Logical Reasoning Verbal Reasoning Non Verbal Reasoning

Sudoku Number puzzles Missing letters puzzles Logical puzzles Playing cards puzzles Clock puzzles

C Programming C++ Programming C# Programming Java Programming

Microbiology Biochemistry Biotechnology Biochemical Engineering

Civil Engineering Mechanical Engineering Chemical Engineering Networking Database Questions Computer Science Basic Electronics Digital Electronics Electronic Devices Circuit Simulation Electrical Enigneering Engineering Mechanics Technical Drawing

Placement Papers Group Disucssion HR Interview Technical Interview Body Language

Aptitude Test Verbal Ability Test Verbal Reasoning Test Logical Reasoning Test C Programming Test Java Programming Test Data Interpretation Test General Knowledge Test

Should the public sector be privatized?

@ : Home > Group Discussion > Economics - Discussion Room

Points to remember before you participate in this disuccsion:

Assume, you one of the member of a real group discussion.
Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
Express your positive attitude towards providing the solution.

Deepanshu said: (Mon, May 20, 2013 12:05:26 PM)

Hello everyone ! I think public sector should be privatized but in a controlled manner, we should not give all the rights to the private companies. The govt sector has certain advantages over public sectors. 1. It is concerned with the social as well as the economic welfare of our country. 2. It increases the employment. 3. It does not neglect the poor man as in case of public sectors. 4. It does not take much work from their employees as in case of public companies. Disadvantages: 1. The reservation system in govt sectors is not good for society as it is a kind of burden in the growth of minded people. 2. Public sector is concerned with the maximization of money. 3. In public sectors every individual will work hard because the would have the fear of losing their job if they would not work harder. 4. It decreases the corruption.
Rate this: +2 -2

Sudheer Kumar Kalyanam said: (Tue, May 14, 2013 12:50:50 PM)

Hi Good Morning, The present scenario of Indian Government is, it is doing puppet dance in the hands of some rich individual owning a chain of Corporate Companies. The petrol prices in the country is decided by them. If one such individual gets angry on government the ruling government will collapse. This is a very severe threat to Indian Economy. The most economically crucial activities like petroleum exploration also should not be handed over to private firms instead of Government Companies like ONGC, Indian Oil etc. The Private sector should be developed and should compete with the public sector for good stronger economy and GDP growth. Privatizing the existing government firms is a huge threat to the mixed economy due to which our country has been in this state today. Thank you.
Rate this: +6 -0

Shubham Wahi said: (Tue, May 14, 2013 12:47:21 PM)

Hello Everyone, This topic which we all are discussing is about the privatization. I first would like to define this It is an action of making any sector as your own, you have your own right to use and run that in your way. See we all are now in a competitive world which is growing very fast. So for surviving we will also to be fast. Private sectors increase the competition among themselves and create motivative environment to do best and get the success. So If there would be privatization our country will not only grow fast but also there will be strong economy of our country. It will also reduce the corruption, which is a big disease of any country, which is there in public sector because people will strictly follow the norms if they won't they will get fired. On the other hand privatization will make every sector money oriented and won't take care about public welfare their convenience and upliftment which is their in case of public sector. But I would still suggest to take a positive action and try privatization in the sectors where it can really bring the change like- Water, Electricity and LPG supply because people would have full control and limit of usage of resources so they would be able to use these in economic and efficient manner. So try because "Not trying is bigger failure than the failure after trying. ".
Rate this: +5 -2

Jainesh Gala said: (Fri, May 10, 2013 01:35:10 PM)

Hello Friends, According to me public sector should privatize in those areas where they are not much efficient. While in areas where they have their dominance, they should continue in those areas and also improving their skills. For eg:public transports like railways and bus are more effective means of transport for public and they are even cheap. While in areas like passport government has privatized it and it has been much more comfortable for the public to apply for passports.
Rate this: +4 -0

Rizwan said: (Sat, May 4, 2013 06:28:29 PM)

Nowadays public sectors are also doing very good job in Corporate social responsibility. I myself is in NPCIL and my company has done lot for the area development from constructing school building, Cemented roads up to 50 Km length, avail transportation to peoples to giving job to local persons according to their education qualification. Peoples of the area are happy with the way company treating them. Some public sectors like railway, electricity distribution, water and LPG supply in house must be privatized. It will enhance the efficiency of machinery involved. Privatization of each sector is harmful to society, because private sectors frequently forget their mission and become increasingly involve in money making process. They do not think even once for public goodwill/safety. But on the other way on privatization reservation policy of our country will vanish. There are pros and cons of each coin. Finally I think some areas that I have mentioned above must be privatized for convenience of citizens. If all sectors will be privatized then the day is not for away when India will again become subordinate of more like East India Company earlier.
Rate this: +3 -1

Sudha said: (Tue, Apr 30, 2013 11:09:16 PM)

Well friends. In my opinion all public sector should be privatized. It will improve the economic condition of the country as we all we know that after liberalization in India the GDP of country is increased. After privatization the competition between different sector increased and that ultimately lead to high quality works. Time of people is saved. Work is done very efficiently and with full dedication.
Rate this: +2 -1

Mohammed Amair said: (Tue, Apr 23, 2013 11:46:00 PM)

Hi friends according to my point of view public sector should remain the same because. 1. Public sector will considered the social and economic welfare. 2. As we know the output is low, compare to private sector but the work is more reliable. 3. As we seen that in privatized sector the work will be more when compare to public sector. 4. More, job securities in public sector.
Rate this: +8 -2

Sweta Sinha said: (Tue, Apr 23, 2013 01:59:39 PM)

According to me, the main motto of public sector is to serve the citizens without thinking one's own profit and comfort. But today, this purpose has totally vanished. And the innocent public is paying for it. First of all, one of the main reason for which the public sector should be privatized is the awful reservation system in our country. If the reservation system will be continued with the same pace, then that day will come soon when we have employees only having their caste certificates and nothing else. Secondly, in private sector their is no management, no rules, no punctuality, no responsibility, nothing. We have heard it many times earlier that "government is blind". So I think its better to handover the whole control to one who is physically fit rather than a physically challenged one.
Rate this: +7 -5

Shubha said: (Tue, Apr 23, 2013 01:39:37 PM)

Hi, dears. In my view points the public sector must be privatized, one of the reason is that, private companies are not only make profit but also contribute social welfare for society as a whole. If we take some example like atul industry, ongc, tata reliance and number of industries of foreign companies functioning in India are good example of their social contribution.
Rate this: +4 -7

Shubha Pramanik said: (Mon, Apr 22, 2013 09:23:59 PM)

Dear Friends, Public sector should remain in the control of government, but its recruitment process and job performance should be monitored by the private sector and also provide the authority to suspend those persons who are corrupted, they may also work as a adviser to the government bodies.
Rate this: +2 -6

Imran Kanjoo said: (Sun, Apr 14, 2013 10:21:11 PM)

Hi everyone. According to my point of view Public sector should remain in its original state, but there is a need to convert Private sector into Public sector. Why? Because in Private sector the organizations have their infrastructure well managed, and they are gaining profit in a sophisticated manner, If govt own the private sector there are more chances for India to flourish because of the more profit Govt will attain the more it will be utilized for the welfare of the natives of India. Despite Private sector is gaining so much but not using a single rupee on human welfare because they didn't aim for that, they aimed only for profit, Then why we need for them? they earn profit or not it will not make any effect on the life of individual compatriots. But keep in mind! It will only true if your ruling party wants to do something for Indians without making money for their own.
Rate this: +3 -5

Subahan Shaik said: (Sun, Apr 14, 2013 07:57:19 PM)

Hi friends. According to my opinion public sectors should be privatized, because in private sectors there is no reservation and we cannot find that boon in private sectors and they will hire students who are having great strength of knowledge not reservation. But in public sectors they will hire only the students who are having reservation strength. Because of this most of the students who are having great knowledge migrating to foreign countries and they are helping those countries to grow up. Finally I conclude that if government take off these reservations in studies and public sector jobs definitely our country will reach to high position than other countries.
Rate this: +26 -5

Sharat K Malick said: (Sat, Apr 13, 2013 03:36:16 PM)

Dear Friends, Let us be clear about the role of public sector and private sector. The major objective of introduction of Public Sector in India was to make all around development which requires heavy investment and low return i.e. for the welfare of the society as a whole. The formation of public sector was not profit earning. Where the private sector could not enter due to resources constraint public sector stepped in for the welfare objective of masses. Heavy dams, infrastructure projects, thermal power projects, banking and like such projects were initiated and completed only for the welfare of citizens. Whereas the primary objective of private sector is profit maximization. This sector is not responsible for the welfare of masses in general. So the question of privatising public sector is just like killing the basic objective of public sector. Although there are many corrupt practices since cropped in the Public sector mainly due to Politicalization of these organisation. But we have to eradicate the cause and not the purpose of public sector. Thanks. Sharat.
Rate this: +11 -1

Rohit Kumar said: (Fri, Apr 12, 2013 11:31:14 PM)

Hi friends , in my view public sector as a caretaker for poor person and in india more than 65% people are poor and public sector is is directly amenable to public while due to privatization there is no interference of public and total right will be private as a dictatorship.
Rate this: +3 -2

Mamta said: (Fri, Apr 12, 2013 01:50:39 PM)

Hello friends, Yes, definitely public sector must be private because in our daily life we see every small work whether it is related submitting bills, water connection, caught by police etc all work are done on the ground of Bribes. Thats all the result of our red tapism hierarchy which is not only loose taking decision but corrupted also. For every work whether related to passing rules, design it they are habitual of bribes. If the tree will be rotten, weak, how could you expect the fresh and healthy fruits from there. Similarly, bottom and middle part of this hierarchy will act as their master do. That's Why theses such sectors are losers in their work. Privatization not only gives the punctuality, niche of time of work, but also better results in economic growth and development of country. But again for this top order (govt) must be strict in rules, administration and ruling in parliament.
Rate this: +0 -2

Niladri Saha said: (Fri, Apr 12, 2013 12:32:27 PM)

Hi, friends I am Niladri I would like to add some points regarding this topic. To me public sector should be remained as in its position but to avert less corruption and speedier working results they should follow the strict rules imposed by the private sectors towards their employees. For example:- the delivery of voter cards, ration cards the public sector employees don't have any responsibilities. They just jot down the people's description and without checking it give it away to the people where there are some big mistakes take place which is sometimes irreparable. But if the policies of private sectors are implemented on this slow and irresponsible public sectors then less risk, less errors may occur. Thank you.
Rate this: +1 -0

Leo Vatsa said: (Tue, Apr 9, 2013 11:12:01 PM)

Hi Everyone, I just want to share my recent incident, The Guy who is come for taking unit reading for electricity meter has advance the reading upto 2000 from the meter, and according to them I have to pay Rs-10, 000. While I paid my elec. Bill in advance & I have to pay only for 40 units, I went to electricity office several times but they people always denied to process my request, and they asked me to give him 4000 buks to make them correct. After roaming 4 months they did not update my correct bill & disconnect my connection. I spend 2 weeks without electricity in my home. And on every day I went to office but they always said bring this & bring that. Means I can not do anything and ultimately I have to spend 2000 bucks to restore my connection. So my opinion is PUBLIC sector should be PRIVATE. That is more helpful for common man (MANGO PEOPLE).
Rate this: +3 -7

Neeraj Bhatt said: (Fri, Apr 5, 2013 11:43:12 AM)

Hello Dears, I think before we discuss on "should government sectors be privatized or not?", we should understand the difference between Private Sector and Government Sector. In Private sector on rule follows 'More work More money' whereas in Government sector 'Less Work Less Money'. For example an accountant of private company getting salary 40 thousand or may be more whereas in the other side an accountant of government office, getting salary 15 to 17 thousand which is almost 1/3 of what a private accountant getting. Therefore, the question raise, can our government afford the demand of private employees. The other main thing is the lower education system in government schools, which indirectly but strongly connects with our topic. As we all know the lower teaching standard of Government schools, many students of government schools can't compete with students of private schools. So there will less possibilities for government schools' student to get job if government converts the public sectors into private sector. Government should uplift the teaching quality in government schools. Thanks.
Rate this: +16 -5

Sandeep said: (Sun, Mar 31, 2013 02:31:15 PM)

Hello everyone. I'm sandeep. I think privatization of public sector is definitely the need of the day as public sector is seeming to be working at very slow rate. You can take an example of AADHAR CARD issue. It's nearly taking a year for the delivery. Making public sector privatized will definitely increase the speed of the work and its strict rules will help us to avoid corruption as well. Also following modern lifestyle will definitely help in development of our country as well.
Rate this: +17 -4

Nitesh Shukla said: (Tue, Mar 26, 2013 08:56:41 AM)

Hi I think privatization of public sector should not be good for over all because in private sector, the had of department only view the creamed people who is responsible for the growth of department but in public sector they also work for poor people to perform which is good for our overall growth because we should work in unity not individual.
Rate this: +13 -2

Arihant Jain said: (Thu, Mar 21, 2013 11:58:00 PM)

Hi friends, I do not agree with the view that public sector should be privatized. Private companies just looks for the profit and once given the complete chance to rule over our country, things are then going to change completely and only rich people will live life and the rest of the people are going to suffer because private will change the scenario. I agree that private sector can provide better services but they are going to charge extravagant money on all these services which even a middle class person can't afford then what about the poor people. Where they will go.
Rate this: +27 -5

Gourav Singla said: (Mon, Mar 18, 2013 11:17:08 PM)

The question is why public sector became a so called 'Public Sector'. It is because of corruption and unwillingness to do work quickly. Both above things come from lack of management and administration over employees. Unlike Private sector, public sector employee does not have fear of lose job, even of bad performance, once he gets appointed. That makes him relax and lazy. Like private sector, if public sector employee gets scared about losing of job due to lack of performance then he will start performing in a better way. Disadvantages: 1) In my view private sector services are much costlier than that of public sector and 80% of Indian population cannot afford it. 2) Private sector does not guarantee in the transparency of job for all caste of population. Generally poor population does not able to even apply for it. 3) Another aspect is low pay scale. As India has more unemployment percentage, it could be possible that the Private sector start giving low wages to some of the employees and employee will compel to work in drastic situation also.
Rate this: +10 -3

Sahil Singh said: (Fri, Feb 22, 2013 09:30:13 PM)

It may happen we feel that the privatization of the public sector in the prevailing scenario of cut throat competition may lift the standard of Public sector, but the consequences may be different as the globalization may lead to distract the righteous person to be in the same capacity. The privatization empowers the potential of the work man but in parallel make the selfish in idea to pertain him or herself till the success story is according to his her doing, the moment the dissatisfaction arises the person quits without making a judicious decision about the firm serving with bread and butter earlier. The values in the world of privatization are missing and in fact degrading and deteriorating. Remember the world can only exist when the values are standing with a sound status.
Rate this: +20 -5

Prateek Jain said: (Tue, Feb 5, 2013 05:26:33 AM)

Hi Every One, Privatization of the Public sector has the benefits and limitations too. If we do the privatization of the public sector than this will create the burden on the common people because the government has only one way of income which is tax to meet its needs. And the private company does not guarantee us that they will not create the huge amount of tax on the common people. Now we come on the benefits, the privatization of public sector will also avoid corruption too. Because in a private company all works are organised and done under the chief of that company and he will not tolerate the mistake in any type of calculation for the company purpose.
Rate this: +59 -11

Bagavathi N said: (Wed, Jan 30, 2013 09:13:32 PM)

Friends in my mind think privatization of public sectors is good for all because its scheme make in value all of them work in company and innovative can use this scheme to introduce the own idea to progress and make job all graduate now a day in private much improved so one company to come lot of company privation shows one man quality like anil ampany and vijay mallaya.
Rate this: +8 -26

Rubin Qureshi said: (Mon, Jan 21, 2013 10:07:06 PM)

Hi everybody. According to me privatization of the whole public sector will neither benefit our economy nor citizens because then government will have only tax as its main source of income and to meet fiscal deficit it will impose highest level of taxes on people. So again it will negatively affect common man.
Rate this: +29 -4

Rakesh said: (Wed, Jan 16, 2013 05:37:43 PM)

Public sector should not be privatized. Because if any person want to work with government then what he will do if public sector converted into private. As compared to private public sector jobs are more convenient and easy and also permanent in public sector people get befitted like pf, pension, gratuities etc.
Rate this: +13 -39

Ankit Negi said: (Mon, Jan 7, 2013 08:10:25 PM)

Hello friends, I am ankit and I do not support the privatization of public sector. As public sector is the backbone of our social and economic welfare. Social welfare in terms that, public sector is providing cheap education to the poor children through government schools and government colleges and if education is privatized, it becomes costlier resulting out of reach to the poor children. Also, for an employee, doing a job in public sector is more secure and provides more social and economic upliftment. Corruption in public sector can be reduced by enforcing strict rules, and there is no need to change the whole public sector company to the private sector just for reducing corruption. And it is also not guaranteed that the conversion of public sector to private sector will reduce the corruption because the employee will remain same which are before privatization. Instead we should look forward to make our public sector more productive, more efficient and more corruption free rather than throwing them in hands of business people whose only aim is to get profit and only profit without thinking about the welfare of society and individual well being.
Rate this: +280 -7

Harsh said: (Fri, Jan 4, 2013 07:54:42 PM)

According to me, public sector should not be privatized but we should focus on the joint effort of both sectors. Privatization depends on the sector. For example, education has to be in public sector and government should take steps to make education of government institutes and school as good as private, this will ultimately lead to quality education at affordable price. In other sector like road construction, the join effort of public and private sector will be very useful. As this joint effort provide quality of private sector and at low cost of public sector.
Rate this: +30 -3

Twinkle said: (Fri, Dec 21, 2012 08:47:12 PM)

Definitely public sector is so lazy to be expressed beyond words, I will specially take up the posatal serives where very often speed posts are missed. My two very important documents were missed which landed me in a great trouble and tension my checque I got after one year my bros form reached very late. How disgusting is the public sector. Eating country.
Rate this: +12 -40

Sam said: (Mon, Dec 3, 2012 06:41:45 PM)

Hello friends the topic is pretty quite good. I had some perspective and points on about the topic both for against and support. AGAINST: According to my point of view the public sector should not be privatized for following reason. I agree that public sector yields lower output as compared to private sector but what I think is that government emphasizes more on about human and social welfare as well whereas this scenario is not similar in case of privatized sector as their ultimate aim is to yield more and more profit they primarily focus on increasing the marginal rate so as to yield maximum profit. They had no time for thinking about the human welfare. So instead of converting the public sector to privatized sector we could adopt the strategies policy rules which the private sector follows for increasing the efficiency. If public sector got privatized then rich person will become more richer and richer and the poor ones will come on the road. SUPPORT: Yes the public sector must be transformed into the private sector on account of the following consideration. The public sector doesn't not having stringent policy and laws etc which ultimately leads to the corruption 2g case scam is an example for this. The employee are irresponsible and their ultimate motto is just to have their salaries eventually and they are devoid of motivational factors as well there doesn't exist strong relationship and bonding between the employee which ultimately seizes their interest towards their works. Whereas when it comes to private sector they are manifested with stringent policy rules which are to be followed and if the employee doesn't give their best there maybe chances of getting fired. So taking all this into the consideration its necessary that public sector must be privatized.
Rate this: +92 -3

Gowrisankar said: (Sat, Dec 1, 2012 11:49:11 AM)

According to me public sector is meant by a organization in the hands of a government. We see a scam as 3G spectrum scam by some politicians to leading mobile operators lead to a loss in amount of government and where does that money come from?from us. I am not opposing privatization but if government wishes a certain public sector to be privatized then it should take care about the happenings. Making a psu privatized leads to the a speedy completion of the tasks as it will be handed to a well expert professionals such as shamsabad airport in Hyderabad done by GMR infrastructure with in a very short span with quality.
Rate this: +6 -5

Bharat said: (Wed, Nov 21, 2012 08:23:38 PM)

Yes public sector should be privatize because the main thing will happen that cut the reservation that will help new deserved talent who make country developed and also time cutting is there.
Rate this: +37 -18

Raza said: (Wed, Nov 21, 2012 05:17:13 PM)

Hi, Privatizing of the public sector is not as good as the using of the privatization format and method in to the public sector, i.e. instead of privatizing the public sector if we use that formula which private sectors are using for their excellent performance, durability and time reducing processes, using that concept we can experience the same benefit in the public sectors also. If privatization every where will be a tough decision for the middle class families. We can not privatize our defense system, private companies will do well but they won't work for country they will work for money. By improving our public sectors performance we can improve the countries economy also.
Rate this: +39 -3

Mohit said: (Mon, Nov 19, 2012 10:29:26 PM)

I think public sector can be privatized because the speed of work will move to fast. 24 *7 work can only possible in private sector as we better know all the development sheets in both govt and private sector. In early days private sector is costly but after some time when they got a good profit they can cut their cost to minimum cost.
Rate this: +10 -5

Deepankar Kukreja said: (Sun, Nov 4, 2012 06:21:03 PM)

I think there is no need to privatized the public sector instead on focus for privatization please focus on improving the performance of public sector if the public sector is privatized than there is no importance for government in peoples mind so government don't privatized the public sector.
Rate this: +26 -5

Jishnu said: (Fri, Nov 2, 2012 02:40:50 PM)

The biggest boon in privatization is "kick out" of reservation. In our country where the general quota people are fighting over a few places, the reserved people are having to break no sweat to have a job. Private sectors are a blessing in disguise for the unemployed general status people. Where your is purely base on merit and not from where you came from. Its a launchpad for a person's career. There is this corruption and politics in a government sector which is not seen in private companies, except for the smaller ones. It is the only way to improve our society. Yes, the financially backward people may find it difficult to come terms to the huge application fees, but that can be sorted off. Privatization do indeed create a level field.
Rate this: +68 -11

Sandeep said: (Wed, Oct 31, 2012 04:32:18 PM)

As per my knowledge privatization is good for fast growing economy but some point to be considered before the decision taken for privatization every public sector can't be privatized due to some securities reasons like our defense sector and internal security of our Indian territory and other sensitive zone can not be handed over to private company which are more conscious for more profit.
Rate this: +19 -3

Jegan said: (Thu, Oct 25, 2012 10:27:50 AM)

In my point of view public sector should be privatized. Because in public sector everywhere only corruption only takes place. There is no fear at all to the public servants. So totally irresponsible people only work in public department. So in private sector people may fear to their authorities and more responsible for his job. So for public sector at the end of the month they get their salary only. I am not to privatize all sectors some of them only. So I finally conclude that there is a change in public sector or we simply change the private sector.
Rate this: +12 -20

Shubham Mittal said: (Tue, Oct 16, 2012 11:25:39 PM)

Guys as far as I thought as if. If you want the building and upkeep of public infrastructure to be in the hands of private interests consider the following:. 1) It'll be more expensive than if it was publicly done.(For profit enterprise). 2) Lots of information about upkeep and infrastructure will not be available to public scrutiny. (Non-democratic). 3) Access to private facilities can be restricted. So think about roads. If a private company builds roads, they could require that people who use their roads have special tags, or pay tolls to use it. Failure to do so would mean restriction of access. Also, how would road construction be paid for? How would you know how much of that money is being wasted? How much would be necessary? Who would benefit from the creation of new roads, and who would pay the price for lack of access? The government should take care of infrastructural needs because costs can be kept down, and building and maintenance is kept in public hands, and therefore democratic in nature. Take the same scenario for any public service. How would schools be effected by privatization? How would poor people be able to afford a decent education? How would standards be made? Would certain kinds of information be censored or distorted in a private school? (Say like the theory of evolution. ". Isn't it. !
Rate this: +45 -5

Mona said: (Tue, Oct 16, 2012 02:58:08 PM)

The public sector, sometimes referred to as the state sector or the government sector, is a part of the state that deals with either the production, ownership, sale, provision, delivery and allocation of goods and services by and for the government or its citizens, whether national, regional or local/municipal. Examples of public sector activity range from delivering social security, administering urban planning and organizing national defense. The organization of the public sector (public ownership) can take several forms, including:. • Direct administration funded through taxation; the delivering organization generally has no specific requirement to meet commercial success criteria, and production decisions are determined by government. • Publicly owned corporations (in some contexts, especially manufacturing, "state-owned enterprises") ; which differ from direct administration in that they have greater commercial freedoms and are expected to operate according to commercial criteria, and production decisions are not generally taken by government (although goals may be set for them by government). • Partial outsourcing (of the scale many businesses do, e. G. For IT services) , is considered a public sector model.
Rate this: +20 -6

Vivek said: (Sun, Oct 14, 2012 02:23:03 AM)

In my point of view, all the public sector should not be privatize but sectors like Delivery they are not able to revive due to high competition from private and they are not generating the enough revenue so they should be privatized. When we talk about hospitality in rural area's it is pathetic so it should be privatized.
Rate this: +8 -6

Amruta said: (Sat, Oct 13, 2012 02:27:15 PM)

According to my view all the public sector should not be privatized because in some area such as electricity,industrialization we require a quality but in area such as hospitalization,gas cylinder we want service at low cost,which only public sector can provide us.
Rate this: +18 -4

Sucheta Sharma said: (Fri, Oct 5, 2012 03:26:52 PM)

Hi friends. According to my opinion, That all public sector should not be privatized. We have to focus on some areas not an overall like as (railway, power supply, education system) If these sectors should be privatized they know the value of money and time, they energy as they required, they should be punctual and they have chance to get education like as foreigners. By this in future we can compete with our competitors.
Rate this: +28 -5

Vignesh said: (Thu, Oct 4, 2012 09:49:34 PM)

Public sector should be privatized only in some department. I am happy to say that regarding service department private sector is more good than public sector for ex tcs have taken passport seva really awesome and wonderful I am ready to encourage this process. But some confidential issues like granite, gold mining, coal mining in these area it should strictly under the control the control of government.
Rate this: +13 -4

Deep said: (Wed, Oct 3, 2012 04:57:21 PM)

From my point of view, in every field there should be equal participation of both private sector and public sector. For example in Education system, everyone cannot afford the fees of the private schools and colleges. Only children of the rich person can take admission in private schools. Because education is need for everyone ant it is the main part for any developing country, so everyone has right to study. Only government schools fulfills their need. But government schools should change their method of teaching. Means there is no need to change the public sector into private sector there should be change in their patterns and methods of their work.
Rate this: +110 -7

Anks said: (Sun, Sep 30, 2012 11:56:29 AM)

Friends I think that only in some part of the government needs to b privatized like in railway, bus as these leads to the competitive in this field which gives us good service. But on the national level like in defense should be under govt control as if this will b given to pvt sector can b lead to very big problem. Also we can see from the current scenario of communication that due to competition between govt and pvt sector we are getting good service at low cost.
Rate this: +14 -1

Manu said: (Sat, Sep 29, 2012 10:56:54 PM)

Well. According to me what is most important rather than discussing on privatization is to change mindset of people. The company culture provided in private companies aught to give the employees a sense of responsibility. Which is definitely lacking in public sector. If a public sector company is privatized and people working are still lethargic in there job. I bet even private sector will fall short! So if privatization is ready to turn mindsets of employees then it surely be welcomed. Or else some strict and immediate and compulsive efforts by Government will serve the purpose. Though not taken yet! Lets hope for the best!
Rate this: +11 -2

A D S said: (Fri, Sep 21, 2012 10:21:04 PM)

According to me privatization is needed partially with if possible, co-existence. Sectors such as agriculture, retail business or road transport should be free of government control. There is no need for the govt. To run bus services or its own retail shops. Complete privatization in these sectors will bring real development to this sectors and this help them to flourish in all ways. Privatization leads to better quality service and infrastructure while the competition between the competitors will help to get better product at low price. Also, the govt. Will be released off from the unnecessary burden and focus more on its real work. But sectors of national and strategic importance has to be kept always under govt. Control as the private players always has a tendency to exploit the needies and its the govt's duty to protect them. Sectors like Railways-Lifeline in India or the Arms and ammunition industry can't be privatized as the are too vital for the country to leave in private hands. In some sectors, the co-existence is the best option. For example, in the Power sector, govt. Must have its hand so that it can provide power to those people who really needs it at a really reasonable price. But there must be private players also to develop better infrastructure and bring the newest technology in the power sector. The consumers should have an option to choose between the two. Similarly, in health sector also govt. Has to provide healthcare for the common people, whereas the rich can always opt for better healthcare or private healthcare in expense of money from the private facilities.
Rate this: +31 -7

Wannabe Mba Graduate said: (Thu, Sep 20, 2012 10:53:30 AM)

Hi Friends;. I feel that public sector must definitely be privatized. Lack of progress in India can chiefly be attributed to the sense of complacency that the public sector possess. Government employees neglect to do their jobs as they are safely cocooned in their own world, with a fixed salary, permanent jobs and pension after retirement. They expect bribes even for doing the routine work that they are supposed to do. Every one of us must have experienced this at some point of time. When we apply for a license, a bribe is expected, when we try to get permission to build an apartment, a bribe is expected. Where is this going to end? We are caught in tug of war between political parties trying to out do each other by promising to do many things once they come into power, but finally not living up to their claims. Once the public sector is privatized, job opportunities will increase, the quality of work and life will be made better and every individual will work to the best of his capability. Rural areas will also get urbanized and benefit in the process.
Rate this: +9 -6

Siva said: (Sat, Sep 8, 2012 09:56:19 PM)

Hai friends. I have another view. Privatisation of public sectors creates good effects. It makes people to be punctual, fast & competitive worker, creates business competitions which gives results in quality. Every man have to think the job as god. Today how many public sector workers are thinking like that. So privatisation of public sectors will make positive results.
Rate this: +18 -12

Nikssssss said: (Mon, Sep 3, 2012 06:17:28 PM)

hello friends according to me AGAINST Statement :- public sector should not privatize because all private companies have a aim to earn money and the aim of public run on motive of servies in minimum price for an example govt hospital they give many medicien free or in less price as compare to private hospital here we can give one more example of indian railways the tickets are cheeper in price soo public sectors should not privatize according to me. FOR statement:- according to me private sector will help in generating more emplyeement and new technology wil be used by private counties as compare to public sectore companies .it wil help in removing corruption from country. with private sector it help in improving services
Rate this: +27 -8

Nikhil said: (Thu, Aug 30, 2012 03:39:44 PM)

Hi folks, In my opinion it must be privatized because than only the dream of living in the sanghai or newyork will be happen as our politicians promise we will do this ,that and make mumbai the next sanghai with in 10 yrs and so....this all is not possible because without privatization flow of funds will not take place properly and more importantly the youth will not be attracted towards these sectors which seems a bore to youngsters because of no proper HR practices (it will take a person 10-15 yrs to get promoted),no proper motivation and financial perks nothing ...in sanghai more than 60% people work for these municipal bodies which were privatized ,unlike INDIA where a small signature of a politician brings 6 lane highways,while in US UK a group of highly educated people sit together and discuss the pros & cons of any project and decide the best possible option.
Rate this: +7 -5

Siva said: (Sun, Aug 26, 2012 06:41:13 PM)

Hi friends, I am Siva, on my opinion public sector should not be privatized because public sector is able to serve the common people in the undeveloped rural areas in the same way people trust only public sector in these days. Private sector unable to serve as like as public sector.
Rate this: +10 -6

Vineet Kumar said: (Sat, Aug 25, 2012 09:29:28 PM)

Hi friends. My name is Vineet Kumar. According to me, public sector should not be privatized. As it is well known there is a capitalistic approach in private sectors and they believe in money and money. Privatization only concentrates on capital formation. And it creates a major gap between top class families and lower class families, and a poor being dumped to more severe condition of poverty and starvation. Apart from this, if we take example of our country, we are democratic and there is socialistic approach in our country and in our society i.e. government and public sector think for each section of society and provide facilities what being required. As there are so many schemes for below poverty line people and for all. If there will be privatization. It is obvious that there will be economic growth i.e. GDP growth will be more but there won't be development because society develops only when there is equal opportunity for all and all participates equally in country's development. At last what I conclude that is there should not be privatization in public sector. Thanks to all.
Rate this: +52 -4

John said: (Sat, Aug 25, 2012 07:14:12 PM)

I personally feel that govt sector should be privatized because there would be more transparency in the system. As we can relate to one instance that our telecom minister Mr Raja enjoyed the benefit of working in public sector because if he would have been in any private sector his actions would have been scrutinized much earlier and moreover we would have been thrown out for his works which didn't happened just because he was in public sector. Many such instances I personally experienced also.
Rate this: +11 -2

Mitali said: (Fri, Aug 24, 2012 01:04:55 AM)

In my opinion both public sector and private sector have their own advantages and drawbacks:. Advantages of public sector are:. 1. Regulated by government authorities therefore more reliable. 2. Has huge access to the people of India even in the rural areas also. 3. Works not only for profit making. Drawbacks:. 1. Employees working in public sector sometimes become lazy since they get fixed amount of salary (i. E. Their salary don't depends on targets they achieved). 2. In some public sector technology up-gradation and good working conditions are not properly being in practiced. 3. Along with technical skill, training related to soft skills like customer- relationship, behavior skill should also be provided. And in case of private sector they have overcome the drawbacks of those of public sector but it is true to some extent that they are profit oriented. If they can come up with the solution of this drawback, privatization of public sector may be a good option.
Rate this: +36 -3

Sange said: (Thu, Aug 23, 2012 06:58:48 AM)

If I want to answer I will say I can't. A sector is in public hand the resources are not fully utilized and the lack of funds and infrastructure problem. Most are running at lose. But they are working for the public interest to help the needy and poor at low tariff. Also in private sector the quality is improved and the efficiency service are all improved. But the problem is they are running for profits. They don't bother about public interest. There are problem in both public and private sector. So, I would be in the favor of "Public- private partnership". The govt will favor for public interest. The private fill favor for Efficiency and profit. So, they both compliment each other.
Rate this: +10 -1

Wizard said: (Tue, Aug 21, 2012 07:19:51 PM)

The public sector should definitely be privatized for it to perform actively & efficiently. In my opinion it is the best option to curb the losses of the public sector. Pulic sector incurs such heavy expenses to render the services which can be provided by private sector at lower cost. The reason being lack of initiative & some individual or group's capital not at stake. Unfair practises like bureaucracy & red tapism comes into play which too hamper their working. There is a lot of cost incurred in the selection of the employees & their lack accountability to get the jobdone is yet another reason. Slow & long procedures in decision making put them behind their competitors, thus taking the jist of an early start. To conclude privatisation is an apt solution if a private firm is ready to take the initiative or where it it can be done with semi privatisation.
Rate this: +3 -4

Gopal Arjun Nandankar said: (Tue, Aug 21, 2012 08:34:39 AM)

In my opinion public sectors should not be privatized keeping in mind the present scenario wherein majority of the population in India belongs to rural area. Private sectors won't pay much attention to the development of these areas. Hence it will lead to socio-economic problems in these areas. It will increase the gap between poor and rich. On the contrary public sectors should be strictly scrutinized with the help of tools like RTI Act. Public sectors are answerable to the common people and as we can see due to awakening of common man many scams are being exposed. If public sectors are properly regulated it will definitely help to bring down socio-economic hindrances like corruption.
Rate this: +8 -2

Priyadarshan said: (Mon, Aug 20, 2012 01:14:35 AM)

Hi All, It's a serious concern and hence i am also trying to contribute my views here. Public Sectors are in comfort zone and hence they either under perform or face loss. Government Organizations have sufficient funds and surplus to invest for future growth which are somehow misused. The one and only biggest problem in the Govt. Organizations is the "MISMANAGEMENT". The private companies earn profits only because of proper management of the available resources, whether it be financial resource or human resource. IF growth and profitability is the root concern then the best solution is that 49% share should be privatized and 51% share should be in Government's control.By the efficient and effective management practices only the Public Sector Companies would show remarkable performance.
Rate this: +4 -5

Pankaj said: (Thu, Aug 9, 2012 09:35:58 AM)

Private sectors in India are not growing. 90 to 95 percent employees of private sector have no work to do after 15 to 20 years of service. That is roughly 35 to 40 / 45 years of age. They switch to self employment after that but self employment does not fetch them guaranteed standard of living. Government organisations are better. They provide job security and steady life until 60 years. Don't make the mistake of leaving government service and joining private sector. Even if you did so, do it only for taking a break. That is, spend a few years in private sector preferably abroad, get a decent bank balance, and then move back to government sector. Government sectors will not close down. Every country needs Government servants.
Rate this: +11 -15

Neha Salve said: (Wed, Aug 8, 2012 04:27:44 PM)

In my opinion public sectors should not be privatized keeping in mind the present scenario wherein majority of the population in India belongs to rural area. Private sectors won't pay much attention to the development of these areas. Hence it will lead to socio-economic problems in these areas. It will increase the gap between poor and rich. On the contrary public sectors should be strictly scrutinized with the help of tools like RTI Act. Public sectors are answerable to the common people and as we can see due to awakening of common man many scams are being exposed. If public sectors are properly regulated it will definitely help to bring down socio-economic hindrances like corruption.
Rate this: +19 -1

Arna said: (Tue, Aug 7, 2012 01:16:58 AM)

Hi friends. I an not against the private sector, because for growth of a country private sector contributes a major portion. Some private sector also looks into the social development besides their profit. Also in private sector resources are fully utilized which also helps the country. So privatized is needed. But few sector which should not be privatized like-health, education, rail, defense as those are not for profit. The main object is to serve the nation. Looking the hole thing I want to say privatized is needed but not all the section to develop the nation.
Rate this: +65 -2

Yashwant Kumawat said: (Tue, Jul 31, 2012 10:32:58 AM)

I am always in the favour of getting the public sector converted into private sector as far as privatization is concerned. If public sector gets privatized then over all growth of the entire country will be emphasized. Its been observed that LPG (liberalization, privatization, globalization) is been taken under course of action by Indian government since 1991. And eventually India has got an influencing change in its economic growth. Growth in terms of : 1. More employment. 2. Better productivity. 3. Enhancement of professionalization. 4. Excitement to get on to the platform where we can learn a lot. 5. NO WASTAGE OF ALL RESOURCES AND BETTER EFFICIENCY. Don't feel bad. But it is my opinion that country is running because of private sector. Not because of govt sector. Because government sector is totally corrupted. Thanks a lot.
Rate this: +31 -30

Hans Raj said: (Sun, Jul 29, 2012 10:27:38 PM)

Hello friends. In my opinion, change is always better. Everything has its merits and demerits too. Some employees in public sector are not performing their duties honestly. If some of the public sectors are partly privatized, there will be definitely improvement in those departments.
Rate this: +7 -9

Amit Rathore said: (Sun, Jul 29, 2012 12:51:08 PM)

As per the my opinion, there is no requirement for privatization in India. Because the government segment is the only segment which thinks for the public welfare otherwise in today's scenario nobody has the time & money to spend for the welfare. Instead of that, government Always try to do the work only for the nation's welfare. Although there are some management oriented problems with the government Sector but it can sort out by the proper management rather than to shift government Sector into private sector.
Rate this: +33 -3

Sudipta Ghosh said: (Sat, Jul 28, 2012 02:29:25 PM)

I think privatization could be really useful to the society. Public sectors are almost run by the taxes that the public pays. So their has to be for the welfare of the public. We are not paying any kind of tax to the private companies in order to develop the country. So they are less interested about public welfare, and look into there profits. But there are companies like TATA, Vedanta etc who spend for public welfare from there company income. So some public sectors can be privatized taking care that the company being handed over with he public organization do not think only of their own profit. Private sectors are also far more systematic than the public sectors. When those private sectors are in loss they should be financially supported by government for the public org being privatized so that the public company don't recovers the loss putting a burden on the public by rising the price of services.
Rate this: +2 -10

Subbu said: (Wed, Jul 25, 2012 03:54:01 PM)

And according to my view the public sector should not be privatized as if it is done it would have many bad effects. As in today there are 9 main sectors which are completely under government i.e.railways, defense atomic energy, and if these are privatized it would have a huge effect like. 1. Firstly these are the sectors which requires huge investment which is not possible for the private owners. 2. Secondly the serve the society without concentrating on there private profit motive which will be against the principle of privatization. 3. Moreover these sectors are too crucial that if are privatized it may lead to mismanagement which would effect the society mainly in the case of defense and atomic. 4. If these are privatized then the private owners would exploit the public in best possible manner for there own profit. The only benefit from privatization will be that, that the management will be good. The solution which I think no need to change public sector into private sector.
Rate this: +45 -7

Nipul said: (Mon, Jul 23, 2012 04:36:55 PM)

Hi Friends, Indian economic system is a mixed economy system. So, both private and public sector have role in economic system. But there are some sectors of Indian economy which should not privatized. Like health, education, army & police, railway, road which are related with public interest and welfare. Otherwise private sector becomes monopoly in all sector. In private sector resources are fully utilized. Proper utilization of resources helps to develop the country. In public sector there some managerial faults and negligence mind due to public interest. If public sector incur lost that level person thought that it is not his personal lost. But there are some public sector like OIL, ONGC etc. Are gain day to day. My conclusion is that both private and public sector are necessary for the country.
Rate this: +24 -1

Kangkan Roy said: (Sun, Jul 22, 2012 01:19:36 AM)

Hi friends, I am not totally against the 'privatization of public sector' rather I would like to say some public sector which is directly related to the basic need of people & their life i.e.- education, food, health, railway (transportation) , army/police (security) etc. Should not be privatized as private sector will only bother to their benefit, they do not sacrifice for any issue. On the other hand its also true that our so called public sectors performs in a slower process than private as there is a lag of competitive weather. The utilization of human resource is much better in private sector. So for better growth, development of country some public sectors should be privatized.
Rate this: +34 -1

Hitesh said: (Thu, Jul 19, 2012 06:21:58 PM)

Hi friends, Firstly I want to clear that public sector is to make and public sector is to serve. Some or the other way we have to scarify things. If we go for privatization some where we see monopoly under private regime on the other hand public sector leads to corruption. It doesn't mean both of them are voracious, it means if they are together they keep an eye over one another, hence we need a system which concerns both public and private sectors. That's the only thing which will give result. At last, We all know the power of democracy being a citizen of Indian country. We have transference media, through which can know each and every information regarding our nation. It doesn't mean that private sectors are not doing well for our society. We can see TATA, Reliance who are increasing our nation's GDP like anything.
Rate this: +11 -5

Rajnikant Sethiya said: (Thu, Jul 19, 2012 02:44:56 PM)

Hi friends, here we discussed about the "public sector should be privatized or not" and as they all discussed in there own point of view I want to put some points in the respect of all the point. 1. Let us take an example of the satyam group which is an private organization and we know that CEO of the company thinks only about the company's profit not for the public. 2. If the Indian railway should privatized then the rate of the tickets are raised by a huge % of the previous. 3. I am living in indore and if all sectors which are here get privatized then 98% population can't afford the private sector. And by these opinion I want to said that 'public sector should not be privatized'.
Rate this: +15 -5

Sandeep Rao Ghadge said: (Wed, Jul 18, 2012 08:25:28 PM)

Hello friend. I'm fully agree this point that ''public sector should be privatized'' because you can see in any public sector like. Bank's-hospital's-school's and many sector. In this sector a government employee don't work with honesty, he\she don't serious with our work & other hand in private sector every employee know that what's their work & they do our work with full enthusiastic and honesty and in private sector a customer always satisfied with their service.
Rate this: +6 -10

Sonika Bhatnagar said: (Sat, Jul 14, 2012 10:23:13 PM)

Hello friends, In my opinion I am totally against of making public sectors as private due to following reasons: 1. Privatization mainly focuses on its own benefits and profits. It doesn't aim at the development of the whole nation. 2. Private companies make the employees do a lot of work. On the other hand poor will not be benefited from privatization. 3. We can take the example of private companies like HCL WIPRO ACCENTURE and many more they only focus on their own development, they are not concerned about public profit. 4. Moreover, as public sectors are concerned about the welfare of nation and its progress. Normal people and middle class people can easily avail the expenditure of their family. So these points are the basic facts which should be kept in mind and public sectors should not be privatized.
Rate this: +26 -6

Jabar Singh Mahor said: (Sat, Jul 14, 2012 06:09:33 AM)

Hi friends, in my opinion every things has two aspect one is good and other is bad. If we improve rules and principles of the public system that should be equal for poor as well as rich people of the society. By doing so no need to privatization of public sector and it become efficient as compare to private, work fast and batter way than private sector did.
Rate this: +5 -4

M.Azhagu said: (Thu, Jul 12, 2012 01:26:33 PM)

According to me also public sector should not be privatized. I think that when the control goes to the hand of private sector it will help only in the improvement of rich people and it will not help poor people i.e. rich people get richer and poor people get poorer. Nothing can be perfect so I think that only under the control of public sector more people get benefited comparatively.
Rate this: +15 -6

Dhaval said: (Tue, Jul 10, 2012 10:47:31 AM)

Hi friends, According to my opinion public sector should not be privatized. There are certain points which justify this. 1) Poor will not be benefited by private sector as compared to public sector. 2) If privatization made then this will lead to rise in prices as private companies are only interested in earning profits. 3) Private companies make exploitation of employees & also not granted more leave in case of any emergency. 4) As it imported machinery from abroad it will employ only foreigners as they know more about this machinery then Indian people. So, it will lead to unemployment in our country. So, I firmly believes that in-spite of doing privatization we should try to find solution to make public sector more efficient.
Rate this: +25 -5

Somase M said: (Tue, Jul 3, 2012 10:12:31 PM)

Good evening gentleman, I think if we want to see our nation shine through over the world and fully employed youth, then it may be in need to convert some public sectors in to private sector. I don't say that all public sectors to convert but some are must in need, like electricity, postal etc. There having some reason to say these things, for example if you go to the state bank of India and ask some one to help then no one will response to you in other way if you go to axis bank there you will feel much better than sbi, because sbi employees knows that they have fixed job and there has no one to compete them. There are many more reasons are there like this. In our nation the corruption word has going to completely attached with public sector. And no single scam and corruption come to view in private sector. That's why some public sector convert's in to private sector it will goes to some better result to shine our nation. Thank you.
Rate this: +17 -10

Vinoth said: (Mon, Jul 2, 2012 11:36:02 AM)

Hello friends, this is Vinoth from Chennai. According to my point of view the public sectors should not be privatized. Because if it is done then it restled into huge bad effects and few good effects. First of all I would say some bad effects. 1. Public sectors only to manage highly economic organizations like railways, oil corporations, postal departments, etc. If it would be in private hands then They not provide that high cost. 2. The private sectors only motivating the profit policies. So it could be resulted in hike in price. 3. Public sectors will give subsidies to poor peoples for managed the hike of price. But privates would not give. These are the bad effects on my point of view. Good effects are few only. 1. Corruption is stopped. 2. Talented employees only working in this organizations. I would think these are the good. I would conclude with public sectors should privatized if the good effects of not privatized are reformed.
Rate this: +29 -8

Rano said: (Sat, Jun 30, 2012 05:12:56 PM)

Hi friends, I would like to share my mind on this topic. In my opinion if privatization of public sectors would have both good and bad effects. First of all lets consider the good effects: 1. Corruption can be stopped which is showing its ugly face in public sector companies. 2. People will also start working efficiently as they will have the fear of losing the job. 3. Private sector companies also don't give lift to sycophants. 4. It will give place to real talent. But it will not solve the problems entirely. Now coming to bad effects: 1. The facilities which the poor are getting from government will stop. They won't be able to get benefits from the private sectors. 2. Also it would increase unemployment among the young mass. It will increase poverty in the country. 3. Also the private will start exploiting the young mass. They will get more work done by the people by giving them low income. 4. Also attention will not be given to the rural people. Thus in my opinion public sectors shouldn't be completely privatized as public sectors improve the Indian economy. In fact there should be joint collaboration between the public sectors and private sectors. Thank you.
Rate this: +21 -3

Punit said: (Fri, Jun 29, 2012 10:06:18 PM)

The Main Disadvantage of completely privatizing the public sector companies will lead us to destabilization of economy when it comes to world wide recession. But with Government as regulating authority will help us to take effective steps, in those circumstances (for ex: as well managed by Reserve Bank of India). As the prime motto of Private companies is to earn profits, this will lead to Capitalism and economic disparity in the society. This will lead to the exploitation of the poor section of the society. With Privatization, Market would become highly fluctuating, this will result in very low FDI. Hence at-last I would like to conclude that Public Private Partnership would lead to best results with extracting out advantages of bot.
Rate this: +11 -2

Aruna said: (Mon, Jun 18, 2012 09:17:47 AM)

In our current world energy one think that we have to get job in government sectors and provide security to their life, but many people don't want to survive our country. Many people in the public sectors are becoming selfish and they think they don't have any need to serve to our country. Earlier days people were very responsible and faithful about their society, now a days we see very rare like that. In my view now a days private sectors are good than public sectors. I may not say that it's entirely bad, its some what good, but they don't have proper leadership and guide. In private sectors they take out the talent what they want from the people. Thank you friends for giving this opportunity to share my ideas. PROUD TO BE AN RESPONSIBLE CITIZEN.
Rate this: +23 -6

Piyush Deshmukh said: (Wed, Jun 13, 2012 11:22:33 AM)

Before we jump onto a conclusion, firstly factors forcing privatization and factors constraining public sector should be well understood and analyzed, with a view of finding a most probable justification, moreover India where majority of our population is under privileged, a public regulation is very critical, also the sector to be considered for privatization shall be sought out keeping in mind, regulation of certain price and quality domains. Therefore the matter of privatizing the public sector is a sector based consideration.
Rate this: +2 -7

Piyush Deshmukh said: (Tue, Jun 12, 2012 04:17:46 PM)

Before jumping to any rigid conclusion, firstly factors forcing privatization and factors supporting public domain should be analysed, simply privatization is not the solution, because in a country like India where majority of the population is under poverty, Public sector regulation is very critical. Moreover the problems like lack of efficiency, corruption, and other issues shall be dealt with better improvisation rather surrendering to the problems.
Rate this: +9 -1

Geetha said: (Fri, Jun 8, 2012 05:19:44 PM)

In my point of view its better to privatize the public sector because however the postings in government sectors will be in the hands of the higher authorities of that company so they will b recruiting their people, common people will not get selected in that may be in rare cases. So recruiting and maintenance should be down by private sector under the government.
Rate this: +5 -15

Sankalp said: (Tue, Jun 5, 2012 01:11:32 PM)

Well I think privatization of the public sectors should not be done because first of all it is not going to solve the present problems of laziness and carelessness of people working there & secondly it will create new problems. For example the rates of fuel LPG etc. Which poor people are getting are the subsidized rates done by government, because of having control over the prices. Now if these are being privatized, they will not going to give these benefits to poor, rather it will be more expensive since private bodies are only there to make profit, which is quite obvious. In my opinion, instead of privatization, the system of public sectors working should be make better to make a tight working condition so that they start competing with private sector.
Rate this: +59 -7

Meenakshi said: (Fri, Jun 1, 2012 06:23:02 PM)

Plus and minus points exist everywhere. In public sector the employee is not sincere in its work because of no fear. Corruption also exists more comparatively. But in private sector there is a check. Also new technologies are introduced but our government is too lazy. So in my view, privatization should be done but keeping in view that every citizen should get its benefits particularly in case of education.
Rate this: +16 -3

Donald said: (Thu, May 31, 2012 11:38:22 AM)

From my point of view public should not be privatized, because most of private companies will work for their profit and the main objective is to earn profit so difinetly there will be hike in price and there will be a great impact on comman people, but even public sectors higher authorities are the one responsibilities for corruption, the staff who work their not honest and sincere to their work and most of them are unfit for there jobs, For example RBI is public sector which controls and manage all the banks, so I can conclude like this work should be given to private and finance should be provided by public sector.
Rate this: +2 -4

Amruta said: (Wed, May 30, 2012 10:47:45 PM)

As per my opinion, public sector should not get privitised beacause, The public co. Has government cantrol. There not more loss of public money unlike private sector. Most of public are trust on public sector. The main reason is profit of public sector is invested for development of country but, in case of private sector, there profit is enjoy by there self.
Rate this: +5 -0

Akshay Midha said: (Wed, May 30, 2012 04:48:57 PM)

Well, if this a thinking that public companies should get privatize then its very hard in India. And on a second thought public companies are those company who is run by the people, so are so incapable that this need is occurring. Private company are ahead are ahead of public one but this is because the employees brood over their work understand the need to be in corporate world, where as the public one due to large number of stakeholders associated with them hampers the rate of taking decisions and the value of time gets punished and rather than saying public companies lack behind we lack behind. And corruption if are talking about I think Satyam was a private company. Yes corruption is a great slur but must come forward to eradicates its root why to blame the government always.
Rate this: +3 -8

Anand Kartik said: (Wed, May 30, 2012 10:38:18 AM)

Public sectors must be privatized because of the rampant corruption which has led to the downfall of work ethics in public sector and moreover the working environment is. Way behind 'competitive' world use old and outdated system lack of facilities for the employs what defines the public sectors today.
Rate this: +5 -3

Priti said: (Tue, May 29, 2012 02:31:13 PM)

Hello friends. In my view privatization of public sector does not possible because. Every person needs a money so middle class people cab not afford these. This demands that's why it should nor be possible.
Rate this: +2 -15

Vinay Shah said: (Tue, May 29, 2012 09:53:52 AM)

According to my point of view, the privatization of public sector not good because the main motto of private dealer to create money and just fill own pocket instead of given preference to the public convince and raise the bar of Indian standard so i"ll not in fever of doing public sector private.
Rate this: +1 -8

Vidhya said: (Thu, May 24, 2012 02:19:15 PM)

As per my view. I think public sector should not be privatized instead the work culture and environment that prevails within the private sector needs to be changed. If there is big word corruption attached with private sector the exploitation is attached with private sector. If the service provided by the service sector gets improved it will surely lead to less exploitation of common people compared to what private sector do. The whole and sole motto of private sector will always remain the same to enlarge its own pocket size.
Rate this: +2 -5

Saurabh Birthray said: (Sun, May 20, 2012 06:13:33 PM)

According to me privatization in public sector should not be done because I admit it privatization will done then the results will be far better as they are now. But I want to ask that what ever the facilities government is giving now will they will be given later also. The answer is no. Because government is lazy but it thinks for the people and specially for poor ones but a privatized company will never think this. Because its goal is to earn profit and it can't think for common people, and this privatization practice will make a rich person more rich and poor will come on road. Thank you!
Rate this: +30 -5

Jhon Abraham said: (Thu, May 17, 2012 10:57:09 AM)

In my view, public sector should be privatized. There are two reasons in supporting of my statement. One, it will increase the competition in job market and as a result better output from each individual which leads to growth in our economy. In Government sector what generally happens is that most of the individual do not work sincerely. Their only motto is to get salary at the end of the month. This happens only because they think that their job is permanent, nobody can do any harm with their job. Two, most of the individual in government sector are lazy. They are so irresponsible with their work. If privatized then the same individual will do their duty sincerely as they have always fear of losing their job. Thanking you.
Rate this: +34 -6

Phani Vardhan said: (Mon, May 14, 2012 08:34:40 AM)

The public sector should be privatized,Toady in india corruption levels are very high in india the public sector employees are with full of freedom they are not concentrated on the development of service and the development of the autherised sector. 1. The investment levels are very poor 2. They are not innovative not utilizing the creativity like japan and china 3. Corruption levels are very high 4. No proper command of chain or domination 5.political influence is very high 6. showing the deficit trade and always saying we were in looses SUGGESTIONS Very high profit public company sector units should not be privitised Very sick industries should be privitised The accounting should be perfectly done jv,s should be done
Rate this: +9 -4

Sudhishna said: (Wed, May 9, 2012 10:32:28 PM)

Hi friends. In my point of view I would like to say that the public sector should not be privatized. If the public sector is privatized the society has to face so many problems. If society is given equal importance to both the sectors. Their is no comparison between these two sectors. If the both sectors are having equal importance the society people they won't consider about the management. If management is in proper way only the society will run in an effective manner and it will good for the improvement of the society. For example here the public sector means the management or a government. If public sector is implemented any rules, conditions, and standards it will be common to all the people in the society. Where as in the private sector what they implemented it is not common to all why because means even thought their the head it not a standard and also their is chance for the misrepresentation and mainly their is no evidence for any thing. In case of public sector their will be a standards for every thing. If the management is done wrong it is based on mind set of the person intention in my point of view the management is necessary for every thing. If the public sector is privatized it will be common to the all people and their is no management if any problem rises the people want to approach the management only. Here the case is if the public sector is privatized that means the management is not necessary to the society that's wrong in my point of view so because I strongly say that management is necessary for the development and public sector should not be privatized.
Rate this: +6 -9

Shweta Kajalekar said: (Tue, May 8, 2012 12:23:44 PM)

When we look at the slow working process and plenty of scams and corruption in public sectors, its obvious to feel that they should be privatized. But privatization will not completely improve the system, rather new flaws will be introduced. Being under the thumb of government helps keeping a check on price rates so that they are affordable to common man. It will be impossible to control these rates if sector is privatized because companies will look after their benefit at the end. So instead of taking very extreme decisions, I think it is good to improve the ongoing system.
Rate this: +47 -5

Speak Your Mind:
...
Name *:	Email: Alert me
Please do not use chat terms. Example: avoid using "grt" instead of "great".