Verbal Reasoning - Blood Relation Test - Discussion

Discussion Forum : Blood Relation Test - Blood Relation 1 (Q.No. 12)
12.
Pointing a photograph X said to his friend Y, "She is the only daughter of the father of my mother." How X is related to the person of photograph?
Daughter
Son
Nephew
Cannot be decided
Answer: Option
Explanation:

'The only daughter of the father of X's mother' means mother of X.

Hence X is the son of the lady in the photograph.

Note: Still have doubt like "How X is a male?" - Let's see the discussions.

Discussion:
158 comments Page 4 of 16.

Puvan said:   1 decade ago
The option"D" is right. The answer "MOTHER" because the word "only daughter" is there!

Kiran said:   1 decade ago
Thanks each sentence is important.

Sweety said:   1 decade ago
How its possible? I can't understand sir please explain sir.

GD Malana said:   1 decade ago
'The only daughter of the father of X's mother' means mother of X.

Hence X is the son of the lady in the photograph. And it is WRITTEN that "HIS" friend that mean X is a male.

Anil patel said:   10 years ago
How can you determine the gender?

Mohith said:   10 years ago
As per the given question x is female.

Ayushi said:   10 years ago
X can be a female who have a male friend. So answer should be cannot be determined.

Palash Protim Boruah said:   10 years ago
We don't have any connection with what the gender of Y. Since X said to his friend Y, it is clear that X is Male. "She is the only daughter of the father of my mother".

'The father of my mother' means grandfather : It implies 'only daughter of my grandfather' which means 'my-mother'.

So it is clear, since X is male and is pointing to his mother, therefore X is the son which is the answer.

Hope this clears all doubts.
(2)

Hriman Mandal said:   10 years ago
Here x said to his friend his indicate male so x is a male.

ANGEL said:   10 years ago
Even if x is a female and y is a male, x will call y 'his friend' only. Answer can't be decided, its wrong.


Post your comments here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.