Is Reservation in Higher Education Only Alternative for Social Equality?
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
- Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
- Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
- Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
- Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
168 comments Page 8 of 17.
Ashraf said:
4 years ago
Hello friends.
My view in this topic is;
Reservation should be abolished as early as possible especially for the competative exams.
Because many general category students are preparing very hard and even scoring more marks than the SC ST category students but not getting selected just because of the caste.
And an SC/ST Category student even scoring less marks than the general category students they are getting selected.
By giving more efforts, being more deserving for the seats the general category students are not getting it.
So, the reservation system based on caste is very bad.
My view in this topic is;
Reservation should be abolished as early as possible especially for the competative exams.
Because many general category students are preparing very hard and even scoring more marks than the SC ST category students but not getting selected just because of the caste.
And an SC/ST Category student even scoring less marks than the general category students they are getting selected.
By giving more efforts, being more deserving for the seats the general category students are not getting it.
So, the reservation system based on caste is very bad.
(69)
SURESH said:
10 years ago
I have only one question, whether any person got employment under reservation helped his own siblings to get educated or well settled? No, he simply ignores his own family members including parents as he feel them outdated. Whether he try to educate his own children with merit? No, he wish his children also come up with reservation.
Even an MP/MLA s children get reservation and lakhs of rupees scholarships. Whether ever Government called for the accounts from beneficiaries how the scholarship was spent? No, if so, does the nation or the society is benefited from reservation?
Even an MP/MLA s children get reservation and lakhs of rupees scholarships. Whether ever Government called for the accounts from beneficiaries how the scholarship was spent? No, if so, does the nation or the society is benefited from reservation?
(22)
Gopalkrishna said:
10 years ago
Friends.
Present reservation system widens the gap between communities & area. Our great constitution granted equal rights to all its citizens. So here I want our supreme court must try to implement it in right spirit of our constitution.
Denying seats to highly meritorious students seats in professional course is violation of basic education rights and it is human rights abuse. Students who have scored much better is denied will leads disappointment. As our judiciary declared that lesser meritorious students need not be given better seats & colleges.
Present reservation system widens the gap between communities & area. Our great constitution granted equal rights to all its citizens. So here I want our supreme court must try to implement it in right spirit of our constitution.
Denying seats to highly meritorious students seats in professional course is violation of basic education rights and it is human rights abuse. Students who have scored much better is denied will leads disappointment. As our judiciary declared that lesser meritorious students need not be given better seats & colleges.
(10)
Harsh said:
1 decade ago
I think, reservation should be permitted, but to some extent only. For example, my age is 27, now onwards I would not be able to apply to some government organization or PSU. Person belonging to reservation category can apply with 5 years of relaxation. How can you justify reservation by his or her age. Also general category applicants pay fees Rs. 500 and reservation category applicants pays only 50. Also there is reservation in marks. From my personal point of view there should not be any reservation in age. And government has to think 100 times on it.
(13)
Anuradha Krishnaratnam said:
1 decade ago
Yes yes. Everyone should be against reservation. Due to this reservation children are taking advantage and this is followed only in India. They are taking undue advantage that is they are not even feeling stressed while writing exams like MAINS and ADVANCE for IIT, they are saying casually that they will get a rank in those exams. Now, we the general caste people are feeling that if we were born as a member of SC/ST caste then what will be our future.
We should totally oppose this so that we will have a developed nation as other countries like US.
We should totally oppose this so that we will have a developed nation as other countries like US.
(9)
Verma ji said:
5 years ago
The reservation system was introduced by Dr BR Ambedkar to provide equal opportunity and works for lower caste people.
But in present time reservation is not required because due to reservation system talented person not getting better opportunity and they are going abroad.
And other countries are taking advantage of it.
Due to reservation India is not growing perfectly.
In my opinion, reservation should be based on economic condition, people who are facing economic problem he should be given reservation in education or other fields.
Thanks.
But in present time reservation is not required because due to reservation system talented person not getting better opportunity and they are going abroad.
And other countries are taking advantage of it.
Due to reservation India is not growing perfectly.
In my opinion, reservation should be based on economic condition, people who are facing economic problem he should be given reservation in education or other fields.
Thanks.
(47)
Holmes said:
8 years ago
The reservation has become an inevitable part of life. Why is it so important? Reservation in higher education is like placing an order for water in Amazon. It ruins the importance of education system and degrades the self-confidence of merit candidates. Reservation is never a constrain for social equality. Indian education system has been producing scapegoats since IITs. How can social equality be attained? Uplifting the standard of education and evaluation system plays a vital role. One nation One Education system is mandatory for excellence.
(8)
Satyendra said:
7 years ago
Reservation is the most highlighted topic in our country dr BR Ambedkar include reservation in our constitution for sc, st, OBC.
So they could grow themselves and develop their society. In that time the condition of sc st and OBC was very worse so they need a reservation but nowadays many people have got the advantage of reservation so I think people who already can get the advantage of reservation should be left reservation so that other people of their society could get the reservation. Then our country and society will become better early.
So they could grow themselves and develop their society. In that time the condition of sc st and OBC was very worse so they need a reservation but nowadays many people have got the advantage of reservation so I think people who already can get the advantage of reservation should be left reservation so that other people of their society could get the reservation. Then our country and society will become better early.
(10)
Vishakha said:
8 years ago
Reservation should be there, but not because of casteism but for background status, but one more thing, As being a brahmin, my Dadaji told me DAT their ancestors or upper caste people didn't allow sc st people to grow up, the brahmins n pandits created the casteism n sc st people were not allowed to go to school even, Dr.BR Ambedkar he seated on the floor n studied, he was not allowed to drink water from same well. This is what upper caste, we people did, so definitely they will ask for their rights of reservation, from my end it's OK.
(22)
ASHISH said:
1 decade ago
We are living in a country which is still developing instead our country is the world largest democratic country. But we are facing many problems and reservation is one of them. By giving reservation we are giving chance to the people who belongs to schedule caste/tribe but what is for people of general caste.
Poor people are in all classes but why giving this only sc/st. I think it must be given only on the basis of financial condition. There must be a criteria for getting reservation n there must be a transparency regarding it.
Poor people are in all classes but why giving this only sc/st. I think it must be given only on the basis of financial condition. There must be a criteria for getting reservation n there must be a transparency regarding it.
(15)
Post your thoughts here:
Quick links
Quantitative Aptitude
Verbal (English)
Reasoning
Programming
Interview
Placement Papers