Is MNCs Superior to Indian Companies?

Group Discussion
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
  • Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
  • Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
  • Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
  • Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
122 comments Page 5 of 13.

Bipuljee said:   9 years ago
Hi, As I am working in an MNC. I can't deny the fact that MNCs are better than Indian companies. But I would like to add that if there is political corruption in Indian companies then MNCs is also not an exception in this aspect. Here is also cut-throat competition for the higher post and package and yes, the ultimate goal is to go 0ff-shore. So. What restricts the Indian companies. Again we Indians are responsible. So the need of an hour. Is collectively organized efforts to shine our Indian companies by taking a valuable lesson from MNCs. Which we consider far better than Indian ones.
(13)

Vijay k said:   9 years ago
There is a myth or truth can say exactly but most of the people will say if I go for the MNC then there I will be getting lots of resources and I can extend and grow myself on international standard. On the other hand, we do have also companies who operate on international standards but the fact is we don't have too much option so people fear for completion and simply go for the MNCs. I think we should change our thinking at this point just come in front and do your best for an organization in whichever you are. So conclusion of this topic is yes, MNC are superior then Indian companies.
(12)

Himanshu Tiwari said:   9 years ago
Yes, MNCs will more superior than Indian companies because the more important point in MNCs is 'How to save your job?' there will be more competition in MNCs as in Indian companies if people get job then he is getting that job for full time which make people lazy from mind the result due to that type of mind setup is that people do his job in lazy way or many times ignore work if work is not important in present time.

And in MNCs, all people fight for his/her job which affects in work. Work done smartly and first and by these work complete more fastly as compared to Indian companies.
(4)

Karan said:   1 decade ago
Well I have worked with an Indian company for 3 years, although all the projects are for US clients. I started at a low salary but after 3 years today it is probably greater than the MNC. This was possible because a smaller organization means transparency and more challenging work due to less people and your talent gets focus to the topmost hierarchy in organization. So I would say smaller and Indian companies are fine to start your career but shift to MNCs after a period of time since MNCs provide better infrastructure, growth in long time, better pay in long race and job security.
(32)

NIKHIUL DOOHAAN said:   8 years ago
In terms of stages of progress of a business, YES.

Companies are basically Businesses with a certain level of achievements that makes up a hierarchy.

IN this hierarchy MNCs are at the top because they have excelled at their field so much that they are now operating successfully in a different country and a different race has accepted that and Basically, your classification is wrong.

In business, there is no such thing as MNC vs Indian company.

What about TCS it is an MNC and it is INDIA company.

So you should learn to classify thing in a correct basis.

Thank you.
(10)

Sakthi said:   1 decade ago
According to my point of view, still we depending only foreign country. In India itself making any companies and provide the opportunities to the Indian people get good income and also benefit for the economy. Most of the people can get the employment opportunities. If it was happened we don't need to expect other foreign companies. Past few years about the dollar depreciation it has hit in Indian economy for getting imports more when compare to export. If keep on importing from other country it will effect on Indian gross domestic market better we will try to export.
(15)

Basu said:   1 decade ago
In my point of view Indian companies are not inferior than MNCs because now these days Indian companies are also become multinational companies. They provide good salary package, better work environment, good increment etc. Companies like TCS, INFOSYS, HCL, Reliance run their business in many countries and also provide job opportunities to the residents of that country.

It is true that Indian companies has less budget than MNCs and they also spend less money in R&D as compared to MNCs. In the end Indian companies are not inferior but they have to go long way.
(72)

Mahesh said:   9 years ago
No; MNC is not superior to Indian because in now few years there is tough competition in all sector MNC doesn't provide competition to his employees as compassion to India Co. And 2nd reason is that MNC creates the monopoly in India and another reason is that they spend more money on R&D and SELLING COST they give better advertisements companion to Indian Co. And show himself superior to him the main motive of MNC is to earn profit not social welfare they achieve only their goal nit countries goals.

But; Patanjali gives tough competition to MNC.

Thanks.
(11)

Tanuja said:   1 decade ago
There is question for all of participant's Why people prefer MNCs? The answer is, people rush to MNCs because they offer high salary, and many incentives, but Indian company does not do so. They give the employee as small as they can do. So in my point of view if they can work upon these reasons then people will automatically follow Indian company rather MNCs. If we use our knowledge in our own company then definitely our Indian companies will reach to MNC's. But we have to work upon these basic things cause we all know Indian people are very much talented.
(25)

Neha said:   9 years ago
Hello friends,

As we know, MNC's are very much resourceful and powerful than our Indian companies. The MNC's extends thier assets and facilities in more than one country like Walmart has operated in about 28 countries and many other companies also like this - Volkswagen, Toyota motors, Toshiba, Honda, BMW and all. More involvement of countries leads to highly skillful employees and use better and enhanced technology.

Thus MNC is superior to Indian companies, and also influencing our country economy, growth and obstruct the development of the nation.
(31)


Post your thoughts here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.