Reservations in the Private Sector
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
- Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
- Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
- Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
- Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
146 comments Page 7 of 15.
Mayank said:
3 years ago
Reservation in the private sector will be a death sentence not only for OBC or UC but also for SC ST after 3 to 4 years after it will be implemented once it will be implemented.
1) The first thing will be huge protests by general and OBC people riots and all that some may choose Naxalism too after all ST people don't have sole right to do bomb blasts and Naxalite activities.
2) protest from the private sector which will try to locate to different countries flow of FDI will become very less leading to less foreign reserves.
3) with reservations in the private sector quality of our products will go down we will not be able to export leading to less foreign reserves and outside companies will earn profit leading to an outflow of foreign reserves.
4) with foreign reserves going down govt will ban the import of many things leading to inflation in India and also leading to poor quality of indigenous goods.
5) with fewer exports, fewer foreign investments, and fewer jobs, the high inflation economy of India will start collapsing.
6) now as there is high inflation and no jobs people won't pay taxes and as govt doesn't give subsidies to OBC or UR it will try to cut subsidies of SC and ST.
7) SC ST will start a huge protest our foolish politician will accept their terms and will continue their subsidy by taking loans from other countries or IMF.
8) economy going down, no jobs, less tax collection, high inflation, repayment of loans, and less foreign reserves will lead to dark ages.
9) collapse of Indian economy unrest Naxalite separatist movement and activities will rise.
10) disintegration of India.
There is no doubt that reservation will be applied in future after all 16 per cent of India is SC 9. 5 per cent is SC 32 per cent is OBC than there is EWS ex-serviceman vimukt janjati females Physical disabled so practically India's 90 per cent population is reserved and India is a so-called democracy and our fool politicians will do anything for winning elections.
In simple words reservation in private sector will make India hell like pakistan.
1) The first thing will be huge protests by general and OBC people riots and all that some may choose Naxalism too after all ST people don't have sole right to do bomb blasts and Naxalite activities.
2) protest from the private sector which will try to locate to different countries flow of FDI will become very less leading to less foreign reserves.
3) with reservations in the private sector quality of our products will go down we will not be able to export leading to less foreign reserves and outside companies will earn profit leading to an outflow of foreign reserves.
4) with foreign reserves going down govt will ban the import of many things leading to inflation in India and also leading to poor quality of indigenous goods.
5) with fewer exports, fewer foreign investments, and fewer jobs, the high inflation economy of India will start collapsing.
6) now as there is high inflation and no jobs people won't pay taxes and as govt doesn't give subsidies to OBC or UR it will try to cut subsidies of SC and ST.
7) SC ST will start a huge protest our foolish politician will accept their terms and will continue their subsidy by taking loans from other countries or IMF.
8) economy going down, no jobs, less tax collection, high inflation, repayment of loans, and less foreign reserves will lead to dark ages.
9) collapse of Indian economy unrest Naxalite separatist movement and activities will rise.
10) disintegration of India.
There is no doubt that reservation will be applied in future after all 16 per cent of India is SC 9. 5 per cent is SC 32 per cent is OBC than there is EWS ex-serviceman vimukt janjati females Physical disabled so practically India's 90 per cent population is reserved and India is a so-called democracy and our fool politicians will do anything for winning elections.
In simple words reservation in private sector will make India hell like pakistan.
(20)
Sriram rdn said:
10 years ago
Hi friends,
We are having reservations in public sector which was decided by our constitution writers. We can not blame them because the conditions which were existing those times made them to take that decision. Because they faced many obstacles based on caste at that time. But now conditions were changed.
World is becoming smaller due to globalization. There is no need for reservation at any sector. But we can't do anything with the public sector. Implanting reservations in private sector does not make any sense because the private sector is the survival of the fittest. They need talented people irrespective of their caste.
Thank you.
We are having reservations in public sector which was decided by our constitution writers. We can not blame them because the conditions which were existing those times made them to take that decision. Because they faced many obstacles based on caste at that time. But now conditions were changed.
World is becoming smaller due to globalization. There is no need for reservation at any sector. But we can't do anything with the public sector. Implanting reservations in private sector does not make any sense because the private sector is the survival of the fittest. They need talented people irrespective of their caste.
Thank you.
(19)
Rkart said:
9 years ago
Reservations are meant to bring equality. But it divides actually. The equality should be from beginning. Make Education (primary, secondary, HS) mandatory and free for all and students should go only to home school based on the boundary. In Collage, provide loans to study that can be paid back slowly. Shuffle teachers to get parity among schools. Change the boundary by levels of education and the boundary as well. Equality will automatically come. Never ask caste or religion to kids or in application forms etc.
Test the below with the so called politicians who are demanding for reservation.
1. They should not go to skilled Doctor for themselves and their family. They will be directed to some who come just by quota with the lower score. Because there are good folks all around.
2. The parties should implement reservation in all their deputies. Say it party leader, speaker, treasurer, local positions etc. Provide minister roles based on it.
3. Their kids should not go to Private school.
Test the below with the so called politicians who are demanding for reservation.
1. They should not go to skilled Doctor for themselves and their family. They will be directed to some who come just by quota with the lower score. Because there are good folks all around.
2. The parties should implement reservation in all their deputies. Say it party leader, speaker, treasurer, local positions etc. Provide minister roles based on it.
3. Their kids should not go to Private school.
(19)
Karmayogi said:
9 years ago
For reservations you do not need to scratch your head so much, reservations are given to backward castes because society to begin with does not provide them equal educational opportunities. Hence, to repent for that, it provides them seats in jobs and higher education which they would have had if equal schooling coaching facilities were available. So, if we bring equality in education and basic facilities for all children, then, reservations would not be required at all. Till then, we should just work to bring educational equality instead of complaining all the time.
(19)
Arjula Nithish Reddy said:
9 years ago
According to me, reservation should ban. Because now we are in 2016 not 1950's. There is a lot of changes occur up to now. Example for this OC category students also going to government schools. They are also there in below poverty line. And in my opinion, if the reservation is necessary then government should not give the reservation to students those parents are working in govt sector and also based on the income.
(19)
R.Tharun kumar said:
8 years ago
Reservation is not necessary nowadays so many "OC" candidates are not having any jobs with them because of this reservation.
(19)
Pawan said:
7 years ago
Now, reservation is needed in private for sc, st and obc, because of lacking jobs in government sector.
Around 2% jobs are in government sector and 98% jobs are in private sectors, and now government convert government sector into private sector due to it now reservation in private sector needed.
Around 2% jobs are in government sector and 98% jobs are in private sectors, and now government convert government sector into private sector due to it now reservation in private sector needed.
(19)
Arnab said:
10 years ago
India will always remain a "developing" country, but never a "developed" country till reservations exist. Scrap off reservations from public sector, and the difference will be seen immediately.
I feel today there is more discrimination based on caste, just because someone is getting extra benefit (Why will others agree to their own friends getting more benefits?). Many of my friends think that lower caste = lower income group. But, this is not always true.
Reservations were implemented in India for only 10 years. But, now it has become a political issue. So, my opinion about reservation in private sector is a big NO-NO.
I feel today there is more discrimination based on caste, just because someone is getting extra benefit (Why will others agree to their own friends getting more benefits?). Many of my friends think that lower caste = lower income group. But, this is not always true.
Reservations were implemented in India for only 10 years. But, now it has become a political issue. So, my opinion about reservation in private sector is a big NO-NO.
(18)
SUNDAR said:
9 years ago
Reservation is the process/system by which the government promotes the inclusive growth. But now, it has became a family reservation rather than caste reservation. A man who became IFOS or ACP or other administrative and executive jobs in public sector, become financially rich in the society.
According to me, he should be removed from the Quota once he used the opportunity. In India its not happen. His son became educated and he also get good job using Quota, even though he is rich. Already people are agitated against this in many parts as we know.
Completely eliminating the Quota will affect the deserved. Abraham Lincoln said " Government is for the people, by the people, to the people". So It's necessary for inclusive growth. It should be there in Government Sector.
But extending it to the private sector will lead to chaos. Once the reserved people get the Quota education, government's duty is over (According to me) , because they are already empowered. Apart from that, they also have the reservation in the public sector.
Private companies nurture competitiveness, growth. Forcing them to recruit people based on reservation will collapse the system. I am not saying, reserved people are not talented. I am saying if they are talented, let them compete with others. Let them prove themselves to the society and the recruiter.
In the private enterprises point of view, their main aim is profit maximization. Everyone runs company for profit not for charity. For their part, they are doing CSR activities. They are providing employment opportunities to the society.
They are contributing to the growth of GDP. Forcing them and involving in their decision making process will make them frustrated with the system. Then they have other nations, which are ready to welcome them with the red Carpet. Our aim of 7.6% GDP growth and Make in India will vanish in the near future, if it is allowed.
I want my country to grow in a proper way which includes inclusive as well as talent oriented growth. Dear bureaucrats, please think and decide. No reservation in Public sector needed.
According to me, he should be removed from the Quota once he used the opportunity. In India its not happen. His son became educated and he also get good job using Quota, even though he is rich. Already people are agitated against this in many parts as we know.
Completely eliminating the Quota will affect the deserved. Abraham Lincoln said " Government is for the people, by the people, to the people". So It's necessary for inclusive growth. It should be there in Government Sector.
But extending it to the private sector will lead to chaos. Once the reserved people get the Quota education, government's duty is over (According to me) , because they are already empowered. Apart from that, they also have the reservation in the public sector.
Private companies nurture competitiveness, growth. Forcing them to recruit people based on reservation will collapse the system. I am not saying, reserved people are not talented. I am saying if they are talented, let them compete with others. Let them prove themselves to the society and the recruiter.
In the private enterprises point of view, their main aim is profit maximization. Everyone runs company for profit not for charity. For their part, they are doing CSR activities. They are providing employment opportunities to the society.
They are contributing to the growth of GDP. Forcing them and involving in their decision making process will make them frustrated with the system. Then they have other nations, which are ready to welcome them with the red Carpet. Our aim of 7.6% GDP growth and Make in India will vanish in the near future, if it is allowed.
I want my country to grow in a proper way which includes inclusive as well as talent oriented growth. Dear bureaucrats, please think and decide. No reservation in Public sector needed.
(18)
Naveena said:
9 years ago
Hello friends,
A reservation is needed for people. But whatever the present situation is going on under reservation for SC, ST and OBC candidates, it's not in the correct way. Reservation should give depends on the economy. By the reservation lot of students unable to getting the jobs.
If a person is not correct in the organisation, if it increases, that organisation improvement will decrease.
A reservation is needed for people. But whatever the present situation is going on under reservation for SC, ST and OBC candidates, it's not in the correct way. Reservation should give depends on the economy. By the reservation lot of students unable to getting the jobs.
If a person is not correct in the organisation, if it increases, that organisation improvement will decrease.
(18)
Post your thoughts here:
Quick links
Quantitative Aptitude
Verbal (English)
Reasoning
Programming
Interview
Placement Papers