Aptitude - Time and Work - Discussion

Discussion Forum : Time and Work - General Questions (Q.No. 10)
10.
A machine P can print one lakh books in 8 hours, machine Q can print the same number of books in 10 hours while machine R can print them in 12 hours. All the machines are started at 9 A.M. while machine P is closed at 11 A.M. and the remaining two machines complete work. Approximately at what time will the work (to print one lakh books) be finished ?
11:30 A.M.
12 noon
12:30 P.M.
1:00 P.M.
Answer: Option
Explanation:

(P + Q + R)'s 1 hour's work = ( 1 + 1 + 1 ) = 37 .
8 10 12 120

Work done by P, Q and R in 2 hours = ( 37 x 2 ) = 37 .
120 60

Remaining work = ( 1 - 37 ) = 23 .
60 60

(Q + R)'s 1 hour's work = ( 1 + 1 ) = 11 .
10 12 60

Now, 11 work is done by Q and R in 1 hour.
60

So, 23 work will be done by Q and R in ( 60 x 23 ) = 23 hours = 2 hours.
60 11 60 11

So, the work will be finished approximately 2 hours after 11 A.M., i.e., around 1 P.M.

Discussion:
95 comments Page 9 of 10.

Shekar said:   1 decade ago
2(1/8+1/10+1/12)+x(1/10+1/12)=1 we get x value is 2.09. required value is 11am+209=1.09pm,we taken approx value 1pm.

Rahul said:   1 decade ago
All the machines are started at once.
we have got the solution as 4 hrs for both machines q & r
they have started at 9 a.m.
q & r work for 4 hrs

So 9+4=13 i.e,1 p.m.

Ramkumar said:   1 decade ago
Can anyone tell

Why you put last step as 9am+4?

Already p, q, r done by 2hrs and (q&r) in 4 hrs know.

Then 2+4=6 only know.

On this step I am in confusion. Help me.

Piyus said:   1 decade ago
Friends

P's 2 hr work = 1/8*2=1/4
rest 3/4 work done by q&r
q+r 1hr = 1/10 + 1/12=11/60 work
3/4 work by q&r=60/11 * 3/4=4.09

The work complete time was 9a.m+4=1p.m

Manju said:   1 decade ago
Thanks naveen sir.

Div said:   1 decade ago
Since machine p stops after 37 units of work is completed from 60 units of work, still (60-37=23) 23units of work is remaining. hence, 1-(37/60)= 23/60

Syed said:   1 decade ago
Can some one tell me why 1-37/60 ?

Naveen kumar said:   1 decade ago
Hi friends... In this problem it is having some confusion in the last step....i will explain that step in a easy way....

The work completed by q and r after closing of p machine is
23/60....
but we don't know the time...
we have to calculate it...

(q+r)'s 1 hour work = 11/60.

we can represent the above relation like this....

11/60 (portion of work)-------> 1 hour (time)

23/60 (portion of work) ------> ....? (time)


By cross multiplying the above terms we will get.

11/60 * 60/23 = 23/11

that is approximately equals to 2 ....

q and r machines took 2 hours to complete the remaining work....

i.e.,
11+2 = 1 p.m

the total 1 lakh books will be printed by 1 p.m

Gayu said:   1 decade ago
Hey is above told methods are applicable? to this type of problems with a small change.

Shashank said:   1 decade ago
Easy Solution

let total time to print the book be x
therefore
x-2/8 + x/10 + x/12= 1
Solve for x we get approx 4
so time will be 9+4=1 pm.


Post your comments here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.