IndiaBIX.com
Search

Reservations in the Private Sector

@ : Home > Group Discussion > Politics - Discussion Room

Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
  • Assume, you one of the member of a real group discussion.
  • Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
  • Express your positive attitude towards providing the solution.

Vishal said: (Wed, Sep 2, 2015 05:06:12 PM)    
 
In India as per constitution article 16 talks about the equal opportunity. Still in India after 68 years of independence we do not have equal opportunity in all sectors. Only in government sector we have reservation for Disabled person (3%) and weaker section of society.

As all sector utilizing natural resources and government scheme then why private sector not showing too much interest for Disabled person and weaker section of society. If India really wants to be developed county then we must have equal opportunity everywhere. Still people are struggling to get their constitutional rights. Still we are under develop country because we are lagging economically, social and politically to provide equal opportunity.

Our country has maximum number of poor people and they are not getting opportunity in private sector. As per Corruption Perceptions Index 2014 India rank 85. As per government report per capital income is the key areas in private sector of Indian economy that have surpassed the public sector are transport, financial services etc.

Those spending over Rs 32 a day in rural areas and Rs 47 in towns and cities should not be considered poor, an expert panel headed by former RBI governor C Rangarajan said in a report submitted to the BJP government. Poverty index India Rank is among top nation. According to this revised methodology of World Bank, the world had 872.3 million people below the new poverty line, of which 179.6 million people lived in India. In other words, India with 17.5% of total world's population had 20.6% share of worlds poorest in 2011.

Reservation in private sector, it means reservation in jobs in private companies or other private places where people prefer there near and dear ones. For the post available in their company rather than conducting interview of all the eligible candidates in the region.

Rate this:   +2   -0


Gopal Agrawal said: (Fri, Aug 28, 2015 12:20:47 AM)    
 
In India, where every Indian talks about constitution in that country where is right to equality? Is all are treated as equal then why there is reservation quota only for OBC, SC, ST students why not for the open category student also a separate education quota is kept.

Rate this:   +5   -2


Akash Gupta said: (Wed, Aug 26, 2015 08:12:58 AM)    
 
Hello everyone,

Sir as you all are talking about caste problems. Firstly I want to say that we can not remove cast problems.

In our society. We can remove only when we got a success to remove the corruption in our country because in India everything thing is belong to corruption and it is root or first of all we will have to eradicate it then we can overcome of cast problems.

From upper side someone was saying that reservation should be given those person who have been facing economic problems whether they are belong to General caste or belong to SC and St caste. Sir I'm totally accepting but question is that how we can recognize that this person economical condition is poor because you know that India is expedient country country.

Now you will tell me we can take serve and find that he is poor and he is reach and sir you know in this case everyone wants to get benefit of it and show himself that I m very poor. Now what will you do in this case. First of all we will have to work on corruption if we got a success to remove corruption than everything will be so easy whether cast or anything.

Thank you sir. And don't take it another way.

Rate this:   +3   -5


Shraddha said: (Mon, Aug 24, 2015 08:56:09 AM)    
 
Reservation in private sector, it mins reservation in jobs in private companies or other private places where people prefer there near and dear ones. For the post available in their company rather than conducting interview of all the eligible candidates in the region.

For ex: If any person is working on a good post in a private sector, then he would prefer giving the available job opportunity to his son or dear ones rather than taking some outside merit ranker for the same job.

I feel there is a difference between reservation in private sector and reservation in government sector. Reservations in government sector is where you get admissions or jobs based on your caste.

Rate this:   +4   -2


Shadab Alam said: (Sun, Aug 23, 2015 01:19:19 PM)    
 
In my opinion, reservation is very helpful in our society to support the needy people, but the process of giving reservation to the people is wrong, in our country reservation is given based on caste, religion. It might happen that the person who belong to general category is more needy than a person belong to SC, ST or OBC category.

So according to my point of view reservation should not be given on the basis of caste or religion it should be given on the basis of merit, economy conditions, physical conditions.

Rate this:   +16   -4


Av Kunniyur said: (Wed, Aug 19, 2015 09:40:45 PM)    
 
Hello everyone,

In my opinion reservation based on caste or religion doesn't make sense. Reservation should be given on the basis of merit and economical status especially in educational and employment system.

Rate this:   +19   -3


Tarun Jandyal said: (Mon, Aug 17, 2015 06:41:39 PM)    
 
Hi everyone.

I want only speak on topic i.e. reservation in private sector. I think there should not need any reservation in private sector. But the question is that in some private sector there is some people they prefer mostly their near and dear. Due to which some poor people not grab up their opportunities. There should be need of the govt to see.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +9   -3


G.Ramulu said: (Sun, Aug 16, 2015 07:43:11 AM)    
 
Hi friends,

Here, all of the participants either opposing or supporting the reservations on caste basis.

The discussion is around the CASTE. The root cause of the Discussion point Is "CASTE". If the caste is eradicated, automatically the reservation on caste basis would wither away. Imagine on what basis the reservation would continue? That's why, I request all of friends, who are participating in the discussions don't continue 'CASTE PRACTICES'.

All of You know, the marriages are the main source to continue this caste system. We know 99% marriages are being taken place in their castes only. If the SAME CASTE marriages are either boycotted or banned, then the caste issue be no more. If we reform the marriage system, we can build a "Caste free India". How many are ready to leave their original castes?

Rate this:   +12   -13


Dinesh Kumar said: (Sun, Aug 9, 2015 11:00:53 AM)    
 
Good morning all of you.

The word reservation tells us that it should be given to the poor and needy or merit students. But in our country it is based on caste. Even though students are not utilizing it well reservation makes some students feel lazy. For example for SC/ST people it is easier to qualify than for OBC/General as cutoff for them is easier. So, reservation should be based on merit or background of students.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +18   -12


Aryan Singh said: (Thu, Aug 6, 2015 12:53:09 PM)    
 
Reservation is good for the society, but the problem is that profit is not going to the people who really needed this.

Because in our society reservation is based on the caste category SC, ST are getting more profit than OBC and general. But I think it should not be based on caste system rather it should be based on economy condition, poverty and physical condition.

Rate this:   +30   -1


Sanket said: (Wed, Aug 5, 2015 05:07:17 PM)    
 
Hi friends,

I'm not saying Reservation System should not be there, but reservation in private sector doesn't make sense. Some people who doesn't do hard work and they are just dependent on their caste. Such people are not well educated nor well informed. So private sector should take only those who are capable, talented and giving equal opportunity to all.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +9   -4


Abhay said: (Mon, Aug 3, 2015 08:18:49 PM)    
 
Yeah, reservation is good for the society but the problem is that profit is not going to the people who really need this. Because in our country reservation is based on the cast category, SC, ST are getting more profit than OBC and generals.

But I think it should not be based on caste rather it should be based on economic conditions, poverty and physical conditions. This might happen that person belonging to general category is from more poor family background or person belonging to SC, ST is from more higher family. In such cases the person who really need for reservation is not benefited.

So I think the reservation should not be based on castes rather it should be based on economic conditions, physical conditions.

Rate this:   +12   -1


Ayesha Shaikh said: (Mon, Jul 20, 2015 01:50:07 PM)    
 
Hi frinds,

Private reservation is not proper solution for open catagories student many time open catagories student have more knowledge but thay can not give addmission to better college because of cast as well as reservation.

In some time other categories student get low marks but they have easy to admission in good college. Because of this reason private reservation is not good process so please consider problem of open cast students.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +28   -3


Amk said: (Sat, Jul 18, 2015 11:31:56 PM)    
 
Hai everyone,

I would like to say a few things about this,

1) Reservation is necessary, but only the financially backward people or Physically challenged people should be given reservation - In short the really eligible ones. For example: (a) A financially sound family or student should not receive any stipends or Fee discount only because he or she belongs to a particular caste.

(b) A person born in the higher caste who is struggling for his education is not given any aid or reservation in jobs. Where is the equality in this?.

2) It is very difficult to really get this reservation law modified because the politicians who tries to bring a positive change in this current system are afraid of losing their political support from minorities.

3) The skill also should be given a better priority and so in Private sector jobs there is no need of caste based reservation.

Rate this:   +27   -5


Ayesha &Amp;Praju said: (Tue, Jul 14, 2015 05:06:01 PM)    
 
Hi friends,

Reservation in private sector follow first come first serve criteria There is no need for any reservation because of reservation in private sector student who not able get admission and the talented student not get admission.

Rate this:   +27   -6


Krishna said: (Tue, Jul 14, 2015 12:04:43 AM)    
 
Hi friends,

I think there should not be reservation in private sector or even in government sector because there is reservation in the education so there is equal opportunity to all students to get education, hence they (reservation candidates) have good knowledge in their field as general student, so there is no requirement of reservation in any job sector.

Rate this:   +18   -4


Pramod said: (Tue, Jul 7, 2015 08:31:12 AM)    
 
Hi friends.

Every one talking about reservation. As per my concern seat reservations are not good for getting job in any sector. I know that SC, ST, OBC they are little bit week in knowledge Because of lack of money. At least government should have give age relaxation to getting job in private sector.

Ex : Aviation sector. In this sector there is no job from many years ago and age is going. If they will give age relaxation in private sector so they can get gob there. Because they are week in study because of lack of money. That's why they are taking more time to getting job in private sector. If government will give age relaxation in private sector too. So that they can get a job without seat reservation.

Thanks.

Rate this:   +9   -38


Balaji said: (Wed, Jul 1, 2015 03:23:24 PM)    
 
Hi friends,

Every one is talking about reservation, reservation but why the reservation came to the system. Because, to bring people who are living in dark to limelight that is during independence time. But What is the necessity for reservation now, only the political reasons. People were in poor situation in almost all castes. If we provide reservation based on caste, so called high caste poor people will suffer. In my view, here is the key place where corruption starts. If you people were accepting Reservation is right thing, then you should too accept corruption is also a right thing.

One small scenario, one person who belongs to upper caste middle class family, he is having ample of knowledge but he is not able get government job. One more person with lower caste high class/middle class, not at all having knowledge is getting government job. What he will do, he don't know how to work and started corrupting nation. But, a person from upper caste middle class family now will start buying job and what he will do again to bring earn his spent money, he also will start doing corruption.

In two persons case due to this reservation, destination becomes only one that is corruption. As a educated person we should take necessary steps to stop this reservation which leads to corruption. Finally, I would like to say one thing reservation is key thing for corruption. So, If reservation is correct, then corruption is also correct.

Rate this:   +60   -10


A Pugazhendhi said: (Sat, Jun 27, 2015 03:24:14 PM)    
 
Can you identify any one CEO OR CMD of a PSU where reservation exists, or of a private company where reservation do not exist, or a person in top post of a govt job at secretary level. I Bet you cannot name one. Does that mean that there is no one capable enough you may argue the person who got in PSU is less talented than other castes, but what happened to person who got in private industry where there is no reservation and all are recruited only by their talent.

Even after 100 years of independence this will not change. That is the mindset of the Brahmins and Hindus (It was even said that SC ST are not Hindus during independence by our great Mahatma Gandhi). Please study some history why these rules came into existence and what is the necessity of this which I cannot explain here. There are lot of details and minute things which are taken into account, discussed thoroughly and finally formulated.

Leave aside IAS and politicians as exceptions as top posts because they are results of direct recruitment by exam and polls. At least few are there because of the direct results.

Rate this:   +10   -9


Naveen said: (Fri, Jun 19, 2015 11:29:08 AM)    
 
As all your points and views are too good to notice, in real time group discussion You won't find time to express much about this. So cut short the message and try to tell it in online.

Rate this:   +6   -5


Satyam said: (Sun, Jun 14, 2015 10:37:59 PM)    
 
Everyone is saying reservation is foolish but not it is necessary for the people who struggling with insult and partition from the Brahmins and Kshatriyas and others since so many years till now it happening in villages if you want to study you can go in villages you can found the barriers of caste. In some villages the Brahmins and others are not allowing low caste people into the Hindu temples.

You all are commenting against reservation sitting from the city only but you can go in villages and see what the true is. The reason for diverting low people into Christianity is only because of Brahmins and others doing bloody partition in temple also. You all saying everyone is equal then why are you not ready to marry as low caste women.

Before you commenting others it is better to know the lively hood of the people in the society. Till now you are not agree with that you always ready to marry those people who are below in the society and make equal for coming years automatically reservation will disappears.

Rate this:   +19   -29


Yogesh said: (Fri, Jun 12, 2015 10:23:22 PM)    
 
Hi everyone,

According to my point reservation should not given in private sector. Still there are many peoples who are in SC, ST category they having problem. Politician should stop criticizing reservation. Giving reservation about education is good but in industry eligible candidate must be selected. So, there is not a good policy of reservation in public sector.

Rate this:   +14   -8


Bindu said: (Fri, Jun 12, 2015 08:13:19 PM)    
 
In my opinion reservation is a bad culture because so many people that belongs to backward castes are not at all afraiding and not concentrating on any exams this is only due to this reason. They thought that if they got less marks also they can easily gain their satisfied job.

So that the talented people are loosing their innovative ideas which are useful to develop our country with their suggestions. So government should see and think about this topic and also so many governments are changing over but their is no use.

Thank you for giving this opportunity with you.

Rate this:   +17   -5


Sumit Pandey said: (Wed, Jun 10, 2015 03:52:32 PM)    
 
With due respect to feeling of my friends I would like to conclude that reservation is good for no one as many candidates unsuitable get chance instead of skilled once instead it should be given to (BPL) below poverty level class.

Rate this:   +11   -3


Robust said: (Sun, Jun 7, 2015 03:44:07 PM)    
 
I would say that reservation is not good for anyone, even some of those who are getting it might know this fact as after getting it you might jump far long than any other who didn't got it but it's temporary you failed to improve yourself for the long run in the mean time also when it comes to job either in private or government sector if you don't have enough talent than surely you are not going to grab it overall It's a person talent and hard work which result in success.

But in India we failed at this policy due to reservation, why a person should get the reservation why? Just because 1000 years back people categorized each other according to their work they were doing, named the work as caste and human race were divided in to group of people which will be identified by their castes only rather than they also are human being but doing the different work, Simply Caste is nothing but the work ancestors did and now so many years has been passed but still backward class peoples are identified by that same work (caste) and getting the benefit of that.

Due to reservation backward class people are still not able to evolve themselves by doing the enough hard work as other general candidate has to do to become successful. In private sector each company wants talented people it doesn't matter which category you belong to if you have enough talent than you will definitely reach at the level. Simply government needs to change the rules now, it's a time for a big new change to push the India towards growth.

I will conclude by saying this if someone needs financially support than start some policy which will support the needed peoples (without taking care of their caste) why reservation should be provided to them which will not help them in the long run if they didn't have talent or if they won't work hard. Reservation is snatching the opportunities from the hardworking and talented peoples and providing them to those who are not capable to hold them.

Everyone should stand the fair chance to grab the opportunities by their talent only not by some irrelevant reservation (boosting technique). Lastly in my opinion reservation should be stopped.

Rate this:   +17   -4


G.Ramulu said: (Sat, Jun 6, 2015 10:58:13 PM)    
 
Hi friends,

If all the means of productions (i.e. lands and industries etc) are nationalized, the necessity of the reservation may not be needed. To end this existing reservations system, shall we fight to abolish the private property? All the reservations, which are being enjoyed presently by the upper & lower castes would automatically be wither away. The root cause of the all the evils stems from the private property only.

Rate this:   +1   -7


Mohit Soni said: (Sat, Jun 6, 2015 06:20:14 PM)    
 
Reservation system in different field must be completely abolished from India. Reservation System completely vanish the competition among students and people. Students having more skills or talent are not able to prove themselves because they have limited offer, students who fall in SC, ST and OBC category are enjoying the reservation system.

Government also took steps to abolish JAAT reservation in several fields, because it is assumed that these people have enough source to utilize, no need of reservation.

Rate this:   +6   -6


Sasikala M said: (Mon, Jun 1, 2015 10:22:34 AM)    
 
Reservations are making people to suffer for everything in their life example take OC caste their are some poor people in of their trying for jobs but their is no reservation for them how long they have to suffer with this problem this is to embarrassing.

Rate this:   +6   -1


Vishal Wasnik said: (Tue, May 26, 2015 03:16:07 PM)    
 
1000 years back there was caste system. People were taking all rights on basis of caste. 100% reservation. Now its only been only 60 year & still not achieve equality it takes time. Let first have equality, lets destroy caste system then reservation. First come first go.

Rate this:   +11   -9


Animesh Bose said: (Tue, May 26, 2015 09:41:41 AM)    
 
I think, the reservation system should completely abolish from all sector rather government should help who are economically backward and also physically challenged. Now the reality behind this reservation is falling of marginal quality in all aspects as they (backward caste) have no tendency to improve their efficiency.

Whereas a economically backward general candidate with a bright possibility cannot complete his/her race due to this congestion in track. But only government can make a chance to improve their quality by providing a free training, free coaching or by providing special scholarship instead of reservation and by this way the job market will be competitive for all.

Lastly, if this reservation system becomes a political weapon to increase the volume of vote bank for all political party then this picture will not be changed.

Rate this:   +8   -3


Sreenivasulu A said: (Tue, May 26, 2015 09:11:42 AM)    
 
I am against to the reservation system. If the person is talented, he or she don't need reservation at any level.

If we talk about poor people, who can't afford to send their children to school. I would say government should avail a facility of free education for few years. For higher education government should set a criteria like minimum percentage to get a scholarship near to the tuition fee.

We can see in developed countries US, Japan, Singapore. They have facility for free education. In our India, OBC, OC persons are unable to get a government job even they scored good marks in exam because of reservation.

Otherwise government has to set strict rules in private and government schools. If you see in our government schools most of teachers have lack of knowledge. Even they also don't know what they are going to teach the children. In private sectors, management is demanding 50,000 to 200,000 school fee even for L.K.G, U.K.G students. How poor people can afford that much fee to their children.

At the end, I am going to say is, government has to set strict rules in government sector or has to take an action on private sector instead of provide reservation to people like SC, ST, OBC, OC etc.

Rate this:   +18   -3


Animesh Bose said: (Tue, May 26, 2015 12:44:08 AM)    
 
I think, the reservation system should completely abolish from all sector rather government should help them who are economically backward. If this reservation process continue then the total quality will be fall and by this way they (reserved category) will have no tendency to improve their quality, whereas a economically starved general category candidate cannot cop up with this, though she/he possess a bright possibility.

But government can improve this quality by providing free training, free coaching or by providing special scholarship and thus keep the job market competitive for all. So, I conclude that to improve quality government have to set the market free from any reservation.

Rate this:   +1   -1


Gramulu said: (Mon, May 25, 2015 12:55:31 AM)    
 
Hi friends,

In real sense, one who gets, either financial assistance or infrastructure assistance or transport facilities from the state to their companies or services or institutions would't be treated the private sector. And come under public sector category Hence, these are to be covered under reservation preview.

In any way, reservation in private sector, is genuine and useful to our country also.

Rate this:   +1   -2


G.Ramulu said: (Mon, May 25, 2015 12:37:47 AM)    
 
Hi friends,

Reservation is not a new to India. King ships were reserved for their heirs, education, properties &honors were reserved to the Brahmin, Kshatriyas and Vyasyaas for nearly 3000 years. And to their heirs only.

Illiteracy, poverty&. Humiliations were reserved to Sudras. Priest ships are being reserved for Brahmins & their heirs only. Interesting thing is that, the anti-reservations, I think would not have think or question about it.

Rate this:   +2   -5


G.Ramulu said: (Sat, May 16, 2015 12:43:43 AM)    
 
Hi friends,

The needed persons definitely be given reservation. But in our Indian society, the scene is reversed. The particular people, who are denied, centuries together the right to education & property (SC, ST and BC) and are being given nominal reservations. These are the laborious majority. They have been suppressed and humiliated.

But the educational & property castes, whose population is very very small in number, are enjoying a lot. All the facilities are reserved to these leisurious, lazy and minority upper castes only. They are holding 97%industry & business, 94% of land, 92% media, 66% of political reservation. The interesting thing is that they are not having any governmental reservations. How to asses this ? Can any intellectual, who are against to caste reservations, answer it?

Rate this:   +8   -10


Shivani said: (Fri, May 15, 2015 11:47:22 PM)    
 
I am against this reservation system. According to me if a person is talented then he or she don't need reservation at any level. If we talk about poor families who can't afford to send their children to schools then for them I would say that government should avail the facility of free education for few years.

After few years government should set a academic percentage criteria and provide scholarship which is nearly equal to school fees so that students can continue their studies without any intervene of any kind.

Also if reservation on the basis of caste is implemented then every reserved candidate must be given this opportunity only once. Either they take admission in a school on basis of reservation or in college or in securing their job. By doing this the real talent of the candidate can be judged.

Rate this:   +11   -1


Mukesh Negi said: (Thu, May 14, 2015 12:23:07 PM)    
 
Reservation on basis of caste should be ended and reservation on basis of family income should be uplifted. Reservation provides a very nice concrete road to the reserved category person whereas unreserved person gets a small landsliding hilly foot way for getting succeeded. Reservation dims the talent and shines the untalented one.

Rate this:   +6   -2


Anup said: (Mon, Apr 27, 2015 03:29:05 PM)    
 
In my opinion reservation must be there, but only based on the family's annual income. According to our constitution makers, "reservation rate must be a danger one not a upgrading one". But unfortunately In India the reservation rate is not going down. Reservation system is responsible for the destruction of talent and not responsible for any uplift of talent. I believe if the reservation is based on family's annual income the sufferers will be less.

Rate this:   +25   -6


Habi said: (Wed, Apr 22, 2015 09:39:35 PM)    
 
According to my point view, reservation should not be implemented in private sectors and even government sectors also. Because of reservation some peoples are taking light in their education and studies. They thought we have the reservation so we can easily get the job.

So my opinion is reservation should be removed from the govt sectors also. If reservation is must? Then the plane the education system, exams all are separated for the reservation people and not reservation peoples. All are equal.

Rate this:   +7   -10


Rohit said: (Tue, Apr 21, 2015 01:11:44 AM)    
 
You can't ban reservation because people with reservation facility will create a havoc and riots in the society the only thing can be done to improve the opportunity of open candidates that the person with whose family income goes above a certain limit with reserved category should not be considered as a reserved candidate. His family should not be given the reservation facility this will give chance to lower section of society and will also keep the interest of open category candidates.

Rate this:   +11   -6


Dinesh Kumar said: (Sun, Apr 12, 2015 02:51:03 PM)    
 
I think reservation is very complicated and sensitive issue. I support reservation. According to me body did not want reservation in historical era and today but its given by mahatma Gandhian. Dr.B.R.Ambedkar did not want reservation, he demanded separate state. If you will read the Poona pact then can understand.

If you think reservation is not good today then you have to open their cast system door open for marriage equality will come in society, reservation will collapse in future.

Rate this:   +11   -7


Ramendra Singh Mandloi said: (Wed, Apr 8, 2015 12:37:15 AM)    
 
Hi everyone,

As I think we should remove the reservation system from both Govt as well as private sector, because due to that no cast and religious criteria will be allowed reservation looks like handicapped economy of our India and it will be danger for our country's future and the person who has sufficient knowledge, proper technical skills and good qualities (Either they are from general category) will get job easily in both sectors. So I want to see my country well improved.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +18   -4


Vikash Kumar said: (Wed, Mar 25, 2015 01:13:59 AM)    
 
Hello everyone,

According to my opinion I am against of reservation, because today 70 percent seat are reserved. Today good student are not get their ambition. Because some times he unsuccessful few marks, but reserved student selected. Its started at the time when the India is free from English man.

On that time there are casticsm. Lower cast not came to the trample and not get the higher position of the job. So the reservation is started for the equability of cast. But now I think today reservation should be remove by the India government.

Thanks all of you.

Rate this:   +20   -4


Yatendra said: (Tue, Mar 24, 2015 01:55:01 PM)    
 
I think reservation should not be there because our country needed talented people to survive in the world, not reserved people who have no knowledge, if person are reserved they get knowledge easily but people who are more industrious they always failure to get job or admission.

Rate this:   +14   -8


Raveendra Reddy Navuluri said: (Mon, Mar 23, 2015 07:57:32 PM)    
 
According to me Reservations in private sector is totally insane because in present situation the government jobs are filling with nearly 60% by reservation. Unreserved candidates who are willing to work in Government sectors are hardly trying to get it.

But due to nominal cutoff marks for reserved candidate they are losing their opportunity. Because of this they are choosing private sector.

So introducing reservation system in private sector my cause lot of damage to the unreserved candidates. In my view the now a days the public and private sectors need to have talented persons not the reservations.

Rate this:   +5   -5


Arka said: (Mon, Mar 23, 2015 10:36:22 AM)    
 
Hi.

According to me the reservations based on caste and religion in private sector should be allowed then only private industry/sector won't grow further as public sector and then only the power will be at the hands of public not of others.

Government should form some restrictions on reservations. The family which is used the reservation already is not eligible for further using of it this should be must otherwise it is not possible to see reservation free India.

It may be good to provide reservations based on economic background and merit base that to for single time only. The people who had same facilities should have same type of opportunities.

Rate this:   +10   -5


Tapabrata Pal said: (Mon, Mar 23, 2015 12:29:43 AM)    
 
Hi friends,

I am fully against to the reservation system. In the general cast, many of the student has good knowledge and good marks but they do not get any job. In SC/ST/OBC cast, many of the student has not better knowledge but they get a good job. So that the development of our country is decreasing.

In other way, the financial condition of the many good students are not strong but they do not get any financial opportunity from the government. So I do not support the term "reservation in the private sector".

Rate this:   +4   -3


Sonu Rastogi said: (Fri, Mar 20, 2015 05:40:41 PM)    
 
Well, if I would keep my opinion on this topic then I would say that reservation in private sector is not necessary because if, a person is opening his venture after investing a lot of money so he would definitely hire a person who would be supremely talented according to him because he would open his business only to extend.

On the other side if government make reservation mandatory in the private sector then employer has to hire a person according to reservation category in that situation may be a talented person could not get the job.

Then I cannot expect from our country to see on the next level like other countries in the world then we would only have the reservation but nothing else.

If you people agree then like it.

Rate this:   +51   -7


Mahadev Rajguru said: (Wed, Mar 18, 2015 10:02:14 AM)    
 
Hi friends,

As per my opinion the reservation is essential for private sector. Because, some poor peoples are in our country. So reservation allows in private sector then they will get good opportunity for doing something exhaustive. Otherwise they don't missed for opportunity.

Rate this:   +2   -58


Swapnil said: (Tue, Mar 17, 2015 09:06:54 AM)    
 
Reservation in private sector is not needed actually, Government is already providing the reservation from schools and colleges choices. So if the person is talented enough he must get a job after availing reservation for education.

For giving services a person should be qualifying enough. Moreover people should be given equal opportunity for a job it should be purely on a basis of talent one person posses instead the caste.

Rate this:   +16   -2


Rahul said: (Thu, Mar 12, 2015 07:31:45 PM)    
 
1) Government should make sure that one nation one Board for education should be created all over India. CBSE, ICSE, State Boards should be amalgamated.

2) Knowledge should be delivered in one language (i.e) English. It is unfortunate but english is the language which units India.

3) Learning regional language should be motivated.

4) No matter who one is (i.e. son or daughter of either CEO of a company or worker of a company) , one should get equal education (e.g) Jack Welch's son studied in same school where son of GE's worker studied.

5) Endowment should be motivated. Prosperous Alumini's of colleges should give back to their Alma mater.

6) Inter-caste marriages should be motivated otherwise depending one's surname job or opportunities would be given.

After one such generation completes 10+6 years education. Reservation should be removed.

Rate this:   +11   -9


P. Satish Patro said: (Tue, Mar 10, 2015 06:44:45 PM)    
 
Upto what I think, Reservation must be there. But it must be for senior citizens, Handicapped persons, & BPL category.

Now-a-days, reserved peoples become rich & availing the facilities although they are rich. A student who know more than a reservation quota student, who must get the jobs.

If a reserved category boy/girl get a job of pilot, but general caste boy knew more than him/her. Who must join the service? Think twice.

Although some of rich families are also making BPL cards, but the corrupted percent will decrease so much.

This is my view.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +10   -4


Yugalkishor said: (Tue, Mar 10, 2015 02:33:35 PM)    
 
I think reservation system is good in Indian education system because it eradicates the backwardness of ones family. Before he/she enters in reputation institutes like IITs/NITs/PMT etc he/she have weak/poor background, but by getting quality education he can enhance his capabilities, skills and can become a message for his community. It is better utilization of reservation in our steeping.

GREAT INDIA. Thank you.

Rate this:   +8   -27


G.Ramulu said: (Fri, Mar 6, 2015 06:50:44 AM)    
 
Hi friends,

According to me, reservations are many types. (please try to understand my point). We can see the berth reservations in the railways, at least before 90 days. &180 days in the flights. Should it continue?

Reservations to the senior citizens (above 60 years) & disabled are there in the society. Should it continue?Many seats are reserved in the buses & trains for ladies. Should it continue?There are reservations, in the local body elections, for women, BC, SC&ST categories. Should it continue?

The SC, ST categories are having reservations in the education, employment, state assemblies &parliament. Still their conditions are worse. 90% are living in below poverty line. Should it continue?The above reservations are provided by the government. The elected representatives have made the proper laws.

But it is interesting to note that, the upper castes who are less than 15%, have been enjoying 90% of the lands, industries, assets with out having any present governmental reservations. Do you know that, prior to the present constitution, there was a "Manu Dharma "which reserved all these facilities to upper castes?

Do you know that the education & properties are rejected to Sudras&atisudras and the poverty & illiteracy had been reserving to 85% people. Please we are think and apply humanitarian out look, which reservation has stay?And which reservation has to go?

Rate this:   +12   -18


Pavan said: (Thu, Mar 5, 2015 09:20:40 PM)    
 
Hi everybody,

Our friends said reservation means showing status with other castes. I mean reservation is a virus who will convert unreserved caste to reserved caste they are getting this virus. So I am saying please implement the rules for reservation. Then only India will be a developed country.

Rate this:   +3   -8


Chilvalwarsathish said: (Sat, Feb 28, 2015 10:21:58 PM)    
 
According to my view our Indian Government should change the reservation system. Because some students having good knowledge and good score but they dint get the job because of the reason reservation system. Mainly in competitive examination system can change the reservation system. Who are the getting highest scores in written examination they can eligible to that jobs and government cannot provide the any reservation in this exams.

For example I am taking the OC cast in that OC some family's having rich and some family's having poor family but both family are named unreserved family. Rich people family living life is very nice but poor people living life is very bad.

And the last thing is government can change the rules and regulations for regarding this reservation system. And should make new changes in this reservation system.

Thanks to all.

Rate this:   +15   -3


Suresh M. Humane said: (Mon, Feb 23, 2015 09:23:19 PM)    
 
Dear All Friends Jaybhim.

This is the fact all above. Since, last ancient period only lower caste people bearing all trouble. But nobody forwarded to give the justice & equality to them. Only God create & gives the birth to Dr. Ambedkar giving the justice and equality to the downtrodden people in recently means implementation of 'Indian Constitution' to the Government In his speech Dr. Ambedkar to the the Government Only in 10 years full fill the backlog. But Government Doesn't mind.

Every Government Of India it is used (reservation) for voting of SC/ST's communities. Means, it time to time increased. So, Government Should take strict action against the implementation of reservation as early as.

Rate this:   +12   -7


Surya Pratap Singh said: (Mon, Feb 23, 2015 01:01:10 PM)    
 
Reservation should be terminated but the government must make strong law for security of SC/ST/OBCs peoples.

If any private sector deny to entry of lower caste, it should be punish.

Rate this:   +6   -8


Nagaraj Mahajan said: (Fri, Feb 20, 2015 06:27:06 PM)    
 
Today reservation is increasing along with Indian population. This is a not a good thing for Indian peoples. Because every one should fight for their surveillance. Today government making separate category for separate people according to their economy, places, languages, religious.

General merit students facing the problems in jobs. If the category people are not much good in their marks, qualification, they are eligible to get a jobs in government sections. These kind of peoples will not need any extra work, any extra qualification. They will be settled by their category.

But now a days this will be affecting general merit students. If this reservation is balanced everyone may get the jobs and they lead their life happily.

Rate this:   +6   -7


Riya said: (Tue, Feb 17, 2015 06:41:24 PM)    
 
There is no need for reservation in private sector. Now a days no means left of reservation. Because the purpose for which it is started don't seem now. It is started for low income people that is analyzed by their caste.

But now a time income can not analyzed by their caste. In government sector reservation is enough for those people. General quota people is now jobless, if in private sector also reservation apply then they will be absolutely jobless.

Rate this:   +8   -3


Desai said: (Thu, Feb 12, 2015 10:25:20 PM)    
 
Hi everyone,

Now a days government is taking advantage by giving many reservations for different categories, for this reason general people are suffering from unemployment even they are educated because, these reservations people are getting employed even they did not study so, this reservation system should be eliminated.

In private sector they are giving less importance to reservations so the company shares are increasing because of educated guys. Reservations should be given for the people only who are economically weak.

Rate this:   +18   -4


Nagaraju.Sambu said: (Mon, Feb 9, 2015 10:07:59 PM)    
 
Hello friends,

Our respected democratic Indian constitution is defining the nation as a secular country, which means the governance must be separated from the religions or castes. Providing reservations for the minorities and lower classes is a good idea, but it isn't only the solution to raise them.

Being a secular nation, the government itself reminding and interfering indirectly with the religion and caste. Now a days no caste is lower and no one is upper, all are equal. If we really desire for a real secular, religious and caste free nation, reservations must be based on economic conditions of the citizen, not based on caste.

Rate this:   +27   -1


Deepak said: (Mon, Feb 9, 2015 02:31:37 PM)    
 
Reservation makes a person handicap. Because he works only that much which is required to get qualified. Therefore in providing reservation compromise in skills, marks, requirement should not be permitted.

In reservation only monetary assistance to the poor should be provided under strict observation so that he can't make misuse of it regardless of his cast. Lastly reservation should be provided on the bases of need not on the bases of cast.

Rate this:   +12   -3


Devraj said: (Sun, Feb 8, 2015 10:43:24 PM)    
 
My opinion about reservation.

We should remove reservation from our system. All knows that many institute of "IIT" & PMT selected student basic of reservation. Because reservation it got lower category student and many talent student doesn't show his talent.

If lower category person became teacher then "What would I teach children". Because he doesn't know anything. Because reservation our education level is come down.

Rate this:   +3   -5


Mahi said: (Sat, Feb 7, 2015 04:18:45 PM)    
 
I think government must destroy this reservation process in every field reservation is like a handicapped economy for our country and danger for our country's future. For example in our army why does not government take reservation because he wants our army strong and he only elect qualified person and psychically strong person. I request to the government please eject the reservation process in every field and makes our country strong.

Jai hind and jai bharat.

Rate this:   +15   -6


Sivaroop said: (Thu, Feb 5, 2015 11:50:51 PM)    
 
Hi friends.

In my opinion reservation in private sector is not good. Now a days govt providing reservation based on their backwardness and caste but I oppose this one. Govt should be provide reservation based on their income level, facilities only not on their caste and backwardness.

If govt want to provide reservation they van provide in education only so many people are interested to study but they are unable to study because of their economic condition. So govt provide based on their economic situation and people who are talent.

Coming to jobs govt should not provide any reservation for the vacancies filling. They should be treat all the people are equal. They give jobs based an their talent, qualifying in exam only not based on their reservation.

In jobs competition in between on their talent only not on their reservation. I am telling one thing the candidate who is having reservation got less marks in written exam when com pare to other general category person in final result the one who having reservation got job other one not. This makes discourage their confidence of general category people.

In my opinion govt focus on providing good educational specialties,

Education is most important for now a days so we can provide education fr all is first thing that's why I support for reservation in education but while coming to jobs we encourage talent only not reservation system.

If we encourage talent we get good result in economic growth, and better result out come. So friends govt not give reservation private and public sectors.

Rate this:   +5   -2


Amruta said: (Tue, Feb 3, 2015 04:45:14 PM)    
 
Your view is also right friend.

But providing reservation in private sector is not way to help them. Government already given reservation for studies. Exception from fees. If government is providing such facility to them. Then its their turn to prove them self.

Rate this:   +4   -2


Vishu said: (Tue, Feb 3, 2015 01:18:29 AM)    
 
By reading all of your comments against reservations, I had realized that all of general candidates are viewing the reservation as per their convenience. Go to villages and see. You will find exact opposite situation there. All the general category people (Gaavwalas) rule the villages because they are of higher caste.

Then why don you people raise your voice against them. Rural areas are also part of India. They also have to be brought up. 1st start abolishing this discrimination from village itself and then you have the rights to speak against reservation!

Rate this:   +18   -20


G.Ramulu said: (Wed, Jan 28, 2015 09:39:14 PM)    
 
Reservations are creating many suspicions in the minds of upper caste brothers. They are not against to reservation on the basis of economic criteria. You might have known that the less than 2% are controlling the Indian economy, politics, higher jobs etc. Should this existing order be continued? If you are really against the reservation, would you ready to fight?

Rate this:   +9   -1


Anupam Shrivastava said: (Wed, Jan 28, 2015 12:38:43 AM)    
 
My opinion is to remove reservation on cast basis from both sectors Private and Government. As we can see that cast reservation system is really hampering the growth our nation. Students gives their best efforts in their examinations and even they get good marks too but still they didn't shortlisted for their desired Institution or job because of cast reservation. And I think it really reduces their confidence.

I think reservation should be applicable to those candidates who are handicapped or lying below poverty line only as they cannot afford better training centers or study material. Reservation in private sector may lead to negative growth of our economy because candidates then will be selected through their cast and quotas instead of their result and experience. I also think that reservation system is humiliating the Right to equality.

According to our constitution, every caste is equal then how can they provide reservation to certain castes? For example: A person belonging to General caste studies well and gave his best efforts to crack an exam to achieve a job. He is well talented and skilled and fortunately he gets good marks in his exam as well and another side a person belonging to a lower cast secures marks lower than him. But he got selected because of reservation but the general candidate didn't. So won't it reduce his confidence?

Rate this:   +25   -7


G.Ramulu said: (Tue, Jan 27, 2015 10:44:51 PM)    
 
Hi friends,

Majority of the participants are basing on economical issues and are assessing the Indian situation only on that basis. But it is not correct method.

Many issues are influencing the country. Caste is also a major issue. It has been influencing the Indian society more than two thousand years. It divided our society in pieces. In a ladder type caste system, upper castes are getting honours and lower castes are getting humiliations. This can be called "social capital". Naturally the social capital is with upper castes. Addition to this, education & wealth was denied to "Sudra" lower castes.

I can say one thing confidently that the participants in the discussions are from either upper caste or non-observers of the Indian society. At least, now on-wards study the Indian social system. To get the some more knowledge, please study the writings of Pulea, Dr. Ambedkar, Sukh dev thorat, Mungrekar, Kancha Ilaiah etc.

Rate this:   +12   -5


Ankita said: (Tue, Jan 27, 2015 07:23:49 PM)    
 
Earlier days reservation came into mind because there were some group of people who did not receive the proper treatment from others. That is why reservation system came into existence.

Now a days reservation system dominates the proper growth of a common man. We can see a person who is from a backward class having little knowledge is being preferred more than a person having a great knowledge. A child is being dominated on the basis of caste which affects a lot to him.

So I would say reservation system should be avoided in private sectors and each and every person should be given equality and they should be judged according to their performance and capability.

Rate this:   +3   -4


Yash Bhatt said: (Sun, Jan 25, 2015 08:06:09 PM)    
 
Hey friends I agree with all of you and I want to say that the reservation system should not be banned completely but the proper implementation is applied on it. Like it should be enforced in the basis of financial strength not in the basis of caste.

Because it discriminates people and also encourages them in doing something harmful for their society, community and country. And at last I want to say that it should not be implemented in the places where we needs quality like in the civil services and other sectors for employment. By this the structure of our country is deteriorating.

Thank you friends.

Rate this:   +5   -1


G.Ramulu said: (Sat, Jan 24, 2015 10:40:05 AM)    
 
Hi friends,

I have been writing in support of "Reservation in private sector, ". All of you know that our Indian society is a caste ridden, complicated one. Here are more than 6000 castes. No caste is equal to any other caste. We can't see this kind of worst systems in the world. This caste system is becoming major hurdle to the country's development.

Let us root-out the caste-system. To eradicate the caste-system, every person, family, mass front and political party should promote inter caste marriages. Reservation are required, due to caste system. If there is no caste, there is no necessity of reservation. Are you ready to do it? "Same caste marriages should be banned".

Rate this:   +10   -7


Akshat said: (Wed, Jan 21, 2015 01:57:55 PM)    
 
Guys today reservation is done not only in private sectors but in government and tertiary sectors as well. Whether it be in the form of job, promotions, several quotas or some other of its kind. This reservation scheme play an impartial role in our lives. On one hand if it helps a person in achieving something then on the other hand its takes something from hands of some other person. I am taking about the various kind of quotas involved in reservation for admission or jobs in private sectors like for example in any private institutions any private company etc.

Due top such things the person who actually deserve to be on the top is actually below to the person who do not deserve it. Like in many cases of jobs and education. But this is not the only thing reservation if does something bad then it does good to many of us. Reservation helps one to represent oneself and it fulfills the requirement of many backward classes people. It promotes some class of people and their communities.

As a conclusion I would like to say if reservations are done it should be done keeping in mind the other people of the society too and if it promotes some class of people then he should also keep in mind the other deserving class of candidates too. He should maintain an equal balance between the two groups.

Rate this:   +3   -4


Baban said: (Fri, Jan 16, 2015 08:38:44 PM)    
 
According to me, there should not be reservation in private sector. If the government will allow the reservation in private sector then lot of company or investor will not invest in India because no one want a weak or average employee. And also this decision may be harm Indian economy. And also I do not support cast based system because there are lot of person are poor who belong to upper cast. And also I would like to mention that cast is good but not on cast based but on income based.

Rate this:   +3   -5


G.Ramulu said: (Thu, Jan 15, 2015 11:56:50 PM)    
 
I saw Venky's comment on "reservation in private sector" (on 15-1-15). Economic factor is one of the reasons, but it is not the whole thing. Caste is determining all the issues. In various aspects, we can see the caste factor. Caste is linked with birth, school admission, relatives, marriages. And even in burial grounds too. Did any body observe this?

Why the big industrialists, land lords, supreme & high court chef justices, chief editors of the print & electric media, are from upper castes only. What is the reason? Many of the people don't know that education and property rights were denied to Sc, St and Bc's centuries together.

The poor, from the upper caste, can be considered as they were victimized by economical basis. But they have not been victimized by other non-economical issues. Many of Our Indian intellectuals are not in a position to understand all the factors, due to their caste leanings.

Rate this:   +5   -5


Danish said: (Thu, Jan 15, 2015 11:50:59 PM)    
 
Reservation is not good way to secure the seats of SC, ST in private sector just like in public sector, and why they want. I meant to say that we are all equal and no need to put cast reservation in private sector on the basis that they are poor and belong to lower cast. I think lower caste people are taking this as a+ point.

And if the law will pass for reservation than so many deserved person will not able to get the job because reserved persons already acquire their certain seats. And they are already reserved their seats in public sector. Secondly, it will be well and good to reserve the seats for handicap rather to reserve for lower caste. Because somehow, practically handicaps are not as much physically fit as compare to common man.

Rate this:   +13   -1


Venky said: (Thu, Jan 15, 2015 12:50:32 PM)    
 
I'm against for reservation system because government is reservation giving basis of "cast". That's not good. All sc, st candidates are not poor persons and all oc candidates are not rich persons. Some poor persons is there in oc cast and some rich persons are there in sc candidates so it's not good point of my way. If you want give reservation you can give basis of talent and you can give handicaps. This is my opinion. If it follows the India will develop definitely. We can see the India in top position without corruption.

Rate this:   +20   -3


Sonu said: (Tue, Jan 13, 2015 10:55:29 PM)    
 
Reservation is necessary for poor peoples and majority belongs to lower cast. After the 60 year of freedom all people are poor who are belong to lower cast. Cast is related to birth so any person may be in lower cast or in upper cast but we need to think about humanity. There are many resources of money in upper cast family but lower cast depends only have a job. Some lower cast families also rich and some upper also poor but these are few.

In the past or in history lower cast peoples were good servants than why some peoples are in oppose in their reservation. Reservation must be in both private and government sector. And if any person is in oppose of reservation and he thinks that he is right than he must allow love marriages of his relatives to lover cast person and than if he thinks about no chance of marry with lower cast than he must think about reservation if he loves to his country or country growth.

Rate this:   +7   -10


Srinivas said: (Sun, Jan 11, 2015 06:14:49 PM)    
 
Dear friends! as above all you said take out the caste system both in the private and public sector.

Actually we have to know well about, why reservations, as the poor people are not able to study and eat and to get well trained to meet the present challenges in the interview, there are so many reasons why poor is still becoming poor and rich is rich. Reservation should be continue until and unless all get minimum needs.

Rate this:   +5   -6


G.Ramulu said: (Tue, Jan 6, 2015 10:18:40 PM)    
 
Which has to go? Either caste system? or reservations? The caste system benefits upper castes,
where as the present reservations benefit, some of the the suppressed castes.

Rate this:   +2   -2


Shrishai.N said: (Tue, Jan 6, 2015 09:12:14 PM)    
 
Hi all, according to me there should be reservation only limited to EDUCATION but when come to Job either Public or the Private there should not be any reservation. If you have SKILLS & the Knowledge you will get the Job any where you want.

As I observed in the above debate it does not mean that those who can read and write are from upper caste and those who don't are from the lower caste.

According to me even the Reservation Patterns has to change I can not say how to change because if I say anything then either (upper or lower) caste people will blame me, so the Gov. Has to take some corrective Measures.

Rate this:   +9   -4


Md. Ragib Alam said: (Tue, Jan 6, 2015 04:14:42 PM)    
 
After listening all of you I got to learn many things about Reservation in private sector but according to me reservation should not be there in private sector because it creates discrimination between upper castes and lower castes and those belongs to schedule castes, schedule tribe and other backward castes also belongs to rich family and having a enough resources to survive their life. And those who are having capabilities ultimately he will get the job and there is no need to having reservations.

Thank you.

Rate this:   +1   -5


Naman said: (Mon, Jan 5, 2015 12:22:49 PM)    
 
First of all reservation is creating inequality in Indian society.

Another thing is that Government failed to provide exact benefit of it in last 50 years. Now it is just like a custom.

The people who is getting benefit of reservation is becoming more idle. They feel that they can crack exam or get job with a very less effort then why to worry about examination.

They are already getting benefit for cracking exam like low passing score and low examination fees. They also get the scholarship for their study. So now its their time to prove their mettle to get job without reservation.

The criteria of defining reserved caste in India is not proper measure. Higher caste population is also poor. They are also low educated.

Government need to prepare report on reducing reservation every 5 years based on some criteria and also remove some people from the benefit of reservation.

Rate this:   +11   -1


Suraj Chauhan said: (Fri, Jan 2, 2015 02:54:49 PM)    
 
In my point of view the reservation is correct in his place but if this exist in government sector is good not in all place. Can anyone tell me why people are against the reservation from long times the upper caste ahead in money and upper post because they are in good position to achieve that post. Who are talking against reservation can give their money to poor people to achieve their dream. Poor people have not enough money to gaining higher education but they try and government also want that everyone to right to achieve good education, respect in society. If every rich man ready to distribute their money among people then everyone is equal then competition is took place.

Rate this:   +10   -5


G.Ramulu said: (Fri, Dec 26, 2014 10:52:39 PM)    
 
Hi friends,

Due to the caste system, our country is not getting forwarded.

Centuries together, 90% of the people, who were the work force of the nation, were barred from the education& the literacy. At the same time, the lazy section of the population were educated but did not participate in any kind of production.

This kind of situation did not existed in the world. This might be the major reason to our backwardness. If this caste system does remain in future too, the reservation has to fallow. If the caste system is eradicated, automatically the the reservation issue will wither away.

How to eradicate the caste system is the real issue. The caste has come in to existence only after marriage system came in to being. Due to the "Same-caste marriage", it is continuing. The caste system was existed so far, is continuing and going to remain only through the same caste marriages only.

If the two generations are away to the same caste marriages, the caste will be no more. Only one solution to eradicate the caste system is boycotting the the marriages in the same caste. Are any anti-reservation participants in the discussions, are in a position to marry other caste, rather than same caste to you or your family members?

Rate this:   +8   -9


G.Ramulu said: (Sat, Dec 20, 2014 08:59:55 PM)    
 
Hi friends,

You observe one thing, The caste is basis for the reservation. If caste is eradicated, there is no question of reservation either in private or public sector. Those people who are opposing any kind of reservation, are in a position to oppose the caste also? caste is also a reservation.

The fathers castes are are being reserved for their kids. Should this reservation continue? Respects are reserved for upper castes, where as humiliations are reserved for SC, ST, and OBC. How to correct it? Can any body in a position to leave their caste? Why all the marriages are being taken place in the same caste only, Why?Please explain.

Rate this:   +20   -1


G.Ramulu said: (Tue, Dec 16, 2014 11:00:59 PM)    
 
Hi friends,

Many friends, who participated in the discussions are proposing that either the government or the private managements should take the responsibility to provide special facilities the needed people. If this is not done by the govt or private management, what should be the alternative?

Rate this:   +3   -0


B.Subbarao said: (Sun, Dec 14, 2014 10:34:56 AM)    
 
Subbarao,

Hi friends,

At present global competition time, skill full persons are needed to the society for uplifting the country and as to be placed in the better mark in the world. I perceived that the reservation in private sector indicates negative economic growth because of those real talented persons may not be placed in the product based organisations. At the time of independence, situation was very different that was why our leaders created reservations to the backward people. But now 70% of the people are living in better way.

If political parties are following the patriotism and working for the country development, they should change their mind set regarding to the reservation. They may choose alternate facilities to the backward people. There is a way to support the backward students that to provide enough privileges to those who really economically backward and physically handicapped without naming any caste and religion because of all "ALL ARE EQUAL" as per our fundamental right.

Finally my conclusion is that the voice of reservation insisting in the private sector is to be avoided for better future of our country.

"TALENTS MAKE MEMORABLE WONDERS".

Rate this:   +24   -3


G.Ramulu said: (Mon, Dec 8, 2014 11:25:11 PM)    
 
Reservations can be divided in to two categories.

1) Upper caste reservations & 2) Lower caste reservations.

Reservations are also can be divided in two types.

1) Positive reservations & 2) Negative reservations.

(Positive reservation for gain and negative reservation for loss. ).

The positive reservations have been continuing centuries together to upper castes.

And negative reservations for lower castes,

Where as the lower caste (positive) reservations have been started nearly 100 years back only.

Nobody is mentioning about the upper caste positive reservation, what is the reason?

But the upper caste intellectuals are not realizing this factor. How to make them realize?

If all the means of production (land, factories etc) are nationalized, the question of reservation would not rise.

If there is no private sector, what is the necessity of discussing this issue ?

Let us fight for nationalization and against privatization. Are any body take this challenge?

Rate this:   +4   -13


Bisht said: (Sun, Dec 7, 2014 05:30:22 PM)    
 
Disagree, reservation give only for basis of income in lower caste some people are so rich as compare to upper cast and they grab reservation even they don't need this. Government say we should not create line between upper cast and lower cast but in real government.

Create line b/w upper cast and lower cast by giving reservation to lower cast. So conclusion is Reservation is good for our country in Public sector Or private sector.

Rate this:   +4   -4


G.Ramulu(Hyd) said: (Sat, Dec 6, 2014 11:29:36 PM)    
 
Hi friends,

Where there is inequality, there needs the reservation. Inequality stems from exploitation. Generally exploited needs the reservation, but in India, exploiters availed the reservation centuries together. If we can impartially observe, all the wealth&knowledge is forcibly reserved to upper castes only.

In other countries who could afford, can get the education, every one had the right to have the property. In India these rights were rejected to to the majority people, only due to the caste system. This factor is not understood by the majority of the participants of this debate.

As long as caste remains, discrimination will continue. If discrimination continue, the reservation demand will in be in live. If any body, who really oppose the reservation, has to fight against the caste system. If caste system is disappeared, where is the question of reservations?

Rate this:   +9   -1


Deepak said: (Wed, Dec 3, 2014 04:25:54 PM)    
 
Hello friends,

Let me put my point straight away, there should be no reservation for anybody in any sector, whether its public or private. Not all upper caste people are intelligent and rich, in the same way not all lower caste people are backward.

When it comes to work in private sector its just purely based on the skill of the individual and there is no caste column anywhere in private sector, Meaning that if you have skill then you are most welcome, no matter which caste you belong to. Even in the work place there is no discrimination done either in terms of caste of in terms of gender too. Ultimately Talent and skill should be the winner, and not the caste.

Rate this:   +45   -1


G.Rramulu said: (Fri, Nov 28, 2014 12:16:47 AM)    
 
Reservation in private sector is needed to lower castes. Lower castes naturally invites this demand. Where as upper castes oppose it. Upper castes generally claim that they are merit and efficient, & Lower castes are quality-less, merit-less and inefficient people. This is absolutely wrong understanding. If upper castes are only the patent to merit, how can they justify it?majority of the collectors are from the upper caste (merit) people.

Why did the districts which were controlled by them are not developed?many SP's are from merit (upper castes) then why law & order not controlled there? Many chef ministers are from upper castes, then why this backwardness in the states ?all most all the supreme& high court judges are from merit people (from upper caste) then, why the lakhs of cases are pending in the courts ?all the prime-ministers are from upper castes only. No body were either ST or ST. Why India is so backward till now ?what can they say?.

According to them that they are not availing any reservations. It is not right. Can any body tell the reason, how could 15% upper caste people are owning 94% of lands in the country?. How the 97% of business& industry are in the hands of 15%upper castes, 68% political representation with 15% population.

Reason is very simple, except last two/three generations education & properties are denied to lower castes. Education, properties & honours were reserved to upper castes & poverty, illiteracy and humiliations were reserved to majority (lower) castes.

Reality is that the upper castes are availing the reservations since 3000 years, where the sc, st & bc's are only from 1930 on wards. That too very recently. To continue their centuries together reservations, the upper caste "castiests" are attacking the lower castes reservations. With out understanding this Indian reality, no one would be a intellectual in the country.

Rate this:   +11   -14


G.Ramulu said: (Wed, Nov 26, 2014 02:57:43 PM)    
 
Hi friends, above 90% participants in the discussion are against the reservation in private sector. Majority of them definitely might be from upper caste. Their population in the society is not more than 15%. But they are in a position to write in English.

85%are not trained up in English. What is the reason? Who are responsible for it? Any speaking or writing person can answer it? If you are a merit man, give explanation.

Rate this:   +16   -9


Surabhi Sharma said: (Sat, Nov 22, 2014 03:19:58 PM)    
 
Hello everyone. From my (a student) point of view reservation is dangerous problem of our country because there is preference by their cast not by ability. In India everyone says corruption, black money, etc. are the biggest problem but they don't know that reservation work like a barrier in progress of our country. A person who is not able for clerical post get a high position by reservation.

So this problem should be short out as soon as possible.

Rate this:   +25   -5


Jordan said: (Thu, Nov 20, 2014 10:03:03 PM)    
 
Hi All,

I would like tell one thing in Pvt sector or Govt sector, there should be no reservation. Actually I don't understand why need reservation is that needed till today? Ask everyone yourself because everyone studying the same subjects but coming to this reservation students are bifurcated. In India this is the worst thing I will say. Hope in future no reservation should not be there and all are equal for all opportunities.

Rate this:   +14   -1


Pawansut Yadav said: (Thu, Nov 20, 2014 11:55:09 AM)    
 
Hello Mitro (friends) ,

We know that everything have positive point but its mirror image always have some negative point we should try to neglect negative thought (point) but a long time neglection of those point then that point become poisons for us so implementation is much important for that situation eventually RESERVATION is important but must important that reservation is provided for which type of candidate.

Rate this:   +7   -1


Shalini Singh said: (Sun, Nov 16, 2014 12:02:40 PM)    
 
So guys, the topic is should reservation be there. First of all I totally disagree the statement and reservation should not be there in any sector. Everyone work hard to succeed and then why there is partiality with some people.

I think if our "India" is group of religions n believe in "unity in diversity" then why it is dividing people on the basis of caste as well as religion. Instead it should be on the basis of economic status. This will also help improve poverty and also direct our country in right position.

Reservation has many other disadvantages such as it creates hatred among the people of different community, the disappointed among the unreserved candidates which should not be ignored.

So, I think its enough and we should fight or our rights and must change the rules.

Rate this:   +22   -7


Speak Your Mind:
  • Please do not use chat terms. Example: avoid using "grt" instead of "great".


  • © 2008-2015 by IndiaBIX™ Technologies. All Rights Reserved | Copyright | Terms of Use & Privacy Policy

    Contact us: info@indiabix.com     Follow us on twitter!