Should India break Diplomatic Ties with Pakistan?

Group Discussion
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
  • Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
  • Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
  • Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
  • Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
116 comments Page 10 of 12.

Moin said:   1 decade ago
In my opinion just breaking the relation or tie up is not the solution. Every country is surrounded by society, which comprise of good people, gentlemen's, senior citizen. As whole it consists of many families. About "Terrorism", every home consists of cockroaches, just to kill them you can't burn the house. Same way breaking the relation is not an option. Pakistan is bit occupied by taliban who's playing all this strategies. The role of a human should be towards humanity. We can put a step forward at least by letting Pak players play in IPL, Cricketers are just Cricketers they are not terrorists. Once we (Indians) lend our hands of friendship then the later steps will come up automatically.
(26)

Sanjeev seth said:   1 decade ago
All the works of sardar vallabhai patel is going in vain. He united India and today it is getting bifurcated into a number of states. Regionalism, in near future is going to harm our country manifold.
(9)

Pavan said:   1 decade ago
I don't think breaking relation is the solution to any problem. The best way to solve any problem is to sit together and talk, breaking relationship will only lead to anger and loss of economy. In Pakistan the military is the supreme power greater than the supreme court and government Breaking relationship will only hurt the business and common people, common people are struggling to earn their livelihood they haven't done any wrong so why break the diplomatic relationship. The main problem is the negative thinking of the govt and some official peoples of the pak military. There corruption is very high and people for the sake of votes provoke the people of pak against India and fill their vote banks. Hence, I don't think breaking diplomatic relation is the answer.
(10)

Pritam said:   1 decade ago
According to my point of view we should not break the relation with pakistan because both countries facing same problems of terrorism. Not only pakistan, India also have terrorist groups like simi, one group in kerala etc so we should try to eradicate the terrorism from both countries by help the to eradicate the terrorism. All pakistan's people are not terrorist some people are trying to spoil the relation b/w two countries for their selfishness. If we break relation with pakistan then it is encouragement for those people. We should concentrate on development, education, new technology, new infrastructure that help us to increase our economy. War is just waste of time and money that is retrospect move.
(32)

Sushree Kanti Panigrahi said:   1 decade ago
To my mind, India should keep friendly relation with pak in the current situation.

We can't change our geography. We have to accept pak as our neighbour. Wars and fights will only lead to loss of lives and property of many innocent people. So we should engage pak in dialogues and as a big brother of pak we should be friendly with them.
(13)

Dibya sahoo said:   1 decade ago
the partition of indian subcontinent is 66 years old.14th of august,1947 was the starting phase of india pakistan division.Till today the conflict hasn't decreased and peace is also not established.Today also the roaring of the rifles can be heard at the border.Last week 5 brave soldiers of indian army were ended to life by some pak soldiers.It is a matter of great concern that pakistan is breaking the no weapon treaty.India should take necessary steps to stop this
(11)

Tahir Shah said:   1 decade ago
Well speaking as a Kashmir from Baramulla, I have not read such naivety. India and Pakistan have never had any sort of diplomatic relations to speak off except through the gun barrel. Why do you assume that either sides army is innocent of violations. There are no innocents when armies have their interests to worry about. Neither are looking for peace as attrition is in their self interest. Its jobs for the boys so what if a few are sacrificed on the way. Without a free Kashmir with friendly and open borders with India and Pakistan we will not have peace.
(8)

Sonali said:   1 decade ago
If diplomatic ties are broken it will lead us to war which will result in loss of blood of innocents but there is limit of tolerance of everything. Everytime we trust Pakistan result comes as simple betray. They are trying word puzzle with us because there govt says they want peace but their army and extremist kill our brave soldiers everyday.

I think our country should never sit quiet requesting Pakistan every time for peace. Time to find out who is causing this and why. Attack that individual or group collect enough evidence to show Pakistan like america done in case of laden. Our govt politicians even remark like this that people join army to die. If we underestimate and show sincerity to Pakistan after our soldiers killed brutally one day will must come when no one will join Indian army.
(35)

Rajat said:   1 decade ago
Cultural interaction should never stop. We ought to understand each other which helps in removing the illusion which pakistani leaders have created at the ground level among common masses. But our security agencies have to fight the terrorists activities executed by pakistan army as well as the extremists at the same time. We should understand that the pakistan comes in two pieces (common people who wants peace and harmony in the region and other, the culprits are the social evils consists of politicians, extremists etc. ) India should always be ready to fight the war against anyone who create unrest in the region. We have to win this fight against terrorist by using terrorism against social evils and by social interaction at every level possible.
(6)

Rahul said:   1 decade ago
I totally agree with all our previous speakers that.

Breaking diplomatic ties will led to war,

India is a strategic partner of Pakistan,

Pakistan is also facing similar crunch of terrorism as india,

But my question from all is until when?

Every time we give chance to pakistan and it always not live up to our expectations.

How could we forget "kargil war" were thousands of our soldiers were killed. As long as "Kashmir" issue will be there Pakistan will not stop doing such things.

We should ask from them whose mother, sister, brother, father, son, daughter died in 26/11 terrorist attack. What was there fault? Answer will be Surely nothing. Recently 2 of our Indian soldiers were beheaded and 5 our army men were shot dead by them. Enough is enough, we should teach a lesson to pakistan and break diplomatic ties with them.
(80)


Post your thoughts here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.