Reservations in the Private Sector
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
- Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
- Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
- Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
- Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
146 comments Page 7 of 15.
Yash said:
9 years ago
First of all, Reservation should not be there in any criteria as if a reserved category person doesn't have potential, he very well knows his caste will give him the opportunity, and a doctor or an engineer who really isn't good enough taking our bodies or our houses in their hands can create dangerous situations. If at all you have to give them the reserved category right, give it to them only once, he / she can use his caste certificate only once either getting an admission or getting a job. This should be practiced in all sectors.
(16)
Shivaram said:
1 year ago
I don't know still why the government begs votes to all without cross-checking of reservations. In any sector, reservation plays a major role that is shameful to all our peoples. Though he had a talent, he was not supposed to do in that because of caste reservation.
According to the Reservation, why government begs to vote from people Its better to crosscheck their caste and then only allow to vote in elections. What is the use of the talent he acquried even though he was not supposed for certain role because of resevation.
According to the Reservation, why government begs to vote from people Its better to crosscheck their caste and then only allow to vote in elections. What is the use of the talent he acquried even though he was not supposed for certain role because of resevation.
(5)
Pradeep said:
9 years ago
How long we want to continue this reservation? And how are we measuring if it's solving purpose or not? People will keep asking reservation irrespective of their need. It's been 70 years and if it's still not working let's abolish it and find the root cause.
How a mere job add a value or improve condition of reserved category instead let's give them facilities and chance to grow by themselves, give them extra classes, training to improve their knowledge/skills. Freebees is not going to help who gets it nor who provides it.
How a mere job add a value or improve condition of reserved category instead let's give them facilities and chance to grow by themselves, give them extra classes, training to improve their knowledge/skills. Freebees is not going to help who gets it nor who provides it.
(2)
H.k said:
9 years ago
To all those who think reservation should be economic based,
How many of you are married based on economic/education or love irrespective of region & religion?
How many are married irrespective of Caste?
So is the difference based on economic consideration, no. It goes deeper?
Why upper castes reserved education & Economy for themselves if it is the reserved castes which are scared. Who was scared to part with knowledge knowing fully well with the knowledge they will break free and better the former?
How many of you are married based on economic/education or love irrespective of region & religion?
How many are married irrespective of Caste?
So is the difference based on economic consideration, no. It goes deeper?
Why upper castes reserved education & Economy for themselves if it is the reserved castes which are scared. Who was scared to part with knowledge knowing fully well with the knowledge they will break free and better the former?
(17)
Ram Sherma said:
9 years ago
I could see many are voting against the reservation system. I am from a reputed company and I have seen people from all classes perform well with relative changes with their knowledge and applications.
We haven't grown in a long term and are starting to now. They have reservations in education for they will have to compete with the reservations already they have got. If they are incapable of competing in the private sector without the reservations, the reservations in the education should also be reduced.
We haven't grown in a long term and are starting to now. They have reservations in education for they will have to compete with the reservations already they have got. If they are incapable of competing in the private sector without the reservations, the reservations in the education should also be reduced.
(6)
Shubham said:
9 years ago
I think, there should be reservation in private sectors, but on the basis of someone's financial condition. After all private sectors also need good quality people to maintain their status in market. And poor people are having too good qualities. But just because of poor financial problem they are unable to express it. So private sectors should have some reservation quota for those who are willingly want to do something on the basis of their knowledge so that private sectors would get benefit of it.
(33)
Ankit said:
8 years ago
Reservation should be banned in private as well as government sector.
It made for only 10 years but our politics is using it for votes. It divides our community in reserved and general pool. Also deserved candidates are jobless and unreserved are on higher posts. There is the only private sector where a number of general candidates are more than reserved and that's why private companies are on top and earning much money. I'm not against of any caste but against of reservation like propagandas.
It made for only 10 years but our politics is using it for votes. It divides our community in reserved and general pool. Also deserved candidates are jobless and unreserved are on higher posts. There is the only private sector where a number of general candidates are more than reserved and that's why private companies are on top and earning much money. I'm not against of any caste but against of reservation like propagandas.
(23)
CoolGuy said:
9 years ago
Let's keep it simple:
--Reservations for the historically deprived class in education, central & state jobs is valid, as it's the very mandate & duty of theirs to improve their social upwardly & welfare.
--Reservations in private sectors is a disastrous proposition, since they're not obliged to do public service to which they already contribute a substantial part of their incomes as taxes for that very purpose & people elect governments to utilize those funds for the same.
--Reservations for the historically deprived class in education, central & state jobs is valid, as it's the very mandate & duty of theirs to improve their social upwardly & welfare.
--Reservations in private sectors is a disastrous proposition, since they're not obliged to do public service to which they already contribute a substantial part of their incomes as taxes for that very purpose & people elect governments to utilize those funds for the same.
(2)
UMANG CHAUHAN said:
8 years ago
If we discuss the reservation then in starting, the reservation had made only for 25 years to lift up the backward class but politicians make it as a vote bank. Nowadays, I can see many students around me from SC AND ST. I will get 60 percent than also I will get add. In medical and OC student has 90% and still he will not add.
So nowadays, RESERVATION SHOULD BE REMOVED BASED ON CAST AND TRY NEW RESERVATION SYSTEM BASED ON INCOME .
AND ALL THE GOVT EMPLOY SHOULD BE OUT OF RESERVATION.
So nowadays, RESERVATION SHOULD BE REMOVED BASED ON CAST AND TRY NEW RESERVATION SYSTEM BASED ON INCOME .
AND ALL THE GOVT EMPLOY SHOULD BE OUT OF RESERVATION.
(41)
Harsh mukul chaudhary said:
7 years ago
According to me, reservation is not good for the education system, it makes poor society. A candidate who has sufficient knowledge and ability to get an opportunity but he can't because he/she belongs to general category.
In my opinion, reservation should not be based on the caste such as sc/st, obc.
Reservation should be on the bases of economic condition Because in our society both families of strong and weak economic condition are lives.
Then our country will grow up.
Thank you.
In my opinion, reservation should not be based on the caste such as sc/st, obc.
Reservation should be on the bases of economic condition Because in our society both families of strong and weak economic condition are lives.
Then our country will grow up.
Thank you.
(51)
Post your thoughts here:
Quick links
Quantitative Aptitude
Verbal (English)
Reasoning
Programming
Interview
Placement Papers