Aptitude - Time and Work - Discussion

Discussion Forum : Time and Work - General Questions (Q.No. 2)
2.
A can lay railway track between two given stations in 16 days and B can do the same job in 12 days. With help of C, they did the job in 4 days only. Then, C alone can do the job in:

9 1 days
5

9 2 days
5

9 3 days
5

10
Answer: Option
Explanation:

(A + B + C)'s 1 day's work = 1 ,
4

A's 1 day's work = 1 ,
16

B's 1 day's work = 1 .
12

Therefore C's 1 day's work = 1 - ( 1 + 1 ) = ( 1 - 7 ) = 5 .
4 16 12 4 48 48

So, C alone can do the work in 48 = 9 3 days.
5 5

Discussion:
224 comments Page 19 of 23.

Parthasarathy said:   1 decade ago
@HIREN.

If A can do some work in N days.

So A can do that same work in one day =1/N.

So the answer 5/48 obtained by (1/4) - (1/16+1/4) =5/48.

So you should consider this as only 48/5.

Amit.J said:   1 decade ago
A+B+C=4 day.
A=16 day.
B=12 day.
C=?

Formula..

A+B+C=A*B*C/AB+BC+CA

4=192C/192+28C

4(192+28C)=192C

768+112C=192C

768=192C-112C

768=80C

768/80=C

C=48/5 Ans.

Hiren said:   1 decade ago
Why you write 48/5 from 5/48.

Suryakiran varma said:   1 decade ago
Look,
A can do a work in 16 days,so his one day work will be=1/16
and also B's one day work will be =1/12;
in the same way A,B,C together do a work in 4 days,so thier one day work will be=1/4
C 's one day work will be=(A+B+C)'s one day work - (A+B)'s one day work
i.e..
=(1/4)-(1/16+1/12)
=(1/4)-(7/48)
=(5/48)
thus,C's one day work is = 5/48,
so,he can do the work in 48/5 days..i.e..9 3/5.

Rajasekar said:   1 decade ago
How 5/48 is written 48/5?

Anshu said:   1 decade ago
"A" can do the 1/16 of the work in a day.
"B" can do the 1/12 of the work in a day.
A + b + c = 1/4 of the work.
1/16 + 1/12 + c = 1/4.
3/48 + 4/ 48 + c = 1/4.
7/48 + c = 1/4.
C = 1/4 - 7/48 = 12-7/48 = 5/48.
C can do 5/48 of the work per day.
Therefore he can complete his work on 48/5 days = 9 3/5.

Amrut said:   1 decade ago
C s one day work is 5/48. But how you came to 48/5, I mean C finish job in 48/5 days. Is there any formula for this result?

Udita said:   1 decade ago
@Saquib Ali.

Please explain the following step.

Units of work in a day by a = 48x/16 = 48 units.

Tiny said:   1 decade ago
@chandrakant.

Your method is totaly wrong. When c comes in right hand side it will become negative.

Indian said:   1 decade ago
@ Ovii

Thanks for explanation, Now I understood well.


Post your comments here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.