Verbal Reasoning - Blood Relation Test - Discussion

Discussion Forum : Blood Relation Test - Blood Relation 1 (Q.No. 12)
12.
Pointing a photograph X said to his friend Y, "She is the only daughter of the father of my mother." How X is related to the person of photograph?
Daughter
Son
Nephew
Cannot be decided
Answer: Option
Explanation:

'The only daughter of the father of X's mother' means mother of X.

Hence X is the son of the lady in the photograph.

Note: Still have doubt like "How X is a male?" - Let's see the discussions.

Discussion:
162 comments Page 1 of 17.

Siddhi jain said:   3 weeks ago
How ? Because we have no idea about the gender of x. So we can't decide.

That it is son or daughter! Correct me, if I am wrong.
(5)

Yash Gupta said:   1 month ago
Option D should be the correct answer because the gender of X is not mentioned clearly. Although in the beginning it is written that X said to his friend but this also does not reveal the gender of X clearly.

From this statement, we get the gender of X's friend but not the gender of X.
(5)

Anom said:   2 months ago
Agree, It's son.
(1)

Rohit said:   4 months ago
Thanks all for explaining the answer, clearly.
(1)

Anon said:   5 months ago
Please explain me the answer.

Kalyan Athota said:   5 months ago
The answer is son because as mentioned before that if we observe.

"Pointing a photograph, X said to his friend Y" Here it says that X is a male character.
(21)

Jjyh said:   5 months ago
The given Statement states 'his'so it will be son.
(15)

Tanish patidar said:   6 months ago
Correct Option: Cannot be decided because we don’t know whether X is a son or a daughter.
(14)

Pkm said:   7 months ago
The Gender of X is not given. Then how the answer is son?
(25)

Maymus said:   9 months ago
Yes, you are correct @Aloha,

Data is insufficient because it is not known if X is male or female.
(18)


Post your comments here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.