Should We Pursue our Policy of Dialogue with Pakistan?

Hello every one.

The topic which we are discussing is very sensitive, because pakistan is our neighbor and for peaceful environment of our nation, it is very important that relationship between both country would be healthy. I know that there is much problems between both countries. These problem may be solved by talking with each other. Only war is not a solution.

According to my point of view, it is very necessary to speak between two countries not only to reduce terrorism and also to increase business for development.

Yes, I agree with the process of peace talk with Pakistan. To make strong our home in all respect it is necessary to have good relation with neighborhood. Pakistan will remain our neighbour forever. We nothing got by our previously three wars.

Thank you.

We can change history but not geography. Clearly, our X Pm's these line are valid enough in any scenario. Lack of communication always create misunderstanding and give aggravates chance to deteriorate situation. Dialogue should be avoided when we finally in mood of clear declared war, but are we?

Surely we can drastically defeat Pakistan but war always ends with two way loss. We are developing country with bright future but its not the case with Pakistan, so its our duty to continue peaceful steps, as always fruitful tree bow down.

Pranay from Chandigarh.

It's extremely important to continue the peace talks with Pakistan. It's an open secret that Pakistan is a terrorism promoter, essentially controlled by its military. By letting go of peace talks, we absolve Pakistani leadership of stopping the peace process and give them a chance to blame India for the same while jumping along the lines of its military without a single hurdle. It would always say India stopped talking, thus the world won't focus on Pakistan anymore and each and every Pakistani would potentially become a terrorist.

And our military, however powerful, cannot stop a more than 10 crore Pakistan terrorist force unless it recreates tens of Hiroshima-Nagasaki's in Pakistan today. In response to that, of course, the world would hate India.

However, talk with Pakistan doesn't mean coffee discussions. India can pressurize Pakistan to get serious about terrorism, and in case of leniency, impose heavy economic sanctions which would break Pakistan already dismal economic situation.

The most horrific consequence of freeing Pakistan of this 'peace talk compulsion' would possibly be a redirection of mujahedeen in Afghanistan which are doubtlessly going to enter Pakistan now that NATO forces have left Afghanistan to Kashmir. Just like it did in the 1990's, and we very well know that Kashmirs have suffered for decades due to that militancy.

We talk of India being stronger than Pakistan in all respects and being more important to the world. Thus, by masterful diplomacy, cannot we force Pakistan, especially when the world already knows what Pakistan in reality is? We can China does it all the time to Tibet, Taiwan, etc.

War is an option only when we are attacked first. Never start a fight, but always finish it. We've done so in the past and should stay with this plan.

Dialogue is necessary. I wish there was an alternative. Sadly, there isn't.

Hi everyone,

We are discussing in a very very sensitive matter whether India should continue peace talk with Pakistan or not, I would like to state my opinion in this regard that India should not talk with Pakistan regarding terrorism any more. Its a open secret that Pakistan has no control against terrorism as terrorism killing hundreds of people in their won country, then why for talk with Pakistan government. First Pakistan must get control against terrorism then India should talk with Pakistan.

No, we shouldn't Pursue our Policy of Dialogue with Pakistan. As we all know Pakistani does not want peace.

Now what India needs to do is in Pakistan there are various good people also means (they understand that there government can not do anything they have no Pakistan in there country they should be in side of India).

So India should not harm such peoples and, Now India should make military center in Pakistan and perform anti-terrorist operation against terrorist in Pakistan as america did in Afghanistan) and India should clean all terrorist in Pakistan.

And also army of Pakistan (army which is like terrorist which always takeover government of Pakistan) that army should be in category of terrorism. So in this way Indian can remove every day attack by Pakistan and save lives of innocent people.

Hi friends.

We are humane, we have to respect other humane in our neighboring country. May be there are some people who want a peaceful relation with our country. So peaceful talk with Pakistan is necessary because we are Indian. We have to respect humane.

Hi friends,

I don't think it be the time to just make dialogues with pakistan. It is the time to take some action, our government now has to strict in this matter with pakistan. Either they take some action against terrorism or let us do.

But it doesn't mean war at all as it will result in loss of life of thousands of innocent people in pakistan as well as India. Our fight is from terrorist not other innocent people. Who are also suffering from terrorism.

We have to find solutions like one my said making military centres in pakistan and fight against terrorist.

Policy of Dialogue are just big words - "Agendas to discuss on and about " but sadly not much progress has been seen for all practical purposes.

Cross shooting still goes on at border between the two bitter enemies with neither willing to accept defeat. Both the countries spend enormous amounts for "defense" purposes which could be easily avoided. But it is easier said and done.

The major issue proving to be a roadblock in peace talks is the issue of J&K, POK being the icing on the cake. People of J&K are also divided amongst themselves regarding the issue.