Women are not fit for Defense Services

Group Discussion
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
  • Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
  • Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
  • Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
  • Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
159 comments Page 3 of 16.

Aadarsh jaiswal said:   9 years ago
Hello, friends.

I think that women are fit for defence service because nowadays women are taking participate in all field or sector so that don't underestimate the power of women as we know that women handle the family very well in the same way nowadays women can handle the office, defence and many other sectors we know that our battle queen was Jhansi ki Rani she was also a women but she take participate in freedom of India and fight with Englishman just like a nowadays soldiers so we can say that women can also achieve all things if she have courage and patience.

If someone has courage and desire whether she or him they can do any things.

Thank you for reading my opinion.
(45)

Venkatesh said:   1 decade ago
Strength to fight, skills to command to think, to make wise decisions in the battlefield where every second's delay costs a life, these are acquired by years of practice, trainings, experiences they gain. A person is not born a fighter, a soldier, even a man needs to go through rigorous trainings to become a soldier, to fight for nation and so does a woman. Any person man or woman if provided proper training can serve the nation at the battlefields.
(43)

Ishita said:   6 years ago
Women can do whatever she wants.

In women, there is a power of men, there is no difference between boys n girls nowadays women doing all those things which men can't do in there whole life, one mother can fulfil the requirements of the father but father can't Same as a mother.

In every field, women are doing a very great role (ie. Cricket, astronaut, pilot, politics etc).
(43)

Manoj Pradhan said:   4 years ago
Hello, we are here to discuss that whether women fit for defence service or not.

Let's start;

* All we know for defence technical services there have no single doubt that women are equal to men mentally.

*Next in field duty, some think that women have loose body they can't bear the pain.

But we also figure the fact that even not all men are fit for defence. Whereas women like Rani Lakhsmibai, for now Mary Com and also there have other examples, who are strong enough to fight with men. So, if girls do everything like playing outdoor games with boys, practice with them then they surely will be able got that fitness what men have.

* So it depends on them if they want to do they can do.
(43)

Dipanjali Chatterjee said:   1 decade ago
Hi Sir, I like your discussion! Yes, it really makes sense. But I guess nobody here is being feminist or whatever from your comment, it is clear that you know a lot about the life in army. Your knowledge is awesome!

You have claimed in your third paragraph that under certain common conditions (in army) , 95% of women faint. Okay let us admit that most probably you are absolutely right. But we are talking about the rest 5%. What about them? I think they should be in army. (I totally respect everybody's views).
(42)

Roshan sharma said:   9 years ago
Women are fit for defense because of they able to manage all activities areas. So that don't underestimate women power, women can handle the family, office and other areas. Some women physically challenging the army. But they don't know our battle quine is Jhansi ki rani. Women can possible to achieve all things. Thank you for reading my opinion.
(42)

Dibyendu Saha said:   1 decade ago
To those who say women do not belong in armies/navies/air force because they lack the upper body strengthen ability to withstand pain, may I remind you a few points that we see in nature:

1. Females such as tigers, are the hunters.

2. Females go through immense pain while giving birth, which is not just during the time of giving birth but throughout a major portion of the 9 months.

Females are not as weak as you see them to be. I can even bet that a female like Mary Kom can take on any man here in this forum. With proper training, every man and woman gets stronger.

As for them being vulnerable to sexual torture if captured, that's probably, about the only reason why a woman would prefer not to be in the front-line in the army (not saying that there are none). There are many posts in the army as tactical support or navigational officers, etc that can suit their strengths fine. Also in the navy and air force they can take on any role a man can efficiently.
(41)

Lavanya desula said:   9 years ago
Hai.

I totally disagree this why because nowadays women are in all sectors. At a time they can balance both their family responsibilities and duties. They are physically weak but they have good power and much patience, hard working. So women are perfectly fit for defense services.
(41)

Raj said:   8 years ago
I would say womens are not fit for Defence. Eventhough Womens have equal rights with men but while consider defence they fail to have such qualities to move into defence. I won't say she can't. She has to workhard more and sacrifice a lot. She got abilitiy to override this obstacles but chance of possibility is less.
(41)

AKSHITI PRASAD said:   6 years ago
Hi friends,

We are living in the 21st century and nowadays women are shining in all the fields. They are in no way inferior to men. Starting from doctors, engineers, pilots etc, we have our women in each and every field. In the earlier days, women used be treated like street dogs by their husbands. They did not have their own identity in the society and were never allowed to express their views. But today there is a respect for the Indian women in the eyes of each and everyone. As an Indian girl, I feel that women should be given the chance to serve their motherland. I totally succumb that women are physically weaker than men but proper training will surely enable them to join defence services. They also possess the capacity to defend Mother India from the brutal terrorists just as men do.

JAI HIND.
(40)


Post your thoughts here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.