Reservations in the Private Sector
|
|
 |
Points to remember before you participate in this disuccsion:
- Assume, you one of the member of a real group discussion.
- Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
- Express your positive attitude towards providing the solution.
|
|
V.Lakshmi Narayana said:
(Tue, Mar 20, 2012 12:58:35 AM)
|
|
| |
| In India getting education also depends on the family background like number of educated individuals. So if we look into the history of India these general category people enjoyed the right to education and got a very good education and naturally a high status in the society people. But sc/st people or what we call as untouchables were betrayed of education and anyone from this category hardly learned in those days. So reservation is a better idea to uplift those kind of people. Government is not picking anyone randomly and giving him the opportunities but the best among the category or the individual who deserve it is given the chance which may be through a common entrance examination etc. So I strongly support that reservation system should be continued in India for some more years. |
|
Rate this: +10   -6
|
|
Kishore said:
(Sun, Jan 29, 2012 06:33:41 PM)
|
|
| |
| All those who talk of quality / merit and reservation can once just for sake of imagination think of a situation whereby 100% resevation and opprtunities to progress are given only to backward class persons in all educations/ jobs of society ( and the rest are not allowed infact punished if they attempt to learn anything or progress by themselves) from Junior KG onwards and in all Jobs except the sweeper and alike jobs only for next 50 years NOT 5000 as has been the case otherwise, and then put the argument of merits and quality after these 50 years how fair that would be ! |
|
Rate this: +2 -5
|
|
Himadri Tanaya said:
(Sat, Jan 28, 2012 04:10:12 PM)
|
|
| |
| "I belong to the backward class yet i completely defy the "job reservation plan". The government ought to recognize the competition for jobs in the market. When such a huge population sits unemployed at home,it is just a shame to discuss about giving priority to low caste.Even, one must know that, today, there is no more violation regarding caste and getting job depends purely on one's potential, personality and of course the tough competition. The government should better focus on helping the poor, irrespective of there caste and stop making such plans which will arouse conflicts." |
|
Rate this: +14 -1
|
|
Vikkie said:
(Thu, Jan 19, 2012 06:15:36 PM)
|
|
| |
| Miss Richa, with due respect i think what you just wrote is totally rubbish. How do you know that a student of lower caste won't be able to perform well, how can anyone say that getting in good college would get him in depression. Well if you have examples in your explanations then keep it with you. And your thoughts to create separate institutes to help the students of lower caste, then you sound to me like a heartless person of the past who used to discriminate people on the basis of their caste. Can anybody tell me that why in school we have uniforms, so that all of the kids look alike, but i guess some people here still have that old mentality . Grow up people. |
|
Rate this: +7 -3
|
|
Jubs said:
(Wed, Jan 18, 2012 08:39:39 PM)
|
|
| |
| Reservation was given for the betterment of the backward classes. but, nowadays, it is being miss used. coz, some people who belong to backward classes also holds a good position and earns ahandsome salary. so, in that case, reservation should be given only interms of financial condition. |
|
Rate this: +13 -1
|
|
Sushant said:
(Tue, Jan 3, 2012 10:46:19 AM)
|
|
| |
| Reservation is given for the people so that they can grow up at economic and social level in the society. This is an step which is governed by government in our country. Reservation was a good step but now a days it became an path for success. This resulted in continuous degradation in quality of government jobs but there is also a good increment for the government job seekers. |
|
Rate this: +5 -2
|
|
Nikita Gupta said:
(Mon, Dec 19, 2011 07:45:49 PM)
|
|
| |
Reservation is not at all required in the present India. It was meant to raise the status of the SC'S and ST'S etc. but now this facility is misused.
If the basic school education is given to the children of every poor family free of cost not on the basis of caste but on the basis of financial conditions, then there will be no need of reservtaion at higher levels.
If they are primarily educated then they will be at the same status as of the general category and they will be able to compete at the higher levels also. |
|
Rate this: +21 -6
|
|
Nikhil,Mumbai said:
(Thu, Nov 10, 2011 11:25:38 PM)
|
|
| |
| Reservation is very much needed in Private organization and Conglomerates for upliftment of the individuals belonging to backward castes.The people who have replied/commented here in this forum have replied in ENGLISH which means most of you belong to Tier1,2 or 3 cities,but what about the else.The rich will get richer and the poor will get poorer as they belong to backward communities.You all only for the sake of commenting say that we should help poorer/backward people but when it comes to giving a helping hand everyone is on a better back foot.Private org reservation is must to get every individual on the same page |
|
Rate this: +5 -15
|
|
Sankalp said:
(Fri, Oct 21, 2011 08:13:14 PM)
|
|
| |
| Well friends reservation is not all necessary as per the academic and jobs matter are concern. If at all it's being provided looking on backward cast economical and financial situation that should be in form their finance term so that they could spend that money in the right way and reach to the race of today market moreover that's the basic principle behind reservation. In the point of view it should not be based on cost and religious rather it should be open to all looking on their economical as well financial condition. |
|
Rate this: +2 -3
|
|
Sankalp said:
(Fri, Oct 21, 2011 08:09:42 PM)
|
|
| |
| Well friends reservation is not all necessary as per the academic and jobs matter are concern. If at all it's being provided looking on backward cast economical and financial situation that should be in form their finance term so that they could spend that money in the right way and reach to the race of today market moreover that's the basic principle behind reservation. In the point of view it should not be based on cost and religious rather it should be open to all looking on their economical as well financial condition. |
|
Rate this: +2 -3
|
|
Amrit K Mohanty said:
(Thu, Oct 13, 2011 09:26:07 PM)
|
|
| |
| Look friends reservation in govt sector too is absolutely a counter productive idea. If we support reservation in pvt sector I think we are all going in wrong direction. Look our economy is highly dependent on pvt sector production/ services. This is the only private MNC and domestic companies for which our economy growth is constantly maintained. Hence a little deviation in PVT sector out put will shake the whole economy. Pvt sectors demand high skilled people for their growth, for thier very exhistance and quality enhencement they always require dynamic/quality resourcefull manpower. By reserving seats in pvt sectors we will cease their developement as more and more unproductive/undeserving men/women will join them. So in private sectors no reservation should be entitled. |
|
Rate this: +6 -2
|
|
Anjali said:
(Mon, Sep 12, 2011 01:37:52 PM)
|
|
| |
| Reservation system is a incurable disease to society. Where it waz intorduced for betterment of SC, OBC classes now it is being misused. Now India don't need reservation system where we have grown in every aspects this resevation is being loophole to society. The idea dnt have ny problem. But due to this resevation system deserving are being neglected. Deserving will get what he deserve, need is of boostup not of sympathy. The conclusion is India don't need resevation system nymore. |
|
Rate this: +10 -3
|
|
Anil Kumar Mundhra said:
(Thu, Sep 1, 2011 01:58:16 AM)
|
|
| |
I do not agree the reservation system like in India. The reservation system started by Dr. B. Are. Ambedkar for giving a chance to backward classes to participate in development of India. It was only for 10-20 years not for whole life. But, Now a days, it is only for politics issue for collecting more and more votes. Now a days reservation should be based on economic not on the cast system.
Specially in education sector, there should be no reservation for any one. If anyone can not study due to financial problem, government can provide him financially help. So that we can produce a good quality of people who help in our economic and social growth.
But as we know that India is a democratic country. If system wants to change this reservation strategy, the people (who come under reservation category) will come down road. So system is also helpless. |
|
Rate this: +31 -4
|
|
Anubhav Sharma said:
(Thu, Feb 17, 2011 08:29:39 AM)
|
|
| |
| I totally oppose the reservation in private sectors because we can all see how these reservation hampering the progress of India and talented people belong to general category, if there is a reservation in private sector also then how the young talent people belomg to general category would come forward, theu would loose every oppurtunties, like they have been missing from the years whn reservation started. Although upliftment of socially backward classes is good but giving all to only one category suppressing other category is not good at all. There should be some competttive level in private sector, because if not then it will greatly effect the growth of private sectors. |
|
Rate this: +11 -5
|
|
Vinod said:
(Tue, Dec 28, 2010 02:08:44 PM)
|
|
| |
| Resevation is needed for the social upliftment of social and economic backward class people. Corporate responsibility dictate that private sector also has a big role to play in social re-engineering. Country can said to be develped only when all the stake holders in the democracy has truly prospered.The argument aganist reservation is that many who are not eligible are reaping benefit out of this social upliftment policy. I like to mention that there are many who hide their money and not pay the income tax. But that does not mean that income tax has to be abolished. Hence my take is for the reservation and by due deligence we can bring down the cases where ineligible candidate has been given the job. |
|
Rate this: +9 -9
|
|
Richa said:
(Wed, Dec 22, 2010 01:42:45 AM)
|
|
| |
Reservations are steps taken by the Government of India for the promotion of backward peoples.But do these people really get the benefit of these reservation.We take a example if a student of backward society get admission in a reputed government engineering college, will he be able to survive there?
Answer is: NO
The responsibility of government will end as he get the admission in college, but now he suffer because he is not that qualified and he under go depression. in my opinion government should provide fundamental education by opening more number of school and colleges for such student so that they may become self-dependent and they should not depend on these reservations. For this government can open more number of colleges and schools especially for backward students and provide scholarships to them. |
|
Rate this: +30 -17
|
|
Niteesh Mittal said:
(Wed, Oct 27, 2010 01:59:38 PM)
|
|
| |
Reservation is meant for the development of minorities, or the people who have lesser resources. Those who cannot grow by themselves are helped by the government to do more.
But, is it the real development process in which one category is developed suppressing the opportunities of other? It is not. It is like that, you are giving someone's prize to another.
Moreover, reservation has lead to the corruption in public sector. As we can see, we can hardly find any general category person in the government offices today and these are most corrupted sectors.
One more point is that, reservation in the higher studies is enough for anybody to grow well and boost his potential to a competition level. Then why to reserve seats in jobs. At least, jobs must have some competitive level of their own. |
|
Rate this: +14 -2
|
|
Kamaljeet Singh said:
(Thu, Sep 16, 2010 02:39:52 PM)
|
|
| |
Well there is nothing wrong in giving reservations but not in Jobs or in private sector but reservations should be given to people for enhancing their knowledge and becoming independent, So that they can be more competitive like other's who are not getting reservation. But today with the changing scenario, reservation has become a part of politics and not a matter of right to secure social solidarity. Political leaders just in the greed of votes and stability are using this sensitive issue as a weapon.
If each and every caste will demand reservation then there will be nothing like a general class and everyone will be in a reserved class which in turn will abolish reservation or just join hands together to curb red tapism and corruption existing in the present system and work hard to show your abilities in such a manner that in spite of reservation one may stand in a distinct position because even the reservation is not reaching to the one who really need reservation. |
|
Rate this: +8 -3
|
|
Kamaljeet Singh said:
(Wed, Sep 15, 2010 01:03:23 PM)
|
|
| |
Consequences of the Reservation system in Private sectors.
1. Proliferation of forged certificates may arise and the number of cases relating to it will be on the increase.
2. Rich people from backward classes will also be benefited from this system whereas the genuine intention was to benefit the poor in the backward classes. Hence this will affect the the needy and deserved people at the appropriate time.
3. Private companies will find its recruitment process tedious and betrayal and violation of the prescribed rules might become customary.
4. Reservation in private sector is an interference in the free working of market.
5. Lower qualifications hamper productivity and efficiency.
6. How we can compete with other countries as the only way to compete is by having people with talent and more competition and also people who can absorb stress. |
|
Rate this: +5 -2
|
|
Kapil Rathore said:
(Sat, Aug 28, 2010 04:45:48 AM)
|
|
| |
Reservation is given for the people so that they can grow up at economic and social level in the society. This is an step which is governed by government in our country. Reservation was a good step but now a days it became an path for success.This resulted in continuous degradation in quality of government jobs but there is also a good increment for the government job seekers.
Reservation in private sector will result in same and private sector's main motive is nothing else except money and for that they need quality but reservation may not satisfy the quality they want. So i disagree with the implementation of reservation in private sector. |
|
Rate this: +3 -3
|
|
Vjjjj said:
(Mon, Aug 23, 2010 03:16:44 PM)
|
|
| |
Actually reservation was given for the betterment of the socially backward peoples of the country and if we see the condition of india then it is little in better condition in some areas like LEH, KINNOUR-KAZA. People still living without electricity/water supply. In the Govt.. sector reservation give them chance to come forward.
But some really very corrupted people taking advantage of this reservation with enjoying each facility with royal lifestyle and that's why I'm talking about those people but in today's world the Govt.. sector may not be enough for these rural people. So i think we should give them chance with the help of reservation fot their betterment. |
|
Rate this: +2 -1
|
|
Rizwan Ahmad said:
(Tue, Jul 6, 2010 05:07:15 AM)
|
|
| |
I do not agree about the reservation in private sectors because a pravate is lead by the individual and it demands some skill hands do more development for his oragniztion. It has his own money so he has authorised to give pemission for the soft skill always.
All the profit and loss depends on the worker of that dat organization so it wud be definite require about the confidence mind.
Govt has the only take a pride of chance of this reservation but they only open for the talent dat if u have u come, otherwise ....... |
|
Rate this: +8 -3
|
|
|
