Women are not fit for Defense Services

Group Discussion
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
  • Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
  • Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
  • Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
  • Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
159 comments Page 13 of 16.

Akhil M said:   8 years ago
In my opinion women are not completely fit for defense forces, till today's date there are no women who is commissioned in infantry because infantry holds physical and operational move higher than other supporting arms so mentally and physically women can't continue a service in actual defense, in my opinion they are fit for supporting corps like medical side education side in all supporting arms side etc.
(31)

Jithin said:   8 years ago
I feel the women in 21st century is completely fit for defense services. Paramilitary forces like ITBP, BSF, CRPF has moved women to forward post along the border, now I think we should feel proud that our Indian women is guarding the borders. Now army is also recruiting more women forces, so that means women has proven that they are fit for defense services.

We should also not forgot women took part in freedom fight of India against british, so both mentally and physically women's are fit for defense.
(34)

Atal said:   8 years ago
I think womens of 21 century are completely fit for defense services but number of such womens are very less. So, first of all we have to train womens of our nation that helps whole nation. As we all know women have all those qualities which are necessary for defense services. The only thing is to change our mentality that women are not fit for defense services.
(22)

Naveena D said:   8 years ago
Good Evening Friends,

According to me, few number of women are completely fit for defence services. But remaining women are not fit for defence services.

Because of there many number issues available in our society. So women are fearful to face the issues.

However the women empowerment, the rural side women are fearful to face the situation. So the government must increase the defence for women.
(7)

Praveen said:   8 years ago
In my opinion, every human is fit to serve the nation. Talking about women, in defence services they have proved themselves all over the world. In real life, they face more difficulties than men do but despite that, they are no less. On our republic day of 2018 women, soldiers performed really very very amazing bike stunt which was better than what male soldiers did. So if they can do such daring act then they can do anything be it facing the war or any other occasion. In our country, there is very less awareness for women in the army also there are very less opportunities for them. There is only one way to prove that whether they are fit or not and that is giving them equal chances as males.
(39)

Chinmaya said:   8 years ago
A lot of people have debated this from the emotional point of view and I'll try to avoid that, but biologically women and men have same or at least similar lower body strength so running, jumping walls, etc are usually not a problem but when upper body strength is concerned men are stronger than women (as can be observed by the fact than men have broader shoulders and denser muscles), so carrying heavy rucksacks or weapons like LMG (though it is called light machine gun the only thing light about it is the name) and mortars, they also have been known on an average to be able to do less push ups and pull ups than men and are not able to perform as good as men in rope climbing, etc. Now, I have not stated any of these facts arbitrarily, the US Marines conducted a study on women and male Marines and found these facts, anyone who wants to cross check the fact can go read the report it is available to the public.
(30)

Prnk komth said:   7 years ago
Dear friends.

Women and men should give equal weightage when one talking. Our constitution says about equality more. Over equality is a right of a human. Something will be paper and something will come TRUE. This is really happening. The backbone of the family not a rib.
(10)

Nihal said:   7 years ago
I don't agree that women are not fit for defence services, women's play a major role in the armed forces by serving as doctors (more polite than male counterpart), nurses (who very well take care of the patient), educational branch, logistic branch, etc. Our armed forces limited the women's freedom, women can play an equivalent role as men are playing in the armed forces.
(13)

Vasu said:   7 years ago
Well, I totally don't agree with this statement. I'll not go through the emotional point of view, i'll tell you some facts. No doubt, the males are physically stronger than the females but joining the defence system is about your courage. If you are hulk and you don't have the courage to fight in the war, then it's worthless. Either it is male or female if they have the courage to fight and if they are medically fit then they can join the defence services.
(58)

Vicky said:   7 years ago
When it comes to about women our country becomes so soft and became emotional for the women. Women are not fit for the army. NOT AT ALL. Many of you take this wrong.

But I am in the army I know what women do here firstly army duty is to provide security to the nation whereas in Indian army women officer need security For herself if she can't walk alone without buddy Then How would they defend the country.

Secondly, in the army, military training is compulsory for everyone for his own safety at least And these women don't how to fire they can't hold Weapon the because of the Heaviness. But they are expert in one thing how to do a party in officer mess, drink alcohol, smoking, sex with colleagues.

Military nurses don't have any relation to military drill and military operations and they are getting more MSP from soldiers why?

Have you Ever seen any para commando lady officer in India? Who comes out in republic day parade? NO.

Because they don't have guts.

They care about their beauty and skin maintenance. I am in army medical corps I have saw behaviour of nurses and doctors toward the patient. The patient is crying from pain but madam are busy in her gossips. No one shows sympathy for patients.

And lady doctors don't know anything. Bloody third class doctors.

And some people are here justifying the women.

You know compared to male officers women officer do more discrimination in the army. They treat soldiers as a servant and obviously this is India everyone listens to women so the helpless soldiers are not able to do anything.

I want to make many of you clear that in today's world no one joined armed forces for his country they are Used to be unemployed that why they Found defence last option. Because it is easy to enrol compared to other city services whoever it is male, or female and they are serving for the nation and giving their life because army rules are very strict. You have to do it or otherwise ready for punishment so obviously they do their duty and during duty, they got killed and media make them a hero. Government have Army so many powers. So army has authority to punish the defaulters and army person can't seek help from police or court. So army person uses to keep in fear because they are not educated enough to fight for their right.

So take this out of your minds the era has changed So the women have changed.
(46)


Post your thoughts here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.