Reservations in the Private Sector

@ : Home > Group Discussion > Politics - Discussion Room

Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
  • Assume, you one of the member of a real group discussion.
  • Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
  • Express your positive attitude towards providing the solution.

Hemant Raghav said: (Fri, Oct 17, 2014 08:24:23 PM)    
There should be no reservation in private sector by caste point of view. Govt can give reservation to those who are financially weaker. Because it help him/her to show ability that they have but not able to perform just because of money. Only than country development is possible.

Rate this:   +5   -5

Subbarao said: (Sat, Oct 11, 2014 11:24:37 PM)    
My point of view reservation is wast process but it can helpful for some people and those are like handicapped people and orphan. Who has backward people and that people government must be provide dipresitation to college free or others etc. Hence either government or private only provide reservation any fee very less compared to higher class people. I know reservation waste. I don't know not only given to fee purpose but also gob purpose.

For sixty years back could be provide reservation it has been continuing for when had we got independence day. Although it has taken advantages. It is helpful for election time. But anyone of them will never to dare remove reservation.

Every five years it will be increase. Whatever maybe private sectors reservation is worst so I say that who has talent people and that one people are suitable for any of this. As well as India when will never develop in future for let us consider foreign countries are those like Japan, UK and Germany these countries did already developed although these have either poor and rich people should not provide any reservation so that countries.

Rate this:   +9   -6

Sourabh Yerawar said: (Mon, Oct 6, 2014 02:52:14 PM)    
Hello Everyone, before I speak about this topic I shall put forward a fact which says, "every human being has the brain with same capacity which can hold the data in some petabytes. " But the only thing that differentiates the one from another is the utilization of it.

So to utilize the most of it, we need resources for which we need money. And poor people do not have it so if government could provide the fund to these needy people, everyone will be at same position and it would be a fair contention.

So there has to be reservation in terms of financial help only for needy people.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +18   -6

Shadeeda Shahin said: (Tue, Sep 23, 2014 10:18:34 PM)    
Reservation is typically a major problem which differentiates people. Any system to work efficiently needs to be absolutely unbiased. For a country to develop, talent is the key point which should be kept into consideration. Concept of reservation came up during the early times just to give a chance for backward people to get through. But, since the purpose has been served due to equal rights for all, time has come to give it a STOP. It is witnessed that private sectors are much efficient than government just because they don't compromise with talents, thus grab the best hand.

Rate this:   +28   -6

Pratiksha Gawandar said: (Sun, Sep 21, 2014 11:53:48 AM)    
According to my point of view reservation is part of dirty politics. Private sector success is depends his services to customers or this think fulfilled by employee if we should get reservation in private sector the chances is less to company get efficient employee. Reservation should only those people who is financial backwards or handicap. This is my opinion about reservation.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +14   -4

Ankur Saha said: (Sat, Sep 20, 2014 10:49:20 PM)    
Hello friends, I think that their should not be any reservation in private and also in government sectors too. Only poor people should get full help but only in and throughout their education life. Many of my friends who are SC or OBC enjoy those quotas and spend their quota money in fun though they belong to middle class family and they do not need any help. These also develop a sense in them that they will get a govt job in future and they do not study well. So these quotas rather destroys countries future.

Rate this:   +15   -3

Suyash Gupta said: (Sat, Sep 20, 2014 10:27:12 PM)    
Hello friends, Do reservation really help the poor people or minority or some simply misuse them.

1. Well to help the needy the best way is to give them books, help them economically enlighten the whole society with knowledge, technology so that they can stand with their own legs and with proud they can say I reach there by facing same struggles that every one faced.

2. Reservation- Practically up till now it has proved that it help more to political leader for gaining votes by thoughts like this leader is from our minority or will bring reservation for us.

3. It will make country more prone to internal war and will raise topic like secularism.

4. As one minority will rise, soon the other minority or it's equivalent group will rise definitely for it's reservation and will finally lead to rush. In last it is fact that general will spit their anger by saying this is unfair and again this is harmful for country's unity.

5. Naturally it will weakens the real effort of minority or talent of reserved people because they they will feel themselves reserved and will not try their best and so in real terms it can harm them.

6. There should be some other methods and measure which should help minority and cast system should be avoided perhaps society parameter should not be money but should be moral values and knowledge. Money should be equally distributed, real help and real fact is equality.

Rate this:   +12   -2

Nagarjuna said: (Wed, Sep 17, 2014 07:57:28 PM)    
Reservation in private Sector should not be allowed. There are many statements that can support this argument:

The success of Private sector firms mainly depends on the Quality of the Services they provide, they can offer best services to its customers if that organisation is having Talented Employees.

Now, if the private firms start recruiting candidates based on reservation then they may not get the Best Talent as per industry standards. This can affect their business in a big way and may result in a big loss to their reputation.

The reservations may result in a great depression among educated people of higher caste since their employment opportunities will be bleak in both Govt and private sector.

Rate this:   +10   -6

Sagnik said: (Wed, Sep 17, 2014 12:04:32 PM)    
Hi this is Sagnik. I would like to speak "against" the topic given, i.e. I think reservation in private sector is not at all a just option in today's world.

My reasons:

1. As most of my friends have spoken, reservation given on the basis of caste or creed doesn't ensure that the help is going out to the ones who really need it. On the other hand, many who are actually suffering are kept away from its benefits.

2. Reservation breeds mediocrity. Once a person knows, he is being given extra allowances, he will not give his best which affects his performance and the institution as a whole, specially if its a private sector job requiring high efficiency.

3. When a person gets inside an organization on the basis of reservation, even if he capable of the role still others sometimes feel that he has got an easy way out which eventually gives birth to jealousy and an unhealthy environment.

So the solution is formulating a proper, error free system which can find the real needy and backward classes of our society based on their economic conditions and then provide reservations to some extent. Only then can this system be made right.

Rate this:   +7   -4

Ankush Kulshreshtha said: (Tue, Sep 16, 2014 07:17:42 PM)    
According to my point of view, Indian government need some ethical changes in the current reservation system. There is some flaws in current reservations policies. On the other hand, reservation in private sector is completely ridiculous because of the some reasons.

1. Private sector known for their qualities not quantity.
2. Eligible candidate must be selected.
3. The equality between high class and low class is come under to the occurrence when there is no such things like reservation.

Thank you!

Rate this:   +4   -1

Affan Ahmed said: (Mon, Sep 15, 2014 01:58:17 PM)    
Hello friend, I am Affan, from my point of view, reservation is good thing, but the system should change their policy. The reservation should be based on their economy condition not on the caste system. Cast system is the worst thing in our society. If the cast system be abolished from the country then all people unite there is no partiality for anyone. Reservation is like a parasite in our country. Reservation should be replaced by scholarship by which people from lower background get scholarship for their education.

Rate this:   +3   -1

Nishi Gupta said: (Sun, Sep 14, 2014 05:27:19 PM)    
As per my opinion, reservation is not good for society it is a very big reason of backwardness in our society and country. As we always say that everybody is equal right now after 63 years of independence. But it is not the true fact about society low caste people always discriminate and criticized. But to give him equality reservation is not an option because due to reservation talent may be hidden, many of the talented candidate not to get equal opportunity because of reservation. In govt jobs there are a lot reserved seats for backward and lower caste people. And if there will be reservation also in pvt sector then there may be choices of hiding the talents. But private sector always required only skills and talent. So there is no requirement of reservation in pvt sector.

Rate this:   +9   -0

Shruthi K said: (Sun, Sep 14, 2014 12:30:46 PM)    
Hello friends,

I always vote against the reservation, because it not only create discrimination between the low class and high class peoples but also increases the evil castesim in the minds of young generation. Instead of reservation, provide enough scholarship to the economically poor students for their education and provide all the facilities for them to read but don't make their way easy by these reservations and all. If no reservations are there then they will automatically work hard and earn some knowledge and then they fit to get good jobs in both private and public sectors without any reservations.

Rate this:   +8   -2

Rahul said: (Sat, Sep 13, 2014 06:27:53 PM)    
Hi everyone,

A/c to my point of view reservation should not give to private sector or even government sector. At the time of independence matter was different but today it's different.

On the basis of caste or religion to give reservation is totally wrong because today many of the talented persons even don't get the chance in other side many of the rich person get the chance and use reservation category. If we give the reservation in private sector then it won't be good for company because many of the talented person even don't enter in company. So reservation in any sector is not a good policy.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +10   -1

Vikas Sonawane said: (Wed, Sep 10, 2014 04:19:46 PM)    
Hello Guys,

I want to share my few words on Ganesan's statement. Ganesan is totally wrong. Sorry I am not agree with him. Beacause In every govt sector SC, NT gets conession and also get the free exam guidence. In this senario pvt sector is correct. If SC/NT candidates getting more and more concession and their all seats are reserved for them, so why should they apply in pvt sector. Please use their talent in govt sect and not in Pvt sector. Because all OBC and Open candidates are not getting any concession.

This is my suggestion.

Rate this:   +2   -7

Ganesan said: (Tue, Sep 9, 2014 01:58:03 AM)    
Swathi what you said is correct, one of my friend is very intelligent and talented person but he belongs to SC. He is working in private company and searching job change but private sector is not accepting him because he belongs to SC. This is what happen in private sector. So, caste should not come in certificate.

If there is no reservation in private, why private sector is asking caste? They should see his tallen and knowledge not caste. Who asking reservation in private sector? who affected by private sector those people only asking. Why private sector behaving like this. Because some private sector is not accepting SC people for higher position even though he is tallen and intelligent. The only way is caste should not come in certificate.

Rate this:   +18   -2

Ulta Chashmah said: (Mon, Sep 8, 2014 08:49:49 PM)    
Hi Guys!

I would like to add that, reservation succeeds in keeping the problem at bay and not curing it! Rather than fussing over on how to determine a correct reservation system, it would be better if we all can wipe out the need for it.

This implies equitable growth which would come from greater education levels and thus demolish caste prejudices and age old bias, thereby putting an end to inequality which gives rise to reservation in the first place.

Rate this:   +4   -1

Srikanth said: (Mon, Sep 8, 2014 04:44:15 PM)    
Hi friends.

Acc to my opinion Reservation good if the persons coming from the economically weaker sections of the society. But now the thing is different why because the persons from the rich and also they get a reservation then how we can justice to poor people so it has to be change otherwise the economic position of a country will not change. We have to depend on other countries for the small things. India has lot of talented people but their knowledge not useful to the country. Because of reservation when ever we revise the reservation system then only we achieve the economic growth and dream India.

Rate this:   +2   -1

Abhisek Dash said: (Mon, Sep 8, 2014 01:56:43 AM)    
Dr. BR Ambedkar, made this reservation for 20 years, keeping in mind that India will be a developed country after 20 years. But no!, India is still a Developing Country and its all because of its own government who take the much advantage of reservation. Government wants vote, and for that they need the people of India. They are making this reservation as a base for their votes. Clearly speaking, Reservation is and will create a mass discrimination among us. Earlier it was named Discrimination on caste, now it will be Discrimination on Reservation. If this will continue then, what's the value of the talent of a student who struggled to get a job. Now the present scenario of India in not bad, more than 70% people are in good economic state, but still they need reservation, WHY? This reservation will create a bad environment in every Private Sectors. Talent is what drives the outcome of Private Sectors, not reservation. If reservation will be implemented in private sectors, then we better stop our struggle of getting a good job, stop dreaming of getting into MNCs, because those places are reserved. So why struggle? Why to run? For what we will run? For something where is not recognition of talents, a place where my caste comes first then my talent.

The day private sectors will implement reservation, from that day, the hope of doing a good job will die, and our country will remain as the developing country forever.

Rate this:   +7   -3

Abhinav Jadhav said: (Sat, Sep 6, 2014 01:56:09 PM)    
Hi everybody.

Reservation in private section should not be allowed, because it hurts development of India. It should be given to people who really need it like EBC people really need it. Reservation is main reason for breaking unity of our nation.

Rate this:   +9   -1

Alok said: (Thu, Sep 4, 2014 10:23:31 PM)    
Well friend first of all I am alok and and I am agree with most of the above statements but I would also like to add some points. Well the word reservation was coined by dr bhimrao ambedkar and he comprised this word in constitution for providing extra privilege to the weaker section of the society on the basis of cast, creed and community but for only 20 years. And my dear friends as we are living in 2014 it means we have passed 68 years from our freedom that time the situation was different but now the situation is different and there is no need to follow that rule which was enacted 68 years before.

But as for the current situation of many of the families still reservation is required for whom belong to economically low section of the society. I think government should conduct fresh survey for getting data of the economical conditions of Indian. And government should start a fresh reservation policy on the basis of economical conditions.

As the discussion is about private sector and in this case I am against reservation because if private companies recruit employee for the sake of reservation definitely company will get the unskilled students and this can hamper the progress of company and the progress of our country also. So finally in private sector it is not relevant to give opportunity for the sake of reservation.

Thank you friends.

Rate this:   +23   -0

Ranvijay said: (Wed, Sep 3, 2014 11:51:04 PM)    
I am totally against this reservation system. If a man of general category with great ability in respective field doesn't get job or admission then it is injustice to him. In a democratic country where everyone has equal rights and just because of his caste, if he is not getting the actual treatment which he actually deserve than this is one of the major issue which everyone should worry. Government should make active decision on this.

Rate this:   +3   -1

Sourabh Saxena said: (Wed, Sep 3, 2014 07:38:39 AM)    
According to my point of view, born qualities such as caste should not be a suitable criterion for deciding the post or rank of a person, rather acquired qualities such as knowledge and ability should decide their place for them.

Rate this:   +3   -0

Saikiran said: (Mon, Sep 1, 2014 11:25:57 PM)    
Our Country has the saying that "ALL ARE EQUAL BEFORE LAW". But, I don't understand why are these reservations for? If they really want to give reservations, it should be given to economically backward people and physically handicapped people. Due to reservation, most of the talented persons not getting good chances. And if the reservation is introduced in private sector, our INDIA won't develop forever.

Rate this:   +24   -0

Neeru said: (Sun, Aug 31, 2014 04:51:51 PM)    
I am myself a reserved category student. I strongly feel that reservation system should be revived. At the time of independence, things were different and on the contemporary basis, it has to be based on financial status. But on the other hand we can't ignore the partiality being practised on the basis of one's caste. So, elimination of casteism holds equal stake for inclusive development of India. According to data by NSSO, only 2% of boys and 0% of girls have benefitted from reservation in their primary education.

Rate this:   +8   -0

Anutash Pareek said: (Wed, Aug 20, 2014 08:34:23 PM)    
Good evening, friends.

I am fairly against reservation system if reservation is gives then gives those people who needs of it for eg. Economic backward people, handicaps people, in all caste system not in st/sc/obc. Because of this India is not growth rapidly and unreserved people not shown their talent.

At present time all peoples are educated but they are dependent on reservation system instead of this they showed their talent for develop our country.

So remove the reservation system as casteism basis.

Rate this:   +22   -6

S.Kumar said: (Wed, Aug 20, 2014 03:28:27 PM)    
I couldn't see any of the friends able to comment with the help of fact data. It's a general talk for many of them without a reality check. People can understand easily some one able to make it with fact data of reservation. Most of the peoples view is against reservation system which otherwise promote deceleration of development.

My opinion is that the people need to speak on cast system and its elimination from society rather than caste based reservation. The level playing ground should be same to all and allow them to compete each other.

Rate this:   +8   -0

Santhosh said: (Wed, Aug 20, 2014 03:04:57 PM)    
In our country reservation is in high rate. That's a curse of our nation. We should stop by moving towards the reservations and free things that was given by the government in the election promises. We must stand our one legs and also help our nation to stand and looking upward than other countries.

Rate this:   +1   -0

Aastha said: (Wed, Aug 20, 2014 12:34:03 AM)    
In my opinion reservation does not create healthy environment. Reservation should be given to only those who really needs it, like people who lacks in terms of money, but reservation in terms of caste is not good. For example there are reservation in almost all the examinations for higher education, and in government jobs, due to which most of the time, the deserving candidate did not get the chance, and the non deserving candidate because of reservation gets selected. So in my views it should be banned, and a lets develop a nation, having reservation free, where every one is equal, and every one has equal opportunity.

Rate this:   +12   -1

Shubham Kharwal said: (Sat, Aug 9, 2014 12:23:33 PM)    
According to my point of view when reservation is implemented by the government by thinking only a social welfare motive that it will uplift the weaker section of your society SC and st mainly but with the passage of time it become a spoon feeding to the lower caste people today in 21st century as by an example when we talk for the development of private sector the reservation in private sector is totally ambiguous it not only harm the private sector but also provide a way to that people who hide from competition. Therefore reservation is only given to the needy physical defect people. As today private sector plays a important role in the development of of any country economy.

Rate this:   +14   -5

Sami said: (Sat, Aug 9, 2014 10:57:59 AM)    
I'm fully against with reservation system. It is having a bad impact on Indian development. I think a man can do everything if he try. We all are educated person. And we know that hard work, willpower, dedication. For a person with these qualities, the sky is the limit. As a obc cast I say reservation system have to remove from our mind as well as our country.

Rate this:   +21   -6

Anuo Ggupta said: (Mon, Aug 4, 2014 03:03:19 PM)    
Hi guys.

I am totally against of reservation, but if the reservation is given on the basis of gender difference (male o female) and for those people who are handicaps then it is fine. But if its given on the basis of "cast" then its not right and not good. Reservation should be given to those people who actually wants. Eg. - handicaps, economically backward, etc.

If cast system and reservation system remains in India then India will never develop. We have to treat everyone as equal. Hence I am against of reservation system.

Rate this:   +37   -2

Maduri said: (Sat, Aug 2, 2014 02:28:05 AM)    

In my opinion reservations should be given. But it should be given to the people who are I need of it immediately. It means the economically backward people, etc. But all of them do not get it. It means that only some people are getting in terms of education but remaining people are not getting the reservation though they are talented. It means if a forward caste student is talented enough but not getting reservation. It makes him disappointed to his life. Therefore reservation should be equally given based on their economical status and also based on their talent.

Rate this:   +16   -7

Prudvi said: (Fri, Aug 1, 2014 07:47:21 PM)    
Hi everyone.

In my opinion reservation system is not implementing in correct way. The politicians using this system as for their advantage.

And also by this system India is not developing. If reservation system is introduced in private sector, this sector also not developed well. And also economical growth of India lost. Because, if you can seen in public sector the quality of every thing is less. But in private sector every thing is quality even a small thing. Because they recruits on merit basis (75% to 95%), they don't want caste (SC/st/obc). But public sector recruits on caste.

Quality makes anything, but caste ruins everything.

Rate this:   +13   -4

Vivek said: (Fri, Aug 1, 2014 12:31:20 PM)    
We already having such reservation issue in government sector. So there is no need to apply such sick rules in private sector. People have right to get what they deserve according to their knowledge and what they are capable of.

Rate this:   +19   -1

Sharad said: (Wed, Jul 30, 2014 01:31:42 PM)    
According to me there are people economically backward in all the castes & also economically stable. The benefit of reservation does not reach to the actually required people as the reservation is given on the basis of caste. The reservation should be given to person who are economically backward & not to the particular caste. So the benefits can be used by the actually required people. On the basis of caste the benefits are taken by the economically stable person also.

Rate this:   +18   -0

Ridhima said: (Sun, Jul 27, 2014 09:17:39 AM)    
According to me this reservation system is ruining our country and the people. It is the government of India which upheld that all are equal before law. Then why this? it is true that before and after few years of independence this was very essential. But now the time has changed and even the thoughts of people. They are educated now. And no longer believe those superstitions, so when people are ready to compete with their own abilities. Why is that reservation still there? So, in my view reservation should be given to those who are economically backward and not for the caste. We should keep in mind that we are all human beings.

Rate this:   +23   -2

Mann said: (Fri, Jul 25, 2014 10:15:52 PM)    
According to me there should be equality but how can we ignore these people they even have not got opportunities in past we can turn pages and look into the history they were treated like animals they were not allowed to study even not to touch anybody by coining them as "untouchable". These SC/ST/OBC are those which lies below BPL.

Now, how equality can be considered? even in present they don't have money to support education and the competition is among these reserved category people only but not among those general they are not admitted to any general seats and neither generals are admitted to any reserved seats.

In the last I would ask a question assume there's a race competition and some players are placed very far from starting line and then asked to win the race what would be probability that they will win the race? the answer is null and these "some" players are referred to as reserved category people how will they win if they are not supported? if all are saying to maintain equality then first make these people in a position where they are provided all the needs then we can remove the reservations. ALL I SUPPORT IS THE TERM "EQUALITY".

Rate this:   +14   -16

Mishti said: (Tue, Jul 22, 2014 08:58:31 PM)    
Hi everyone,

India is getting more poor due to this reservation system. Many skilled and talented Indians who mainly coming under General category are leaving India in search of good opportunities and thus spending their knowledge on other countries development, just because India is not realizing the need of the talented people for development.

And if the reservation system is removed and candidates are taken for jobs based on their merit then India may have moved forward.

If a person under SC community has got a Government job (Engineer, obviously by reservation) it means he is earning a handsome amount (4.5LPA) with medical and other facilities then why his Son/Daughter are given the SC reservation again. On what basis he is economically down.

Not only that, In power plant operations even if there is a small mistake it is going to damage the whole system, then why the less talented people are recruited for the sake of reservation.

Yes, there are also students under SC /ST community with good merit, then why to accomplish the reservation system to recruit them, Let them come out of their community shell and compete with their aged candidates with same qualification based on their talent.

Thank God, Private sectors are based on merit as it need not showcase the people for votes as Politicians do. Politicians can have this sensible thinking why the private companies are offering more salaries and have high turnovers just because they have selected talented people.

Finally, RESERVATION SYSTEM is having a bad impact on India's development.

And if at all this system cannot be eliminated then instead of community certificates for recruitment and choosing of college, the Government must ask for the Parents Pay Slip to check for their economic status.

Rate this:   +57   -4

Anil Kumar Reddy said: (Sat, Jul 19, 2014 04:44:28 PM)    
Hello friends. In that present situation reservation is useful only politicians, not for students. They crash entire our life and also our talent, based on these reservations. Why I'm saying that is for example if a student get 90 marks out of 100, he don't get the job because of he belongs to "OC" candidate. But another cast person (sc/st) get 70 marks, he get the job because of reservations.

What is that ? This is correct for us ? Our ministers and prime ministers can say for us "all the indians are equal" so then that situation getting the jobs are also equal but why the reservation is implemented? based on these reservation most of the talent persons will go to other countries. Then how to developing our country. Finally what's my answer is reservatio can be avoid then also our India will become a number 1 Place. Thank you friends and thank you for giving this opportunity.

Rate this:   +8   -6

Shanu said: (Sat, Jul 19, 2014 12:53:53 AM)    
All of us know that we have a right called as right to equality in our constitution. But the practical scenario of the reservation system does not prove it. PEOPLE FROM GENERAL CASTE HAVING SAME ECONOMIC BACKGROUND ARE NOT GETTING WHAT THE PEOPLE FROM SC/ST ARE GETTING. So is this called the right to equality? The main motto of the reservation system was to raise the position or standard of the people of the backward classes (i.e. people having low income and low standard of living) in the society. But today's scenario is quite different. People who are now able to stand on their own feet (may be due to this system only) find it hard to leave this system. Son and daughter of rich persons who can easily afford the expenditures of their children are availing this system till date.

The result of which is being bared or entertained by the general caste people. Now this system has been a burning problem for the general caste people. That the day when the general caste people forms some association and demand a general caste kota & create a kind of unwanted environment in the society is not too far, can't be said. The general people are really finding it hard for their Progress in education as well as jobs. This reservation system should only be allowed for really poor and people from backward community.

Rate this:   +4   -1

Saikumar said: (Wed, Jul 16, 2014 12:19:47 AM)    
As per my View in Indian Education Reservation is only for who are unable to get Money to Study Education and good knowledge persons also According to the rank based and caste based everything Remove the reservation system then India will develop in all aspects and more Students will get bright future.

Rate this:   +3   -0

Ani said: (Tue, Jul 15, 2014 03:37:59 PM)    
Hi everyone,

After reading below stated views of the participants. It is clear that everyone is fed up with this system of caste based reservation.

But reservation in itself is not a bad thing, the problem arises when it is given to unworthy people.

So what I feel is there should be reservations to a very limited extent, but they should not be caste based, instead they should be given considering the ability and the financial background of the candidate.

Because there are people who are not financially sound and do not enjoy the luxury and opportunity what other people with equal caliber as theirs do.

So these candidates should be given special consideration through reservation, whether it is private or public sector, so that their talent do not go in vain.

Rate this:   +7   -0

Rajshree Dwivedi said: (Sun, Jul 13, 2014 12:59:13 PM)    
Reservation had been imposed with a motive to enhance and support the educationally and socially backward classes. The criteria which has been devised is caste, which for a period of time was needed in India, but certainly it is not made for indefinite period.

The criteria of reservation should be changed to some method which calculate it on the basis of the financial status, resources available etc. For instance there are two peons one of the general category and the other of reserved category, both of them cannot send their child to coaching for any xyz exam. Both have the same resources and facility still the opportunity for the reserved will be more.

So criteria is wrong not the reservation policy. By changing criteria in specified time and by a proper committee, it can be freed as a politician tool used for vote bank.

If properly implemented it will be beneficial for the society. It should be ONLY implemented in the private sector if above mentioned things are taken care, otherwise unreserved category will be between Scylla and Charybdis.

Rate this:   +4   -2

Rajan said: (Wed, Jul 9, 2014 06:58:07 PM)    
When we say backward communities, what we actually mean is the community of people who have a lower income, low living standards and lesser access to resources than what we call is sufficient. Rather than classifying backward communities on the basis of caste, certain quantifying techniques should be developed which can quantify backwardness of an individual based on which he can have a particular grade of backwardness. Religion and caste are not a good criteria to judge backward communities. As a suggestion, family income, assets owned by the family access to resources etc. Are certain measures which can be included while developing the backwardness index. This approach would definitely help in proper distribution of the advantage of reservation.

This could be implemented in private companies too where after selecting talent, they would choose people from a backward background without compromising on talent.

Rate this:   +3   -4

Nitish said: (Wed, Jul 9, 2014 06:11:52 PM)    
Reservation should be on the basis of income levels, not on caste basis. Castes are considered for the politicians vote bank only. In India the talent should be increased by giving more opportunities. In upper caste also there are backward people and in lower castes also there are people who settled well on the basis of caste, that persons who settled must withdraw their sons or future generations on utilisation of reservations so that others who are backward can be utilised.

Rate this:   +5   -2

Piyush said: (Tue, Jul 8, 2014 04:32:11 PM)    
According to me. I think, Everyone here is talking about the disadvantage of reservation or their hateness for reservation, but I want to tell you all my fellows that India is still a poor country and in our country people are still treating #Dalits and SC/ST very badly, Even SO called educated people of metro cities are also treats bad ! so my point is just that, I know general category guys can say that reservation is not good as it is difficult for them, But the ground reality is very different from your thinking! SO I don't think that reservation in private sector will raise new hopes. I think everyone is jealous of reservation.

Before talking about reservation all I want to say is just that first stop behaving on the basis of cast then talk about stopping reservation!

Rate this:   +20   -19

Kratika Pandiya said: (Tue, Jul 8, 2014 09:00:54 AM)    
After the 66 years of independence, if up till now the reservations of seats for minority classes in different states i.e. SC's and ST's is going on then I think this is also the obstacle in the path of the development of India.

Since the eligible person don't get the seat and the SC's occupies the seat. For the service or job seats are reserved which leads to the small no of seats left for the others i.e.little probability for getting job.

For the students sicking admission in institutions for further studies, have to buy form but why the cost is different for SC's and others? At the half of the cost paid by others have to be paid by SC's.

Assuming that they doesn't have money, Then also after seeking to the high posts why their wards gets these facilities.

The cutoff marks is different for SC's and others. The person who possess the seat didn't get it because SC's and ST's take it even they have less qualifications and marks.

Then the promotion of SC's and ST's get at 3 years and general after 5 years. The eligibility criteria for any exam or for service is different for others and for SC's. That means WITHIN THE SERVICE PERIOD OF 10 YEARS SC's AND ST's GET 3 PROMOTIONS WHILE OTHERS ONLY 2, Why such a discrimination ?

Besides this the politicians make profit of this for their vote bank by promising them to increase the reservation percentage. This is a question among us where should the persons not coming under the category of SC's and ST's should lead so their is proper justice, they doesn't have to sit at home with high qualifications?

Rate this:   +5   -5

Vimal said: (Mon, Jul 7, 2014 11:15:00 PM)    
If government gives all job oppurtunities to a SC/ST community alone then where does the other community people go for their survival. No survivor can say that all poor people in this country are SC/STs. I think this is not a mistake by the government alone. It is a mistake by every government officials (especially SCs) in all sector of govt of India. The government officials wants to give the job opportunities for their own community members.

So, in public sector the govt give full mandatory to the officials and the recruitment should be strictly governed by the central government at least in upcoming days. To rectify this problem the govt should fix a common cut off in all exams (No relaxed cut off for SC/STs). If they really belong to poverty line then the government should give relaxation in exam fees, education fees, etc. But not in a competitive exam cut off.

Rate this:   +3   -2

Sathya said: (Thu, Jul 3, 2014 05:11:12 PM)    
I think reservations are necessary for the upliftment of the backward castes like scheduled castes and tribes because they are not reachable to the modern world. There are many people who are gifted in the rural and backward areas but they are not getting better help for reaching the modern jobs in the mnc companies. Because of their ignorance and poverty they are not seeing the modern world. Already the Indian government is recruiting backward castes to fulfill the reservations in the jobs. Like this the private companies also should hire in the backward areas for the sake of scheduled tribes and scheduled castes. But there are also merit students in other castes also.

So the jobs must be not corruption or caste based it should be merit based.

Rate this:   +8   -17

Vijay said: (Tue, Jul 1, 2014 03:43:53 PM)    
Hai friends. Reservation also one of the major reason for economy drawback for the country. Talent persons are not getting opportunity in public sectors. It spoil the government. But the private sectors are different from the public sector. They require only quality.

Rate this:   +14   -5

Niraj Rai said: (Sun, Jun 29, 2014 10:52:57 PM)    
I strongly feel that the time has come to eradicate the reservation system from our country. After independence, it was the need of hour to bring reservation for the DALITS. So Dr. B. R Ambedkar brought it for them. But now the situation has almost changed. For instance, if a person belonging to SC/ST criteria is an engineer, then why should the same reservation should be given to his children.

I also believe that reservation is weakening our country. Because people getting job through reservation are not as much talented as unreserved people.

In addition to these, reservation should be given on the basis of economical condition, instead caste.

Our constitution says that we all are equal, then why there are reservation. This time needs talent so as to contribute for the development of our country, not the reservation.

Rate this:   +46   -3

Sunil said: (Mon, Jun 23, 2014 04:20:20 PM)    
Reservation. Why? Reservation can never be a solution of any problem but its itself a problem. Our constitution says that we all are equal but I don't feel that in our country. If all are equal then why there is a reservation to particular section of society. I just give one small eg. Which shows how reservation is ruining our whole country. If an ST/SC candidate becomes an IAS officer still his son/daughter will get reservation. Now I just want to ask one question. How they are backward when their father is an IAS officer and can fulfill their all requirement related to studies, upbringing etc. I just want to slap politicians who cannot stop this reservation and using it for VOTE BANK.

Rate this:   +29   -5

Amrit Kumar said: (Sun, Jun 22, 2014 09:57:47 AM)    
Hello friends I am Amrit and I believe that there is no reservation category in private sector because backbone of private sector is quality and quantity and if you are compromising with talent and experience then it shows that our quality, productivity and brand value gets decrease. If this thing happens so you are out of market.

Rate this:   +7   -3

Swapnil said: (Sun, Jun 22, 2014 12:23:34 AM)    
Hi one and all present here.

Reservation in private sector is just a foolish kiddy thing. Reservation was given by Dr. Ambedkar for just 10 years for the upliftment of dalits, economically backward class, so that they can have there own stand, now its going till now for no reasons. Thats very cruel.

In this world of competition, preference should be given to the talent not to the reservation, for the betterment of the nation.

Rate this:   +5   -2

Sudhakar said: (Thu, Jun 19, 2014 12:19:46 AM)    
After independence Shri Ambedkar ji bring reservation through Indian constitution was the most important need at that time. At that time some complete sections of society are living their life under very adverse conditions. So reservation was a very important need at that time but now we are entered in modern India things are completely changed now, almost there was a development in all sections of country now time has come to do some required changes in constitution and stop giving reservation to people on the basis of caste. I don't understand what our politicians are doing the know very well that for development of our country we need more and more talent & reservation is creating a problem in finding top talent then also for vote bank the are supporting reservation.

Rate this:   +9   -6

Priyavart said: (Mon, Jun 16, 2014 08:56:40 PM)    
Hello friends.

Reservation should never be on the basis caste, gender and religion of a person. It creates differences between the people and deprived people from the basic RIGHT OF EQUALITY given in our constitution. Our leaders had provided reservations to uplift backward societies but know our political leaders have changed the definition of reservation they use this to establish their vote bank and they exploit minority peoples for their interests.

If govt want to provide the reservation it should be given to physically handicapped and financially handicapped people. They actually deserve this provision.


Rate this:   +11   -1

Gurpreet Kaur said: (Thu, Jun 12, 2014 07:19:44 PM)    
According to my opinion reservations should not be allowed in private sectors. As we all know that competition is so high, a student has to do a lot of hard work and he or she has to give his complete life for clearing one exam. In government sector most of the seats are reserved for backward classes at last students belongs to general category are left with few seats. Even in some govt exam general seats are only 1 or 2.

So students of this category are fighting for this few seats only. So this directly affects the future of student of general category. So these students has to shift towards the private sector. If reservations are allow in private also then where will these students move. So in some how we are helping backward classes but also taking the rights of other people. In this way our country will remain as it is no improvements will be there.

Rate this:   +28   -4

Ricky Raj said: (Tue, Jun 10, 2014 05:23:24 PM)    
At the time of independence reservation given for the upgradation of backward or schedule castes because at this time their economical or social condition was not good.

And decided to vanish this after some time but after 60 years independence reservation are still continue due to poor politics of our country our leaders use their reservation.

System vote bank they can't understand what problem face by the students or the people of our country many skill people not able to found according to their ability.

I think reservation is not bad but by the system a/c to which reservation given is not good it can be given by economic or social condition of a person or family because today there are a large no of people who required reservation system but can't found because of the system.

Rate this:   +5   -5

Geetu said: (Tue, Jun 10, 2014 04:02:11 PM)    
In my opinion its high time for India to remove the reservation system. It is making the youngsters to work less but rely more on their caste to get a job in government organizations.

But for the relief of other youngsters there are private firms that hire people based on skills rather than on their caste. This reservation system has made students to commit suicides because they are not enrolled in their dream colleges even though they get good marks from their counterparts belonging to lower castes.

The reservations should only be given to those who are economically and socially backwards rather than based on castes. The differently abled people should also be given reservation.

Rate this:   +11   -2

Rohit Bhattacharjee said: (Wed, Jun 4, 2014 04:06:25 PM)    
The reservation system that has been in place in our country, was meant to be for those, who were oppressed, and did not have the necessary exposure to education, and opportunities which were available to other classes of the society. Sadly, now that the state and the severity of the caste system has been reduced, the reservation system, like any other law in this country is being exploited by the people who are rich, and do not deserve it.

The problem with reservations in any sector is that people who are bot deserving of a position of work, gets the job, and then, the quality of work is diminished. But, we still have to keep in mind those who might have the talent and necessary skills, but are truly oppressed and don't have the opportunity to apply for high profile private sector jobs, which we are given exposure to.

That is still no excuse for introducing reservations in the private sector, but if reservations in the education system can be tightened with a few other rules like family income and history, then maybe the kids who really have the talent might come up, and couldn't come up till now for various reasons. The percentage should also be reduced, and a rigorous screening process must be employed.

But all this should be done only till school education. After that, everyone should be treated equally, and fairly. No matter what back ground you are, you should be selected for your talent and ability alone, and no other factor.

Rate this:   +5   -1

Arun Sreeram said: (Sun, May 25, 2014 10:11:27 AM)    
Reservation is for the people who are not skillful. It is amended as a part of our constitution so as to encourage the people to become literates. But this system has ruined the talented and the skillful personalities. All the one who are highly skilled and talented are not given any preference due to this reservation system. It is far better to restrict this system till some extent of the education system because the one who is talented is not coming out and he/she is made discouraged by this system.

Reservation system made Indian people go abroad and settle there, there by all the skilled personalities are involving in the development of foreign countries but not Ours.

Reservation in private sector leads to the same. It meant that the private sector does not require a talented or a skillful person. So the reservation system should be avoided in the Private or in the public sectors. Reservation should be encouraged to some extent and beyond that it is to be avoided. Otherwise it is a loss to the entire Nation.

Rate this:   +5   -3

Thakurji Gupta said: (Thu, May 22, 2014 11:39:27 AM)    
Reservation is given for those who are not able to do some task which general people can do.

But after the drafting of constitution of India Government is misusing the Reservation weapon for fighting in election with others. And low caste peoples are also benefitted by the government scheme. In my point of view reservation should be given to those who are not economically and socially equal whether it may be any caste. But providing reservation in privatisation may lead to negative growth of Indian economy because people then are selected by reservation not by their skill and talent.

So, In real world there are always tough competitions in private organisation in that case that can be won by skilled labour with great technical talent with management values.

Rate this:   +21   -2

Sampad Ganguly said: (Tue, May 20, 2014 08:13:26 PM)    
As far as I am concerned, reservation is needed for that kind of people only who are not physically able and can not afford initiative as much as we can to get a job, as they are not totally fit, reservation should be introduced to those peoples only, other wise we talk about equality and in the other side we introduce this type of concept, this is no cool.

Rate this:   +4   -6

M.Anuhya said: (Sat, May 17, 2014 05:12:56 PM)    

I can say that Reservation is killing the "Skill of people", due to this students are not working hard to gain more knowledge.

On the other hand we are happy that private sector are not introducing these reservations, because they are looking for the skilled workers and that is why the private organizations are earning more profits than government organizations.

Knowledge & Intelligence are the most important things which makes the country to move forward.

I just want to say one thing that these reservations will be there today but not tomorrow but our skill remains with us until our last breath, and the respect we get from others does not depend on "our cast or religion or gender" depends on what we have done for our society and how did we prove ourselves.

Let us remove the reservations. We are all equal. We are indians.

Rate this:   +30   -3

True Indian said: (Tue, May 13, 2014 05:41:35 PM)    
Reservation is the need of a country as it promotes the growth of any country, because by reservation a competitive environment is created (for people who are devoid of it) , it will help in both way; the people getting reservation will definitely get good jobs, promotions, fee concessions and so many benefits; on the other way the person not having reservation has to do more hard work as they have to "achieve" all the things and not merely get in "gift"; so in this way a country can develop in rapid manner, ensuring well being of everyone.

If there is reservation in government sector then why not in private sector as if government has imposed it so there should be some reason which is in favour of everyone.

Reservation but not the basic facilities (who literally want it) is the need of today as giving reservation is easy, money saving, better and fast way to ensure development, while giving basic facilities is time consuming, long process, lot of money is required, which we can use in other areas.

So, reservation is demand of today as person having it can use their valuable time in some other good works, and ensure their development as well as of the country.

Rate this:   +28   -40

Chandan said: (Tue, May 6, 2014 04:29:08 AM)    
Reservation system, do you feel that leads to a developed nation. I believe it never does. For instance, there are many universities where the SC/ST quota seats are vacant only due to non availability of the candidates. And those seats are not given to the deserving or wait list students from general quota.

Who does this reservation empower, if a person is SC/ST, that gets the benefit of SC/ST as well as unreserved sections. Even the richer people from SC/ST take advantages more than weaker one. Today we see the condition of government organizations. There employees don't even talk politely to their consumers.

Think about the condition of private sector, what will happen if reservation is guaranteed, it will never grow like other government institutions.

I believe, there should be margin of qualification like a SC/ST candidate has to score less than a General candidate. But there should not be any reservations for any caste. That should be one of the best thing.

Rate this:   +23   -10

Tejaasvi Bhogra said: (Mon, May 5, 2014 11:18:13 AM)    

I too completely disagree on the concept of reservations in private sector. At one side we talk about the right to equality and at other side we are making fun of this by introducing the concept of reservations. I think we even should not have reservation even public sector. The reservation should be provided to handicapped and BPL people, Rest of us should have equal right to compete. The private sectors need quality of work and it can be provided by people which can be any from any caste, no matter reserved or general.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +25   -7

Shri said: (Wed, Apr 30, 2014 03:07:21 PM)    
Hi Friends,

I am totally disagree with reservation in private as well as government sector.

Because to do particular job required that level skill and knowledge but if we appointing on that position less knowledgeable person then it is totally wrong.

According to me this reservation system should be closed and as per the candidates knowledge and skill he must be got a job in all sector. I think reservation is OK till school or college but not in jobs.

Thanks you Friends.

Rate this:   +15   -6

Debasmita said: (Sun, Apr 27, 2014 11:10:53 AM)    
In my opinion reservation should be given to those who are needy not to those who belong to SC/ST or OBC. Jobs and Competetive exams should not include reservation. Reservation should be given for basic education which will give equal opportunity to compete. Private organisations give first priority to customer satisfaction which is the main key to draw more business from the customer. Customer is satisfied only when organisation is able to deliver quality product which in turn requires skilled workforce. So if reservation is included then organisations may have to compromise with their quality of work which in turn may result in losing the customer.

Rate this:   +13   -5

Raveena Sharma said: (Sat, Apr 26, 2014 03:41:48 PM)    
I think there should not be any kind of reservation in the private sector. Because due to this, general people are badly affected. A few years ago, there is time when sc/st people are under privileged. And at that time to get them developed in education, quota was given. But now, this reservation quota should not be there. Because, reserved people had got developed in every field. It is also a type of corruption in our country to give any benefit 2 reserved people. But there should be quota for below poverty line people, cancer affected people etc. To make the India developed.

Rate this:   +10   -3

Abcd said: (Tue, Apr 22, 2014 12:53:34 PM)    
I Strongly disagree to have reservation on both private and Govt sectors.

How one can do job without having required skill. Most of the government organizations running with loss as there is reservation in it. I encouraged to have reservation in education to make people capable of doing job.

Rate this:   +13   -6

Samiksha said: (Sat, Apr 19, 2014 08:46:41 PM)    
Hello friends,

I want to say that, at the place of giving reservation, give them qualification. Provide facility to be educated, and training to each person so that they can participate equally on the basis of their qualification and talent, not on the basis of reservation.


Rate this:   +10   -2

Manjari said: (Wed, Apr 16, 2014 09:02:43 PM)    
I do not think that reservation should be based on caste because we all are equal. If someone belongs to SC/ST or OBC that does not mean that he is undeveloped, uneducated or poor. There are many people belonging to general category, are poor and their condition is so bad.

Rate this:   +41   -7

Brk said: (Tue, Apr 15, 2014 11:35:38 AM)    
Reservations in private sector is like digging our own grave yard, it is an obstruction for nations development. If the government wants to bring up the poor government can provide loans for their education strictly for BPL (below poverty line) families and ask them to compete with others, giving free education and free job is meaning less, people taking reservation facility are not helping government in any manner, instead they are expecting more benefits from government shamelessly. Unfortunately governments are using reservations as vote bank which is clear cut negative indication for nations development.

Rate this:   +17   -5

Rattan said: (Mon, Apr 14, 2014 06:19:58 PM)    
There is need to abolish caste system, then the question of reservation should be thinked upon. Caste system is shameful, dirty and bad for hindu system of living. Everybody is equal and was differentiated as per their work. Till caste system is there, reservation in govt as well as private institutions should be there. Why upper castes are taking reservations of castes of their forefathers. Nobody should be allowed to write the business/caste of their forefathers with their names and they should designate themselves with their present work/business/caste. The caste was originally the work of person/community which he/that did.

Rate this:   +14   -6

Dhamm Kirti Vikram said: (Mon, Apr 14, 2014 02:39:33 AM)    
Reservation is necessary in all sectors. Because there are some marginalized sections of society who were kept out of their fundamental rights basic needs like education, medical, self respect etc and the most interesting point was that the discrimination was solely on the basis of CASTE not economic health of a person.

Hence these oppressed classes need empowerment as whole on the basis of caste. It is our policy failure that even after 63 years of Independence we failed to empower these sections of society upto satisfactory level as expected by our fathers of constitution who insert the provision of reservation in constitution.

If our reservation policy were fail and we were also fail to give there rights over there resources then there will be two consequences of the same. Here I just want to mention the fact that the real native dwellers are those who are getting reservation that is SC/ST and those who exploited SC/ST are the aryans (upper caste) came from abroad hence logically the share of resources must be higher for SC/ST but scene is exactly opposite.

Now the first consequence will be the same as in USA and AUSTRALIA where the tribal (native dwellers) are still living in forest and living lives traditionally and the govt doesn't treat them as a citizen and never thought about them and still marching the way of development. And the second consequence is revolt like Naxalism which is a big threat to national security is also a result of our failure to protect them from exploitation.

Ultimately I want to say that to insure collective development we have to implement reservation policy effectively and at every stage as needed.

Rate this:   +23   -15

Mukesh said: (Fri, Apr 11, 2014 02:06:58 PM)    
Today many caste take reservation but no effect in change in life only reservations profit rich person not a poor man. Only political view this is take a reservation in sc, , st, obc etc. Reservations is create a problem in many community.

Rate this:   +8   -7

Deepshikha said: (Thu, Apr 10, 2014 04:15:39 PM)    
Hello friends, I don't think that reservation should be provided in private sectors as its not helping in the development of our country, its not helping poor. Many of the reserved category people are already developed and are rich enough but still they are prioritized over the poor and needy people who belong to general category. So, in my opinion reservation should be provided to poor and needy people to develop our country and not to SC/ST/OBC.

Rate this:   +23   -4

Jitendra said: (Mon, Apr 7, 2014 06:17:38 PM)    
I do not agree with reservation system in anywhere in the world. As its simply showing talent hunting. Due to which our all public sector companies are dancing like ship in the sea, not progressive since so many years. One more example. Look your colleges, technical schools where in the entrance examination 90% obtained person not get chance but to full the reservation quota any one can with pass marking only. It's simply showing talent hunting.

In private sector if reservation will come then that will a disaster day for India as per my opinion.

For Example :: Taking IT sector in India. In today date we are best in world just because of outsourcing the talent and getting lots of revenue in foreign currency. Are you Agree ?

If private sector has reservation. Then talent hunting in private sector also. Resulted we'll week in the talent that means loss of project result loss of revenue. We offshores countries will not truant on our talents as there is no process to filter out talents. In simple disaster day for all.

This one example. We can take much more than that. In Manufacturing, In marketing etc. There is lot of example we can think.

What we can do for the lower side people to grow;

- Free education for needed till they want take.
- Job oriented educations where they can sustain easily.
- Food for needed people only.
- Home for needed one only.
- Health care for all categories.

- etc. Which help people to become self-dependent instead of reservation dependent (Handicapped walkers - Crutch).

It's simply increasing distance between communities of India. Its result will be again a home war or Division like Pakistan.

Rate this:   +19   -7

Swapnil Singh said: (Sat, Apr 5, 2014 08:01:53 PM)    
Hi friends according to my view government has started to giving the reservation by saying that a particular "CASTE" is backward, it means they have lack of facilities, opportunities and equality. So my question is that by merely giving a reservation and not solving the root cause will never solve the problem.

You will give them basic facilities like health care, ensure education so they will compete globally. If You are very hungry and I will give you money not food, will not fulfill your hunger. In the same way give the facilities which needy people are deprived off to ensure equal opportunities to them which in true sense is helping them.

Rate this:   +21   -3

Anil Jain said: (Fri, Apr 4, 2014 10:59:37 PM)    
Yes I do agree that as social responsibility there should be reservation in private sector. But the person once got the reservation, his next two generation shall not be allowed any reservation benefit. This rule should also be applicable to public sector, so that the benefit of reservation should reach to all.

Rate this:   +14   -20

Vaibhavi said: (Fri, Apr 4, 2014 03:03:05 PM)    
To all my brother and sister I have to share my opinion that development doesn't mean to development of rich and upper caste people it is all about development of poor and lower caste people if we develop our country in that way then our country will develop in true manner. So there will be reservation to those people who needed it much more in private sector. Because now the condition is that rich becomes richer and poor becomes more poor. Thank you.

Rate this:   +4   -25

Shruti said: (Thu, Apr 3, 2014 08:52:48 PM)    
In private sector if there are two candidate for same post having same talent and knowledge but there is only 1 vacancy then what you consider for the jobs. Of Course they will give prefer to caste and you will give upper caste candidate priority first for jobs because mentality is that they are more talented than lower caste. First we have to change that mentality. If they consider jobs on the basis of caste. Therefore there must be reservation for lower caste.

Rate this:   +7   -29

Raghunanda said: (Thu, Apr 3, 2014 01:31:31 PM)    

Before debating on reservation system in private sector. We should first try to know what percent of reservation is proposed for private sector and proportion of that percentage to different categories like SC/ST/OBC. Also, we need to have a sample survey data of number of Employees Working in Private Sector and their respective categories they belong.

After getting the primary data of Employees Already Working in the Private Sector who falls under categories like SC/ST/OBC and the proposed percentage of reservation, we can think further on this matter. If already employed people belonging to backward category exceeds the proposed percentage of reservation, then there is already auto implementation of the reservation policy in private sector.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +4   -4

Parag said: (Mon, Mar 31, 2014 05:18:36 PM)    
In private colleges there is no reservation but there is management quota, similarly in private industries they have the power to recruit anybody their own related people, no rules, nobody talks about that. In that case no one watch their talent its just about money. Most of thee Upper cast people have the power of money so they can get job easily and admission. But people with lower cast and financial weak people have to face many problems. Talented doesn't means they are honest. Most of doctors are upper cast it is not only because they are talented but also they have money from their generations for education fees. And financial weak people don't have enough money for higher education. Everybody knows that there is more money in private industries than govt sector. To make financial strong to these people there must be some reservation in private industries.

Rate this:   +13   -21

Ashish Sutar said: (Fri, Mar 28, 2014 12:22:13 AM)    
Everyone has spoken about the negative effects of implementation of reservation system by Dr.Babasaheb Ambedkar, I too agree with you all, I would like to add one misuse of reservation system which is in politics, I mean the candidate who stands for election if he is an obc/sc/st or even lower caste candidate he is prefered for election rather than the one who is open/general candidate, here again the caste difference is preferred instead the person's capability is ignored, how the person who is an obc/sc/st be able to solved the local problems of the people? likewise many more questions remained unanswered due the commencement of the reservation system, so according to me there should be a complete ban on the reservation system which will greatly help for the progress of the country.

Rate this:   +7   -3

M Ravi said: (Thu, Mar 27, 2014 05:09:02 PM)    
Reservation and secularism are being used by political parties to divert the public attention from major issues like corruption, black money and price rise. These two are very sensitive so that people forget about the 3 major areas. In education and employment sectors, govts. Ruled so far have not done anything remarkably. The condition is same when Indian population was 30 crores. Now it is 120 crores nearly four fold increase. Political parties will never implement reservation in allocation of parliamentary seats. For instance in tamilnadu out of 40 seats only one was allotted to SC party. After great struggle they got one more. The demands like retirement age for sc/st as 65, reservation in promotions, reservation in judiciary, defence and sports are in the pipeline. Some of the political parties are not interested in upliftment of backward people but they see that the unreserved category should not come up at any cost.

Rate this:   +2   -3

Rohit Kaim said: (Thu, Mar 27, 2014 11:56:40 AM)    
Till the time based prejudice lives, our countrymen have to bear the baggage of reservation. Just an FYI, representation of marginalized society is minimal in media, sports, film industry etc. (less than .01%) because there is no reservation but nevertheless, there are talented people in all societies and castes so why there is negligible representation over there? Truth is caste based profiling by current incumbents in these industries. We live in a country where in merit comes after your surname, so branded surname are always preferred in any sphere of our social lives.

I am not in favor of reservation in any form, but if you study the social makeup of of Indian society, it discriminates on the basis of caste. Pennsylvania university carried out a research with Indian Institute of Dalit Studies, and found out that in corporate india, there exists caste based discrimination in hiring. So if someone is ostracized on the basis of caste, what option do we have to bring her/him, in the mainstream?

Guys just ponder over this!

Rate this:   +6   -2

S.P. Tripathi said: (Wed, Mar 26, 2014 06:18:38 PM)    
Hi friends,

In my opinion reservation in private sector will make inequality among the candidates and make the unfortunate to the candidates who are talented but belongs from the upper caste.

Further private sectors are providing jobs only to those candidate who are highly qualified, talented and good personality irrespective of their caste.

This step also will make lower caste people lazy in their preparation for job hence will result in low level of efficiency.

Rate this:   +9   -3

Shivangi said: (Wed, Mar 26, 2014 04:46:58 PM)    
There should not be any reservation in private sector.

Reservation leads to discrimination among different castes. If a person desires to be in a job or service then he/she must work hard for the position.

Candidates who have good grades, have high efficiency are struggling and are not able to find jobs because of high competition. On top of it if reservation will also appear in private jobs it will only lead to downfall. If we want development then the people who qualify their test interviews should be given jobs. There should not be any question regarding their castes.

If a person deserves it then he/she should have it irrespective of the caste he/she belongs.

Rate this:   +5   -2

Vidya said: (Tue, Mar 25, 2014 10:02:00 PM)    
We are only reinforcing caste thru all these schemes! First of all, there should not be reservation in Jobs. We have reservation in Education. In Tamil Nadu its arnd 69%. It makes sense to some extent. If they have the talent they should study properly and get a good job. These kind of systems will only make young Indians lazy and make them dependent on these kinda schemes rather than talent. It is overall bad for our country. Also if at all they bring these it should be based on the economic situation of the family and not caste. Strongly condemn these kinda stupid proposals!

Rate this:   +23   -12

Dsr said: (Tue, Mar 25, 2014 08:57:43 PM)    
Why India is not developed because this is one of the reason reservation.

Most of talented person in higher caste they can't do anything because source are not available for them.

For ex.

By reservation lower caste person got doctor job in govt then what about the patient?

By observing in public and private. In private companies higher caste people only there because there is no reservation. In public sector most of lower caste people are there because there is reservation with high percentage.

Rate this:   +25   -11

Diya said: (Sat, Mar 22, 2014 09:10:55 PM)    
Those people who have talking that lower caste people should not get reservation because they are developed they don't need it or reservation divides India. Why those people do intercaste marriage to lower caste people. If you want unity then this is best option also it will help to lower down reservation otherwise for god sake don't talk about unity.

In private sector like media there is no reservation there is "TALENT" and they are working for"TRUTH" and "HUMANITY"then why they cover only news related to the Upper caste problem not cover news related to lower caste violence. When it about shopping, eating then you want international brand not Indian. Should these Indian having no talent. So don't talk rubbish that you care about India. First change yourself and then talk about India. So reservation is needed in private sector also it should be for economically backward class in upper caste. Because everyone having rights to "RISE".

Rate this:   +15   -32

Akshta said: (Sat, Mar 22, 2014 08:19:23 PM)    
If you are talking about talent and merit then there is also no reservation in sports and film industry then why we don't get olympic medal and oscar. Is these people don't having talent or merit? lower caste people get only reservation but upper caste people owns that college. Just like our sportsmen are not equal to compete to foreigners because they didn't get needed training and equipment similarly lower caste people have to face this problem in education.

If upper caste people opposing the reservation then they must donate their lands and property to government that they get from their old generations and then have oppose to reservations and talking about merits. In almost every field upper caste is at the top position in govt or private so why India is still poor and corrupt ? so don't talk rubbish that reservation is the reason behind corruption. There are some people who are economically backward in upper caste they should also get reservation in private and government also lower caste people will also get reservation in private sector.

Rate this:   +15   -28

Vivek said: (Fri, Mar 21, 2014 12:25:53 PM)    
Reservation in private sector is not needed. Because already we have seen what happened in govt sector due to reservation. Highly corrupted system and no jobs for upper caste people. Of course Dr ambedkar started this to create equality in society.

And even he himself mentioned in constitution that reservation would valid for a decade oly. The private sectors are running due to talent not the bull sheet caste. OK let the govt give them good coaching, financial assistance. And of course caste system has to be abolished in the same way reservation too.

Rate this:   +22   -10

Jitendra said: (Thu, Mar 20, 2014 08:48:58 PM)    
Implementing the reservation will remove the lobbying system from the private industries.

Now a days we all know Industry owners are recruiting their own cast HRD people and the HRD in turn recruits their own candidate.

So as reservation is governed by constitutional laws I think this will help in forming a better society and a better country.

Jai ho !

Rate this:   +9   -26

Shantanu Ghosal said: (Mon, Mar 3, 2014 12:35:13 AM)    
Private sector is a highly competitive field and profit driven. The companies out there in the private sector have to continuously evolve and keep updating themselves so as to stay afloat in the market.

For companies which are involved in such a sector, it can be very dangerous to compromise with their talent pool just to satisfy the political aspirations of some people. Its a talent driven sector which recruits talented people to whichever caste or creed they may belong.

Moreover seeing the role the private sector is going to play in future in the development of India inc, it will be very inimical for our country to have the sector compromised like our public sector by introducing baseless reservation laws into it. Talent should be worshiped and that's it !

Rate this:   +18   -7

Mallika said: (Mon, Feb 17, 2014 02:37:52 PM)    
No, reservation in the private sector is not at all needed. If so what will happen to the ones who does not have reservation. Then they will become backward classes. Then after some period of time, they should be given reservation. So better to stop even reservation now. Because according to the constitution reservation was valid only for 10 years. But it was six times the time given. So at least now the reservations should abolish in the mighty India.

Rate this:   +27   -9

Bhagat said: (Fri, Feb 14, 2014 12:47:11 AM)    
The question arises every time in my mind that when Dr. B. R. Ambedkar started the reservation system in our country for 10 years then, why it is needed now? Did 10 years were not enough to eliminate the disparity that we have in our society? And this term 'Reservation' has become the deep rooted problem in this society that every youth and people of this country are getting frustrated out of it. First, we need to understand the society. Dr. B. R. Ambedkar started reservation to upgrade the backward people socially and economically.

In 10 years we have not able to eliminate the difference, therefore the government extended the reservation for several more years. In OBC category we have accomplished to create an equality with a general category people thus, the government has reduced the seats for them in public sectors and in many institutions as well. But for SC/ST we have the reservations. As far as I am concerned about the reservations, out of 100% seats 60% of seats are fixed for the general category & the remaining 40% seats are given to the reservation.

Out of those 40% seats 30% are distributed between the SC and ST & the remaining 10% seats are given to the OBCs, knowing that thousands of people fight for those seats. Still people have problem in this. Those people whose previous generations have never seen educations in their lives or never get the equal opportunities are getting those benefits just to get some hard core education background so that they may able to prepare themselves to educate their next generations. Reservation in the education for 2 generations will be enough to create an equality with respect to social, economical and educational in the society.

Thank you :).

Rate this:   +21   -8

Speak Your Mind:
  • Please do not use chat terms. Example: avoid using "grt" instead of "great".

  • © 2008-2014 by IndiaBIX™ Technologies. All Rights Reserved | Copyright | Terms of Use & Privacy Policy

    Contact us:     Follow us on twitter!