Do Women make Good Managers?

Group Discussion
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
  • Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
  • Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
  • Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
  • Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
168 comments Page 8 of 17.

Mark said:   1 decade ago
Hello friends,

Yes I agree with the fact that women make good managers. But It would be inappropriate to discriminate talent on the basis of gender. Any one who posses the qualities like creativity, knowledge, commitment, versatility, discipline etc can become a good managers. But talking about the topic of our discussion I think women are way better than men in managing more than one stuff at a time.

You know back in ancient days men would go into the forest for hunt and the women used to do all the stuffs like taking care of kids, agriculture work, household chores etc. So It shows that women are better at managing things from those days.

Talking about the present scenario, Indra Nooyi, CEO of pepsico, Arundhati Bhattacharya, first women to be the chairperson of State Bank Of India, Chanda Kochhar, CEO of ICICI bank, Pratibhatai Patil, first women president of Independent India, Meira Kumar, first women speaker of Lok sabha. I think these are the best example to prove that women make good managers.

Thank you.
(31)

Prince pathak said:   10 years ago
I partially agree with all. But according to me women are good manager because they always think profit and loss before starting any work so they can manage any task in good manner but man never think before starting any work.
(31)

Amit said:   9 years ago
As per me my opinion it is baseless to compare man and woman for a post. Managerial responsibility requires talent, good understanding, managing skills, communication skill. If any person either man or woman has these characteristics he or she can be a good manager.

In short those who possess managerial quality they can be a good manager.

Although I agree that there are more men managers than women and the reason is our society attitude towards women. Women are understood as homemaker only and not allowed to live their dreams. If we give opportunity and treat everybody equally without any gender discrimination then women will show their talent in every field and can shoulder all responsibility as men do.
(31)

Yogesh khanke said:   8 years ago
Hi guys. I think that managers are known for tyeir qualities of management, decision taking ability, involving everyone in their work and presence of mind.

We know that women are much more better in terms of family management but it should not be the basis of a good manager. A good manager shoupd be due to its higher qualities. So no one can be judged on basis of gender instead of that qualities are much more imp.
(31)

Aaruz said:   1 decade ago
Women are always good managers. Because she need to look her parents, husband's parents, husband, siblings, children, if cattle's its too. If she got a job she is capable of managing it too. So women are the good managers. Behind the success of every man there is a women.
(30)

Joanna das said:   8 years ago
In my view, I think that.

Men and Women both can make good managers because how a boy will manage like a girl can manage. In this generations, we can see that many girls are managing their home and their office. If in a house there a child so that child's mom has to manage her child and also her home. So if she can manage this side so she can manage her office also like a boy. So I think that if we will say that girl can't make good managers so we are insulting the girls.

Thank you.
(30)

Shreyansh said:   8 years ago
Hello friends.

I Am Shreyansh.

Yes, I agree with this content that women is a good manager than men because she organises everything in good & perspective manner.
Even in the home also we see females of our family manages the family &n kitchen well.
Mens only provide thing related to the kitchen she only manages that.
We can see that men can waste money but women think both positive n negative both side n then spend it.
She works 24/7 without expecting anything from anyone.
(30)

Saurabh kumar said:   7 years ago
Hello friends,

In my opinion, both women and men can be better for managerial works. But if we see the current scenario of India's society we can think that women if doing the corporate job they also manage the household works, but even after doing hard work, everyone has his or her own pros and cons. Talking about men, men also make good managers and if we see, they are more physically tough than women. So for the discussion, we can conclude that men and women are both opposite faces of a same coin and capable for probing to have good managerial skills.
(29)

Neha said:   1 decade ago
Hi.

I'm Neha.

@Nisha said very true.

Yes well in my opinion definitely women is a good manager because she has a potential to manage the thing. It's a known fact that women are more organised then men and women's are most of time effectively handle all domestic responsibilities even in the financial domain.
(28)

Radhika said:   9 years ago
I feel that whether the Manager is a Man or a Woman, it all depends on the qualities that they possess, which is required to handle that particular job. For example, Indra Nooyi of PepsiCo, Kiran Mazumdar of Biocon and Narayana Murthy of Infosys. It is the capability that decides whether that person is good or not for a job, and not gender.
(28)


Post your thoughts here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.