Women are not fit for Defense Services

Group Discussion
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
  • Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
  • Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
  • Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
  • Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
159 comments Page 4 of 16.

Prachi said:   1 decade ago
A women can do anything and everything if she is willing to do. Today women are not lag behind in any field, and so do the army. But somewhere, something is drastically wrong in the organisational system our country, that women nowadays have to face, sexual harassment, exploitation etc. To move ahead.

I therefore believe that government should allow a bit reservation for women to avoid such obstacles in women's success way.
(19)

Rahul Kumar said:   1 decade ago
Hi everyone,

Women are always fit for any type of defence services. But one thing that are obstacle in their life is that they are not free like men. If parents are not restrict them.

Then women can do anything. Most of their example like mother teresa, Rani laxmibai, P. T usha.

That are done best of their life. Now a days, in our country women are not free like a men that are wrong. Parents should be freedom for their girls but for doing this thing first of all we have need to change their mentality about the girls.

Hence, the main conclusion behind the women are that they are Surely fit for the Defence services. I think after few year women are more free compared to that days and also put their.

Self in every field like technical, non tech, defence and son on.
(19)

Venkatesh said:   1 decade ago
Strength to fight, skills to command to think, to make wise decisions in the battlefield where every second's delay costs a life, these are acquired by years of practice, trainings, experiences they gain. A person is not born a fighter, a soldier, even a man needs to go through rigorous trainings to become a soldier, to fight for nation and so does a woman. Any person man or woman if provided proper training can serve the nation at the battlefields.
(43)

Shubham said:   1 decade ago
I think women are fully fit in each & every role or position of life. . Like if she plays role of homemaker or working lady or businesses women or government employs or any other field. They works from his full dignity, and with full honesty.

If we give to chance them with full support & encouragement then they definitely prove herself in defence or any other field better then male power.
(28)

Rudraksh goel said:   1 decade ago
Women should not join the defense as they had to look after their house, children and her husband too. If will not work she will have some time to spend with their families and also make their children learn good things.
(15)

Bharat Midha said:   1 decade ago
I am not agreed with this statement that women are not fit for Defense services, today women are not treated as weak personality. For example if Kiran Bedi leads and take strictly actions actively and with discipline then any women can do any job. If someone has a courage to do something then no one can stop her.
(13)

Natasha said:   1 decade ago
Women in army as soldiers is not a new idea. Since time immemorial tough scarce thee have been female warriors. With liberation in prevailing gender roles, archaeologist are uncovering more and more evidence of women warriors.

Society does restrict women as has been stated clearly and argued correctly in previous discussions. There is absolutely no doubt about the fact that women can accomplish themselves in non combative departments and there are many of them in defence services. Its the combative department where women are not recruited. And mind it, that its not in vain.

Women are not physically as strenuous as men, its basic biology and combative are where physical strength and capabilities are as important as mental and emotional strength and that's where women lack behind.

The social environment further amplify this problem. You can take any street sport in any colony of our country less than 5 percent girls participate in sports making them weaker (physically that is). However that doesn't mean women can't be recruited for combative, I being a taekwondo player myself can say thus that with training, which has to be harder than that of men.

More than that there is a need for little princess of homes to come out on street and play hard. Its hard but not impossible.
(14)

Shivangi said:   1 decade ago
A woman is emotionally very strong person. If a woman loves her country then she is ready to die for it more than a man like she is ready to always die for her husband. Moreover, defense is not just about dying, it is much more and women are superb administrators.

To join defense forces, a girl must first forget that she's a girl. She is no less than any man and defense doesn't differentiate between its personnel whether it be a man or woman.

But if someday country's men fail to come forward to die for nation, government must seek for woman participation in combats along with man.
(27)

Amit said:   1 decade ago
It is true that women generally are not as strong as men physically. But that doesn't mean they are not fit for defensive services as modern warfare or defense operations are not about fighting with your physical strength.

Its not like they will be exchanging fists in the war. They will have all kinds of modern weapons for that. Also being a defense personnel doesn't mean having brute force only. It requires an individual with balanced mind who can take good decisions under critical situations and one has great fitness and stamina.

So, I believe women can do fairly well in defensive services.
(24)

Ritu said:   1 decade ago
Hi friends. I'll go with motion. Girls are weaker because of their anatomy when compared with boys. I know, no one can be as patriotic as Girls. They have ability to sacrifice even life. But why? We want minimum causalities. If we had 4th generation technology as in develop countries then would have gone against the motion.

As every coin has two faces, so here just difference in technology makes difference in two faces.
(10)


Post your thoughts here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.