Logical Reasoning Verbal Reasoning Non Verbal Reasoning

Sudoku Number puzzles Missing letters puzzles Logical puzzles Playing cards puzzles Clock puzzles

C Programming C++ Programming C# Programming Java Programming

Microbiology Biochemistry Biotechnology Biochemical Engineering

Chemical Engineering Networking Database Questions Computer Science Basic Electronics Digital Electronics Electronic Devices Circuit Simulation Electrical Enigneering Engineering Mechanics Technical Drawing

Placement Papers Group Disucssion HR Interview Technical Interview Body Language

Aptitude Test Verbal Ability Test Verbal Reasoning Test Logical Reasoning Test C Programming Test Java Programming Test Data Interpretation Test General Knowledge Test

Should the public sector be privatized?

@ : Home > Group Discussion > Economics - Discussion Room

Points to remember before you participate in this disuccsion:

Assume, you one of the member of a real group discussion.
Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
Express your positive attitude towards providing the solution.

Vidhya said: (Thu, May 24, 2012 02:19:15 PM)

As per my view. I think public sector should not be privatized instead the work culture and environment that prevails within the private sector needs to be changed. If there is big word corruption attached with private sector the exploitation is attached with private sector. If the service provided by the service sector gets improved it will surely lead to less exploitation of common people compared to what private sector do. The whole and sole motto of private sector will always remain the same to enlarge its own pocket size.
Rate this: +0 -0

Saurabh Birthray said: (Sun, May 20, 2012 06:13:33 PM)

According to me privatization in public sector should not be done because I admit it privatization will done then the results will be far better as they are now. But I want to ask that what ever the facilities government is giving now will they will be given later also. The answer is no. Because government is lazy but it thinks for the people and specially for poor ones but a privatized company will never think this. Because its goal is to earn profit and it can't think for common people, and this privatization practice will make a rich person more rich and poor will come on road. Thank you!
Rate this: +7 -0

Jhon Abraham said: (Thu, May 17, 2012 10:57:09 AM)

In my view, public sector should be privatized. There are two reasons in supporting of my statement. One, it will increase the competition in job market and as a result better output from each individual which leads to growth in our economy. In Government sector what generally happens is that most of the individual do not work sincerely. Their only motto is to get salary at the end of the month. This happens only because they think that their job is permanent, nobody can do any harm with their job. Two, most of the individual in government sector are lazy. They are so irresponsible with their work. If privatized then the same individual will do their duty sincerely as they have always fear of losing their job. Thanking you.
Rate this: +14 -2

Phani Vardhan said: (Mon, May 14, 2012 08:34:40 AM)

The public sector should be privatized,Toady in india corruption levels are very high in india the public sector employees are with full of freedom they are not concentrated on the development of service and the development of the autherised sector. 1. The investment levels are very poor 2. They are not innovative not utilizing the creativity like japan and china 3. Corruption levels are very high 4. No proper command of chain or domination 5.political influence is very high 6. showing the deficit trade and always saying we were in looses SUGGESTIONS Very high profit public company sector units should not be privitised Very sick industries should be privitised The accounting should be perfectly done jv,s should be done
Rate this: +4 -1

Sudhishna said: (Wed, May 9, 2012 10:32:28 PM)

Hi friends. In my point of view I would like to say that the public sector should not be privatized. If the public sector is privatized the society has to face so many problems. If society is given equal importance to both the sectors. Their is no comparison between these two sectors. If the both sectors are having equal importance the society people they won't consider about the management. If management is in proper way only the society will run in an effective manner and it will good for the improvement of the society. For example here the public sector means the management or a government. If public sector is implemented any rules, conditions, and standards it will be common to all the people in the society. Where as in the private sector what they implemented it is not common to all why because means even thought their the head it not a standard and also their is chance for the misrepresentation and mainly their is no evidence for any thing. In case of public sector their will be a standards for every thing. If the management is done wrong it is based on mind set of the person intention in my point of view the management is necessary for every thing. If the public sector is privatized it will be common to the all people and their is no management if any problem rises the people want to approach the management only. Here the case is if the public sector is privatized that means the management is not necessary to the society that's wrong in my point of view so because I strongly say that management is necessary for the development and public sector should not be privatized.
Rate this: +2 -6

Shweta Kajalekar said: (Tue, May 8, 2012 12:23:44 PM)

When we look at the slow working process and plenty of scams and corruption in public sectors, its obvious to feel that they should be privatized. But privatization will not completely improve the system, rather new flaws will be introduced. Being under the thumb of government helps keeping a check on price rates so that they are affordable to common man. It will be impossible to control these rates if sector is privatized because companies will look after their benefit at the end. So instead of taking very extreme decisions, I think it is good to improve the ongoing system.
Rate this: +18 -1

Deepak Barnwal said: (Fri, Apr 27, 2012 06:21:59 AM)

We know that there are so many problems in public sector. There is corruption at its peak. People are fed up with the bureaucracy. The benefits for the poor is not reaching. Leakages in the distribution system is at its extreme and we are seeing privatization of all non-performing PSUs (Public Sector Units) as a sure shot remedy to all those ailing problems. However, privatization is not going to solve these problems. And, even if, it did, other problems of private sector will arise like, money driven-profit making approach, huge margins and high job insecurity. Also, privatization of public would make those important and crucial sectors unpredictable and unstable. Privatization of the public sectors will ruin the very purpose, why the government has been holding on to these sectors, which is human welfare. What needs to be done is, that there should be a public private partnership (PPP) and government share should be no less than 51% so that it can take any decision. Also, FDI in these sectors should be allowed so that new technology could make a way to these sectors. Also, in those sectors where a private interference may not be feasible like defense, government database management, etc, we can appoint a monitoring body with stringent punitive laws to govern and monitor the proper functioning of those departments. In some sectors like, railways, roads construction, etc we could have both public and private companies working so that there is fair amount of competition. Banking sector, Mutual Funds and Insurance sector are some excellent examples. At the end, I would like to conclude that we don't need to completely privatize the public sector. Rather, we need to open the gates for the private companies to work together with public sector.
Rate this: +31 -1

Siva said: (Fri, Apr 20, 2012 06:41:32 PM)

Hi good evening. In my perspective is that public sector should be privatized some major part should be under taken by the government since if we give the power to the private then there will loss for the government employers since they loss there jobs and this leads to the some problem for the government because they should obey the order that the private sector put before the government this lead to a very critical position for the higher order.
Rate this: +11 -5

Vinita said: (Wed, Apr 18, 2012 11:24:02 PM)

I read many views of you I agree with some extent of you private sector should not be privatized but here all the government issue are mismanaged no one is ready to take any case seriously even issues are very important, very emergency. In government sector people doesn't understand the problem of a general person who has no any contact with a superior person they don't ready to listen the problem of general person. Government gives very fund for distributing among the poor people but this fund don't reach among them. Education level is also destroying in government sector same teacher who take the class in government school don't want to teach there but when they start the teach privately they teach very well. Government gives reservation only those people who belongs to OBC, SC, ST they don't think about poor person. Its not necessary who belongs to backward cast will be poor that's why some candidate having a good knowledge after then they are not able to grow up due to the poverty. Government should think what will be the level of education and anywhere where this people will go. Corruption and insecurity is also increasing day by day in government sector.
Rate this: +13 -6

Amrita said: (Tue, Apr 17, 2012 09:41:57 PM)

As my point of view public sector should not be privatized. When we talk about privatization of public sector first things come in my mind everything will be costlier. As we know in India most of the people lie below the poverty line and middle class they can't effort this economy. Anywhere the privatization thinks only first about the profit, they put very high cost for all thing. Now a days BPL(Below Poverty Line) person can travel in train at least in general class or sleeper class but after doing private they can't effort this. We take example like kingfisher airline due to costlier BPL can't effort this and this gone in very loss and now a day kingfisher want a support for government. Government gives subsidy on many things like LPG gas and in villages for farmers subsidy is very necessary on agricultural thing for developing them. The government is only who care about that after privatization no one will look about that.
Rate this: +29 -7

Mahesh,Iiit said: (Tue, Apr 17, 2012 05:06:05 PM)

Hello my dear viewers, I think public sector need not be privatized if we privatized it many people will not able to buy all the items. If it is privatized railway department and postal office rates will very high and it is very sad to middle families. From the government fund will be released and it will be uses for that year. If it is in privatization fund will not be allotted and every body will work to get some money at this time everybody is trying to get job but it is not possible to get a job for middle familiar and rich persons becomes very rich. There is some piracy in politicians and public workers in government jobs. So government should take action on this issue and try to country's clean.
Rate this: +1 -3

Porto said: (Mon, Apr 16, 2012 07:44:20 PM)

My answer is yes and I will explain why. The state is the worst administrator of a business, and the employees in the public sector don't have the same productivity as those in the private sector. In order to increase the productivity in a country and to increase the salaries, is better to start privatizing the public sector and the public industry.
Rate this: +4 -7

Rupa Singh said: (Sat, Apr 14, 2012 08:58:00 PM)

In my point of view public sector sector be privatized because govt provide allot of fund & bank also but mostly public sector showing loss and their service is not better than private in other side govt give very less support to private but their service quality is very good.
Rate this: +3 -3

Deepak said: (Sat, Apr 14, 2012 11:02:12 AM)

Hello, friends I m deepak in my views it public sector should not be privatized because it create many problems. If we see in India electricity, defense some the service is in public hands and these are the necessary things. If it handle by govn. It gives benefit for people. But if it go in private hands it become business and the burdon comes on the people. And all knows that in India most people are lower than the poverty line. Still they are gives more effort to earn food. So how can they pay for these service.
Rate this: +5 -1

Barkha Singhal said: (Sun, Mar 25, 2012 12:18:16 AM)

Hi friends this side Barkha singhal, I would like to present my views to the topic. And according to my view the public sector should not be privatized as if it is done it would have many bad effects. As in today there are 3 main sectors which are completely under government i.e.railways, defense and atomic energy and if these are privatized it would have a huge effect like. 1. Firstly these are the sectors which requires huge investment which is not possible for the private owners. 2. Secondly the serve the society without concentrating on there private profit motive which will be against the principle of privatization. 3. Moreover these sectors are too crucial that if are privatized it may lead to mismanagement which would effect the society mainly in the case of defense and atomic. 4. If these are privatized then the private owners would exploit the public in best possible manner for there own profit. The only benefit from privatization will be that, that the management will be good. The solution which I think can be that only the management is privatized and rest or the major control is with government.
Rate this: +82 -17

Abha said: (Sat, Mar 24, 2012 10:36:12 AM)

I would go for this topic saying that we all know very well that Indian Govt is not in correct hands. If we go through the analysis then we can very clearly see that private companies are going way ahead than those of public companies. The improvement and development that private companies are going through cannot be compared at all with those of public. I think it will be good if public companies get privatized. I would also like to convey a message to my friends out here who go against this that, as you all are pointing out that private companies work just for profit you are totally wrong in this point of view. We have got many examples in front of us that private companies too do human welfare and have contributed highly to Indian society for its development. You can check out with Vedanta, TATA Steel, etc.
Rate this: +18 -20

Ca Himanshu Kansal said: (Fri, Mar 23, 2012 02:42:22 PM)

Hi. What my view point is. We need to understand first that what is private sector company? the company in which government acquires more than 50% stake than such co. Is called Public sector co. and there are various reasons for divestment in public sector:. 1 Govt. Needs short term funds. 2 Some view point is that such company perform well after it will get privatised. Etc. So there are various reasons for this. If there is a privatisation then, you will find RIGID STRUCTURES/PRACTICES as in govt. Deppts. Are removed and liberal policies are generally framed in order to speed up the communication and take the right decisions on time. But sometimes it creates JOB INSECURITY in the minds of employees working in that company when privatisation happen. So what my point of view is. It depends upon the situation and we should take this in positive sense.
Rate this: +6 -7

Divya said: (Wed, Mar 21, 2012 08:15:32 PM)

India is growing country therees no need of public sector to privatization. If we talk in terms of economy of India there is not only solution of privatization. Corruption, mismanagement occur in both of cases. But India is a agricultural country where mostly people from middle family who wants low prize nd not go with very high quality which can only provide by public sectors. Public sector do benifits for peoples wheares private sec only concerned about own profits. By taking a good action and intelligence of technical public sector ll also grow in terms of technology advancemnt nd corruption less nd give a very good economic environment to our country with full of every persons happiness. :).
Rate this: +14 -2

Namrata said: (Mon, Mar 19, 2012 03:44:25 PM)

According to me, public sector should not be privatised. Beacause public sector over all works for the poor people or for the country. private sector works for their own profits. As compare to both their is lot of corruption is going in public sectors but very much of polytics is going in private sector. But at last we can take action against corruption in public sector & vice versa we cant do anything in private sector for the same thing. So no need to privatised public sector.
Rate this: +20 -3

Varsha said: (Mon, Mar 19, 2012 03:40:00 PM)

Hi friends. I think private sector has its own benefit that it gives us employment, corruption less environment, good technology, better income but if all public sector is privatized then I think private sector will work for their own benefit, their policies are not for public welfare. Government gives us subsidies from hih we can get our daily uses items in affordable prices. But in private sector their is no concept of any subsides. I think not public sector is not completely privatized but their should be partnership. Or some new laws for changing ND IMPROVEMENT OF DRAWBACK OF Public sector as corruption, irregularities, low quality etc.
Rate this: +13 -4

Shrija Chauhan said: (Tue, Mar 13, 2012 12:21:36 PM)

As according to my view, public sector should no be privatized due to some causes. Like, every one knows that each coin has it two effects i.e. positive and negative. In the same way public and private both are having its own effects. Public sector using subsidiary but private sector does not used. Public sector is made for welfare for country and they work for the public benefits. But private sector company works for their own benefits. They rated their price according to the competition in the market. If we consider the draw backs of public sector, there is corruption, irresponsibility but they do not work for their own profits. Private sector also giving new technologies, improving employment among youth but they all working is for their own purpose, profit not for country or for public. So, according to my view public sector is much better for the society rather than privatisation.
Rate this: +45 -6

Shrija Chauhan said: (Tue, Mar 13, 2012 12:20:36 PM)

Hi friends, I am Shrija chauhan. As according to my view, public sector should no be privatized due to some causes. Like, every one knows that each coin has it two effects i.e. positive and negative. In the same way public and private both are having its own effects. Public sector using subsidiary but private sector does not used. Public sector is made for welfare for country and they work for the public benefits. But private sector company works for their own benefits. They rated their price according to the competition in the market. If we consider the draw backs of public sector, there is corruption, irresponsibility but they do not work for their own profits. Private sector also giving new technologies, improving employment among youth but they all working is for their own purpose, profit not for country or for public. So, according to my view public sector is much better for the society rather than privatisation.
Rate this: +7 -2

Sangeet said: (Tue, Mar 13, 2012 10:47:43 AM)

MY dear friends India where 70% of population lives in villages, one third of population are BPL, ENROLLMENT PERCENTAGE in school is just 20, home of highest number of malnutrition child. A country where social attention is priority and foremost need and in this scenario if we transfer the powers to private hand the very goal for social and economic upliftment of poor will be defeated. But need is to strengthen our public enterprise with committees like BIFR and sick industrial act which will definately take out them from ashes to firmament of success. If government wants it can definately come in par with private co. Example being ONGC, COAL INDIA LTD, RAILWAYS which are profit making and listed in maharatna list. SO at present context where we want inclusion of each and very people for indias development governmental organisation are must and privatization is not the answer.
Rate this: +14 -2

Vijay said: (Thu, Mar 8, 2012 11:41:09 AM)

I won't think privatization is the only solution to overcome all the problems in the public sector. At the end of the day govt has to rule the country, not the private sector. So if there are any problems like corruption or mismanagement in the public sector, govt has to take measurable actions to over these problems. Many big industries (coal, steel, oil etc) which are making crores of turn over, and I don't know why govt want to privatize these companies even though they are getting benefits. And at the same time private sector is also playing a key role in country's development using new technologies. They are providing employment to the youngsters in the country basing on merit, this is a good sign for improving our economy, so govt should encourage private sector.
Rate this: +21 -5

Surojit Saha said: (Wed, Feb 29, 2012 01:30:58 PM)

My frnds, I believe that it is better to modified public sector than to privatised. Why? India is a country where 70% of India is so called poor or so called middle class m and remaining of them may be accustomed to all the facilities for them by paying any amount. But what about this 70%. And here comes the public sector. Public sector provides you all the basic facilities that a common man needed by paying a very least amt as compared to private sector. May be private sector gives you better facilities than public sector but in cost of high amount that a common man specially like in India cannot afford. Private sector mainly aims for money making policy since it is contolled by individual whereas public sector is mainly intended for social welfare since it is controlled by gov. Just take a example of kingfisher airlines a private sector enterprise which is now in great loss due to its high price tickets which only nearly one-fourth of India cannot afford. So it is better to modify or reconstruct to make it better for the majority of Indian people.
Rate this: +32 -5

Shweta said: (Mon, Feb 27, 2012 03:59:51 PM)

I am of the view that more than highlighting pros and cons its the mutual get-going that can work for our economy . Public sector suffers from mismanagement but at the same time ensures job security and life changing services . Private sector lacks security but provides with the best growing and learning environment . Kingfisher rite now is suffering waiting for government's support though private it shares 20% of our air services and can't be left unattended . We need to strengthen the ties of private with government sector . Foreign direct investment would increase the employment in unorganised sector , provide better market to farmers minimising the intermediatories and extend better customer services with more choices . We at present need finance which can be ensured by private participation since fiscal deposit goes down to 5.6% .
Rate this: +11 -11

Vijay said: (Mon, Feb 27, 2012 11:17:31 AM)

Hai friends, I'm not agree with the view that the entire public sector should be privatized, but I'm supporting the view that the some parts of public sector should be privatized. As we all know that in public sector the corruption, irresponsibility and negligence is ruling all over. Suppose if we take the services like ambulance services, fire control service and all emergency services need immediate reaction and service and if above services are in the hands of public sector we can't expect immedite services. So, my opinion is that the emergency services should be privatized. In Private sector profit is the main objective so they don't think about the people's welfare and satisfaction. So, services like hospital, agricultural trades, transportation, education, rural development projects, road constructions etc shouldn't be privatized.
Rate this: +37 -4

Siva Shankar said: (Fri, Feb 24, 2012 12:57:20 AM)

According to my point of view, privatalization of public sector is not neccesary. Because, private sector will focus only on profit, unlike public sector will focus on the welfare of the people. Health is more important than wealth. Some of them told that, corruption will be avoided, if it is privatalised. Me too, accept that it will be one of the merit in privatalization. But, comparitively, it is not an major advantage. Private sector won't focus on people's health and their welfare. Customer satisfaction will be reduced if it is privatalized. They won't fullfill all the needs of the people. Since, their focus is only on profit, it is possible for them to sell the hazardous one. There is chance to break the rules and regulations. Humanity will be reduced. These are the major advantages in public sector. On the other hand, privatalization also has more advantages than public sector in some fields. So, I'm concluding that all the sector shouldnot be privatalized. If the field, which has more advantages than public has to be privatalized.
Rate this: +28 -1

Dinesh Jakhar said: (Wed, Feb 22, 2012 10:08:43 AM)

Hii. Buddies. I hav gone through various opinions, my opinion is that public sector should not be privatized completely because many of the public sectors like NTPC (national thermal power corporation) , CIL (coal India limited) and many others are so much big firms and also earning high profit and is working for the shake of welfare. So why should we privatize them. But many like HMT, Indian airlines, etc are facing a big financial problem. Here we have two options either privatise them or to improve its management. Also one more option is dere to overcome this problem is the corporate sectors, means both govt and private partnership is there in this.
Rate this: +12 -12

Sangeetha said: (Mon, Feb 20, 2012 06:56:37 PM)

Hi friends, Nowadays public sector run under corruption. So their finance goes down, which leads the government also meet finance problem. This leads to cause inflation in the country. If the public sector should be privatized corruption can be reduced and who are all knowledge they are eligible to get the job. Growth of the country can also be improved.
Rate this: +4 -13

Vishal Modi said: (Sun, Feb 19, 2012 07:21:50 PM)

I think privatization should be there because it is good only in stories that public sector works for poor people ....today all public sectors are as much corrupted that poor people fear to take the advantage from these company's. Govt should make the rules and should apply these rules on private companys so poor people could take the advantage from these company. Definately India will grow if privatization should be there because new technologies used by every company to make in the competition. No Reservation in these companys so deserving candidate will get good job.... May be there are some negative points also but positive points more than negative...
Rate this: +13 -8

Ajay said: (Sat, Feb 18, 2012 06:23:42 AM)

In my point of view needn't necessary to change public as privatesector. The people look for privat sectors because they do work efficiently. If the public sectors do work efficiently, the people neednolook for privatesectos. The corruption is also one immportant thing, it is mainly in public sectors. If you people will not give money, the other persion not able to take the money. It is the time to change ourselfs.
Rate this: +3 -4

Ankit Bhawalkar said: (Thu, Feb 16, 2012 11:21:47 PM)

Hello friends, I think that public sector companies should not be privatized. Because government works for the upliftment of our society and these public sector units act as a medium through which government provides services for poor people. For example, through financial inclusion, the government is planning to avail banking facilities to all unbanked areas of our country and it has been made compulsory for all public sector banks to open 25% of their branches in rural areas having population of 2000 or more. PSUs, despite of being in loss, are funded by the government which is not so in case of private sector companies. Private sector aims at earning more and more profit while PSUs are bound to work for human welfare because they are fully under control of the goverment and do not concern about the losses. So I completely disagree with privatization of PSUs. Thank you!!
Rate this: +27 -1

Ravindra said: (Thu, Feb 16, 2012 09:13:56 PM)

Hi friends my name is kranthi. I wish to spoke about the present topic. In my view public sectors are the back bones and it is the life for the physically handicapped and reservations (sc, st etc). Taking into consideration about the production the public sector should be privatised in the view of completing the production required in and on time. Rather than this the public sector should not be privatised in case. As our friends said that corruption increases if they are privatised I don't agree with this because govt means only corruption. Converting in private leads increase in new technology introducing robotics wer ever needed but due to this man power decreases and finally leads to unemployement. In order to increase ny machinery if funds are not there in govt inturn they increase the prices of goods and daily needs for people
Rate this: +4 -19

Satya Padhy said: (Wed, Feb 15, 2012 11:34:34 PM)

Hi friends, from my point of view it should not be happen. Because almost all people from the country are getting some subsidized product by the gove. But no private sector is interested to do this, only they will provide some discount to the product by increasing the price of the product so high. Also if it happens then there is no problem for rich people as they have much money, but the poor people will be the sufferer as they are getting some allowances from gov. E. G BPL category peoples.
Rate this: +3 -1

Abhisek said: (Mon, Feb 13, 2012 08:25:43 PM)

In public sectors (PSUs) the promotion of an employee takes place depending on his/her confidential appraisal report, knowledge in written test, interview & also some other parameters. So there is always an urge in a public sector employees to learn work and deliver work. Moreover nowadays public sectors are very much in competition among themselves and also with the private sectors. So work is done by them with utmost sincerity. Reduction in man-power in PSUs has increased the work load on the employees many a times. Many PSU bank employees even work from 8.00 am to 8. 00 pm. This competition, work load etc. Has done filtering of the real talents upwards in the promotional tests & that is also a reason why PSUs are doing better when compared to private sectors in most of the fields (AS mentioned in my discussion dated Nov 29, 2011). Question arises if public sectors are privatize what will happen to the prices of say domestic gas cylinders, electricity, rail fare, bank hidden charges, oil rates, medical treatment (In government hospitals) etc ? With increasing prices PSUs also can earn high profits like private companies and pay their employees high remunerations. Even with subsidized prices to customers as I have seen PSUs in average pay much better remuneration, perks & allowances to their employees than pvt sectors (except IT companies). & last but not the least aim of a govt. of any country is to provide job security to their citizens and not to keep them under the threat of firing resulting in increase of their blood pressure etc at an early age.
Rate this: +7 -3

Tweety said: (Sun, Feb 12, 2012 10:09:52 PM)

Yes it should be because as globalization is becoming more and more and private institutions are becoming more and private sector is quite attractive when compared to public sector, as the things are very slow in public sector and employees working there are quite irresponsible as they get salary even though they don't work. But whereas in private sector customer-employee relationship is very important, the people working there will loose jobs if they don't respond properly to the customers. Privatization would definitely improve the country growth and thus makes INDIA a developed country.
Rate this: +21 -11

Ajay said: (Fri, Feb 10, 2012 11:02:18 PM)

The public sector like government school should not be privatized because the poor person not afford the money for private institution the private institution can take fees in big amount. There are change are need in government school because in government school no teacher will be complete their syllabus in good manner they only come for time pass and they provide the information about some portion of course.
Rate this: +4 -6

Divyasinghyadav said: (Thu, Feb 9, 2012 03:42:47 PM)

If this do then it will good for our society because in the public sector people thinks they are safe and if they do not do work still they get their income so their behave towards customer and public is very rude and they do not give respect to public their behavior is bizarre and they have no passion to do their jobs hence the developing growth of our country is very slow while in the private sector people thinks to be up to dated so they give proper respect to their customer and the activeness of the employee maintain. Every body scaled according to their quality not their approach.
Rate this: +6 -5

Raja said: (Mon, Feb 6, 2012 07:47:39 PM)

I do not think that there is need to change public sector to private, because it needs a lot of infrastructure with proper planning and even then also we are not sure whether we will be satisfied. I do not thin that in private sector there is no corruption. The biggest example is of A. Raja. And do you think that private sector gives you proper service. Are you all happy with your mobile connection. These are also from private sector only. What is important we need to change ourselves and try to improve the existing system by giving vote to right person. We all are here discussing about right system but how many of us vote during elections, first try to change yourself then govt will automaticaly change.
Rate this: +27 -5

Sagar Guptta said: (Sat, Feb 4, 2012 11:13:03 PM)

In my opinion, public sector should be completely privatized. It will make everyone work properly. Everyone will be working by following the conditions. There will be no violation of rules. There will be no corruption at all. Because employer will be in fear that they could be fired. As the complaints can be directly made to the higher authorities. It will take the development rate of the country to the new heights.
Rate this: +12 -11

Srinivas Rotti said: (Sat, Feb 4, 2012 08:18:02 PM)

I vote for the privatization. Probably privatization is the only way we have, to eradicate the corruption in India. Private companies may be profit oriented, but their service is customer oriented. At least the paid customer will gets satisfaction. As we can see from history that new technologies introduced at the age of British rule to India like post department, railways etc. Are still used by our government. Privatization leads to the implementation of new technologies and will make our country to develop rapidly. Privatization gives importance to individual creativity and sponsor the good projects. Privatization reduces the irregularity, corruption and. Laziness of the employees and politicians. It is also difficult to make public sectors private. In order to do this, Amendments for minimum qualification of phd for politicians should be made and bills for the same should be passed. Then the privatization will happen automatically and India will move from a stage of developing country to a stage of developed country.
Rate this: +14 -4

Anvesh said: (Sat, Feb 4, 2012 05:03:05 PM)

Hai friends according to my point of view privitisation is important but not in all sectors upto some extent because we can't trust all the privatised constitutions every time. . Example most of the people show intrest to save thier money in public sector companies not in a privatised sector why because mainly safety purpose. We can't trust the the private sector banks and invest money all the time. . So I think that privitisation is necessary not important in all the public sector field.
Rate this: +21 -0

Sandhya said: (Thu, Feb 2, 2012 11:19:17 PM)

According to me, public sector should not be privatized even though there are benefits of privatization that does not mean the government officers should not work and privatization is the only option rather there should be strict rules then I am sure that even public sector will be as efficient as the private sector or may be more efficient since the main motive of public sector is not profit.
Rate this: +5 -3

Shashi said: (Thu, Feb 2, 2012 08:27:01 AM)

Citizens and Public sector establishments are the wealth of a nation. We form a government to protect it. I am against privatization and also to foreign direct investment. It seems that the government is evading from its responsibilities and selling India. Instead of closing the gap between haves and have-not s they are classifying people as BPL IPL and APL. Why this is happening. Because citizens have no control over the government. When election approaches they offer sops to gather votes. Government spending is not priority based. Health, Agriculture, Education, Environmental protection, all Public Sector companies and so on. Let there be loss, but improper management should not be tolerated. Support farmers by collecting produce for a higher price and distribute at a lower price. Support and encourage farmers by absorbing their expenses in case of natural calamities so that more and more poor people can enter into the sector for a livelihood. Enhance the distribution and supply system. It is very sad hearing tons and tons of grains went rotten. If there was a smooth supply system we could have given it out free for the poor. By the way, why collecting one rupee two rupee for that. Children are dying. Farmers committing suicide. In my opinion government must spend. Above fifty percent only for supporting the poor and to enhance the public sector rather than supporting the big corporate houses. All luxuries must be over taxed. A car above 5 lacs, a house above 50 lacs etc. No body is against the right of enjoying luxury. Here rich is getting richer because they cannot spend even a. Fraction of their earnings or returns. Let them enjoy while supporting the nation and they will be happy to do so as long as they could say that I paid 1 crore in tax. Alone last month. Let them enjoy that sort of richness also. In calamities government. Must insist private companies to donate one days production for rehabilitation and rescue. It would have been enough and more if they had collected and distributed damaged or discarded woolen cloths during the recent winter season to help the homeless. All government hospitals should be upgraded at least to the level of private hospitals. Government should collect one days production from all pharmaceutical companies for use in the government hospitals. Dear my friends don't. Let the private sector and foreign bodies to dictate terms on us. Think seriously. For a radical reformation in our electoral system and act seriously to save our democracy. Say no to all political parties who come out to meet you during election who spend much of their time for blaming each other. We are not for that. I am sure every one of us will have a vision India statement. Please forgive me for my poor English as well. Thank you. It is like a burden I dislodged.
Rate this: +19 -7

Prafful Agarwal said: (Mon, Jan 30, 2012 02:43:58 PM)

I don't agree whith the statement that "public sector be privatised" as, we all know that private sectors are profit based firms and the thing that matters them the most is profit and only profit. These are the following points why I don't support this topic are 1. I think very few people know that today the methane filled cylinder we use at our home actually costs govt 600rs but being provided to us on very subsidised rates, in the same way there are a lot of things which we have on subsidised prices. Which I don't think if private based sectors will come into the power going to provide us. 2. I also have an example from history, when India was in the control of EAST INDIA COMPANY. That time also the company did not favour the lower caste moreover they were being called as untouchables, even EAST INDIA COMPANY was also a private company. 3. I also strongly believe that if public sectors be privatised, then at the time of natural calamity in a particular region then it may be possible that govt will support only those regions that are resourse rich.
Rate this: +23 -7

Anshul Saini said: (Sun, Jan 29, 2012 09:17:26 PM)

It shouldn't be privatized cause in public sector schemes and policy flow which are easy for a layman to get the maximum benefit out of it. But, then too it takes to much time and long processor to be followed to get benefit. The only change needed is that to correct the entire chain which is our "SYSTEM". If you privatize the things what guarantee they have that they wouldn't change in public sector. For example - I have seen people come and asking to cashier in bank from they will get pension form, he is not the right person to answer this. So here comes the problem asking wrong question to wrong people disturbs him and interfere in his/her work. Over crowded public makes it difficult to work out things smoothly you can easily seen at any "PASSPORT OFFICE" in India. Why don't they learn few things from privatized sector which make their work easier, never let the customer give a change and ask you such stupid things put as much as information you can for this type of queries or tie a person from rope who is sitting on help desk so he can't flunk the duty after all he is a public sector employee.
Rate this: +5 -2

Ask said: (Thu, Jan 26, 2012 11:46:25 AM)

Hi friends. My opinion is the public sector should not be privatised, few public sectors are not efficient because the system that the governmnt sectors following are not as efficient as in private comps. Though job guarentee is not in case of private comps, that is the one which drives the employees to be more productive to the comp they work and so the result of any work will be profitable. Oly few modifications are to be changed/facilitated in govt sector to make it as successfull as prvte players. Also, whatever may be the reason, privatising the govt sectors would be largely understood by outsiders as inefficiency of govt to manage companies which is not true.
Rate this: +8 -2

N.Aishwarya said: (Wed, Jan 18, 2012 06:27:43 PM)

Public sector companies are prefarably best because in that all the people are included impartially irrespective of their richness or poverty.It also follows the equality and treats everyone equal so that everyone are provided due respect and we could also able to see that no people are cheated by the public sector companies(central government).
Rate this: +11 -12

Vyas Bhargav said: (Wed, Jan 18, 2012 08:24:13 AM)

Hey Friends , According to public sector should not be privatized because if it happens then the problem of corruption will become worse then what it is today.Because everything will be manged by private sector so it can happen we deal with the problems like time limits , quality ,job opportunity etc. so according to me it should be 50-50 so that government can also work effectively with private sector.
Rate this: +15 -5

Ravi said: (Mon, Jan 16, 2012 09:24:05 AM)

I think we are well awared about the term recession the gov sect. Is only untouched by recession due to strong financial status. Only the gov. Can afford deficit not any private company. It (p company) will not take much time to fire those employees which are unproductive for them. So it will be better few people are save to serving with gov. Sector. So effect of recession will be less.
Rate this: +15 -1

Ashok said: (Mon, Jan 16, 2012 02:40:45 AM)

At some extant public sector is good and at some level private sector is good. In privet sec The work, progress and result will be very fast than public sector. The simple and short reason is if we do not work carefully and sensibly we will loss our job. For this fear we will work fast and good. But it is true that in privet sector some high level authorities may involved in corruption if they get a change, I mean to say in the race of competition with other companies they may involve in corruption to get better benefit. It will be wise decision to keep sharp, efficient, and trustworthy people in public sec as well as privet sec. Thank you.
Rate this: +3 -4

Kajal said: (Wed, Jan 11, 2012 07:27:38 PM)

Well freinds, In my point of view to a large extent it is good to privatise the public sectors. Its give more beneficial outputs. First thing it improves the ability and habit of a person to fulfil his/her responsibility very well because in private sector we have to answer each and evrey moment the work we have done as it decide the sureity of our job. It also minimises the chances of corruption. Efficiency level increases thats lead a good environment of work & it result in a profitable Business.
Rate this: +9 -5

Babalu Yadav said: (Thu, Jan 5, 2012 03:56:58 PM)

It would be better if we give equal opportunity to both the sectors. By doing this the draw backs of public sectors can be recovered by private sectors. If we take a look at the population of India, it is increasing day by day. A lot of unemployeed people need good jobs. If they belong to a poor family then they can only think to earn money and live their lives. So they go for private sector. They are making profits,it's true but also they are offering a job.
Rate this: +3 -9

Abhijeet said: (Thu, Jan 5, 2012 02:10:27 PM)

According to me privatization should be there because in gov. Job there is no such load on employee, no target is there if public sector privatized then there is competition and employ also do job think beyond the box and also such hope to increase the rate of production and economy of the country it necessary to privatize public sector there is a necessary to complete given target.
Rate this: +7 -6

G.Sampath Kumar said: (Wed, Jan 4, 2012 04:20:35 PM)

Hi friends, according to me, if public sector is privated, then it is having both merits and demerits. Becoz the piivated sector is under govt, then every thing will be done legally, there is no way for the public to express their views. Mainly competitpn will be increased in govt jobs, then the self employment rate will be decreased. So, normally the way of thinking of public will turn to govt, no one will find a new life style for survival. So more demerits are there than making public sector is privated.
Rate this: +7 -3

Mouni said: (Fri, Dec 23, 2011 12:51:10 PM)

According to me public sectors should be privatized. By this everyone can complete there work faster. I think it will be end of the corruption upto some extent. There willbe no recommendations for every thing. Employment will also be generated according to their capabilities.
Rate this: +19 -8

Dhruv Sarin said: (Thu, Dec 22, 2011 09:14:47 AM)

Hi friends I think privatization will help in development of India in all the sectors. First and foremost I would ask you why people prefer govt jobs? simple reason they fear of targets job security and also one reason may get some easy money by 2nd means, but same time privatization will lead to growth because they believe in perfection, profits and efforts which will lead to a better service and performance as their main aim would be to establish in market and maintain the standards. And at the same time they will also have fear of competition among employs and companies so they strive for perfection. These all things you won't find in govt job, rather they ignore and won't perform.
Rate this: +40 -11

Vithal Vyas said: (Wed, Dec 21, 2011 07:23:54 PM)

Though Privation leads to competiton, it also enables employee to be more active Since there pros & cons of everything privation is lead to situation were profit is the main motive. Public sector company do there work on social cum profit motive while private company are maily concerned to earn for there stakeholder and India is still a developing country we all know how much social object is important for us. So privatisation shall be partial only.
Rate this: +9 -3

Akash Kumar said: (Tue, Dec 20, 2011 05:58:03 PM)

Hi friends. This is akash. According to my opinion public sectors should nt be privatised. The reason if public sectors are nt competitive to the private players is that in public sector organisatios there is a lack of performance based incentives and disciplinnary actions for incompetent persons. We need to address these problems by implementing some new promotion schemes in which the no. Of years in service will not be the only criteria for promotion and disciplinary actions could be taken against indisciplined ppl. Moreover giving full commands to the private players will create problems for common people because many a times public sectors take decision keeping in view the social welfare of the people also, which is nt in the case of private organisations. There only target becomes the maximization of profits earned. As example if today coal sector is privatised and the prices are determined by the private sectors then our country will pass through a difficult phase.
Rate this: +39 -4

Sameer said: (Tue, Dec 20, 2011 01:57:44 PM)

Dear all, according to me the government plays a very critical role in public administration. It designs and executes various welfare schemes. In doing so, it is very difficult to manage and monitor such huge population with few officers and staff who also have limitations and restrictions embebbed with pressure. Current policies and welfare schems are running smoothly because of their effort. In private sector the only priority is profit by any means. The welfare of employees is only for name sake. Hence I am of the view that their should be no privatisation of public sector organisation. To enhance the working ability of public sector employees, they must be boosted, monitered and feeling of belongingness must be increased in them. This is the only concrete solution.
Rate this: +12 -2

Pravin Fargose said: (Mon, Dec 19, 2011 07:59:48 PM)

Dear friends, my name is Pravin. In would like to add my views on this topic. I think privatisation is the must in few public sector this will reduce corruption and improve the quality of service we get. However this won't come in cheap as we will have to pay premium price for the premium service. But this will save us a lot of money as there won't be queue and no government officer would be there to ask bribery. Private sector is more transparent and competent this will surely improve the services. However I am sceptical about the success of privatisation of govt hospitals as this is necessary, and must be affordable for the poorest people of India. Defence and policing can not be privatized. Entire transport system, communication, media, highway management etc will entirely change the scenario in the country. Anyways, who does not want to see clean roads, better communications, no queues in any off the private sectors, better standard of living and after all a huge saving of taxpayers money, huge tax generation due to more transparent private sector, effective and efficient workforce. I can't wait until this things begin as the govt can not be trusted anymore.
Rate this: +7 -3

Suneel Kumar said: (Thu, Dec 15, 2011 11:13:53 PM)

First think my dear friends. What is the reason behind this problem ? Private organizations are providing better services with efficient/effective manner. Why there are providing services like that? The main reason is in any private organizations contains so many employees. Here each and every employee should be monitored by the management. If any of the employee can't do their work properly they can simply punished by management. As well as each of the employee are able to provide the better services to the people because if they not providing better services to the people means then don't want to visit the organization again and again. But the government sector is not like that it is simply providing so many offer to the people but they can't able monitoring the things. That is the main drawback and in public sector each of the employee are able to get their salary with or without working properly. When ever the public sector is able to monitoring the services weather the things are properly reached to the people are not? then only there is no need of conversion. It's my opinion.
Rate this: +40 -1

Sayyad Ali said: (Wed, Dec 14, 2011 09:57:29 PM)

I am Ali and i think that privatization of public sector is not going to work in favor of common man generally Public sector units work in favor of the public there main or basic objective is to serve people and then the intention of profit comes into fray whereas private sector units work mainly for profit maximization and due to which public welfare is kept aside it is considered but secondly. I think ideas or methods of working of Pvt. sector can be adopted in P.S.U. but complete privatization is not a good idea as we are already witnessing price rise in electricity after its privatization, so it will be good to adopt the some concepts of Pvt. units but making total privatization is not a valid idea.
Rate this: +11 -1

Teja(Teju) said: (Tue, Dec 13, 2011 04:27:02 PM)

Well friends my view is that both public sector and private sector have their own advantages and disadvantages. But the point is that if public sector is changed to private sector their is a loss to the government. I still remember in my schooling my social mam used to say India is a developing country now in my graduation too I hear India is a developing country. If we change public sector to private sector then I am sure that our future generations will also know our country as developing but not developed. So the thought of changing public sector to private sector is not good for countries like India. We can impliment some of the advantages of private sector to public sector this is a good idea too or else we can make some of the organisations both private and public so that it is useful to all the people.
Rate this: +19 -8

Santoshi said: (Tue, Dec 13, 2011 11:39:03 AM)

In my point of view public sector should not be privatized. Because the people who get the government job think that once they got the job the government will pay for them without doing the work and they can easily get the money by corruption and they have no fear.These are the main points which may lead to the downfall of public sector. Rather than privatizing we have to solve the problems like the government have to control them and have to maintain strict rules if any person were corrupted he should be taken out of the job and if he found he is lazy and not doing his work he should be imposed with fine. Then the public sector can also lead to the profits and can compete with the private sector.
Rate this: +9 -7

Shalini said: (Fri, Dec 9, 2011 04:05:36 PM)

Hi friends, In my point of view, public sector should not be privatized because they should look only for their personal profits. They trust only machine power leads to unemployment. They will also make rules of their own, this will treat the people like slaves. They will misuse authority. But in public sector there will have job security and retirement pension etc. Even though there is corruption it can be minimized by changing the rules.
Rate this: +21 -4

Abhisek said: (Tue, Nov 29, 2011 01:21:55 AM)

As far as I know the latest figures, 6 companies among top 10 companies in India are public sectors.Even SBI the largest bank in India is a public sector. So public sectors are doing comparatively better than private sectors.I agree corruption is very much there in employees who comes directly under the govt. but much much less in public sector employees whose majority or full shares are held by govt. of India. To eradicate corruption why PSUs has have to privatize when they are doing very well except a few like Air India?Why some other system can't be innovate in order to eradicate corruption. If public sectors are privatised then there will be a problem regarding oil rate,regarding non payment of insurance claim, regarding minimum balance in savings account in banks,regarding granting of loans in priority sectors, etc.Let me give you a few examples. 1. Largest Bank- State Bank of India. 2. Largest life Insurance company- LIC of India. 3. Largest oil company- India Oil corporation. 4. Largest credit insurer- ECGC of India Ltd. 5. Largest telecom company- BSNL. 6. Largest aviation Company- Air India. All the above are public sectors. & for example in private, cell phone companies because of high competition are giving SIM card of cell phones to Tom,Dick & Harry even without checking the backgrounnd of the person which is totally illegal.Isn't it a type of corruption? So public sector should not be privatized.
Rate this: +148 -8

Buji said: (Sun, Nov 27, 2011 01:34:15 PM)

In my opinion also public sectors should privitised. Ihope that it may not give accurate results as it has some advantages with some isadvantages also. We know that many public sectors are became corrupted by privatising them we can reduce corruption to some extent only but not accurate. By privatising all public sectors we find competetive environment some times it may cause loss to people. So in my opinion it change must come from people only. In private sectors their will competition so it is difficult to have qualitative services to the people.
Rate this: +2 -11

Mohammed Mohtashim said: (Sat, Nov 26, 2011 05:17:32 PM)

HI friendsss good evening, First I want to put some point that public sector should be privatized but we know that today public secotrs are sffering form curroption so that there is a bariar in growth of public secotr and we will face same problem till the time when these secotrs would be curroption free. I am not totally agrre with this point that public sector shlud be privatized. We have so many examples of privatized sectors wihich are going ahead very well I. G. Insurance and banking sectors are the very good examples these sectors are in now private hand aslo but still we have a control by a ragulatory of Government so that I want to say that we should not totally privatized the public sector but yes it shluld be privatized in a limit so that a setuation of nmonopoly not rise if our government would follow this mathored I am sure that rest f the public secotr will be shine as a diamond.
Rate this: +8 -4

Mohammed Mohtashim said: (Sat, Nov 26, 2011 01:06:12 PM)

HI Friends good afternon, As we know thta MNC the company which is running in m ore than two nation. No doubt these cmpanies are providing more facilities and high salary pacakge to indians but reason to provide these facilities and salsry is that indians deserve it. We know that indians are the backbone of MNCs becuse noone can ignore this fact that Indian emplyees are helping to grow these company by contrubuitng thier services and new ideas and they are getting paid only for this. So we can say that if Indian comapnies which are suffing form curroption would be curroption free like other MNCs we have the power to become the superior then MNCs and this time also many Indian companies are prooving that like reliance infosys wipro etc. These companies has good repotatin in the internatonal market. In the end I want to say that like MNCs Indian companies are also superior who are delivering better services tgo thier client.
Rate this: +4 -15

Sandeep Kr. Singh said: (Thu, Nov 24, 2011 09:25:21 PM)

According to my point of view the pubic sector should not privatized. If the all public sector will be privatized than , 1. The only some part of the profit will go to the Govt. 2. The price will be increase. 3. In the private sector organization will not think about the poor people. 4. For example if the Indian Railway will be privatized then the fare will be increase and you can not ask any single question to them and govt. will not interfere . 5. The unemployment will be increase. 6. If the public sector will be privatized then poor people will suffer most like if the govt want to increase the fare of railway then first they will think about the poor people but if it will be privatized then they will not think about the poor person. Pubic sector helps to develop Indian economy. It is the main assets of the govt and by the help of public sector they earn the profit.
Rate this: +66 -2

Tilling Chama said: (Wed, Nov 23, 2011 02:19:35 AM)

Well say my dear friends. Now a days public sector has been dominated by private sector in every field but govt should not take depress themselves they should gain the concept from private except their objective i.e to gain huge profit from citizen. If govt take in this way so it would be definitely changing in economic status.
Rate this: +1 -3

Subha said: (Tue, Nov 22, 2011 06:53:26 PM)

In my perspective, public sector should not be privatized. Though our country's economy will raise to a good rate but people who are in BPL sectors will suffer a lot. They are able to have a square meal per day only because of ration shops which comes under public sector. Of course lack of efficiency, corruption etc. Are major drawbacks but still we should consider the goodness of people. So, public sector should not be privatized. Rather we can have a mutual partnership with private sectors which may control corruption.
Rate this: +4 -1

Shriharsha said: (Mon, Nov 21, 2011 02:03:23 PM)

There should be healthy competition between public and private sectors. For example, after private sector participation in the field of aviation, the service of Air India and Indian Airlines is comparatively better to earlier. Indian Railways too is giving competition to the field of aviation by giving improved services with good food to survive in front of quicker and time saving airline services. This type of healthy competition will improve the future trend of Indian Economy. Finally, I would like to say, there should be public-private competition in majority sectors in a balanced manner, so that the economic growth shall show targeted growth for a particular year.
Rate this: +22 -0

Kundan said: (Mon, Nov 21, 2011 10:37:23 AM)

"Because things are the way they are, things will not stay the way they are. ". Bertolt Brecht. But the movement should not be from public to private or vice versa. The advantages of privatization is surely effective for some people but if we look our economic growth we can't even think of this. In 2011 the GHI (Global Hunger Index) Report ranked India 15th amongst the three countries where the GHI between 1996 to 2011 went up from 22. 9 to 23. 7. So how should we forget those people who are lagged behind just for the callousness of our elected ministers. What'll be the result if the big private companies take over the public sectors?How could they (our so called downtrodden people) survive?While the public sector units (RAIL, LIC, ONGC, NTPC etc. ) served us well. In case of Growth, Honesty and Innovation does not depend upon the fact wheather the industry is public or private this entirely depend upon our work ethics. Corruption starts from me and end with us. To improve India's economic growth we need to change ourselves.
Rate this: +6 -3

Tilling Chama said: (Sun, Nov 20, 2011 04:39:28 AM)

Hi! Well say their my buddies. I would like to add something about regarding this topic. Always the Public and the private sectors they run differently their organization and they have different motivations and contributions their skill and effort are differently utilized with following some certain principles in order to fulfill their objectives. If we utilize advanced conceptions, contributions, motivations, skills and efforts from both into the organization without having any prejudice these two sectors. So both the public and the private sectors they would run 90% similar and also it will make effectively run the organization.
Rate this: +1 -3

Deepesh Dharmchari said: (Wed, Nov 16, 2011 02:29:25 PM)

I was thinking why not Privatize our Judicial System. It also works very slowly and Generates no financial profits. Privatization is the way to kill power of public you can never ask a single question from private sector. Increasing quality of Public sector is the only way to India.
Rate this: +7 -10

Naga Suresh Repalli said: (Tue, Nov 8, 2011 01:11:20 PM)

Hi, those people who know the power of a public sector will not support for privitization. As earlier our friends said that the major differences between private and public sector are Corruption and Quality of work, its our duty to make them work in order to get our work. We are public they need to serve us. We should ask them or we must order them to do so. Instead we ourselves are spoiling our system by bribing them. Even if they ask us we should not give. If one gives bribes they will always wait for the other to give. If no one gives bribes and ask them to work they will definitely work because at some point of time they are also public. If it happens so I feel there will be a day shortly where a question arises that why private sector not be governmentized. There flies our flag high. Jai Hind.
Rate this: +9 -9

Subhasmita Rath said: (Mon, Nov 7, 2011 11:52:59 PM)

Public sector should be privatized. Because now a days no one are ready to work if there is not certain rule and regulation. They are working with own mind in public sector. Just take as a example between government hospital and private hospital. A patient lost his life only due to absent or ignorance of doctor. At the same time if you will go to private medical you can save that life although much expense.
Rate this: +20 -11

Saravana said: (Sat, Nov 5, 2011 11:33:42 PM)

Friends I would like to add that both public sector and private sector are need of the hour and have to be interlinked rather than giving anyone monopoly over other. In economy like us it would be better to give chance to all the sector under the control of government. For Example in the case of Functioning of Banks in India, though there are many private banks RBI is the one which regulates all. Most of Public sector industries are not run in efficient way as the private ones. We can also enter in public private partnership as in airport and make sure that all play a positive role in developing our economy.
Rate this: +36 -3

Priya said: (Sat, Nov 5, 2011 07:03:04 PM)

Hi, In my perspective, it is better to change the system and principles of public sector rather than make it privatization. As you know the public sector offers more employment and good for public. Only problem is that lack of efficiency, corruption etc. Avoid that problems and provide more efficiency and quality that is better.
Rate this: +16 -3

Shikha said: (Wed, Nov 2, 2011 10:58:49 PM)

According to me public sector should not be privatised because in india 75% population is rural.They can't afford the high level standard. Private sector ignore the rural area and 54% people depend on agriculture and 36% in service sector.So most of the people deprive of private sector services...
Rate this: +23 -6

Mohan Raj said: (Sat, Oct 29, 2011 07:17:41 AM)

Hi Everyboby,Some Public sectors can be privatized,bcoz many public sectors render service to public at affordable cost say post office,mtc,train..at the same time service rendering shop like ration,tasmac,many banks governed by state and central bank indulge in corruption.whereas many private banks offer loans against mortgage viz.home loan,gold loan,even education loan can be availed at simplest way the same can not be done in govt.banks. so some public sectors can be privatized.
Rate this: +9 -7

Prateek Mishra said: (Tue, Oct 25, 2011 04:00:47 PM)

Public sector should not be privatised completely because it is clearly mentioned above the private will always look for their personal profits. No body will have any command on them which leads the common people to suffer. I am not deny with the fact that privatisation increases competition which results in growth but public sector should have some command on them. Which will prevent them from misuse of the authority.
Rate this: +22 -3

Sahil said: (Thu, Oct 20, 2011 01:42:02 AM)

In my point of view the public sector cannot be private because of 1. There main intension to earn money in any situation. 2. The corruption increase because of there monopoly. 3. They increase the unneccessary price to any thing because of money. 4. At last but not least we have to take step to control this at shorter distance we use bycle instead of car. Make aware to public so they can use less.
Rate this: +6 -6

Pawan said: (Tue, Oct 18, 2011 09:23:51 PM)

Hi Friends, I would like to add that there should be privatization of maximum of the public units. The public units now a days in economy like India has turned as the 'sick units'. The meaning of such word is that the capital investment on these PU are more than they are properly utilizing it, i.e. output/input ratio of resources,capital,employment,land,labor of public sector units are poor competitively to the private sectors and such units hardly work for achieving goals rather than to promote a safe job of public sector units employees. If there is no competition there is no growth of national income.Moreover private sector runs on entrepreneurship giving pace to overall economy and empowers the employment opportunities.
Rate this: +6 -3

Mehul Parmar said: (Wed, Oct 12, 2011 06:00:10 PM)

Hii friends, In my point of view Public Private Partnership would be the best possible solution, with Govt. as the regulatory authority and outsourcing of work will help to check rate of unemployment. Secondly with the participation of Private Companies It would help to check Corruption, and also it helps to completion of work in time with accuracy. The Main Disadvantage of completely privatising the public sector companies will lead us to destabilization of economy when it comes to world wide recession.. but with Govt. as regulating authority will help us to take effective steps, in those circumstances (for ex: as well managed by Reserve Bank 0f India). As the prime motto of Private companies is to earn profits, this will lead to Capitalism and econoimic disparity in the society.. This will lead to the exploitation of the poor section of the society. With Privatization, Market would become highly fluctuating, this will result in very low FDI. Hence atlast I would like to conclude that Public Private Partnership would lead to best results with extracting out advantages of both.
Rate this: +41 -5

Garima said: (Wed, Oct 12, 2011 04:40:23 PM)

Hello all, I would like to say that public sector should be privatised. Because it would make people in public sector to do their work effeciently and in time, as they have the fear of job security. They have respond to their higher officials for their work. This also leads to decrease in corruption which is often seen in public sector because people (means citizens) have to pay bribes for get their work done. Also there are some wrongs associated with this like may be unemployment in creases. But Privatisation of some public sectors is really necessary.
Rate this: +8 -7

Venkysam said: (Wed, Oct 12, 2011 02:26:49 PM)

Hello everyone. 1. Both has its own importance. 2. If public sector is privatised its like we are privatising our govt. 3. Partiality, corruption, unemployment increases. 4. There is no one to control if the private sector takes any unethical decisions. 5. Private sector concentrates more on profits, personal profits. Both sector has its own pros n cons so I would like to conclude by telling both sectors must follow the rules strictly and stop being selfishnd public sector will be privatized we will be facing lots of problem. For example, our railway department is one of the economical earning dept. The fare of the local train is very low comparing with state bus transport fare. So, its very good for middle class family. In other haI feel public sector should not be privatised because.
Rate this: +20 -8

Deivasigamani Thamizhmani said: (Thu, Oct 6, 2011 11:55:21 AM)

Hi friends, So many of you have aired your views on this and when I could read some of them I could find the views thrown are excellent. This had ignited my mind also to share some of my thoughts. Now almost, in most of the sectors, in which the service provisioning functions, which were earlier with Govt had now thrown open to the Private sectors, limiting only the Regulatory functions with the Government When these service provisioning functions are given to Pvt sector, the Govt held one of the view that this will lead to lot of employment opportunities to the young citizens of this country. What actually had taken place. Many people works are given to one person and he/she is being squeezed to max extent and paid a salary, of course which was better than the Govt SALARY but comparatively less for the quantum of work extracted. With the result the dreams of the Govt that this will lead to lots of employment opportunities to the citizen has been successfully defeated, as one do many person jobs in private sector and thereby the man had been made to work like a machine. Govt could not regulate them and instead agrees to the private sector stand. Therefore the Govt regulatory mechanisms 100% does not work on private sectors. When it comes to Govt sector, after implementation of the 6th Pay commission pay perks and allowances, it is really good. But the bad part is such a good pay pockets had been given with a justification of creation of good work culture in Govt/ Pvt sectors. Therefore in every area whether its is a private sector or in Govt sector, people takes only the features which are advantageous to them and leave the other things which they are supposed to give it back to the Country. As one of the friend had pointed out Govt should check and not allow the private sectors to make a very high profits by carefully checking their P/L account. Govt also must adopt a lit bit of innovative methods being adopted in Pvt sector should come in Public sector by taking the employees into confidence. With respect to the rules and procedures being followed in the Public sector in the country, its is really a bad state of affair today that when an Executive is not taking decisions and leave the problems as such are considered to be a good executive and the executive, who takes a decision for the betterment of the organisation will get punished even if 5% of the decision is faulty, forgetting the 95% of the decision had yielded the gain to the organization. This indirectly makes the situation that the Executives in all level tend to take a stand in public sector that better delay the decision to the other man or avoid taking decision and leave it to some other man to venture it. As long as out Audit mechanisms like C&AG, CBI, CVC and similar agencies are not gear up to unearth how the cases of delayed or no decision had resulted in losses to the Govt without limiting to do the post mortem of the decisions taken cases, this situation in Govt/ public sector will not change. The investigating agencies also, now a days, it is observed that they need to have a public image and hence try to project abnormally a high figures of looses of fraud have been detected by them, as these Govt agencies also given a target that how much cases and involving how much mis appropriations have been detected by them. Therefore this leads to such over reporting in the public takes place. These organisations should also be assigned with the functions of detecting losses due to " No decision, Delayed Decisions by the Top management and also the middle and lower level Executives, who are responsible for creating such a situations etc. In effect, the mute or silent or ineffective spectators of executives at all levels should be possible to be detected in the investigating process and warned them, so that everyone will become accountable in the Govt and Public sectors. In a nutshell, our country should develop a via media of Public-private partnership (if the innovativeness of the Private sector could not be implemented in Public sector as employees are protected by various rules and procedures) in every possible areas to give up the present trend of the management view of Private sector that " one and only aim is the profit in Private Sector at the cost of everything of human life " & the views of the employees in Public sector that " no aim of making any profit - whatever happens in the organisation, but I should get all my salary, perks etc etc in the public sector ".
Rate this: +10 -38

Nimisha said: (Wed, Sep 28, 2011 07:48:45 PM)

Basically privatising public sector will lead to more competition in the market ..today many public sectors are not performing well and canot provide proper service to the public...today private sector is constantly working on how to satisfy thier customers...and to get the number 1 position...hence privatising would definately help ...public sector.
Rate this: +34 -5

Nitish Gupta said: (Mon, Sep 26, 2011 06:38:15 PM)

Hello Friend. Yes Exactly, I am not agree on that the public sector will be become the private. Beacuse if the public sector are private then the peoples only motto in the market would be to earn profit and corruption also increase in country. Every human beings think about himself. Its will lead the unemployement. There is no one to control if the private sector takes any unethical decisions. Private sector will always try to reduce man power and increases machine power.
Rate this: +22 -11

Vamshi Srinivas said: (Fri, Sep 23, 2011 03:44:53 PM)

Friends, in my opinion, Privatization of the public sector is necessary but only to some extent. I think the privatization could decrease the level of corruption in the company since most of the private companies have been inherited and they run under big names like The Tatas, Birlas and Ambanis. I think that they don't encourage corruption much for, they have to protect the name they have earned in decades. Though there are some departments that should not be handed over to the private sector, as @Pinki said.
Rate this: +15 -3

Satabdi said: (Sat, Sep 17, 2011 10:04:18 PM)

In my opinion I would say that my converting the Public Sector into the Private will not solve the purpose. Our main motto should be to eradicate the existing loopholes encrypted within the system and establishing those laws that will provide some fruitful result. As in the past the most of the companies were privatized because the companies were all sick and became a burden for the Government. But it was never thought to why these industries are working as a sick units so I will conclude that government and through public voting a policy should be established to remove the negative elements to bring positivism within the system.
Rate this: +16 -3

Peter said: (Fri, Sep 16, 2011 12:37:54 AM)

Public sector should noe be fully privitised, as major departments like defence systems, Indian railways, and in fields where major chunk of people are simultaneously affected must not be privitised. Instead we should implement certain policies in Public sector also so that there work efficiency can be inccrease like pvt.
Rate this: +15 -3

Avinash Raj said: (Thu, Sep 15, 2011 12:08:37 AM)

Hi friends as the topic is that should public sector be privatized. In my opinion it should not be privatized. As we all know that there are already so many private companies who are doing well and contributing to our economy. The only thing is that we should change the process and working culture of the sectors. Whether it is private or public. The other issue is corruption. According to me there is not only one player involved in it. If one will stop to give other will automatically not able to receive. Its not time to change the system, its time to change yourself.
Rate this: +51 -2

Chitrasen Kumar Singh said: (Wed, Sep 14, 2011 07:47:19 PM)

Hello friends! I am Chitrasen kumar singh and I am very happy to see that you all have given good points and I also want to be your part and taking this discussion in a next level. Here I want to emphasize what are the main causes to be privatized the public sectors. There will be no any authentic advantages to change term and system. What are the loopholes in the system we should remove. Whole change directly related to the welfare of the people not the only systems. We know that main causes are corruptions, bad time managements and not good environments to achieve magnificent goals. So friend I agree with to change work procedures, environments and work culture and cope with the present demands. Thank you all giving time for me. Go on!
Rate this: +3 -4

Souvik Mishra said: (Mon, Sep 12, 2011 01:18:17 PM)

Public sector is the backbone of our economy basically ours because they are concerned with production of things of national interest like power, defense equipments, heavy industries, infrastructure etc. Privatising these may help in short run but will not be effective in long run. Basically public sectors have better job guarantee and salary so it also helps in reducing unemployment not like US where, due to capitalism, there is lot of unemployment when there some economic turmoil. Public sectors are run by the rules and regulations framed b the government with the sole intention of national welfare unlike private firms which see only profit of there firm. So in long run and in an circumstances job security remains intact in case of public sector. Also Public sector is like a private sector firm with more than 51% got. Share and rest for the public, so overall it can also work like a private sector. But again if we consider private sector there are also lot to be seen. In an private firm one is paid proper salary if he/ she does proper work so this increases work efficiency. Sometimes what happens in public sector is that employees tend to be casual in there duty n do not work properly which leads to delayed and inefficient work. Large private sector firms are also very much responsible for employment oppurtunities and economic growth and there is very less scope for corruption. It also leads to expose ones talent in a particular field and learn the work culture and also have privac in doing a work. Like in China man people want to flee from china and settle elsewhere so that the can avail better opportunities. So complete public ownership is also not good as it has no work freedom. So it will be better if public and private sector work together b following the rules and regulations of the govt strictly.
Rate this: +45 -5

Dheeraj said: (Sun, Sep 11, 2011 01:41:21 AM)

Friends, I would to tell that public sector are basically build for to improve the infrastructure of country they are not build for profit whereas private sector main motto is only profit and also private sector are not take making bigger items so if we privatized our public then there many losses.
Rate this: +25 -3

Speak Your Mind:
...
Name *:	Email: Alert me
Please do not use chat terms. Example: avoid using "grt" instead of "great".