Aptitude - Time and Work - Discussion

Discussion Forum : Time and Work - General Questions (Q.No. 2)
2.
A can lay railway track between two given stations in 16 days and B can do the same job in 12 days. With help of C, they did the job in 4 days only. Then, C alone can do the job in:

9 1 days
5

9 2 days
5

9 3 days
5

10
Answer: Option
Explanation:

(A + B + C)'s 1 day's work = 1 ,
4

A's 1 day's work = 1 ,
16

B's 1 day's work = 1 .
12

Therefore C's 1 day's work = 1 - ( 1 + 1 ) = ( 1 - 7 ) = 5 .
4 16 12 4 48 48

So, C alone can do the work in 48 = 9 3 days.
5 5

Discussion:
224 comments Page 22 of 23.

SHAILESH SALVE said:   3 years ago
How 5/48 to 48/5? Please explain this step.
(24)

Tarun kumar agrawal said:   3 years ago
Given that;
A complete the work in --> 16 days.
B complete the work in --> 12 days.
With the help of C (A+B+C) complete the work in --> 4 days.
We take LCM OF (16,12,4) comes --> 48 unit.
A complete --> 48/16 = 3 unit per day.
B complete --> 48/12 = 4 unit per day.
A+B+C complete --> 48/4 = 12 unit per day.
C alone do --> 12-3-4 = 5 unit per day.
so C take time to complete the work in days = total unit/unit per day by c.
= 48/5.
= 9(3/5) days.
When we divided 48 by 5 quotient comes to 9 and the remainder is 3 . it is a mixed fraction.
(122)

Ion Strait said:   2 years ago
The reason that 5/48 becomes 48/5 is that C's one day work = 5/48.
Here it means, the total work in units is 48 and out of that C does 5 units of work in 1 day, so it's 5/48.
But the question asks the time required for C alone to complete the work.
Since, 48 units are the total work, just divide it by the one-day unit of C's work, that is, 5
So, 48/5.
(50)

RAMAKRISHNA MACHARLA said:   2 years ago
A = 1/16.
B = 1/12.
A+B+C = 1/4.
1/16 + 1/12 + C = 1/4
C = 1/4 - 1/16 - 1/12
C = 5/48 = 48/5.
C = 9 * 3/5.
(99)

Rahul Kapoor said:   2 years ago
A work done in 16 days.
B work done in 12 days.

A, B and C work done 4 days.

Total work 16,12,4.
Total work 48.

Efficiency of A 48/16 = 3
Efficiency of B 48/13 = 4
Efficiency of A+B+C = 48/4 = 12.
Efficiency of C = 12 - 4 - 3 = 5.
C completed the work alone =48/5.
(101)

Shivaji said:   2 years ago
Simple logic;

A-----> 16 days.
B ----> 12days.

with the help of C.
AB+C -----> 4 days.

Total work (LCM) = 48.
Efficiency = A--3, B--4, AB+C--12.
A+B = 7,
AB+C = 12
Then C = 12-7 = 5.
C can do work in = Total work/Efficiency = 48/5 = 9*3/5.
(54)

Abhishek Kumar said:   2 years ago
Simple logic;

A-----> 16 days.
B ----> 12days.
with the help of C.
AB+C -----> 4 days.

Total work (LCM) = 48.
Efficiency = A--3, B--4, AB+C--12.
A+B = 7,
AB+C = 12
Then C = 12-7 = 5.
C can do work in = Total work/Efficiency = 48/5 = 9*3/5.
(113)

Tom said:   2 years ago
(A-B-C) = 1/16-1/12-1/4.
LCM value = 48.
A = 16*3 = 48 (3).
B = 12*4 = 48 (4).
C = 4*12 = 48 (12) .

So,
A = 3.
B = 4.
C = 12.

Then subtract value. i.e AB-C.
AB = 7, C = 12.
12-7 =5,
Answer 48/5.

Final answer 9*3/5.
(79)

Siva Ranjini said:   2 years ago
A = 48/16=3w/d
B = 48/12=4w/d
C = ?
Total work = 48.
One day completed work = 48/4 = 12.
3+4+? = 12.
C work per day = 5w/d.
C = 48/5.
Ans = 9 3/5 days.
(96)

Siva said:   7 months ago
Good and clear explanation. Thanks all.
(22)


Post your comments here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.