Aptitude - Alligation or Mixture - Discussion

Discussion Forum : Alligation or Mixture - General Questions (Q.No. 1)
1.
A vessel is filled with liquid, 3 parts of which are water and 5 parts syrup. How much of the mixture must be drawn off and replaced with water so that the mixture may be half water and half syrup?
1
3
1
4
1
5
1
7
Answer: Option
Explanation:

Suppose the vessel initially contains 8 litres of liquid.

Let x litres of this liquid be replaced with water.

Quantity of water in new mixture = 3 - 3x + x litres
8

Quantity of syrup in new mixture = 5 - 5x litres
8

3 - 3x + x = 5 - 5x
8 8

5x + 24 = 40 - 5x

10x = 16

x = 8 .
5

So, part of the mixture replaced = 8 x 1 = 1 .
5 8 5

Discussion:
201 comments Page 17 of 21.

Vky said:   1 decade ago
Here x=8/5 is the amount in liters that has been added to make up 8 liters in total. This added quantity constitutes some part of the total volume. Right? So, this some part is stated as (x/8). Hope everyone's doubt on this has been cleared. => (8/ (5*8) ) =1/5.

1/5th is the part (not liters) from the total 8liters that has been added. Thank You.

Baljeet said:   1 decade ago
Good victor.

Kamini Jain said:   1 decade ago
I did not get it why 8/5 is multiplied with 1/8.

Sam said:   1 decade ago
Great surendra reddy.

Yogi said:   1 decade ago
The first one itself is short solution.
as we assume total soln as 8litre
so if x litre of water is added by replacing
So net water remains is 3-3x/8+x in 8 litre
and syrup is 5-5x/8
equalize both as both becomes equal in content aftr previous replacement.

we get x=8/5
but this is replecement if we assume cotent of vessel =8l
so part of replcement=replced amount/total amount
this means (8/5)/8 = 1/5 ans

Vaishali said:   1 decade ago
I am getting 8/5 as the amount to be replaced. If there is 8litres of the total liquid then 3 litres is water and 5 litres is syrup. Now suppose if you remove x litres of the liquid the remaining liquid is 8-x.

In this 8-x, 3/8(8-x) is water and 5/8(8-x) is syrup.
Now if we add x litres of water to it the equation we get is
3/8(8-x)+x=5/8(8-x) since both the syrup and the liquid equals 4/8

Solving this equation we get x=8/5

Where did 1/5 come from? Please somebody explain. I am highly confused.

Varsha said:   1 decade ago
Thanks ameer.

Nisha said:   1 decade ago
I think amir done good solution.

Mayank said:   1 decade ago
40% of 8 parts is 3.2 and 60% is 4.8 how it's possible to get them as 3 and 5 as this is a big difference .

Prateek said:   1 decade ago
Why is that nthey got 1/5 only becoz syrup is considered?
w s
3 5
+1 -1
4 4

So 1/5 is correct, right? why not 1/3?


Post your comments here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.