Verbal Reasoning - Blood Relation Test - Discussion

Discussion Forum : Blood Relation Test - Blood Relation 1 (Q.No. 12)
12.
Pointing a photograph X said to his friend Y, "She is the only daughter of the father of my mother." How X is related to the person of photograph?
Daughter
Son
Nephew
Cannot be decided
Answer: Option
Explanation:

'The only daughter of the father of X's mother' means mother of X.

Hence X is the son of the lady in the photograph.

Note: Still have doubt like "How X is a male?" - Let's see the discussions.

Discussion:
174 comments Page 4 of 18.

Tanish patidar said:   1 year ago
Correct Option: Cannot be decided because we don’t know whether X is a son or a daughter.
(14)

Siddhi jain said:   9 months ago
How ? Because we have no idea about the gender of x. So we can't decide.

That it is son or daughter! Correct me, if I am wrong.
(14)

Ankit said:   3 years ago
I think option D is correct
Because X tells his friend Y.
So, Y is male but X's gender is not clear.
(13)

Shristi Singh said:   2 years ago
Here, his represents that X is male. So, B is the correct answer.
(12)

Priyanka said:   5 months ago
Given X said to his friend, " Here, this is what we use when X is male, right?

So, son is the correct answer.
(11)

Zamurad said:   1 month ago
@All.

Look at the question; the statement says X said to "his" friend Y, which clearly defines the gender of X i.e X is a male.
(11)

Naman Das said:   3 years ago
The Correct answer is D.
(10)

Rohit Behera said:   3 years ago
According to me, It is mentioned that "X said to his friend Y". Here, "His refers to Y not to X"!

So the answer should be option D.
(10)

Simran said:   8 months ago
It must be option D as we don't know the gender of X.
(10)

Janvi said:   3 months ago
How? We don't even know the gender of X, we cannot decide whether it is a son or a daughter.

Anyone, please explain to me,
(10)


Post your comments here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.