Is Reservation in Higher Education Only Alternative for Social Equality?

Hello everyone.

In my point of view, it should be Banned because sometimes it also increases the rate of brain drain.

The reservation system was introduced by Dr BR Ambedkar to provide equal opportunity and works for lower caste people.

But in present time reservation is not required because due to reservation system talented person not getting better opportunity and they are going abroad.

And other countries are taking advantage of it.

Due to reservation India is not growing perfectly.

In my opinion, reservation should be based on economic condition, people who are facing economic problem he should be given reservation in education or other fields.

Thanks.

Hi, good morning to all of you. I am Ansh Yadav.

Our GD topic is reservation in India.

We know that India is a developing and progressive country. So the reservation should not allow our country. Many developing countries like America China, there is no caste system there. So reservation in India is very harmful to us. And we should abolish this evil and also shall abolish untouchability.

Thank You.

Because of this system, talented people are ignored and undeserved people get a job. It creates many dissatisfactions among talented people choose wrong way like terrorism, crime, legal-illegal work and some talented people use their talent for the progress of other countries called the brain drain.

Education is the ultimate weapon to take away the remnants of a caste based society. If it itself discriminates based on caste then that sprouts the wrong idea in mind of individuals. Education must be made cheaper and of more quality so that the deserving students would never miss their chance for education but also make sure that the quality of education is not compromised at any costs.

Reservation based on caste creates new forms of discriminations as the deserving are denied their chances and also create a sense of injustice in them simultaneously creating a feeling of inferiority in the minds of students backed with reservation. So if at all reservations are given they should be based on income. What is more needed is proper awareness about the importance of education and aspirational thinking from a young age itself.

In my point of view reservation given only that person, who really need a reservation.

Reservation must be given only a financial condition basis, not for a cast basis.

Because of reservation knowledgeable person go back compared to an unknowledgeable person, in our education system need to totally remove reservation so that good knowledgeable person goes to right Place.

Reservation in higher education only alternative for social equality, I think that the system of reservation which is in India is sometimes may not necessarily cause the, suppose the student who came from the poor background but he not able to pay the fees for particular higher education because of financial problems in this situation the loss of knowledge of that student who have really appropriate for it so I think the reservation depends upon the quality of that student not cast of that student hence by this way the students who have the knowledge a lot of which is really required for developing India or their carrier so reservation depends on skill of student.

Hai, this is Anji.

I think reservation is not necessary in education because there is a lot of student's who are directly and indirectly affected in their studies, the govt will support the backward classes offering scholarships, fee reimbursement but not by seat allocation.

The reservation system has helped a lot in the betterment of the society, earlier backward classes were not even treated as humans. It was a very bad scenario. Many of them have actually come out of that poverty line but to say that the problem has been solved is an understatement.

There are still many villages which are in a bad situation, to know the state of the backward people we have to go to the very depth of it. They won't even know about the reservation system.

And the major set back which will follow if the reservation system is suddenly banned is that those minorities are going to suffer massive bullying. Bullying on bases of the cast is still prevailing in schools. People are afraid of disclosing their cast. Dalits are still being the victims of mob lynching.

So, as the topic asks if the reservation system was the only alternative for social equality then I would say no there is still a lot to be done.

Hi, this is Sreevignya. I think reservation is not perfectly necessary for higher education. Because everyone is equal in society. I wish in future, there should be no reservations among castes. Everyone is getting educated. There is no difference between the castes. So, I hope the reservation is not at all necessary.