Aptitude - Time and Work - Discussion

Discussion Forum : Time and Work - General Questions (Q.No. 4)
4.
A is thrice as good as workman as B and therefore is able to finish a job in 60 days less than B. Working together, they can do it in:
20 days
22 1 days
2
25 days
30 days
Answer: Option
Explanation:

Ratio of times taken by A and B = 1 : 3.

The time difference is (3 - 1) 2 days while B take 3 days and A takes 1 day.

If difference of time is 2 days, B takes 3 days.

If difference of time is 60 days, B takes 3 x 60 = 90 days.
2

So, A takes 30 days to do the work.

A's 1 day's work = 1
30

B's 1 day's work = 1
90

(A + B)'s 1 day's work = 1 + 1 = 4 = 2
30 90 90 45

A and B together can do the work in 45 = 22 1 days.
2 2

Discussion:
281 comments Page 4 of 29.

Hindu said:   1 decade ago
Hai sheetal your shortcut method helps lot to understand so quickly its really super.

Naveen kumar said:   1 decade ago
Hi friends, Here is a simple technique to calculate the above problem....

Given,

If the If difference of time is 2 days, B takes 3 days.
If difference of time is 60 days, B takes......?

We can represent the above relation like this,

2------->3
60------>....?

By cross multiplying the above terms we will get... 60*3/2 = 90.

Note:- Always individual term should come in the denominator.

By applying the above procedure you can solve any problem of this type....

I think this technique will help you while doing with this type of problems...

Abdul said:   1 decade ago
Hey Siva your way of solving is fantastic and understandable! Thanks.

Jezan said:   1 decade ago
According to this question if A is x, B will be x+60
1/3=x/x+60
3x=x+60
2x=6
x=30
A+B'S ONE DAY WORK=1/30+1/90=2/45
SO WHOLE WORK S= 45/2( UPSIDE DOWN)
22.5 DAYS.
HOPE ALL LL GET DIS

Jaswinder Singh said:   1 decade ago
Ratio of times taken by A and B = 1 : 3. or 1x:3x
so, we say
3x-1x=60,
2x=60,
x=30, so A will 30 day to complected a work,
B will be complete the work ie 3x, 3(30)=90days,
(A+B) 1 Day work = (1/30 + 1/90)
by solving we get,
A+B 1 Day work = 2/45,
so A and B together can complete work in 45/2 Days.

Sharan said:   1 decade ago
@Jaswinder singh: I understood your explanation man. Thanks.

Sundar said:   1 decade ago
@All (Must read if you have any doubts)

If B takes 3 days then A takes 1 day to complete the task.

Time taken Ratio => A : B = 1 day : 3 days.

1 3 (difference is 2)

10 30 (diff 20)

30 90 (diff 60) <= Here diff is 60 days, So this is the correct ratio to be used in calculation, since it was mentioned in the given question.

A alone can finish the task in 30 days.
B alone can finish the task in 90 days.

Work done by A alone in 1 day = 1/30
Work done by B alone in 1 day = 1/90

Work done by A and B in one day (1/30 + 1/90) = 3+1/90 = 4/90

The no. of days required to complete the task by A and B is
= 90/4
= 22.5 days.

////**** Important Note: ****////

We cannot take other ratios like 1:3, 10:30, 40:120, 60:180 for the calculation. Since the diff is mentioned as 60 days.

Because, it will give different answers for each different ratios used for calculation.

If we take 1:3 => (1/1 + 1/3) = 4/3

If we take 10:30 => (1/10 + 1/30) = 4/30

If we take 40:120 = (1/40 + 1/120) = 4/120

If we take 60:180 => (1/60 + 1/180) = 4/180 ... so on.

I hope this will help you. Have a nice day!
(2)

Deepti said:   1 decade ago
It is not so big and easy to understand.

let work done by B in 1 day = 1/x
so work done by A in 1 day = 1/(x-60)
1/(x-60) = 3/x
so x = 3x - 180
x = 90
work done by A and B in 1 day is 30 and 90 respectively
work done by both together in 1 day = 1/30 + 1/90 = 2/45.
total work done = 45/2

Harsha said:   1 decade ago
Easy method :

A can completed in x days
B can in 3x days then

A = B-60 (A can do in 60 days less than B )

=> x=3x-60 => x= 30 =>

A=30, B=90

Then together work done is (1/30+1/90) = 2/45.

Finally total work done is 45/2.

Pinky said:   1 decade ago
@Sheetal superb explanation.


Post your comments here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.