Is Reservation in Higher Education Only Alternative for Social Equality?
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
- Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
- Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
- Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
- Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
169 comments Page 10 of 17.
Prince raj said:
7 years ago
Reservation in the education system is a very wrong thing because of reservation merit students lose their opportunity.
If the government want each student will learn with equality then the government should ban on the reservation.
Instead of giving reservation on the basis of the caste if it should exist on the basis of the creamy and non-creamy layer.
What I mean to say is it should be provided on the family income basis like those who are poor and never got a good opportunity in their life.
If the government want each student will learn with equality then the government should ban on the reservation.
Instead of giving reservation on the basis of the caste if it should exist on the basis of the creamy and non-creamy layer.
What I mean to say is it should be provided on the family income basis like those who are poor and never got a good opportunity in their life.
(28)
Rachin Singh said:
2 years ago
I partially agree with the given statement because the reservation only creates a gap between the different castes the government should have to modify or revise the rules and regulations in the reservation because the best way to identify the deserving candidate is to go into the ground level and maintain the data regarding that because some deserving people are unaware about it, due to which a large gap is created among the people of the nation and it also increasing the poverty.
(4)
Luvly said:
1 decade ago
Hi friends.
It is very funny to hear that government has only a reservation option for Social equality. In my point of opinion it is very bad idea to set up cotta systems, it sounds bad that due to cotta system the more claimed person are not getting a admission in good colleges and I think due to this the IIT of India's that have a good rank in world. Today they are not reputed due to not very skilled students, government should make alternatives or set up more universities.
It is very funny to hear that government has only a reservation option for Social equality. In my point of opinion it is very bad idea to set up cotta systems, it sounds bad that due to cotta system the more claimed person are not getting a admission in good colleges and I think due to this the IIT of India's that have a good rank in world. Today they are not reputed due to not very skilled students, government should make alternatives or set up more universities.
(16)
Prathyusha said:
1 decade ago
My opinion is reservation is helping the poor students, but our country giving economically developed people.
In olden days there was a poor person, untouchability that way B. R. Ambedkar, he was to. See that situation. So he was to ask our leaders for ten years development the SC/ST. That it was continuously developing. Now where is the untouchability people SC/ST was developed.
Finally, I conclude that. Reservations are only for talent, not four castes like SC/ST.
In olden days there was a poor person, untouchability that way B. R. Ambedkar, he was to. See that situation. So he was to ask our leaders for ten years development the SC/ST. That it was continuously developing. Now where is the untouchability people SC/ST was developed.
Finally, I conclude that. Reservations are only for talent, not four castes like SC/ST.
(46)
Richa bharti said:
1 decade ago
Hi friends.
I agree that in India people are very poor and they should get an opportunity but the poor people in India are not only from a certain caste. Poverty can not be dealt on the basis of caste and if we want a developed nation the criteria for reservation should be based on financial status not on certain caste barrier. It discriminate our society, the caste under reservation itself get smell that they are inferior and that's why they ate given reservation.
I agree that in India people are very poor and they should get an opportunity but the poor people in India are not only from a certain caste. Poverty can not be dealt on the basis of caste and if we want a developed nation the criteria for reservation should be based on financial status not on certain caste barrier. It discriminate our society, the caste under reservation itself get smell that they are inferior and that's why they ate given reservation.
(11)
Vidya said:
1 decade ago
Absolutely agree with all and one's opinion. Reservation should be given to those people who actually need it. Today's world is the competition world. Not a single can afford to lose a single opportunity that may be of getting "A" grade college or good job. If govt want to make India as a developed country then now this is the high time to stop the Reservation on the basis of caste. So that true talent will come out in helping, improving the condition of our nation.
(13)
Sarang said:
1 decade ago
I do not support reservation in jobs, but peoples who don't have enough money to study in good institutions, scholarship has to be given to those, so that they can get admission in good institution and enhance their level and compete with others.
So in my view reservation upto some extent is right in the field of education but that should be on the economic basis, but in jobs there should be no reservation, so that only talented people come in the jobs.
So in my view reservation upto some extent is right in the field of education but that should be on the economic basis, but in jobs there should be no reservation, so that only talented people come in the jobs.
(34)
Himanshu said:
9 years ago
Many are saying that reservations should have to ban. Yes, I also want but To making them able to earn a better life, we should do something. I think, there is a common problem that rich people are getting high education quality and poor are getting low-class education so, in my opinion, they should be provided with a high-class education, give them an opportunity and provide best tutors from best tution and then see what is their potential.
(18)
Konde Dhanu said:
9 years ago
Hello all, the topic given to us is Reservations in India: Caste based Vs Income based. Reservations in India were brought primarily with the objective of providing opportunities and better living standards for weaker and under privileged sections of the society. Dr. B.R.Ambedkar fought for bringing reservation system into Indian constitution to help economically various caste people who were unable to have sufficient opportunities to grow.
(11)
Aparna said:
1 decade ago
According to me, reservations are necessary for the people with financial problems because of which there can be upliftment in those sections of society. There are advantages and disadvantages of reservations. People make fake certificates which is wrong and we can see with students who are having reservations they take career too lightly and take undue advantage of it. One has to work hard to come you in life and not rely on reservations.
(17)
Post your thoughts here:
Quick links
Quantitative Aptitude
Verbal (English)
Reasoning
Programming
Interview
Placement Papers