Women are not fit for Defense Services

Group Discussion
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
  • Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
  • Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
  • Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
  • Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
159 comments Page 6 of 16.

Heera singh gusain said:   8 years ago
As per my opinion, if a person wants to serve his/her country then he/she should be given fair chance to do so. What is bad in it?

I accept that women are not as physically fit as men, but some women are, and army is not only about physical work, it is also about mental toughness, and if a woman thinks that she has that capability, then what is wrong?

Isn't she a citizen of this country, isn't she has a right to join defence and serve their country.

In defence forces, there is a huge demand or lack of officers due to the lack of perfect officer like material in mostly men, but if women also encouraged to join defence then there would be more applicants or candidates for the job, and obviously, more officers will be given commission. And our forces would be much more capable and powerful.

And also there so other branches too in an army in which that much physical strength is not required, so women, if they want can serve in these branches.
(32)

Vijaidimpi said:   8 years ago
Hi.

Friends women's are doing better than men's in the field of sports, Olympic recently only women brought a medal for the country. Women rae very respectable in our society. We should respect them.

While we discuss women should be a part of Army or not then my answer is like this.

Friends as we know that in Army there is a Corps like Army education Corps, Army Medical, Corps, Signals Corps, Army Supply Corps etc where women's are proving herself best.

In combat roll like operation and fighting Corps like infantry, Armoured, ordinance where there is need of more physical and mentally tuff during war and operation women's are not fit and also not allowed.

Thanks.
(29)

Khen zomi said:   8 years ago
Yes, in this generation women are look and given equal status in the society, it right. Women are given reserved seats in govt employment, very right. But women for arm in as a combat role would not be a very good idea, as been mentioned above there are certain things sorry many things which a women herself would have to ignore eg. TBP & LRP will she be able to lead his troops or the troops be engaged in carrying her loads.
(7)

Shubhangi said:   8 years ago
I know that every girl is not suitable for defence but if 93% of girls are not suitable for defence 7% of the girls are perfect for it. You can't compare every girl to one other. Some boys are also weak than why you don't say boys are also weaker sex. You all know how to point out on girls but why not on boys.

THIS MEANS THAT WHO SAYS ILL FOR GIRLS ARE HAVING THEIR THOUGHTS AND MIND ILL.
(28)

Shubhangi said:   8 years ago
Women are also fit for defense as it's our right. You can not say this as you don't know the power of women. You only see women doing household works but it doesn't mean they can't go in defense. As much power, the boy is having girls are also having the same power.
(17)

Saumya said:   8 years ago
Captain Radhika Menon in Indian Merchant Navy, is the first lady in the world who got the IMO award for her bravery. And when I talk about Israel where the radio of man and woman in armed forces is almost equal and you people are talking that women are not fit for defence? There is no field in this world where women didn't prove themselves, tell me, is there any field? Women reached on the moon and in space and on mount Everest and now in India women are flying the combat fighters.
(27)

Saumya said:   8 years ago
If a woman become the president of India and as you know that the president of the India is the supreme commander of the Armed Forces, then how can even people imagine that women are not fit for defence services.
(10)

Kiran said:   8 years ago
It is totally wrong. You can see that in today's world women are ahead of men in every respect like sports, education, space then why women are not considered fit for defense services? I have seen that in defence several posts are only meant for men, why not for women ?also there should be 50 %reservation in defense services for women then you see women are fit or unfit for defence.
(14)

Nikita rathod said:   8 years ago
I am a girl and I am doing B.Sc physics+ Ncc cadet. I am doing my best to join in Army and Air Force and I give the answer to those person and especially for men and narrow-minded people if they think that women are in defense is wrong to think. So first change your mentality that women are not fit for army police etc. Ok if I agree with your opinion then which field is best for women where they go men create problems.

First, I want clear that men know that what they think of women in every field about their physical appearance.
(19)

Kritika sharma said:   9 years ago
It is our society who make them physically weak. If girls bring up as boys at home then she will do well in every field.

Mentally our society prepares them for banks, teaching line, companies etc. Give chance to them after giving equally education to them.
(29)


Post your thoughts here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.