Verbal Reasoning - Blood Relation Test - Discussion

Discussion Forum : Blood Relation Test - Blood Relation 1 (Q.No. 12)
12.
Pointing a photograph X said to his friend Y, "She is the only daughter of the father of my mother." How X is related to the person of photograph?
Daughter
Son
Nephew
Cannot be decided
Answer: Option
Explanation:

'The only daughter of the father of X's mother' means mother of X.

Hence X is the son of the lady in the photograph.

Note: Still have doubt like "How X is a male?" - Let's see the discussions.

Discussion:
175 comments Page 5 of 18.

Tarun Tiwari said:   3 years ago
@All.

As per the given statement.

"She is the only daughter of the father of my mother.
“The father of my mother” refers to X’s maternal grandfather.
“The only daughter of the father of my mother” refers to X’s mother.
Therefore, the person in the photograph is X’s mother.
Determining the relationship between X and the person in the photograph:
Since X’s mother is the person in the photograph, X is the son of the person in the photograph.
In summary, X is the son of the person in the photograph.
(7)

Ayush said:   3 years ago
It can be either a son or a daughter. As the gender of x is not mentioned. So, the answer will be can't be determined.
(17)

Nikitha Patil said:   3 years ago
X gender is not mentioned so, the answer should be D.
(25)

Sai Dinesh said:   3 years ago
B is correct. Because we can easily understand that X is male as they mentioned X is saying to "his" friend.
(41)

Loveneesh said:   3 years ago
Son is the correct answer because it is given she is the only daughter of the father of my mother it is the mother of Y is the only daughter.
(1)

Ankit said:   3 years ago
I think option D is correct
Because X tells his friend Y.
So, Y is male but X's gender is not clear.
(13)

Rohit Behera said:   3 years ago
According to me, It is mentioned that "X said to his friend Y". Here, "His refers to Y not to X"!

So the answer should be option D.
(10)

Eashan said:   3 years ago
@All.

Here, they mentioned 'his' friend, so 'X' is male.
(27)

Sukhman saluja said:   3 years ago
His is used for Y not for X. So, I think the correct answer should be option D.
(5)

Srikanth said:   3 years ago
Maternal grandfather's only daughter is the mother, so X can be a son or daughter.
(4)


Post your comments here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.