Is Reservation in Higher Education Only Alternative for Social Equality?
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
- Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
- Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
- Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
- Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
168 comments Page 14 of 17.
Tomy said:
7 years ago
Reservation was introduced by Dr. BR. Ambedkar to provide equal opportunities for receiving education to those who were denied the right to get the high education due to their cast. Before independence society was divided into castes and a certain section of the society was for doing only menial jobs. They had been denied equal rights for many years. To give them equal rights Ambedkar introduced the concept of reservation.
I think in the present context reservation should be given on the basis of financial condition and the talent rather than on the basis of caste. Because today people from backward classes having good financial condition enjoy the advantage of reservation. They do not relinquish the rights provided to them due to the reservation. That is why students from upper castes with the weak financial condition suffer and they have to work way harder than other castes to get the admission in educational institutions or to get the jobs in government sector.
I think in the present context reservation should be given on the basis of financial condition and the talent rather than on the basis of caste. Because today people from backward classes having good financial condition enjoy the advantage of reservation. They do not relinquish the rights provided to them due to the reservation. That is why students from upper castes with the weak financial condition suffer and they have to work way harder than other castes to get the admission in educational institutions or to get the jobs in government sector.
(52)
Ananthu R Gopal said:
7 years ago
I think the reservation should be banned. But the government should implement some policies to bring out the talents in the society which is facing severe economic atrocities.
(18)
Gagan said:
7 years ago
There are still many villages where the condition of backwards classes is still dreadful. Even, some of the people of this community still cannot get the benefits of reservation because of the ultimate poverty. It is true that good financial backwards classes people use the benefits of reservation, but still if you the see the overall scenario of community, they are still not on the merge to be said developed as the higher caste are.
So, it doesn't matter whether rich backward people use the reservation, poor backward still unable to use the benefits of reservation.
There is improvement over the years in the condition of backwards, but there is still a need for the continuation of reservation system for the betterment, to get that economic status equivalent to the upper classes.
So, it doesn't matter whether rich backward people use the reservation, poor backward still unable to use the benefits of reservation.
There is improvement over the years in the condition of backwards, but there is still a need for the continuation of reservation system for the betterment, to get that economic status equivalent to the upper classes.
(14)
Payal said:
7 years ago
No, it is not the only alternative for social equality. Because of this, alternative many deserving candidates do not get admission and have to compromise. So, there is a kind of trade off. Instead of making reservations, there fees should be subsidized depending upon income of the family. This will help in taking admission easily. But the opportunities for all should be same and same admission criteria must be followed.
(20)
Gulbargawale said:
7 years ago
Yes, reservation is the main thing for India's backward.
Because of reservation, the merit student lost their jobs. And they go out of India for a job so India is losing talented peoples.
Because of Indian talented people, other countries are developed and India is in backwards than those countries.
Because of reservation, the merit student lost their jobs. And they go out of India for a job so India is losing talented peoples.
Because of Indian talented people, other countries are developed and India is in backwards than those countries.
(46)
TRG said:
7 years ago
Yes, reservation in the education system is very bad due to reservation, merit students lost their jobs.
(33)
Trgulbargawale said:
7 years ago
Reservation in the education system is a very wrong thing because of reservation merit students lose their opportunities.
If the government want each student will learn with equality then the government should ban on the reservation.
Instead of giving reservation on the cast basis give the reservation on the current economic scale of family.
Who is really poor give the concessions in fees not in the percentage or in quota?
If the government want each student will learn with equality then the government should ban on the reservation.
Instead of giving reservation on the cast basis give the reservation on the current economic scale of family.
Who is really poor give the concessions in fees not in the percentage or in quota?
(29)
Ravi said:
7 years ago
The main objective of the reservation was to remove social discrimination amongst the people which was highly present in our society before the Independence so that the people who were socially and economically deprived can come forward and be the part of our society.
When this was implemented Reservation was really needed at that time for 'Dalit' people. Now the scenario has been changed there are so many general people who they don't have much money to get their proper education and they are not economically rich, and there are several people who belong to SC/ST category are financially rich and have high Lifestyle and still they are getting the benefits of reservation, so for them which kind of reservation is needed and why not the general people who are victims of poverty, reservation is needed for them.
But still reservation should not be completed vanished, because casteism is still present in villages of India and a major part of SC/ST categories are still not strong economically and they have to be humiliated. So if the reservation will not be provided to them, they can never come forward in our society and will have to face social discrimination.
The people who should have got the benefits of this reservation didn't get. Only a specific community of this categories are misusing it. So, there is a need of modifications of this reservation system and should start the elimination from SC/ST people who has already taken the benefits of it and have become economically rich and should be declared creamy layer, so that who really need of reservation can get it.
When this was implemented Reservation was really needed at that time for 'Dalit' people. Now the scenario has been changed there are so many general people who they don't have much money to get their proper education and they are not economically rich, and there are several people who belong to SC/ST category are financially rich and have high Lifestyle and still they are getting the benefits of reservation, so for them which kind of reservation is needed and why not the general people who are victims of poverty, reservation is needed for them.
But still reservation should not be completed vanished, because casteism is still present in villages of India and a major part of SC/ST categories are still not strong economically and they have to be humiliated. So if the reservation will not be provided to them, they can never come forward in our society and will have to face social discrimination.
The people who should have got the benefits of this reservation didn't get. Only a specific community of this categories are misusing it. So, there is a need of modifications of this reservation system and should start the elimination from SC/ST people who has already taken the benefits of it and have become economically rich and should be declared creamy layer, so that who really need of reservation can get it.
(44)
Satyendra said:
7 years ago
Reservation is the most highlighted topic in our country dr BR Ambedkar include reservation in our constitution for sc, st, OBC.
So they could grow themselves and develop their society. In that time the condition of sc st and OBC was very worse so they need a reservation but nowadays many people have got the advantage of reservation so I think people who already can get the advantage of reservation should be left reservation so that other people of their society could get the reservation. Then our country and society will become better early.
So they could grow themselves and develop their society. In that time the condition of sc st and OBC was very worse so they need a reservation but nowadays many people have got the advantage of reservation so I think people who already can get the advantage of reservation should be left reservation so that other people of their society could get the reservation. Then our country and society will become better early.
(10)
Pardeep Kumar said:
7 years ago
Reservation was introduced by Dr BR Ambedkar to provide equal rights to lower caste. Before Independence India was divided into many castes. People from lower caste dislike by upper caste. Lower caste people had no opportunity to became a respectful person.
But now condition has been changed Govt provide them right of equality. Now their financial condition has been changed. Poor people from upper caste had been suffered.
Reservation in the study is very wrong because of it merit student didn't get the opportunity and incapable person got a job.
Other countries are developed because they have no reservation. They only check their talent and skill.
In my opinion, instead of the caste based reservation, it should be financially based. So that poor people can get a chance to prove ourselves.
But now condition has been changed Govt provide them right of equality. Now their financial condition has been changed. Poor people from upper caste had been suffered.
Reservation in the study is very wrong because of it merit student didn't get the opportunity and incapable person got a job.
Other countries are developed because they have no reservation. They only check their talent and skill.
In my opinion, instead of the caste based reservation, it should be financially based. So that poor people can get a chance to prove ourselves.
(18)
Post your thoughts here:
Quick links
Quantitative Aptitude
Verbal (English)
Reasoning
Programming
Interview
Placement Papers