Should the public sector be privatized?

Group Discussion
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
  • Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
  • Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
  • Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
  • Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
183 comments Page 8 of 19.

Arjun singh said:   8 years ago
There are two things to be considered at most.

1. If we privatise all the PSU, then definitely private sectors won't care about the poor people. They will become free to operate on their own.

2. If we didn't privatise PSU, the progress would remain stagnant. This is because of the fact that government officials do not work that seriously and progressively as private officials do.

So we need to find an intermediate solution and it could be like privatisation of some public undertakings. And with that, we can expect from both the sectors to produce the tangible result and work at their level best in every manner.
(29)

John said:   8 years ago
Keeping the current scenario in mind the Psu's making profit should be left untouched on the other hand psu's which are dealing in a loss should have a public-private partnership so that it can reap the benefits of both work ethics of private and keeping social obligation in mind of the public sector.
(6)

Aayush Chalana said:   8 years ago
I think public sector should not be privatised because,

1. If any of public sector comes under private organisation, they will think of their own good and profit will not be used for social upliftment or development.

2. The working condition of employees in private organisations is not good. They work for 10-12 hours for lesser money.

3. Actually, people working in public sector should change their way of doing work. They should be well dedicated and there should be proper administration & management in public sector. In this way, you all would agree, the public sector will be far better in each way.
(58)

Diwan sha said:   8 years ago
In public sector, political interference is more.

More profit may gain in public sector they will improve in the government.

People safety will more in private sectors.
(2)

Sopez levi said:   8 years ago
Hello every one.

No matter what ever bank it is service is important the most hell banks in India
1. Andhrabank worst service they will make you cry.
2. Canara bank famous for its charges storage bank.
3. Central bank of India and Indian bank 0%support from bank officials first of all these banks has to be privatized remaining banks are ok SBI IS PROVIDING satisfactory service/ ICICI, HDFC, KOTAK, HSBC CITI are providing good service when it comes to axis bank some employees are head strong all in all Private sector is more customer friendly than the Public sector.
(5)

Mohd tabish said:   8 years ago
Our country is at developing stage. When we talk of privatisation, it not merely includes banks. The public sector cannot alone cater all the need and wants of a large number of consumer, in such a case they have to change to privatisation. For example, telecommunications. Moreover, privatisation and globalisation improve the standard of living. But at the same time, it is not advisable that all public sector should be privatised.
(21)

Neeraj said:   8 years ago
14 banks were nationalised in 1969. Thereafter 6 more in 1980. Why?

Because they were mostly concerned for the profit motive. They established their branches in urban areas where profit margin was more. Did any bank think for social welfare or upliftment. The answer is no.

So banks were nationalised to cater the needs of rural as well as poor people.

Now if again banks or any other public sector are privatised it means you are taking your hands out from helping rural people. You are no more concerned about social upliftment. So better options are thoughts for alternate ways to earn a profit by reducing the non-performing assets. Or public-private partnership. So that you can join hands with rural people as well as urban for the profit motive.
(16)

Dr Aniruddh Kumar said:   8 years ago
Please concentrate on public benefit.

In a country like India where democracy is ruling, each and every sector sud be public. Here all people of India as a family, are doing business, here owner and labour are same, profit from business is used for better education, treatments and development of whole country people. What it means the real democracy. Other wise, after growing sectors of privatisation, capitalisation would rise, exploitation of people would rise, as we can see in SIDCUL Haridwar, circumstances is so created by owners that minimum duty hours are 10-12, then also, very fewer payments,

The Quality of work in public sectors may be controlled by good management and administration, and for that, every Indian should committed to, Good luck to all.
(9)

ATC said:   8 years ago
No, Public sector banks can easily make a profit if they charge like private sector bank for each service and stop lending to public for govt scheme and social activities. If only secured loans are lended public sector bank can easily make huge profit. If all govt sponsored schemes are stopped they make huge profit. Now, SBI is shifting towards such a platform and we can see the difference from their performance soon.
(4)

Abhishek said:   8 years ago
I think it is better to privatise the PSU banks because of below reason.

1. All PSU bank are loss making and govt is continuously throwing the good money after bad money. In long term, this model is not sustainable.

2. It is not govt duty to run PSU bank. 30 years ago things were different. Now in rural place, we can see private banks.

3. PSU employee is not doing their duty seriously. Banks NPA are increasing and it is wastage of public money which can be deployed somewhere else for the better purpose.

4. Corruption level is high in public sector banks.

5. Better technology is deployed at private sector banks which will in end and benefit common citizens.
(9)


Post your thoughts here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.