Is Reservation in Higher Education Only Alternative for Social Equality?
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
- Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
- Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
- Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
- Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
168 comments Page 5 of 17.
P.Naveen said:
7 years ago
Hi friends, * Many of students are not getting what they deserve because of reservation. * The main motto of reservation of to uplift the back ward section of out society whose life were miserable before independence.
* up to 20-30 years but the current scenario is reservation still exits and almost 70 years after independence.
* help poor student, the government should take care that money will not reason for any desired candidate to achieve.
* more education seats were going because of ST and SC.
* reservation should exit on the economic background, not on the cast.
*this is reservation in higher education only in alternative for social equality''.
* up to 20-30 years but the current scenario is reservation still exits and almost 70 years after independence.
* help poor student, the government should take care that money will not reason for any desired candidate to achieve.
* more education seats were going because of ST and SC.
* reservation should exit on the economic background, not on the cast.
*this is reservation in higher education only in alternative for social equality''.
(10)
Sreevignya said:
7 years ago
Hi friends! I'm Sreevignya.
Reservation is needed for higher education because everyone is equal in society.
There is no comparison between SC, ST castes and OC caste. So everyone should get an equal education.
Reservation is needed for higher education because everyone is equal in society.
There is no comparison between SC, ST castes and OC caste. So everyone should get an equal education.
(6)
Jain said:
7 years ago
I think reservation should not be given in the case of education and government jobs or for the admission of government colleges. Instead of that, reservation should be on the basis of income and the person who is from low economic growth should be given scholarship instead of reservation of seats. So, this will result in equality for the competition of seats.
(35)
ABC said:
7 years ago
Hello Everyone, As per the discussion I would like to say that reservations should be there,but if anyone says that only the people belonging to the category are getting chance to learn and reserved seats are available for only those.Then I would like to say it is just a big misunderstanding because of our great leader Dr. BR Ambedkar, we are getting the opportunities to learn and put forward our ideas and be one of the parts of these developing nation.
The all thinkings of CASTE is a bullshit thing, which is not the reason to judge that opportunities are not getting to the people who don't fall under categories.
So stop saying that stop reservation, if you want that all must get the chance then government must implement certain rules so that all will get chance to learn.
The all thinkings of CASTE is a bullshit thing, which is not the reason to judge that opportunities are not getting to the people who don't fall under categories.
So stop saying that stop reservation, if you want that all must get the chance then government must implement certain rules so that all will get chance to learn.
(13)
Akash Gonjari said:
7 years ago
Hello friends, I am Akash.
According to my opinion, reservation in education not matters a lot. It's necessary objective is that, students from all caste, it may be poor or rich should get equal opportunities of getting admission and job and family income is much more evident to caste.
In present reservation scheme, the percentage of seats provided are much proportional to population of respective caste except for open which has got about 50 percent; and it is appropriate in order to have opportunity to students from poor families, other casts (SC, ST, OBC) which will lead to development of rural areas with SC, ST cast people.
According to my opinion, reservation in education not matters a lot. It's necessary objective is that, students from all caste, it may be poor or rich should get equal opportunities of getting admission and job and family income is much more evident to caste.
In present reservation scheme, the percentage of seats provided are much proportional to population of respective caste except for open which has got about 50 percent; and it is appropriate in order to have opportunity to students from poor families, other casts (SC, ST, OBC) which will lead to development of rural areas with SC, ST cast people.
(3)
HIMANSHU PANDEY said:
7 years ago
I think reservation should be there but not on the basis of caste, instead if it should exist on the basis of the creamy and non-creamy layer.
What I mean to say is it should be provided on the family income basis like those who are poor and never got a good opportunity in their life.
What I mean to say is it should be provided on the family income basis like those who are poor and never got a good opportunity in their life.
(39)
Bharti said:
7 years ago
Reservation is not necessary because everyone has talent and skills because of this the students having skills are suffering and it's not like that the students who are not getting reservation are rich only everyone has right to explore their ideas and have right to fulfil their dreams.
In many fields, people are taking advantage of this.
In many fields, people are taking advantage of this.
(13)
Aritra Majumdar said:
8 years ago
It is true that once upon a time reservation was needed because the so-called backward classes needed a place in the society so far as education and jobs are concerned. However, the scenario is vastly different nowadays where the same is being misutilized. In my opinion, reservation in higher education can't bring social equality because of the following reasons:.
1. It hurts meritorious and needy students who aren't able to get admission to reputed institutions because of quota.
2. Candidates having some sort of quota have no inclination towards studies because they take everything for granted.
3. Only. 0. 6% of all scholarships in India are merit-based.
4. It is not difficult for someone to produce an SC/ST/OBC certificate just to get admission to the reputed institution.
5. It's a myth that backward classes aren't financially well off these days.
6. Reservation in education is caste based and not based on financial status.
1. It hurts meritorious and needy students who aren't able to get admission to reputed institutions because of quota.
2. Candidates having some sort of quota have no inclination towards studies because they take everything for granted.
3. Only. 0. 6% of all scholarships in India are merit-based.
4. It is not difficult for someone to produce an SC/ST/OBC certificate just to get admission to the reputed institution.
5. It's a myth that backward classes aren't financially well off these days.
6. Reservation in education is caste based and not based on financial status.
(36)
Pooja said:
8 years ago
Hello friends.
The Main objective of reservation is to provide opportunities and better living standard for weaker and privileged section of the society.
Dr BR Ambedkar fought for bringing reservation system into Indian constitution to help economically various caste people who were unable to have sufficient opportunities to grow. Examples Obc, St, and SC,
After independent reservation up to maximum 20-30 years and still exists. Nowadays reservation is required by politicians to get scores of votes. Any political party never try to stop reservation because of the fear of losing the election.
Many students are not getting those opportunities which one they really deserve because of reservation.
Mainly solutions is that.
* The government should give money for St, SC and Obc for primary, secondary and higher education. And provide good health facilities. Government help only economically. No need to give any type of reservation on the caste based.
* government use high technology in the education sector for weaker section. That's where they gain a proper education.
The Main objective of reservation is to provide opportunities and better living standard for weaker and privileged section of the society.
Dr BR Ambedkar fought for bringing reservation system into Indian constitution to help economically various caste people who were unable to have sufficient opportunities to grow. Examples Obc, St, and SC,
After independent reservation up to maximum 20-30 years and still exists. Nowadays reservation is required by politicians to get scores of votes. Any political party never try to stop reservation because of the fear of losing the election.
Many students are not getting those opportunities which one they really deserve because of reservation.
Mainly solutions is that.
* The government should give money for St, SC and Obc for primary, secondary and higher education. And provide good health facilities. Government help only economically. No need to give any type of reservation on the caste based.
* government use high technology in the education sector for weaker section. That's where they gain a proper education.
(28)
Holmes said:
8 years ago
The reservation has become an inevitable part of life. Why is it so important? Reservation in higher education is like placing an order for water in Amazon. It ruins the importance of education system and degrades the self-confidence of merit candidates. Reservation is never a constrain for social equality. Indian education system has been producing scapegoats since IITs. How can social equality be attained? Uplifting the standard of education and evaluation system plays a vital role. One nation One Education system is mandatory for excellence.
(8)
Post your thoughts here:
Quick links
Quantitative Aptitude
Verbal (English)
Reasoning
Programming
Interview
Placement Papers