IndiaBIX.com
Search

Reservations in the Private Sector

@ : Home > Group Discussion > Politics - Discussion Room

Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
  • Assume, you one of the member of a real group discussion.
  • Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
  • Express your positive attitude towards providing the solution.

Ronak said: (Fri, Feb 12, 2016 09:52:01 AM)    
 
Hi friends I think there is no need for reservation system in private sector. Because we all know that there is very much rare change for general caste person for an job in public sector due to reservation system.

So if in private sector is also reserve then there is nothing is to mean as equality for India. One side say all persons are equal in the eye of law and one side this reservation system going on.

Rate this:   +0   -0


Goutham said: (Thu, Feb 11, 2016 11:44:21 PM)    
 
It's representation not reservation. I want everyone to ask themselves since how many generations general merit peoples are getting education in India. Its irrelevant to answer because since Vedic age only upper caste men were getting education. Not only sc st obc even upper caste women were not getting education in this society. Because of constitution everyone are getting education. Sc st obc are now opening their account in education field. They are may be in 2nd or 3rd generation.

Compare to you people who had 100% reservation in Vedic age. Present reservation system is null. And you people think sc st obc means only 3 castes but inside them there are 1000 of community who claim for that minimum reservation. Remaining are claimed by 25% of gm people. These 25% people claim more than they deserve in population.

And coming to private sectors. The present percentage government jobs are reduced to avoid the growth of backward communities by allowing private sectors. Almost all private sectors are owned by upper caste peoples who are giving opportunities to their communities. If reservation is not allowed here one fine day these private sectors will replace whole government sector and they'll eradicate constitutional rights.

Due to unemployment backward communities will stop their children to schools. The whole India will be in the hands of 25% people (private sectors) and rest of them will work as slaves in their hands. If opportunities are not given to backward communities its impossible to develop India.

Rate this:   +0   -2


Sundar said: (Thu, Feb 11, 2016 05:45:16 PM)    
 
Reservation is the process/system by which the government promotes the inclusive growth. But now, it has became a family reservation rather than caste reservation. A man who became IFOS or ACP or other administrative and executive jobs in public sector, become financially rich in the society.

According to me, he should be removed from the Quota once he used the opportunity. In India its not happen. His son became educated and he also get good job using Quota, even though he is rich. Already people are agitated against this in many parts as we know.

Completely eliminating the Quota will affect the deserved. Abraham Lincoln said " Government is for the people, by the people, to the people". So It's necessary for inclusive growth. It should be there in Government Sector.

But extending it to the private sector will lead to chaos. Once the reserved people get the Quota education, government's duty is over (According to me) , because they are already empowered. Apart from that, they also have the reservation in the public sector.

Private companies nurture competitiveness, growth. Forcing them to recruit people based on reservation will collapse the system. I am not saying, reserved people are not talented. I am saying if they are talented, let them compete with others. Let them prove themselves to the society and the recruiter.

In the private enterprises point of view, their main aim is profit maximization. Everyone runs company for profit not for charity. For their part, they are doing CSR activities. They are providing employment opportunities to the society.

They are contributing to the growth of GDP. Forcing them and involving in their decision making process will make them frustrated with the system. Then they have other nations, which are ready to welcome them with the red Carpet. Our aim of 7.6% GDP growth and Make in India will vanish in the near future, if it is allowed.

I want my country to grow in a proper way which includes inclusive as well as talent oriented growth. Dear bureaucrats, please think and decide. No reservation in Public sector needed.

Rate this:   +0   -0


Sandeep said: (Thu, Feb 11, 2016 03:29:47 PM)    
 
I do not support reservation. They make genuine candidates deprived of opportunity. You will not find a skilled worker roaming free. But if reservation in private is done, then skilled people will roam free and all the idiots and stupid reserved candidates will have jobs who will go to office and sleep.

Rate this:   +0   -0


Raj said: (Thu, Feb 11, 2016 01:14:43 PM)    
 
Caste based reservations should go, instead reservation should be based on financial status of a person/family. This will deferentially take our country to new level.

Rate this:   +0   -0


Satya said: (Thu, Feb 11, 2016 09:45:40 AM)    
 
Every revolution is born out of foolish implementation of policies and suppressing people. At this rate, we are not far from seeing the jobless poor people of forward castes start a revolution and end this pseudo democracy. God bless our country filled with caste politicians who only know divide and rule policy!

Rate this:   +0   -0


Santosh Suryawanshi said: (Thu, Feb 11, 2016 02:59:26 AM)    
 
Yes I support Reservation,

Even today Jain, Gujju's Marwadi, Punjabi are top industrialist people from SC/ST are from Labour or worker category reservation will help them to uplift their economy. Because of caste system in India human were not treated like human their condition were worst than animal.

So I think first we should abolish caste system from our society, till the caste system and we people say I am Brahmin, I am shatriya, we are Mishra, we are Pandit, we are Iyer, till the time we won't say we are Indian reservation should remain and it constitutional right of Backward class people.

Rate this:   +2   -0


Pradeep said: (Wed, Feb 10, 2016 01:34:50 AM)    
 
How long we want to continue this reservation? And how are we measuring if it's solving purpose or not? People will keep asking reservation irrespective of their need. It's been 70 years and if it's still not working let's abolish it and find the root cause.

How a mere job add a value or improve condition of reserved category instead let's give them facilities and chance to grow by themselves, give them extra classes, training to improve their knowledge/skills. Freebees is not going to help who gets it nor who provides it.

Rate this:   +0   -1


Coolguy said: (Tue, Feb 9, 2016 11:36:44 PM)    
 
Let's keep it simple:

--Reservations for the historically deprived class in education, central & state jobs is valid, as it's the very mandate & duty of theirs to improve their social upwardly & welfare.

--Reservations in private sectors is a disastrous proposition, since they're not obliged to do public service to which they already contribute a substantial part of their incomes as taxes for that very purpose & people elect governments to utilize those funds for the same.

Rate this:   +0   -0


Raj said: (Sat, Feb 6, 2016 06:36:34 PM)    
 
Article 17 of the Constitution abolished untouchability and punishes its practice. Hope, we are all implementing it in letter and spirit! If we add an Article 17A next to this in the Constitution to abolish caste and religious denominations; and punish practice of caste and religious denomination in any form (means practice of religion is OK, but not stratifying within religion) , there is no need for reservation. If it is argued that caste is found only in Hinduism, it is possible to assume caste is a religious-denomination.

Reservation for local nationals is being practiced globally, wherever migrant masses are large in number for employment. Even industries opened up by Indian businessmen abroad are bound to give quota for the national manpower.

Different parts of the world need different type of affirmative action. Reservation system evolved in India is relevant for its social setup. Real backward sections only should benefit out of it. Review should be periodical and embedded in the system.

Rate this:   +6   -3


Shital Mote said: (Fri, Feb 5, 2016 10:13:14 PM)    
 
Reservation is giving by government and private is need of backward classes but only for education not for job opportunity. Due to reservation backward classes people take education. Job has giving to talent people.

Rate this:   +4   -12


Fathima Zehra said: (Fri, Feb 5, 2016 04:27:59 PM)    
 
I think reservation make everyone upset. Keep their step back for any opportunity they get as they think the first preference will be given to the one who have this reservation though they won't top in their exam. As India being the democratic it shouldn't be encouraged.

The people who have the reservation should be given the chance in other aspect but should not make the real talented guys to lose their opportunities. Thanks for sharing your wonderful time in reading my views.

Rate this:   +8   -1


Vipul said: (Thu, Feb 4, 2016 12:38:56 AM)    
 
I want to ask few questions to those who are advocating reservation. Will they send their child to a teacher who became teacher through reservation? Will they take service of an engineer for building their house who became engineer through reservation?

Will they go for treatment to doctor who became doctor through reservation? If answer to this question is yes then they are right. Otherwise they are simply fooling themselves.

Rate this:   +26   -5


Anjali said: (Tue, Feb 2, 2016 04:32:07 PM)    
 
According to me, yes this reservation can be help poor peoples in education study. But today's situation is that number of peoples which are rich they also take number of benefits of this reservation.

And its necessary that system can be changed now by knowing the property of that person who takes benefit of reservation. So that I think this will be held only poor peoples not a rich. So number of peoples which are lower or upper class they are in same competition.

Rate this:   +2   -8


Aniket said: (Mon, Feb 1, 2016 05:52:48 PM)    
 
Since India is a democratic country therefore, there should be equality among all and through reservation equality is maintained in our country as it gives chance to backward classes. And according to our constitution we all have same fundamental rights and one of fundamental right is right against exploitation and since these classes are unaware of it then how will they fight against it? Then anyone can exploit them. So, reservation should be there.

Rate this:   +2   -14


Aniket said: (Mon, Feb 1, 2016 05:49:11 PM)    
 
Yes, reservation should be there.

The base of reservation is not economic but socially, educationally backwardness. It clears the structure of hierarchy in the society which is so rigid that it can't be easily break even through economic status. So the purpose is clear to equalize the society.

Second, you can't compare two unequal things with the same parameters. So before for fair competition equal merit should be there and these merits or talent also require some amount of cultural capital which comes through an inheritance. So economic status can' t be appropriate parameter until this huge gap is not fulfilled.

It is not an overtake of 'meritorious' student, if they are really 'meritorious' they would be surely selected. Equality should be based on equal parameters, not one sided.

Rate this:   +8   -21


Ashu said: (Sat, Jan 30, 2016 11:13:45 PM)    
 
Friends, reservation has become a big hurdle in our development. This is nothing but only gain politics of leader or some group. It has created discrimination in the name of caste, religion and geographical view. Private sector is a sector where growth and development is exponentially increased and the second point is it is basically gain oriented. If we will go with reservation in the private sector, we will miss a change for development and this sector also come in area of reservation politics and will create hurdle for any person to do business whether that person may belong to any specific caste, religion, or demographic al representative.

Rate this:   +9   -4


Anubhav said: (Sun, Jan 24, 2016 09:46:15 PM)    
 
According to me the definition of reservation system should be changed because it leads to several disputes in society and in colleges. It should be given on the basis of the economic condition of people and to the differently able people, not on the basis of the caste system. Because it leads to create a gap between higher caste people and lower caste people. Now it becomes a more political issue than for what it was implemented. Political parties create their vote bank through this.

Reservation leads to improper growth of the mindset of the people because in most cases a lower caste student study not so well because he thinks I will get the admission because he has some additional benefit provided by the government.

So for the uplifting of the mindset of people, government should amend the reservation system which is currently prevailing in the country.

Rate this:   +9   -2


Arnab said: (Wed, Jan 20, 2016 11:15:01 AM)    
 
India will always remain a "developing" country, but never a "developed" country till reservations exist. Scrap off reservations from public sector, and the difference will be seen immediately.

I feel today there is more discrimination based on caste, just because someone is getting extra benefit (Why will others agree to their own friends getting more benefits?). Many of my friends think that lower caste = lower income group. But, this is not always true.

Reservations were implemented in India for only 10 years. But, now it has become a political issue. So, my opinion about reservation in private sector is a big NO-NO.

Rate this:   +14   -3


Verma. G said: (Wed, Jan 20, 2016 10:30:13 AM)    
 
I have read several comments. It's good a debate has started. But, one thing no one speaks about is the discrimination in the education, itself. I have chance to see different places in India. In cities like Delhi, a child starts education at age of three. In a recent photograph published in a newspaper, the student in Remote Himachal Pradesh, the student brave heavy snow to walk to school.

In Tripura, I have seen the students walking miles in rain and mud to reach school. Definitely they can not go to school before 6or 7 years of age or even more. Teacherwise; Practically no teacher in Government Schools of remote areas. Teachers engaged paying better than Government in Delhi based Public Schools.

An student of Delhi based public school never thinks being below IAS, IPS, Doctor or engineer. In a village school of remote areas or even in a municipal school of Delhi the students never think more than a clerk, peon or jobs like that. I think ultimately despite whatever, we achieve, we are answerable about what we do for the society. In a situation where our system is giving equal opportunities in studies, we claim of giving equal opportunity in recruitment.

Let me explain, as an officer in Central Government while working in North East, I was conducting tests and interview for recruitment for temporary posts. One girl appeared two/three times in test and interview but did not secceed. Next time, when she came for test. I asked her that she had appeared earlier also.

But why could she not do up to marks. She told me sir, I am from a poor family and had no opportunity to learn computer typing. It touched me as that time computer was not within approach of every one. I ordered that typing test be conducted on manual typewriter.

Believe me, the girl came as topper. This is just an example how it matters for have nots who can be from any caste or community to compete. I have several such examples. My firm believe is that unless we give uniform opportunity in imparting education, our claim giving uniform opportunity in employment.

Rate this:   +9   -5


Khan said: (Mon, Jan 18, 2016 12:48:50 AM)    
 
I think there is not need for reservation in higher education and in public or private sectors, but it should be given in the basic education so that a poor can get admission in convent schools and this must not be based on the caste and religion.

Rate this:   +4   -2


Gaurav Kumar said: (Sat, Jan 16, 2016 08:28:34 PM)    
 
Hi everyone.

I have a bit different perception about reservation system existing now. I think reservation should exist in INDIA but with a modified form because still the condition of people under it has not improved. The condition of tribal people is still pathetic though some portion of them has successfully been merged to the mainstream. So depriving them of reservation will make them unimproved. Hence it should be there with some modification, as our constitution was formed 68 year back. And the condition of then and now has seen an immense change.

Rate this:   +2   -2


Nitin Sushir said: (Tue, Jan 12, 2016 10:31:35 PM)    
 
Hi friends.

I agree with all of you. Reservation must not in private sector. Ya according to constitution reservation is for those people who are financially weak but now a days reservation moved in another view. Reservation must be only for physically handicap people.

Rate this:   +3   -1


Sriram Rdn said: (Sat, Jan 9, 2016 07:22:16 PM)    
 
Hi friends,

We are having reservations in public sector which was decided by our constitution writers. We can not blame them because the conditions which were existing those times made them to take that decision. Because they faced many obstacles based on caste at that time. But now conditions were changed.

World is becoming smaller due to globalization. There is no need for reservation at any sector. But we can't do anything with the public sector. Implanting reservations in private sector does not make any sense because the private sector is the survival of the fittest. They need talented people irrespective of their caste.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +16   -2


Lakshmi Gopinath said: (Sun, Jan 3, 2016 03:12:22 PM)    
 
Reservation should be banned at any cost. We live free in a country. Our constitution gives equal rights to every single person. I believe that a person cannot be judged by his caste, creed or physical appearance but his inner glow.

Before caste creed there comes we have to realize that we are citizen of India. Its our prime duty to help each other instead fight each other be the citizen of India not caste.

Rate this:   +8   -8


Kirti Gupta said: (Wed, Dec 23, 2015 03:30:19 PM)    
 
I don't think we need reservation even in public sector. A person should get a job based on his merit and talent and not because he belongs to a particular cast. People in our country are becoming more understanding and positive. They don't consider a cast as low.

So this isn't a taboo as such nowadays thereby eliminating the need of reservation. Instead more opportunities should be created for the poor and less privileged people irrespective of their caste or religion.

Rate this:   +14   -8


Sarthak said: (Sun, Dec 20, 2015 09:00:34 PM)    
 
I still don't understand why we are following reservation system in 21st century. This system has to change now, if not now then when. Instead of reservation we can approach this problems with privileges. Whether it be a Government job or an educational system, reservations will only pull the country back instead of growth. What we need now is a healthy and smart governance and proper utilization of resources.

Rate this:   +10   -5


Neel said: (Sun, Dec 20, 2015 02:46:42 PM)    
 
Reservations should not strictly allow in any organization even Government this facilitate should only for Physically Challenged Candidates. The rest of candidates should be got employment on their skill and ability only. Private organization have to operate in competitive time. If they have to follow reservation norms then they will not get desire out put since they are required candidates with special skill and talent.

Rate this:   +8   -2


Shivam said: (Thu, Dec 17, 2015 12:52:30 AM)    
 
Hi friends,

Yes, its a major problem for our country that we are facing now. This reservation system creating a huge depth between the people belonging to higher caste and lower caste. Today we are on the way of development in every fields, so we required the person who have such talents or skills that can enhancing our countries growth rate.

If a person comes in any sector after completing the exams, he/she must have such skills that's our country demand unless the person comes with the quota are other reservation system may not have such capability. They just put into a grinding halt situation where no-one can focus on us instead of feeling guilty. So we should remove this reservation system in-fact remove this casticism.

Rate this:   +12   -2


Karan said: (Mon, Dec 14, 2015 11:46:22 AM)    
 
@Vishu there are only good and bad people, god did not send stamp on your backs that higher class will bad or good, its your choice which path you wish to walk. If lower cast got rich who now that if he's bad or good.

So we can't say which guys are good or bad on their caste. Any way I live Australia, no one care for your caste over here they think of each other as human and any way when ever you go abroad try telling them your caste then you will know that no body cares for it.

Rate this:   +5   -1


Biju said: (Tue, Dec 1, 2015 12:41:50 PM)    
 
Hi Brothers and Sisters, if reservation based on caste system is good then why can't the government build our national cricket team based on this same rules. I am not against reservation.

But I am against the reservation based on caste, there are many who are earning well but still fall under SC category and there children gets a secured government job, whereas a general category guy might not be earning well and has to fully depend on the insecure private job.

Reservation should reach the needy rather than people acting as need. It would be better if government can come with reservation based on people's yearly income rather than caste.

Rate this:   +31   -3


Raju said: (Tue, Dec 1, 2015 12:10:21 PM)    
 
If reservation based on caste system is good then we can apply this same rule to our Indian cricket team also. I am afraid to say this but reservation system needs to be modified maybe based on their poverty or through their earnings.

Because there are many who earns well but still fall under SC category and gets a government job based on caste and whereas the general category guy might not be earning and he has to believe in private job where off course his job is insecure. I was not against reservation few years back but today I believe this reservation through caste is actually in high time to modify at least based on their true income.

Rate this:   +6   -6


Avinash Medidhi said: (Tue, Dec 1, 2015 11:26:52 AM)    
 
Hi Friends,

Equals should be treated equally. Otherwise, Affirmative action is to be taken if the person is differently able.

India to get out of this vicious caste system, there should be a hope for the talented pool. It is almost impossible to remove reservations in Government sector (According to our constitutional framer B. R. Ambedkar. Its a Provision which has only to be continued for 10 years, but we can see its still existent).

Even belonging to a lower caste and availing reservation. I don't support giving reservations in the private sector.

In broad perspective, India jumped from primary sector to service sector without much growth in manufacturing and deemed to be developing state. After the economic reforms, India's pace of development increased due to investments from the corporate's (India & abroad). If given reservation, it will send a wrong signal that would show India not a good destination for investments and can reduce employment. Government cannot pressurize corporate's who only need the talented pool.

However, Provisions should be made so that the lower sections are not discriminated like there should be apathy towards caste system (No one should be denied job because of his caste, If there is provision to display the caste card then definitely reservations come into picture).

In a narrower perspective, it is really hard to make you understand as India is a plural society and every individual has his own views. It would a big essay as it is Political, Social, Economic, Cultural, regional and a religious issue which is hampering the growth graph of a most capable super power India.

Rate this:   +40   -3


Abhay said: (Sun, Nov 29, 2015 08:07:36 PM)    
 
I think there should not be reservation system in private sector, because if there is reservation then there are so many chances that the person employed in the company may not have such quality as he have been selected based on the reservation.

So in such case it may happen that company productivity will reduce because it also depends on the efficiency of the employees based on their talents. Hence in such cases company may suffer losses which is undesired for a private sector as they needs development of their own.

But if they include reservation system, in such case it should not be based on caste rather it should be based on the economical condition and physical disability of the person.

Rate this:   +11   -4


Surbhi said: (Mon, Nov 16, 2015 11:58:18 AM)    
 
Hello friends.

I am not against the reservation but it should be given to those people who are badly needed this. A general category student who has higher qualification rather than the category student does not get the job. So reservation is done on the bases of poverty not on the bases of category. This is on the basis of my point of view.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +16   -6


Riju said: (Wed, Nov 4, 2015 02:12:57 PM)    
 
Hi friends, in my opinion reservation system in private sector is needed but in a low percentage. India has 70% of their population at below poverty level. The meritorious but needy students get benefits from the reservation.

But we must have to ensure that those who get the benefits must actually be a needy student. There are many out there who, in spite of being capable of bearing expenses, try to make themselves categorized as one of SC, ST or OBC.

Besides this if the reservation percentage becomes higher, the general category students, who are there at large scale with their capabilities might not get enough opportunities to prove themselves.

Rate this:   +12   -9


Deepankar said: (Sat, Oct 31, 2015 09:50:00 PM)    
 
Reservation should be done based on the poverty in public sector. So that Rich people don't get more richer day by day. Now taking birth in SC or ST family is like son/daughter of King who gets all the Royal Facility of the Government.

Rate this:   +18   -8


Harshith said: (Fri, Oct 30, 2015 10:10:31 AM)    
 
In my point of view reservation in private sector is good, but it should not be more than limit, say 10% for some categories, what I'm going to say is if the reservation is less there will be a competition for that reserved seat. Then who have talent can get that seat, and I think this is a solution for those people are very poor, but not coming under any reserved category.

I said this because if 40-50% reservation is provided for the people under the category, there is two possibilities, one is talented person may get the seat or untalented person too. So if a person who have talent but not coming under that category face a problem.

So finally I conclude that reservation in the private sector is should be minimized and given chance to competitors to compete in competition world.

Rate this:   +3   -7


Mulesh said: (Thu, Oct 29, 2015 10:43:28 PM)    
 
Reservation should be look from its positive way also imposing reservation is not bad. I have a very good example. Private companies are developed in special economic zones. So the land which is utilized for those zone is acquired by government on some nominal rate, many people loss their land as well as no security of employment so just to make them secure there should be a reservation policy for lower grade employment.

Also there is such a provision in Maharashtra by its state govt. One more thing I want to add that operator grade employee are earning very less amount, so if they are getting job for from their native means they have to spend a certain amount on hosteling facility and can't save much to educate their children as well as can't care well to their family.

Rate this:   +5   -3


Danish Sk said: (Wed, Oct 28, 2015 06:15:54 PM)    
 
Reservations in the Private Sector. Reservation is the planned way to make our country better.

Reservation is governed by constitutional laws, statutory laws, and local rules and regulations. Scheduled Castes (SC), Scheduled Tribes (ST) and Other Backward Classes (OBC).

When we look years back, professions are know by caste like Dalits can't do the higher position job so because of this trend Dalits does not got the chance to grew up (there are few exception also).

But after the long trend of this reservation system approximately 40% of SC, ST and OBC are on track so there are no need of reservation on caste basis. Need to change the reservation system on the basis of poverty.

Note : We can't give the reservation for every post because there are some post which is can't done by eligibility. Also the job which represent the country (that needs eligibility).

Rate this:   +10   -3


Jamuna said: (Wed, Oct 28, 2015 09:44:59 AM)    
 
Hello friends, my opinion is reservation must be not there because govt itself discriminating the students by offering scholarships, reservation etc (only for backward classes) but what about students come from middle classes.

Government also take care this because they are also citizens of India. So if reservation is announced for backward classes means please provide us also some % of reservation their by student can improve his/her ability to achieve that % of reservation.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +6   -5


Harpun said: (Fri, Oct 23, 2015 12:48:49 PM)    
 
According to me, the reservation concept will kill the will power of the talented and smart students. They were humiliated or cheated by the society indirectly. The reservation based on sex is acceptable. But the reservation based on caste, religion will create the imbalance or bad impression about the society and government.

Rate this:   +26   -4


Lalit said: (Fri, Oct 23, 2015 11:19:42 AM)    
 
Where the system of social management taken to a verge of reservation system which exist in India where billionaire and unfortunate ghetto living guy of same caste treated as weaker section of society, I would say, of course we will be in big problem if this will be introduced in private sector, it may spark civil war kind of situation.

Rate this:   +3   -1


Manish Tiwari said: (Thu, Oct 22, 2015 03:45:16 PM)    
 
First of all greeting to all. Reservation is one of the big problem of India and its cause is corruption. If we want to solution for reservation system we have to minimize the corruption, so that we have provide the reservation on the basis of economy rather than castism.

Rate this:   +6   -4


Shekhar said: (Tue, Oct 13, 2015 07:58:09 PM)    
 
In my point of view the reservation what the govt has made is correct. As of now I didn't see any backward people to grow up even they don't have money to make admissions at higher courses, so even their parents told them to make courses like the Arts commerce because they have problem with money and they don't have form to work in the fields so in that situation what those people gonna do?

The backward people from the ancient season to 20th century they abused/discarded from the upper caste people they put outside from the village or respective fields. The upper caste people they don't provide water, food, and untouchability in such situation some people go for suicide to remove this Dr. Ambedkar had written such constitution to our Indians which is best constitution in the world and they provide reservation for lower caste people. And some articles like right to equality all these protected the lower caste people.

So, finally I conclude that reservation is good for backward people and this is also make on based on annual income of their parents. However every one should have income certificate.

Rate this:   +7   -6


Pritesh R Parab said: (Wed, Oct 7, 2015 08:17:35 PM)    
 
I think reservation is good by many sides and bad from many side because, in reserved categories who are belong to low cast and if they are poor then they will get a best reservation, and by another side who guys are poor but not belongs to any category they have to face many problems, so my opinion is to give the reservation as per the merit not by any kind of cast reservation.

Rate this:   +13   -4


Prabhat said: (Wed, Oct 7, 2015 12:19:59 AM)    
 
Hello,

Guys reservation is good till 20 year more because still 60-68 % people of ST, ST, OBc category still they people are living in village still they tolerate high cast outbreaks who save them guys.

If government gives them only 10 or 12% reservation although you have 85% left, you might easily get your goals in government sector and private too instead of reservation free India.

Rate this:   +4   -8


Asnsu said: (Tue, Oct 6, 2015 01:36:31 AM)    
 
Reservation is must be SC ST and OBC because of that these are belongs to low educated family. When we provides the reservation then that type of person is fight or growth in his life. In India forward cast growth continually because his traditional family is well educated and join the job anywhere.

So develop family has growth increase towards developing and undeveloped family increase to non developing.

Rate this:   +7   -11


Priyanka said: (Wed, Sep 30, 2015 07:45:49 PM)    
 
In my opinion reservation is not done on the basis of caste system but it is done on the basis of financial condition and physical disability because people who are physically challenged and if they give their best then by reservation they will get extra opportunity so that in their life don't face the negative circumstances.

And if we do reservation on the basis of caste system then person who are belong to general category if they are physically challenged and they are good in academic background then they have to face so many challenges in their life because of reservation and person belong to SC, ST, OBC.

And if they are physically good and they are not good in their education then they will enjoy this opportunity and by this also our country remain backward because they don't get talented mind by this our can't country progress.

Rate this:   +60   -11


Krn Belge said: (Wed, Sep 30, 2015 03:27:54 PM)    
 
Hi friends.

As per my option the reservation allocated by government for its benefit not to help to poor people. We know lot of rich people are belong to reserved cast but receives the all facilitate so government think about this and reservation allocated as per income certificate thank you.

Rate this:   +13   -5


Akhil said: (Sat, Sep 26, 2015 03:35:42 PM)    
 
Hi friends,

I personally believe in equality not in reservation, I am an Indian, you are an Indian. This is our identity for entire world, people out side the India identifies us as an Indian not as a GEL, OBC or SC/ST then how can you discriminate us me the basic of my cast in my own country. Reservation is nothing, it just a dirty political game to divide us on the basis of cast and use us as a vote bank.

Rate this:   +61   -8


Harsha said: (Wed, Sep 23, 2015 07:45:58 AM)    
 
Hello everyone,

As I observed from the above conversations some people are saying that poor and tribal people need some reservation as they are economically and socially backward but what I observed in the society is that people with reservation are now well settled and they are doing good in their life. Still with this reservations they are getting some extra benefits. According to my opinion they are getting benefits in public sector then what is the need in giving extra benefits in private sector too.

Actually there is totally different situation at the time of independence at that time backward people don't get any benefits and they are abused by all the people that belongs to upper caste people so government decided to give equal importance to all and Dr. B. R. Amvedkar created this reservations, we can't blame him as he wrote that apply this for few years only but these political parties for the votes they are still continuing these reservations.

Due to these PITY political parties Talent is not getting it's own importance. Finally what I wanna conclude is that people who really belong to socially and economically backward should give these reservations, this reservations should be limited upto there only. Then only real talent comes into picture and this will really helpful in making better and devolved INDIA.

Thank you one and all.

Rate this:   +40   -6


Yogesh Kumar said: (Tue, Sep 22, 2015 04:41:43 PM)    
 
I think in India reservation in really necessary to help the people who are financially poor for their growth because in rural areas conditions are really bad, people who belongs to general category also do not have money to educate their children.

But the meaning of reservation should be only financial help to poor people for their education and survival, not for their security in any entrance exam or government post.

Rate this:   +12   -8


Aditya Kate said: (Sat, Sep 19, 2015 10:39:01 PM)    
 
I feel reservations should be provided for needy people as it is a help for needful not luxury for others. There are many people who have talent and potential but doesn't get a chance for upbringing themselves in our societies in various fields like science, commercial, etc because of lack of seats in schools and colleges which are already been taken by people who take the Indian Education System for granted.

So reservation in schools and colleges should for needy people, on the other hand in industries i.e. private sector there shouldn't be any kind of reservation. Selection of every employee should be done on basis of his skills, his abilities and rightful things for that job.

Rate this:   +37   -3


Chandan Verma said: (Tue, Sep 15, 2015 04:12:10 AM)    
 
As many of the above discussion, I observed that people who have financial problem should be given reservation but it is very difficult to categories them according to Financial growth, so from my opinion people should not get reservation in any educational fields like IIT AIEEE AIMS etc and if Government do so then talent gets Hurt.

Rate this:   +15   -5


Neha said: (Mon, Sep 14, 2015 07:34:08 AM)    
 
Reservation is not good for our society. Due to reservation many talented mind lose. They are not getting job in government sector due to seat are already reserved. In today's time reservation is just become like a right everyone want to take benefit of it. However is should be only for poor people. The benefit of reservation is yet not reach to needy people.

They are still leaving backward life like Aadivasi & and other villagers. I am also suffering from this reservation and facing problems in government Jobs. So I don't think that it should be there in such large aspects. Every cast is fighting today to have reservation. It is not good for our country. It just harming our goodwill before other nations.

Rate this:   +10   -2


Azmat Raza said: (Mon, Sep 14, 2015 12:17:43 AM)    
 
First of all greetings to all.

Reservation is one of the big problem of India and it's cause is corruption. If we want to solution for reservation system we have to minimize the corruption, so that we provide the reservation on the basis of economy rather than castism.

Rate this:   +7   -3


Aman said: (Sun, Sep 13, 2015 04:32:15 PM)    
 
By reservation a poor SC, ST, OBC people are given free seats. This is a good for all us and no objection about that. But a person who is comes in backwards classes but have a government job and is at comfort stage. He also given a reservation for his child. Now what about a poor people who hardly get a single time food but there is no reservation as he punished as born in open category. There must be change in system really need of it.

Rate this:   +13   -2


Avipsa said: (Fri, Sep 11, 2015 12:26:41 PM)    
 
I think that in government sector as well as in private sector, there should be no reservation based on the caste. I think everybody should be given equal chance everywhere. Beside this I think the needy/poor people should be given a chance to get education at a lower cost.

So that they can get the basic education. But when it comes to the jobs then I think that whether a person is from reserved category or from general category the cut off marks of both of them should be equal. I don't think that the intelligence of a person from a reserved category (getting lower marks) is equal to that of a person from a general category (getting higher marks).

Rate this:   +43   -4


Ranjitha H D said: (Thu, Sep 10, 2015 09:14:40 PM)    
 
Hello everyone.

Reservation is needed from my opinion, because still there are many more poor people in our country due to the economic inabilities or they are bit back from education due to the money problem if the govt or private sector make reservation for them it will make helpful to some people, to take a job by the age relaxation.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +7   -24


Arpita Gupta said: (Mon, Sep 7, 2015 10:18:04 PM)    
 
As in many of the above discussions, it is written that poor people should be given reservation, but it is not possible to check the economic conditions of all candidates.

Rate this:   +8   -5


G. Ramulu said: (Sun, Sep 6, 2015 10:41:39 PM)    
 
Hi friends,

I discussed with many people regarding the existing reservation system. 90% upper caste people opposed to any type of reservation. But 90% SC, ST, BC categories people supported the reservations to them. Interesting thing is that I met irrespective of parties, regions, linguistic and gender barriers. The answer is more or less the same. We can easily come to a conclusion that the caste behind other stand.

Rate this:   +9   -1


Vishal said: (Wed, Sep 2, 2015 05:06:12 PM)    
 
In India as per constitution article 16 talks about the equal opportunity. Still in India after 68 years of independence we do not have equal opportunity in all sectors. Only in government sector we have reservation for Disabled person (3%) and weaker section of society.

As all sector utilizing natural resources and government scheme then why private sector not showing too much interest for Disabled person and weaker section of society. If India really wants to be developed county then we must have equal opportunity everywhere. Still people are struggling to get their constitutional rights. Still we are under develop country because we are lagging economically, social and politically to provide equal opportunity.

Our country has maximum number of poor people and they are not getting opportunity in private sector. As per Corruption Perceptions Index 2014 India rank 85. As per government report per capital income is the key areas in private sector of Indian economy that have surpassed the public sector are transport, financial services etc.

Those spending over Rs 32 a day in rural areas and Rs 47 in towns and cities should not be considered poor, an expert panel headed by former RBI governor C Rangarajan said in a report submitted to the BJP government. Poverty index India Rank is among top nation. According to this revised methodology of World Bank, the world had 872.3 million people below the new poverty line, of which 179.6 million people lived in India. In other words, India with 17.5% of total world's population had 20.6% share of worlds poorest in 2011.

Reservation in private sector, it means reservation in jobs in private companies or other private places where people prefer there near and dear ones. For the post available in their company rather than conducting interview of all the eligible candidates in the region.

Rate this:   +14   -10


Gopal Agrawal said: (Fri, Aug 28, 2015 12:20:47 AM)    
 
In India, where every Indian talks about constitution in that country where is right to equality? Is all are treated as equal then why there is reservation quota only for OBC, SC, ST students why not for the open category student also a separate education quota is kept.

Rate this:   +22   -11


Akash Gupta said: (Wed, Aug 26, 2015 08:12:58 AM)    
 
Hello everyone,

Sir as you all are talking about caste problems. Firstly I want to say that we can not remove cast problems.

In our society. We can remove only when we got a success to remove the corruption in our country because in India everything thing is belong to corruption and it is root or first of all we will have to eradicate it then we can overcome of cast problems.

From upper side someone was saying that reservation should be given those person who have been facing economic problems whether they are belong to General caste or belong to SC and St caste. Sir I'm totally accepting but question is that how we can recognize that this person economical condition is poor because you know that India is expedient country country.

Now you will tell me we can take serve and find that he is poor and he is reach and sir you know in this case everyone wants to get benefit of it and show himself that I m very poor. Now what will you do in this case. First of all we will have to work on corruption if we got a success to remove corruption than everything will be so easy whether cast or anything.

Thank you sir. And don't take it another way.

Rate this:   +11   -7


Shraddha said: (Mon, Aug 24, 2015 08:56:09 AM)    
 
Reservation in private sector, it mins reservation in jobs in private companies or other private places where people prefer there near and dear ones. For the post available in their company rather than conducting interview of all the eligible candidates in the region.

For ex: If any person is working on a good post in a private sector, then he would prefer giving the available job opportunity to his son or dear ones rather than taking some outside merit ranker for the same job.

I feel there is a difference between reservation in private sector and reservation in government sector. Reservations in government sector is where you get admissions or jobs based on your caste.

Rate this:   +7   -4


Shadab Alam said: (Sun, Aug 23, 2015 01:19:19 PM)    
 
In my opinion, reservation is very helpful in our society to support the needy people, but the process of giving reservation to the people is wrong, in our country reservation is given based on caste, religion. It might happen that the person who belong to general category is more needy than a person belong to SC, ST or OBC category.

So according to my point of view reservation should not be given on the basis of caste or religion it should be given on the basis of merit, economy conditions, physical conditions.

Rate this:   +63   -10


Av Kunniyur said: (Wed, Aug 19, 2015 09:40:45 PM)    
 
Hello everyone,

In my opinion reservation based on caste or religion doesn't make sense. Reservation should be given on the basis of merit and economical status especially in educational and employment system.

Rate this:   +33   -7


Tarun Jandyal said: (Mon, Aug 17, 2015 06:41:39 PM)    
 
Hi everyone.

I want only speak on topic i.e. reservation in private sector. I think there should not need any reservation in private sector. But the question is that in some private sector there is some people they prefer mostly their near and dear. Due to which some poor people not grab up their opportunities. There should be need of the govt to see.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +11   -5


G.Ramulu said: (Sun, Aug 16, 2015 07:43:11 AM)    
 
Hi friends,

Here, all of the participants either opposing or supporting the reservations on caste basis.

The discussion is around the CASTE. The root cause of the Discussion point Is "CASTE". If the caste is eradicated, automatically the reservation on caste basis would wither away. Imagine on what basis the reservation would continue? That's why, I request all of friends, who are participating in the discussions don't continue 'CASTE PRACTICES'.

All of You know, the marriages are the main source to continue this caste system. We know 99% marriages are being taken place in their castes only. If the SAME CASTE marriages are either boycotted or banned, then the caste issue be no more. If we reform the marriage system, we can build a "Caste free India". How many are ready to leave their original castes?

Rate this:   +19   -19


Dinesh Kumar said: (Sun, Aug 9, 2015 11:00:53 AM)    
 
Good morning all of you.

The word reservation tells us that it should be given to the poor and needy or merit students. But in our country it is based on caste. Even though students are not utilizing it well reservation makes some students feel lazy. For example for SC/ST people it is easier to qualify than for OBC/General as cutoff for them is easier. So, reservation should be based on merit or background of students.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +27   -16


Aryan Singh said: (Thu, Aug 6, 2015 12:53:09 PM)    
 
Reservation is good for the society, but the problem is that profit is not going to the people who really needed this.

Because in our society reservation is based on the caste category SC, ST are getting more profit than OBC and general. But I think it should not be based on caste system rather it should be based on economy condition, poverty and physical condition.

Rate this:   +48   -1


Sanket said: (Wed, Aug 5, 2015 05:07:17 PM)    
 
Hi friends,

I'm not saying Reservation System should not be there, but reservation in private sector doesn't make sense. Some people who doesn't do hard work and they are just dependent on their caste. Such people are not well educated nor well informed. So private sector should take only those who are capable, talented and giving equal opportunity to all.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +12   -6


Abhay said: (Mon, Aug 3, 2015 08:18:49 PM)    
 
Yeah, reservation is good for the society but the problem is that profit is not going to the people who really need this. Because in our country reservation is based on the cast category, SC, ST are getting more profit than OBC and generals.

But I think it should not be based on caste rather it should be based on economic conditions, poverty and physical conditions. This might happen that person belonging to general category is from more poor family background or person belonging to SC, ST is from more higher family. In such cases the person who really need for reservation is not benefited.

So I think the reservation should not be based on castes rather it should be based on economic conditions, physical conditions.

Rate this:   +13   -3


Ayesha Shaikh said: (Mon, Jul 20, 2015 01:50:07 PM)    
 
Hi frinds,

Private reservation is not proper solution for open catagories student many time open catagories student have more knowledge but thay can not give addmission to better college because of cast as well as reservation.

In some time other categories student get low marks but they have easy to admission in good college. Because of this reason private reservation is not good process so please consider problem of open cast students.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +33   -3


Amk said: (Sat, Jul 18, 2015 11:31:56 PM)    
 
Hai everyone,

I would like to say a few things about this,

1) Reservation is necessary, but only the financially backward people or Physically challenged people should be given reservation - In short the really eligible ones. For example: (a) A financially sound family or student should not receive any stipends or Fee discount only because he or she belongs to a particular caste.

(b) A person born in the higher caste who is struggling for his education is not given any aid or reservation in jobs. Where is the equality in this?.

2) It is very difficult to really get this reservation law modified because the politicians who tries to bring a positive change in this current system are afraid of losing their political support from minorities.

3) The skill also should be given a better priority and so in Private sector jobs there is no need of caste based reservation.

Rate this:   +31   -5


Ayesha &Amp;Praju said: (Tue, Jul 14, 2015 05:06:01 PM)    
 
Hi friends,

Reservation in private sector follow first come first serve criteria There is no need for any reservation because of reservation in private sector student who not able get admission and the talented student not get admission.

Rate this:   +28   -8


Krishna said: (Tue, Jul 14, 2015 12:04:43 AM)    
 
Hi friends,

I think there should not be reservation in private sector or even in government sector because there is reservation in the education so there is equal opportunity to all students to get education, hence they (reservation candidates) have good knowledge in their field as general student, so there is no requirement of reservation in any job sector.

Rate this:   +20   -6


Pramod said: (Tue, Jul 7, 2015 08:31:12 AM)    
 
Hi friends.

Every one talking about reservation. As per my concern seat reservations are not good for getting job in any sector. I know that SC, ST, OBC they are little bit week in knowledge Because of lack of money. At least government should have give age relaxation to getting job in private sector.

Ex : Aviation sector. In this sector there is no job from many years ago and age is going. If they will give age relaxation in private sector so they can get gob there. Because they are week in study because of lack of money. That's why they are taking more time to getting job in private sector. If government will give age relaxation in private sector too. So that they can get a job without seat reservation.

Thanks.

Rate this:   +12   -41


Balaji said: (Wed, Jul 1, 2015 03:23:24 PM)    
 
Hi friends,

Every one is talking about reservation, reservation but why the reservation came to the system. Because, to bring people who are living in dark to limelight that is during independence time. But What is the necessity for reservation now, only the political reasons. People were in poor situation in almost all castes. If we provide reservation based on caste, so called high caste poor people will suffer. In my view, here is the key place where corruption starts. If you people were accepting Reservation is right thing, then you should too accept corruption is also a right thing.

One small scenario, one person who belongs to upper caste middle class family, he is having ample of knowledge but he is not able get government job. One more person with lower caste high class/middle class, not at all having knowledge is getting government job. What he will do, he don't know how to work and started corrupting nation. But, a person from upper caste middle class family now will start buying job and what he will do again to bring earn his spent money, he also will start doing corruption.

In two persons case due to this reservation, destination becomes only one that is corruption. As a educated person we should take necessary steps to stop this reservation which leads to corruption. Finally, I would like to say one thing reservation is key thing for corruption. So, If reservation is correct, then corruption is also correct.

Rate this:   +78   -14


A Pugazhendhi said: (Sat, Jun 27, 2015 03:24:14 PM)    
 
Can you identify any one CEO OR CMD of a PSU where reservation exists, or of a private company where reservation do not exist, or a person in top post of a govt job at secretary level. I Bet you cannot name one. Does that mean that there is no one capable enough you may argue the person who got in PSU is less talented than other castes, but what happened to person who got in private industry where there is no reservation and all are recruited only by their talent.

Even after 100 years of independence this will not change. That is the mindset of the Brahmins and Hindus (It was even said that SC ST are not Hindus during independence by our great Mahatma Gandhi). Please study some history why these rules came into existence and what is the necessity of this which I cannot explain here. There are lot of details and minute things which are taken into account, discussed thoroughly and finally formulated.

Leave aside IAS and politicians as exceptions as top posts because they are results of direct recruitment by exam and polls. At least few are there because of the direct results.

Rate this:   +11   -14


Naveen said: (Fri, Jun 19, 2015 11:29:08 AM)    
 
As all your points and views are too good to notice, in real time group discussion You won't find time to express much about this. So cut short the message and try to tell it in online.

Rate this:   +10   -5


Satyam said: (Sun, Jun 14, 2015 10:37:59 PM)    
 
Everyone is saying reservation is foolish but not it is necessary for the people who struggling with insult and partition from the Brahmins and Kshatriyas and others since so many years till now it happening in villages if you want to study you can go in villages you can found the barriers of caste. In some villages the Brahmins and others are not allowing low caste people into the Hindu temples.

You all are commenting against reservation sitting from the city only but you can go in villages and see what the true is. The reason for diverting low people into Christianity is only because of Brahmins and others doing bloody partition in temple also. You all saying everyone is equal then why are you not ready to marry as low caste women.

Before you commenting others it is better to know the lively hood of the people in the society. Till now you are not agree with that you always ready to marry those people who are below in the society and make equal for coming years automatically reservation will disappears.

Rate this:   +25   -31


Yogesh said: (Fri, Jun 12, 2015 10:23:22 PM)    
 
Hi everyone,

According to my point reservation should not given in private sector. Still there are many peoples who are in SC, ST category they having problem. Politician should stop criticizing reservation. Giving reservation about education is good but in industry eligible candidate must be selected. So, there is not a good policy of reservation in public sector.

Rate this:   +15   -9


Bindu said: (Fri, Jun 12, 2015 08:13:19 PM)    
 
In my opinion reservation is a bad culture because so many people that belongs to backward castes are not at all afraiding and not concentrating on any exams this is only due to this reason. They thought that if they got less marks also they can easily gain their satisfied job.

So that the talented people are loosing their innovative ideas which are useful to develop our country with their suggestions. So government should see and think about this topic and also so many governments are changing over but their is no use.

Thank you for giving this opportunity with you.

Rate this:   +20   -5


Sumit Pandey said: (Wed, Jun 10, 2015 03:52:32 PM)    
 
With due respect to feeling of my friends I would like to conclude that reservation is good for no one as many candidates unsuitable get chance instead of skilled once instead it should be given to (BPL) below poverty level class.

Rate this:   +12   -3


Robust said: (Sun, Jun 7, 2015 03:44:07 PM)    
 
I would say that reservation is not good for anyone, even some of those who are getting it might know this fact as after getting it you might jump far long than any other who didn't got it but it's temporary you failed to improve yourself for the long run in the mean time also when it comes to job either in private or government sector if you don't have enough talent than surely you are not going to grab it overall It's a person talent and hard work which result in success.

But in India we failed at this policy due to reservation, why a person should get the reservation why? Just because 1000 years back people categorized each other according to their work they were doing, named the work as caste and human race were divided in to group of people which will be identified by their castes only rather than they also are human being but doing the different work, Simply Caste is nothing but the work ancestors did and now so many years has been passed but still backward class peoples are identified by that same work (caste) and getting the benefit of that.

Due to reservation backward class people are still not able to evolve themselves by doing the enough hard work as other general candidate has to do to become successful. In private sector each company wants talented people it doesn't matter which category you belong to if you have enough talent than you will definitely reach at the level. Simply government needs to change the rules now, it's a time for a big new change to push the India towards growth.

I will conclude by saying this if someone needs financially support than start some policy which will support the needed peoples (without taking care of their caste) why reservation should be provided to them which will not help them in the long run if they didn't have talent or if they won't work hard. Reservation is snatching the opportunities from the hardworking and talented peoples and providing them to those who are not capable to hold them.

Everyone should stand the fair chance to grab the opportunities by their talent only not by some irrelevant reservation (boosting technique). Lastly in my opinion reservation should be stopped.

Rate this:   +22   -4


G.Ramulu said: (Sat, Jun 6, 2015 10:58:13 PM)    
 
Hi friends,

If all the means of productions (i.e. lands and industries etc) are nationalized, the necessity of the reservation may not be needed. To end this existing reservations system, shall we fight to abolish the private property? All the reservations, which are being enjoyed presently by the upper & lower castes would automatically be wither away. The root cause of the all the evils stems from the private property only.

Rate this:   +4   -7


Mohit Soni said: (Sat, Jun 6, 2015 06:20:14 PM)    
 
Reservation system in different field must be completely abolished from India. Reservation System completely vanish the competition among students and people. Students having more skills or talent are not able to prove themselves because they have limited offer, students who fall in SC, ST and OBC category are enjoying the reservation system.

Government also took steps to abolish JAAT reservation in several fields, because it is assumed that these people have enough source to utilize, no need of reservation.

Rate this:   +7   -6


Sasikala M said: (Mon, Jun 1, 2015 10:22:34 AM)    
 
Reservations are making people to suffer for everything in their life example take OC caste their are some poor people in of their trying for jobs but their is no reservation for them how long they have to suffer with this problem this is to embarrassing.

Rate this:   +8   -1


Vishal Wasnik said: (Tue, May 26, 2015 03:16:07 PM)    
 
1000 years back there was caste system. People were taking all rights on basis of caste. 100% reservation. Now its only been only 60 year & still not achieve equality it takes time. Let first have equality, lets destroy caste system then reservation. First come first go.

Rate this:   +13   -9


Animesh Bose said: (Tue, May 26, 2015 09:41:41 AM)    
 
I think, the reservation system should completely abolish from all sector rather government should help who are economically backward and also physically challenged. Now the reality behind this reservation is falling of marginal quality in all aspects as they (backward caste) have no tendency to improve their efficiency.

Whereas a economically backward general candidate with a bright possibility cannot complete his/her race due to this congestion in track. But only government can make a chance to improve their quality by providing a free training, free coaching or by providing special scholarship instead of reservation and by this way the job market will be competitive for all.

Lastly, if this reservation system becomes a political weapon to increase the volume of vote bank for all political party then this picture will not be changed.

Rate this:   +9   -3


Sreenivasulu A said: (Tue, May 26, 2015 09:11:42 AM)    
 
I am against to the reservation system. If the person is talented, he or she don't need reservation at any level.

If we talk about poor people, who can't afford to send their children to school. I would say government should avail a facility of free education for few years. For higher education government should set a criteria like minimum percentage to get a scholarship near to the tuition fee.

We can see in developed countries US, Japan, Singapore. They have facility for free education. In our India, OBC, OC persons are unable to get a government job even they scored good marks in exam because of reservation.

Otherwise government has to set strict rules in private and government schools. If you see in our government schools most of teachers have lack of knowledge. Even they also don't know what they are going to teach the children. In private sectors, management is demanding 50,000 to 200,000 school fee even for L.K.G, U.K.G students. How poor people can afford that much fee to their children.

At the end, I am going to say is, government has to set strict rules in government sector or has to take an action on private sector instead of provide reservation to people like SC, ST, OBC, OC etc.

Rate this:   +20   -4


Animesh Bose said: (Tue, May 26, 2015 12:44:08 AM)    
 
I think, the reservation system should completely abolish from all sector rather government should help them who are economically backward. If this reservation process continue then the total quality will be fall and by this way they (reserved category) will have no tendency to improve their quality, whereas a economically starved general category candidate cannot cop up with this, though she/he possess a bright possibility.

But government can improve this quality by providing free training, free coaching or by providing special scholarship and thus keep the job market competitive for all. So, I conclude that to improve quality government have to set the market free from any reservation.

Rate this:   +2   -1


Gramulu said: (Mon, May 25, 2015 12:55:31 AM)    
 
Hi friends,

In real sense, one who gets, either financial assistance or infrastructure assistance or transport facilities from the state to their companies or services or institutions would't be treated the private sector. And come under public sector category Hence, these are to be covered under reservation preview.

In any way, reservation in private sector, is genuine and useful to our country also.

Rate this:   +2   -2


G.Ramulu said: (Mon, May 25, 2015 12:37:47 AM)    
 
Hi friends,

Reservation is not a new to India. King ships were reserved for their heirs, education, properties &honors were reserved to the Brahmin, Kshatriyas and Vyasyaas for nearly 3000 years. And to their heirs only.

Illiteracy, poverty&. Humiliations were reserved to Sudras. Priest ships are being reserved for Brahmins & their heirs only. Interesting thing is that, the anti-reservations, I think would not have think or question about it.

Rate this:   +4   -6


G.Ramulu said: (Sat, May 16, 2015 12:43:43 AM)    
 
Hi friends,

The needed persons definitely be given reservation. But in our Indian society, the scene is reversed. The particular people, who are denied, centuries together the right to education & property (SC, ST and BC) and are being given nominal reservations. These are the laborious majority. They have been suppressed and humiliated.

But the educational & property castes, whose population is very very small in number, are enjoying a lot. All the facilities are reserved to these leisurious, lazy and minority upper castes only. They are holding 97%industry & business, 94% of land, 92% media, 66% of political reservation. The interesting thing is that they are not having any governmental reservations. How to asses this ? Can any intellectual, who are against to caste reservations, answer it?

Rate this:   +12   -12


Shivani said: (Fri, May 15, 2015 11:47:22 PM)    
 
I am against this reservation system. According to me if a person is talented then he or she don't need reservation at any level. If we talk about poor families who can't afford to send their children to schools then for them I would say that government should avail the facility of free education for few years.

After few years government should set a academic percentage criteria and provide scholarship which is nearly equal to school fees so that students can continue their studies without any intervene of any kind.

Also if reservation on the basis of caste is implemented then every reserved candidate must be given this opportunity only once. Either they take admission in a school on basis of reservation or in college or in securing their job. By doing this the real talent of the candidate can be judged.

Rate this:   +14   -2


Mukesh Negi said: (Thu, May 14, 2015 12:23:07 PM)    
 
Reservation on basis of caste should be ended and reservation on basis of family income should be uplifted. Reservation provides a very nice concrete road to the reserved category person whereas unreserved person gets a small landsliding hilly foot way for getting succeeded. Reservation dims the talent and shines the untalented one.

Rate this:   +9   -4


Anup said: (Mon, Apr 27, 2015 03:29:05 PM)    
 
In my opinion reservation must be there, but only based on the family's annual income. According to our constitution makers, "reservation rate must be a danger one not a upgrading one". But unfortunately In India the reservation rate is not going down. Reservation system is responsible for the destruction of talent and not responsible for any uplift of talent. I believe if the reservation is based on family's annual income the sufferers will be less.

Rate this:   +26   -8


Speak Your Mind:
  • Please do not use chat terms. Example: avoid using "grt" instead of "great".


  • © 2008-2015 by IndiaBIX™ Technologies. All Rights Reserved | Copyright | Terms of Use & Privacy Policy

    Contact us: info@indiabix.com     Follow us on twitter!