Reservations in the Private Sector
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
- Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
- Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
- Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
- Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
146 comments Page 3 of 15.
Shasidhar Annabhattula said:
9 years ago
There are lot of general category people who have suffered in this caste based education system and I am one of them. To be frank reservations are not reaching the people it caters to but people who are having higher positions like government job holders and others with high income. We all general people will surely appreciate when reservations reach to the people who are financially very backwards and are in dire need of help and coming to point no one will allow the reservations in private sector take an example of any MNC like Microsoft who want people who can achieve their work in given deadlines irrespective of being a upper and lower caste person. THEY WANT THE RESULT and they don't want to spoil there reputation by agreeing on reservations. Foreigners will think of us as fools when they hear that education is run by reservations in India. I can see why brain drain happens more in India. Just in the case if you don't know the reason. Jai hind!
(44)
Mohammad ayaz khan said:
7 years ago
Hi friends,
According to me, First, we have to understand that what is Reservation and it is in India. That was the time when India need something to go ahead but the people of don't have enough sources to develop themselves, at that time, reservation passed and provide them who need first.
And also one reason India is a democratic country. When India got the freedom that time lower cast is not getting the respect they always vex by other I mean they have no right to prove themselves. So it is reservation which offers the opportunity to everyone and really India get success, but now reservation should be stopped because it becomes a tool for politicians, it used to win the election on the basis of caste system.
Politicians divide us on the name of reservation. We are equal and we will get the equal opportunity so we should take a decision over it, because it is applied for us that all.
Thank You.
According to me, First, we have to understand that what is Reservation and it is in India. That was the time when India need something to go ahead but the people of don't have enough sources to develop themselves, at that time, reservation passed and provide them who need first.
And also one reason India is a democratic country. When India got the freedom that time lower cast is not getting the respect they always vex by other I mean they have no right to prove themselves. So it is reservation which offers the opportunity to everyone and really India get success, but now reservation should be stopped because it becomes a tool for politicians, it used to win the election on the basis of caste system.
Politicians divide us on the name of reservation. We are equal and we will get the equal opportunity so we should take a decision over it, because it is applied for us that all.
Thank You.
(26)
Jageshwar prasad said:
9 years ago
First of all, I would like to say about the reservation that means a district which is received for a particular purpose. First, it was applied by Dr. Br. Ambedkar after the independent of our country in order to bring the condition of lower categories people up to general people but it was not for permanent. Reservation was based on cast basis also yet it is cast basic which is wrong.
I m not saying that it should be ended but it shouldn't be on cast basic because it is spoiling of our system day by day. Also more knowledgeable persons do not able to get opportunity.
Since, India is a democracy country in which every people have equal fundamental right. But it imparts of peoples right into different part with unique. Thus, it shouldn't be on cast basis but should be on financial condition because every people are suffering from good or bad condition whether they are general or backwards cast.
I m not saying that it should be ended but it shouldn't be on cast basic because it is spoiling of our system day by day. Also more knowledgeable persons do not able to get opportunity.
Since, India is a democracy country in which every people have equal fundamental right. But it imparts of peoples right into different part with unique. Thus, it shouldn't be on cast basis but should be on financial condition because every people are suffering from good or bad condition whether they are general or backwards cast.
(14)
MANIK DANG said:
9 years ago
India is perhaps the only country where people are fighting to be inferior. Reservation was introduced for economically backward who couldn't afford education.
In a democratic country like India where it is believed that the backward classes are not treated equally is completely deceptive. The truth is that today the general category are suffering the most as they are the ones who don't get admission in any good college following which they don't get good jobs.
And now people will say reservations are required so that the gap between the so-called backward classes and the so-called general classes diminishes. But the truth is even after decades, if the backward classes cannot get self-reliant, then they never can.
I am completely against the caste reservation system. It not only destroys the dreams of aspiring and deserving candidates but also create conflicts in the name of religion.
In a democratic country like India where it is believed that the backward classes are not treated equally is completely deceptive. The truth is that today the general category are suffering the most as they are the ones who don't get admission in any good college following which they don't get good jobs.
And now people will say reservations are required so that the gap between the so-called backward classes and the so-called general classes diminishes. But the truth is even after decades, if the backward classes cannot get self-reliant, then they never can.
I am completely against the caste reservation system. It not only destroys the dreams of aspiring and deserving candidates but also create conflicts in the name of religion.
(14)
Saibaba said:
9 years ago
First of all why should be a reservation for anybody?
Remember, at every stage getting reservation means he/she is not the best person.
That means India is compromising in quality. Private sector won't accept it and they go away to another country.
The time has come to enforce Free Uniform Education, Free Uniform Health Care i.e. taking full control of these two sectors by Government and abolish this reservation system and abolish SC& ST Atrocities Act which is widely used for blackmailing or for corruption or widely misused. We are losing many bright students from un-reserved caste, because of this Vote bank based reservation system.
We need India Uniform Civil Code.
No reservation or concession, based on caste or religion.
No personal laws.
Because everything is related to Election system prevailing in our country.
It is difficult to expect such a change in our country.
Remember, at every stage getting reservation means he/she is not the best person.
That means India is compromising in quality. Private sector won't accept it and they go away to another country.
The time has come to enforce Free Uniform Education, Free Uniform Health Care i.e. taking full control of these two sectors by Government and abolish this reservation system and abolish SC& ST Atrocities Act which is widely used for blackmailing or for corruption or widely misused. We are losing many bright students from un-reserved caste, because of this Vote bank based reservation system.
We need India Uniform Civil Code.
No reservation or concession, based on caste or religion.
No personal laws.
Because everything is related to Election system prevailing in our country.
It is difficult to expect such a change in our country.
(25)
Bunny varma said:
9 years ago
I am against to the reservation system. If the person is talented he (or) she don't need reservation for any level.
If we talk only poor people, who can't afford to send their children to school. We can see developed countries like. Us Japan. Singapore. That countries having free education system. In our country OC, OBC person are unable to get government jobs why because Reservation problem. If you see in our government schools most of teachers having a lack of knowledge.
In private management is demanding 50,00 or 20,00 for only LKG, UKG students. How can people can afford to pay so much of fee their children's.
Reservation is making a suffering people. Everything in their life. Why because high cast people also having poor people. And their trying to government jobs. But they not having reservation.
How long they have suffering with this problem this is too embarrassing?
If we talk only poor people, who can't afford to send their children to school. We can see developed countries like. Us Japan. Singapore. That countries having free education system. In our country OC, OBC person are unable to get government jobs why because Reservation problem. If you see in our government schools most of teachers having a lack of knowledge.
In private management is demanding 50,00 or 20,00 for only LKG, UKG students. How can people can afford to pay so much of fee their children's.
Reservation is making a suffering people. Everything in their life. Why because high cast people also having poor people. And their trying to government jobs. But they not having reservation.
How long they have suffering with this problem this is too embarrassing?
(14)
Pallavi Rajput said:
6 years ago
Reservation should not allow on the basis of caste but it should depend on a person's financial status. Nowadays Education is very important and very expensive and everyone wants to give the best education to their children. Poor class peoples also want to give their children to the best education. So, according to my point of view, Reservation should be allowed only in education system whether its private or government schools through some tests according to class level wise But I am not the favour of to allow reservation in employment, especially in private sector. Because our entire nation is based on that. People should get a job according to their talent and skills. The job should never be based on reservation criteria because it will affect our economy, our nation and especially people's mind. According to the time magazine, we are very good in the private service sector.
(67)
Dinesh said:
6 years ago
Hi friend.
It is a very important topic to discuss. I didn't support Reservations according to caste. Why because it plays a crucial role nowadays. Due to reservations, some people get benefits as well as damage to some others. At the time when we got independence in 1947, there is lot of poverty in our country and mostly low cast people are in below poverty. At that time Reservations are introduced for the development of those people. It helps for those people a lot and their conditions become good. But, At present Reservations effect a lot. Mostly, Talented people don't get potential jobs due to Reservations. Due to this many talented people work in other countries like USA Etc. It indirectly affects the development of our country. It's shameful to say that Our talent is used to develop other countries. So, I should support Reservations on Economic conditions.
Thank you.
It is a very important topic to discuss. I didn't support Reservations according to caste. Why because it plays a crucial role nowadays. Due to reservations, some people get benefits as well as damage to some others. At the time when we got independence in 1947, there is lot of poverty in our country and mostly low cast people are in below poverty. At that time Reservations are introduced for the development of those people. It helps for those people a lot and their conditions become good. But, At present Reservations effect a lot. Mostly, Talented people don't get potential jobs due to Reservations. Due to this many talented people work in other countries like USA Etc. It indirectly affects the development of our country. It's shameful to say that Our talent is used to develop other countries. So, I should support Reservations on Economic conditions.
Thank you.
(35)
Anubhav said:
10 years ago
According to me the definition of reservation system should be changed because it leads to several disputes in society and in colleges. It should be given on the basis of the economic condition of people and to the differently able people, not on the basis of the caste system. Because it leads to create a gap between higher caste people and lower caste people. Now it becomes a more political issue than for what it was implemented. Political parties create their vote bank through this.
Reservation leads to improper growth of the mindset of the people because in most cases a lower caste student study not so well because he thinks I will get the admission because he has some additional benefit provided by the government.
So for the uplifting of the mindset of people, government should amend the reservation system which is currently prevailing in the country.
Reservation leads to improper growth of the mindset of the people because in most cases a lower caste student study not so well because he thinks I will get the admission because he has some additional benefit provided by the government.
So for the uplifting of the mindset of people, government should amend the reservation system which is currently prevailing in the country.
(10)
Alok said:
9 years ago
In India, our society is divided into various category by the Indian constitution law this type of tradition was followed by many years ago as brahman, kshatriya, vaish, sudra now it is converted into general, OBC, SC, ST.
In India, some categories are benefited by the reservation system. Actually, the motto behind the reservation system is to develop a person who is weak in economic status and belongs to ruler area.
But the reservation system is implemented according to cast, this is not good, I think it should be implemented according to "economic status". And present time BPL (below poverty line) is a good benchmark to implement the reservation system.
But our politicians don't want to change it because nowadays politics is totally based on the cast system. There is so many communities which is doing riot for taking advantage of reservation.
In India, some categories are benefited by the reservation system. Actually, the motto behind the reservation system is to develop a person who is weak in economic status and belongs to ruler area.
But the reservation system is implemented according to cast, this is not good, I think it should be implemented according to "economic status". And present time BPL (below poverty line) is a good benchmark to implement the reservation system.
But our politicians don't want to change it because nowadays politics is totally based on the cast system. There is so many communities which is doing riot for taking advantage of reservation.
(14)
Post your thoughts here:
Quick links
Quantitative Aptitude
Verbal (English)
Reasoning
Programming
Interview
Placement Papers