Should India break Diplomatic Ties with Pakistan?

Hi friends. War is not a solution of any problem. War between two nuclear country is foolishness. There is no doubt that India is more stronger than Pakistan and more developed than pak. THis is also true If war takes place India will win. But what we will get with wars. Already three wars have happened. And nothing was achieved.

Wars always results in violence and killing of innocent people and a lot of soldier not in destruction of real reason of war. End of one war sows the seed of next war. Our problem is not with pak army. Our problem is terrorist groups in pak. I am in favor of war If these terrorist group will participate in war from front. Then the war will be useful. Also now a day Indian economy is at decliment. War will cause a lot of wastage of money. But I am also not in the favor of talk and peaceful meeting, having delicious lunch with pakistan leader. India Instead of this should take some strict decision. Mere cancel of cricket tour will not work. They should not give any fundamental help to Pak like water and light etc until they show some improvement.

According to me India should break diplomatic ties with pak. Because every time when India put the friendship hand towards the pakistan India had paid for this. Pak always betrayed India. Last year at the border we see that Indian army had killed by pakistan soldiers. And our government do thing and again after 2 days 4 Indian army had killed again and then Indian government remain quiet. And there are many example like pak. Do terrorist attack on Indian innocent people. But India always forget this all thing and make a friendship hand toward them, . But acc. To me its the time to show India. India shows its power not to do fight but just have cut off all the relation with pak so that they get to know what is India. Fight is not the solution because we know that if fight is to be started in both countries India definately win. But the Indian soldiers and the people will die in that fight also a lot of money is wasted in this. And it is not the time to lose the money. So I think India have to break the diplomatic ties with the pakistan but without any fight.

No, we should not break all ties with Pakistan. Our adversary is China too still we have good relation in business sector. Relation depends on give and take if Pak wants bilateral relation we are ready for that if Pak wants war we are ready for war if Pak wants India to eradicate home terrorist, India also supports being neighbor. We should never forget the saying of former PM Atal Bihari vajpayee that "dost basal ja ta hai lakin padosi nahi badalte.

We all know allergy does not have any cure but precaution is the best medicine for allergy. We are discussing because our heroes are dying. I pay homage to all our sepoy heroes but we can do to avoid above allergy. First is constructing wall like Israel made against Palestine, recently our government has taken this step second I request to defense ministry that instead of huge investment on air force we can invest on purchasing bullet proof jacket and helmet that help our heroes. We are raising this question because of current tension on border and martyrdom.

Thank you and Jayhind.

Hello! Friends in my point of view India should not be break their relations with pakistan because war is not the ultimate solution to stop the terrorism. We all know that every time pakistan cheats India and pakistan did not do anything regards this terrorism. So I think our government should think about this and take some wise steps.

If we attack the pakistan then many innocent people will be killed, we can say that for killing the mosquito's of our house we did not burn our house. We cannot forget all the terrorist attacks that pakistan did because of these attacks many people suffers they lost their houses and their family members What is the fault of those people.

At last I want to say that Attack that individual or group collect enough evidence to show Pakistan like america done in case of laden. Our govt politicians even remark like this that people join army to die. If we underestimate and show sincerity to Pakistan after our soldiers killed brutally one day will must come when no one will join Indian army.

Breaking diplomatic ties will achieve what?

What is the objective?

I believe that we would like to get back POK! Also, have an issue free Kashmir valley.

Breaking off diplomatic ties could reach our doors of war, generally, the main objective of war is to achieve a forced peace.

So suppose we go to a conventional war, Pakistan would be annihilated. Suppose if it becomes a nuclear catastrophe, India will survive but will become 30 years behind. However, we still will have a disgruntled group in Kashmir. So is any war achieving us the objective? I guess no.

We can take Pakistan out of the equation but does the problem go? No, it does not vanish.

So the question is how do we get peace in Kashmir?

Eliminating Terrorism is the solution, if that happens, we can call back the army to barracks, this will end the collateral damage. Then over a time as peace prevails, the disgruntled shall no longer have any support. The matter would be solved.

For this, we need talks, diplomatic maneuvers. Not breaking diplomatic ties.

Truly speaking, not only India but the world even cannot believe Pakistani rulers. Public may not be that much bad. But looking at the past and browsing history regarding Pakistani rulers, they have always been treacherous and deceivers. While dealing with Pakistan, India must analyse the history of Bharat since the rule of invader devil Babur.

In Bharat, the Mughals have never been humans and Pakistani being their offspring and fellow beings can not in any matter or front be believed or relied. There are many things negative and devilish in Pakistan coincided in the above facts, but cannot be narrated here. Once one will analyse the above facts, he will get the answer of the question being raised.

Pakistan has fought four wars with India and has been consistently sponsoring terrorist organisations to spread hatred between communities through terrorist activities in India. Pakistan has always opposed India in international forums and has always made sure to keep the lip service going.

Pakistan in itself is a sort of bifurcated nation. It is still struggling to have consistent and uniform command over the implementation of its planned agenda and strategies. Unlike India, Pakistani democratic government don't have enough ruling over its military and its intelligence ambition, leading to independent functioning of both the units. Now here it is mindful that Pakistan has almost lost the democratic touch over the use of its arms. The hostile action on the part of Pakistan against India can't be directly linked to its civilian elected government Rather it is to be credited to the army and its secret alliance to terrorist. We Indians should consider this unstable situation of Pakistan and even perform aggressive research while employing our intelligence to figure out the genuine condition of the country which I believe is tracing the trajectory of Afghanistan. THE LACK OF DIPLOMATIC APPROACH BETWEEN TWO WILL EXACERBATE THE ARMS RACE, AND WILL GIVE CHINA A UPPER HAND.

The experience of India in the last 67 years with Pakistan has amply made it very clear to every one that any effort by India to build good neighborly relations, is not going to work. We have been doing it since beginning and the result is known to all of us. The basic reason behind this is that the ruling elite in Pakistan including primarily its military, has a very deep rooted hatred for India and any thing Indian, for historical reasons. Their polices with respect to India are based on this.

They would never stop their games even if, Kashmir issue is settled in their favor, since the basic cause that is, their hatred for India and its success story will still remain. In spite of all the terror they have unleashed on India in the last more than 20 years and four wars, breaking diplomatic relations with them is not the answer. We need to have a presence in Islamabad to continue to know what all new games they are planning against us and what all is happening in that country.

Some of my friends are saying that we should talk on this topic practically and not emotionally but can you say this same thing to the families to whom these soldiers belong. You can't take away the emotional aspect from this topic.

India has taken ample efforts to improve the relationship between the two nations but we still catch terrorists who themselves tell to have come from Pakistan and when asked to Pakistan about this they deny the truth. Thus by not cooperating with us they are proving that they are nurturing terrorism in their nation.

Another thing which I would like to mention is that we should not have war with Pakistan because Pakistan has got nothing to loose whereas India is on the verge of development.

So on a whole, I feel breaking ties with Pakistan is the only option as Pakistan is not a developed country to affect our country's economy or market by any means. We should also continue their isolation on an international level.

Suspension of Cultural, Social, Political and Economic Relations with Pakistan is perhaps only possible way to bring this notorious country to its heels. I would like to bring some points before the group.

1. To begin with, India should declare Pakistan a Terrorist Country.

2. Call the Indian High Commissioner in Pakistan followed by the immediate shutdown of Pakistan's Embassy in India.

3. All trade relations including cross-border trade should immediately be suspended.

4. All Artists of Pakistani origin be sent back to their country. Movies including Pakistani Film Stars should be boycotted nationally.

5. We can stop playing cricket too along with any other games with the Pakistani Teams.

6. The International Border between the two countries should be sealed permanently.

7. Strategic Isolation of Pakistan at International Level by presenting various proofs available that show that Pakistan is a Terrorist Nation.