Should We Pursue our Policy of Dialogue with Pakistan?

Policy of dialogue with pakistan is of no use:

Firstly, all the earlier attempts have failed, pakistan has always deceived us.

Secondly, their attitude is also not at all good, they have allowed terrorist groups to grow in pakistan and India has provided many proofs of it, pakistan instead of believing and finding out, they denies.

For pakistan dialogue means always the issue of kashmir nothing else.

Dialogue is fruitful only when both the sides wants, but it has been only a formality.

I think we should not engage ourself in policy of dialogue but we have to use our manpower. The idea behind my point is, attacks from Pakistan is not a recent event, they have been toiling with the peace agreement from the day they were born, all the years in which we have gone through war it is India who came out as a champion and to soothe the situation they (pak) has always have to come to us for peace treaties. Taking the case of 1971 war India was engaging themselves in peace talks but when our armies had annexed 100000 of their soldiers they have given us everything, they were the one who came to us for peace. So my point is" break them hard and peace will be ours".

I think the dialogue policy with Pakistan should be continued with Pakistan. We should not forget that doing same with the accused is not the solution. Forgiveness is our nature as foolishness of our neighbor. Let us do ours and let them do in their style. If we take eye instead of eye then one day the whole world will be blind. India is known for peace in the world and we should remain our prestige.

"AN EYE FOR AN EYE MAKES WHOLE WORLD BLIND" this is true and perhaps everyone is in favor of peaceful talk however according to me, we must have a policy of dialogue with Pakistan only to extent as every time they use to violate the ceasefire which result in bloodshed of citizens and warriors. So there are two ways either we show them our power like them in foolish way or by build our army strong like US, so that a enemy must think thousands of time before attacking us thanks.

Dear friends,

In my view, the policy of dialogue should be continued but with the condition of progress on the agreements and assurances made by their leaders in past. It should be kept in mind that war is not the solution of any problem and ie. At this juncture of time when India is aiming to be a developed country. We should continue to follow the path of peaceful talks and simultaneously make efforts to modernise our of Defence forces and weaponry like USA and other developed country so that enemy may think twice before taking any step against India.

If you don't take an eye for an eye then eventually you will be the only one left blind. Is that what we want? we can talk peace with a country who understands what it means. All we ever did was forgive Pakistan for all its violations. Has it led us anywhere? its still doing the same. I think it's high time we take a stern action or let these so called peace talks cover all the bloodshed of our soldiers on border area.

Hello friends,

What we finally want-peace between the two nation. Let us look for the solution by examining the real situations.

History- In past it has been proved pakistan never want to leave with peace, initiated the war many times instead of the fact that Bharat won over pakistan and then showed pity by not conquering it's territory. Pakistan violated the cease fire every time, even after that we are trying hard to discuss over these topics peacefully.

Help from US- Even Bharat (Hindustan) warned US for activities going in pakistan earlier US refused to blame pakistan for terrorism and after Osama bin laden founded in pakistan it was finally proved worldwide. Also from where does pakistan get so many weapon, going little deeper, search who was osama bin laden and who gave him rise and why later US became his enemy. What did US do with Iran and with it's resources, instead of being proved that Jammu and Kashmir is part of Bharat why US could not make final decision. US never want to solve the case of Jammu and Kashmir as in emergency it will help him to fight with china.

War- Is war the final solution, it is no. Main reason is terrorism and I agree with my friends we should look for the reason terrorism. Yes poverty is reason and every one should try to eradicate that but let us go into main reason of terrorism. Main reason is lack of education, they still do not teach maths, science of moons and stars, physics but even to little child they teach how to expand their religion. They teach little kids how to fire from gun and it is fact as they everyone has AK-47 just like pen pencils and vehicles we have. In my knowledge true religion is the which do not say that my religion is best then others or true secular is one who do not kill other if they do not adopt your religion.

So final solution and planning- we should give 2 or 3 three years which is enough time for pakistan to enlighten people with true knowledge, remove mess of orthodox custom in front of world. After that time period if things are not changing then last solution is war. As it is truly said that doing pity cruel is biggest cruelty on everyone, even on cruel because this pity will not help the cruel to know the truth and they will continue their ill doings.

Hello.

Peace talks never means talks without practice, in fact both members should proceed with political maturity and leaving pessimism and blame game aside. Pakistan should help the Indian concerns and India should do same by satisfying the counter blame of insurgency in Balochistan etc. Decide before dialogue that the two are together for progress and problem solving surely not for vogue criticism.

What India and Pakistan need is a bilateral peace process which does not get affected by incident of terrorism in borders.

It has become a routine that every time something happens in loc both government stop the ongoing peace process. It is a fact that ceasefire agreement is violated hundreds of time by both side and some incident gets hyped by media and it frustrates the people of both the countries. Government does nothing then stalling the peace process to placate angry people.

War is not a solution in my opinion, because it will create more hatred among the people of both countries. We already had four wars with Pakistan. We as well as Pakistan have lost many lives in these battles but we still do not have any peaceful accord with Pakistan.

I believe that India should continue the dialogue process with. It is very important that India should have peaceful neighbours. We can have peace either by dialogue process or by using force. But war has never bought any solution to any problem. So dialogue is the only way out. We as a growing superpower should set an example for others that we don't want the use of force to settle the disputes between any country.

It a well known fact that we easily outnumber them in military counts as well as we have the far better technology than Pakistan. Pakistan can be defeated by means of force. Is that what we want? no. Maybe be one day Pakistan will realise that we are not their enemies but just a friend helping them to solve their own internal problems.