Women are not fit for Defense Services

Group Discussion
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
  • Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
  • Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
  • Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
  • Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
159 comments Page 14 of 16.

Shivasankari said:   1 decade ago
Women are perfectly fit to join defense services if they are given proper training. There is nothing a human cannot do then why there is discrimination between men and women. Women stand as the symbol of peace like mother theresa and at the same time they can be a symbol of courage like rani lakshmi. We all say that she can't handle the physical pain, people please don't forget the pain that every girl goes by giving birth. Not to forget that we can our nation as mother India. Then why this cheap discrimination between men and women. Women are equally capable to men and are fit in All sectors.
(138)

Nayan jyoti Borah said:   1 decade ago
Friends, I too don't agree that women are not fit for defense services. In my view women are behind every successful person as a wife, partner, friend, teacher, etc in every aspects of life. We must need to recall our memory and we will understand the fact. A soldier whether a man or an woman take birth through a woman (mother). So we can't assume that women will be never fit for defense services.

This concept is totally wrong. Today if some women are lacking behind is due to the criticism of society, no support for parents and in our country most of us has a view that women is a made for serving her husband, children, stick to the kitchen, etc. Whereas in foreign a girl is given full freedom. And the crime ratio like rapes, murder, sexual assault is much less than ours one.

I hereby try to summarise my view that we should try to give woman the full power and support and try to engage them in every sector in which men are engaged. Our history and mythology speaks how women took victory overs injustice, crimes, evils, etc. So in special in our India we worship 33 crores god and GODDESSES.
(27)

Ujjwal Shah said:   1 decade ago
Hello Friends,

I believe Women are capable for defense services. If given the chance in defense field surely they will prove their mettle.

But basic problem lies in structure of our society where men are on upper tier. Women have to sacrifice their career at every phase of life. There are several hindrance at each level in their career.

> They need parents support to learn SSC and HSC.

> If they are able to get through HSC-SSC, For graduation they need family support and permission. Considering today's condition in India where everyday we hear a Rape news it becomes difficult for family to allow their young girls to go out for education.

> Then comes difficult phase - Marriage; To continue in their career they need husband's and in-laws support to the fullest.

> If at all they succeed in getting through Marriage phase then comes the big one - Motherhood; Now here is a battle between a women and a mother. As usual a women has to sacrifice her career.

So It is clearly wrong to say that a women is unfit for defense career. Let her free from shackles of society and then see her full potential definitely she will be at par from men.
(67)

Krishan said:   1 decade ago
Hi friends my opinion is that women should be in defence services as the role of an army is not only fighting wars and at least in todays world where the probability of the wars is very less. Women in defence can contribute in other factor in handling natural calamities and such incidents.
(5)

Lalit Thapa said:   1 decade ago
Hi I read most of the post and got to know that most of them who Faber that women should be enrolled on combat are unpractical. Friends in infantry, artillery and in fighting troops there are certain tactics which are fixed and didn't need of more technique. Most important is physical capability. When you have to carry 15 to 20 kg and endurance in mountain then you will come to know what is infantry. What ever decision are taken by superior and defense minister is correct. Women have certain limit and can do serve only in ordinance and AEC. Be practical guys.
(26)

Kishan said:   1 decade ago
In my point of view womens are fit for defence. We can take any field for example like police force, politics, technology, space where womens prove themselves that they are not behind from men in any field. They faces many problem in family life happily then why they are prohibited from infantry. Everyone know that commanding officer wife commands on the unit more than CO then how we can say that ladies are not able to do command. So we must give an opportunity to the woman's to come forward.
(12)

Anu said:   1 decade ago
According to my point of view women is capable to do anything if she gets the opportunity but unfortunately at every level she have to sacrifice her career. I think women definitely can do defence services. There are various examples such as kiran bedi, kalpana chawla, indira gandhi, mother teresa where women prove herself.
(18)

Lathif said:   1 decade ago
Women are fit for anything. They can make the world or break the world.

In this world men and women are equal No one should project themselves more when compare to the opposite.

The birth and death are same for both of them. Then why can't be the remaining things.

To get success in any field hardwork and dedication is important. If both these exist, what ever may be the gender they are fit for everything.
(23)

Naveen said:   1 decade ago
Hello friends. I am agree with women are fit in defense. We all are have equal right and freedom to choose our carrier. Women are have same right, and on basis on that women are not physical strong as compare to men we can't deny them.
(6)

Ashish Satpute said:   1 decade ago
Well, You folks are on the right track but you all are not right. Women can be the part of the defense services but at the same time they are not fit for it. Though there are some exceptions but you can't deny the rules designed by nature. Women can be strong enough from their mind but they cannot be as strong as man in physical prospective.

Hence, You can utilize their precised focus for the defense but not the physic, Obviously if you are looking for the best defense force.

As simple as man cannot be as warm as mother.
(27)


Post your thoughts here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.