beaten because of his caste even when he/she can buy that other person can you imagine his mental situation?
(14)
Ami said:
9 years ago
Equity is the basis of reservation policy to bring equality. Reservation gives concession to those who have suffered oppression through generations. The problem with education in India is that it offers free education up to the age of 15 but the level of Primary education in government schools is so bad that children who study there can never compete with those who study in private schools. Till this disparity in standard of education is not addressed, need for reservation in higher education will remain.
(18)
Ranga said:
1 decade ago
Hai friends.
I agree with all but in my view the reservation is not need for casts. It is need for poor students. For example I have 2 friends one is reservation candidate other one has no reservation. In the EMCET exam reservation student get 21 marks and non reservation student get 39 marks. Reservation student is selected but non reservation is not selected. But both the students are come under below middle class families.
So in my point of view education depend upon talent not on reservation.
I agree with all but in my view the reservation is not need for casts. It is need for poor students. For example I have 2 friends one is reservation candidate other one has no reservation. In the EMCET exam reservation student get 21 marks and non reservation student get 39 marks. Reservation student is selected but non reservation is not selected. But both the students are come under below middle class families.
So in my point of view education depend upon talent not on reservation.
(39)
Prince raj said:
7 years ago
Reservation in the education system is a very wrong thing because of reservation merit students lose their opportunity.
If the government want each student will learn with equality then the government should ban on the reservation.
Instead of giving reservation on the basis of the caste if it should exist on the basis of the creamy and non-creamy layer.
What I mean to say is it should be provided on the family income basis like those who are poor and never got a good opportunity in their life.
If the government want each student will learn with equality then the government should ban on the reservation.
Instead of giving reservation on the basis of the caste if it should exist on the basis of the creamy and non-creamy layer.
What I mean to say is it should be provided on the family income basis like those who are poor and never got a good opportunity in their life.
(28)
Post your thoughts here:
Quick links
Quantitative Aptitude
Verbal (English)
Reasoning
Programming
Interview
Placement Papers