Is GST really a One nation, One tax system?

I agree with that - but I see many Negative points of GST.

When I doing Under Grad. In 2008 The Sevice & Sales Tax was Near 8 to 10 % and most highly needed items were also tax-free that time when time went in 2015 the tax rate touched 12 to 15 % and that also highly needed items also tax-free.

But when our PM Modhi Ji Introduce GST - I am Very Happy Like You,

But later I Realized That he doing wrong to us. I Have Some Res. Behind This,

1) They Incre. Rate OF Tax for our diversion they define many tax rates like 0, 5, 12, 18, and 28 % - but earlier the tax rate was only 12 to 15 %, and all most items are there in but now max. Item in 18%, and car, Bike & Luxury items charge 28 %. That was very high.

2) The Main Res. Behind This Central Government want a High Tax Because - 1st when GST Not Apply SG have to collect tax according to his rule they give some money to CG, But after the GST CG give half amt of tax to SG.

3) CG & SG Never Change the Working Style to Clean the City - if you Saw That CG Introduce Smart City Work Project - they give Tender to Other companies - they increase employment but when go in any city where actualy Smart City Work started you See the Reality - they just spent out Tax on the name of some Project. - I Have A Example of that - IF You hear The Name UDAIPUR City (Lake City) in Rajasthan tile today date 11. Oct 2022 they Spent more than 1000 Cr. Rs in name of smart City. (i may be wrong in the Amount Term) ask any local people that you are happy with the work - you Got the answer. From them. And work starts at 5 years ago still not Complete and also saw the Material Quality and our State government create Another Plan as that charged From us 200 t0 800 Rs Every2 months from us - you can say that SG Plan Charge us another Tax.

4) GST also Increase Many Accounting Work related exp. Like every month or Quater wise return file,

GST Mismatch Error, GST LATE Fee, GST Late Payment Interest,

5 If every Person Pays GST on a Maximum ITEM Then why Charge Income Tax From Indiuval and Company? - Because Many Company PAY Gst But Accutal GST is Bear by the Last user of the product - who consumes the product or services,

6 Who Pay Income Tax In the Individual Category - Mostly Salary People because they have No Option in the way of Deduction, But a Business person has many Options to reduce his taxes.

7 due to GST Corruption Reduce I agree that but Gov. Still increases Salary OF Gover. Employee only those who increase the salary of Non-Gov. Employee. And after GST also allow 5 day per Week in Gov. Department work they increase just Creat lazier the Gov. Emp. - all people know how Gov Department work still there have many of corruption Because GST Is one way to collect the tax from the user but Most of the department work only From Bright (Reswat) - who Clear this type of Corruption.

8 I Like Modi's Style but am not Happy With GST.

GST is goods and service tax. It is a good initiative taken by pm of India. Before that people have to pay many tax like service tax, entertainment tax, vat tax etc. People paid for the tax they are not aware of it was kind of not good because every in every state we have to pay a different price for the same product but after GST, we pay and we know, for what we are paying. Well, people don't have good knowledge about GST, so they don't have a good opinion about it. But it is good for a long term. In starting prices has increased and shopkeepers are having issues related to bill and all. They are not aware of how to apply GST but it is good for the nation and people. It joins the country.

Yes, I agree with your point @Rakesh.

But gst is not good in our people. Reason today gst is 9+9=18%. So the poor people affected by the state. So the gst is only agree to the business people.

The biggest benefit that I have observed is this, the person who didn't even know about the taxes prevailing in India is now talking and thinking about the gst. And the fact behind this, is the tax system is now easy to understand and now we know what we paying for what tax we are giving.

See every initiative has it's flaws and you can't even resolve the issue in a country of 125 crore people and you can't make everyone happy, so I think it is a good initiave in my point of view.

Yes, according to me it is a really a one nation, one tax system. Before GST all state had different tax system but after this all state has a uniqe tax system.

It is four type :0%, 5%, 12%, 18%, and 28%.

It is all India with a tax system. And after this tax system ecnomic system is being better than past.

Firstly, thanks for giving me the opportunity for expressing my views about GST.

Gst (good and service tax). I do believe this is the good and a beneficiary move made by our government. One nation, one tax system, it is implemented to eradicate over taxes paid by the public. It also helps in the development of the country and poor people.

Hi everyone,

In my view, one nation one tax system is the enormous solution for corruption. The unallowable taxes taken by various product manufacturing industries increased the prices of all goods. The government service tax i.e. GST will enroutes the problems like this and will make better increments in national economy. After applying GST the all individual's in the entire country will conduct one tax payment system and there's nothing like partiality with anyone in tax aspects.

In my point of view, GST is good as well as bad depending on the level or part of the people we are talking.

It is implemented in different ways as CGST and SGST. Good in the way that every one have to pay tax. Their is transparency in taxation system. Tax revenue increases and much more.

Definitely, these points help the country to grow.

But the other part also for the Petrol and alcohol. Why it not come under GST.

It will benefit if they both come under GST.

If we talk about small shops which are shutdown. But if they get registered it benefits both country as well as them.

Hello, everyone.

In my point of view, it is one of the many good initiatives taken by PM Modi. It enables us to understand the tax system of India in a more comprehensive way. As you see every day many people caught by CBI raids when compared to the pre-Modi era. I believe these are happening because of GST.

Good morning sir,

Thank you so much for giving such an opportunity to express my views over Gst.

Yes, I support this central govt idea. It is very good initiatives one nation one tax system. For this, the whole country will be given the same tax for the same thing. For this, there is no variation of price of an element in the whole country and Unscrupulous businessman don't fulfilment their bad intention. If it properly implemented in our country the economy of our country will grow faster. So the government should look at the matter if it implements all over the country uniformly. Thank you once again.