Aptitude - Problems on Trains - Discussion

Discussion Forum : Problems on Trains - General Questions (Q.No. 22)
22.
Two goods train each 500 m long, are running in opposite directions on parallel tracks. Their speeds are 45 km/hr and 30 km/hr respectively. Find the time taken by the slower train to pass the driver of the faster one.
12 sec
24 sec
48 sec
60 sec
Answer: Option
Explanation:

Relative speed = = (45 + 30) km/hr
= ( 75 x 5 ( m/sec
18
= ( 125 ( m/sec.
6

We have to find the time taken by the slower train to pass the DRIVER of the faster train and not the complete train.

So, distance covered = Length of the slower train.

Therefore, Distance covered = 500 m.

Therefore Required time = ( 500 x 6 ( = 24 sec.
125

Discussion:
81 comments Page 2 of 9.

Adityabala said:   1 decade ago
Hi, Chandana asked why don't we add the length of the train. Well this is a common doubt everybody gets .

Now you think, both are travelling in opposite direction.

Eg:

Train1 --------------> Fastest train

<---------------Train2. Slowest train

When this is the case the train1 and train2 travel with their respective speed. There will be no collision rigth because they travel in opposite direction. So we take only one length of the train that too the train we respect to .ie here we take the slower train which is 500 mts length.

Hope you got it. Have a nice day!
(1)

Dhiru said:   1 decade ago
Both trains driver meet first then time started not before meeting

E.g

Train 1.----------> Fastest train
Train 2.       <------------ Slowest train.

If they go in the way adityabala said they will never meet. So both trains driver meet when time is ZERO or they never meet.

Pinku said:   1 decade ago
If it is 24sec, then time taken by faster train will be also 24.

But how is it possible that both are same. Not getting.

Shro said:   1 decade ago
I agree with Pinku. If this is the way to find for slower train then what if the question is asked for faster train.

Even that will come as 24sec.

Then whats the use of asking slower and faster train in question?

OR is there any other method for it?

Manohar said:   1 decade ago
Its a simple brain teasing question.

Dineshgct said:   1 decade ago
Here they have asked only the time taken by the slower train to pass the driver of the faster train and not the length of the entire faster train.
So here we need to consider only the length of the slower train ie.500.
So,
Time=500\(75*5/18)
Which is 24sec.

Rohit gupta said:   1 decade ago
Its given that they are running in opposite directions and parallel to each other. And answer is given when they are running in same directions.

Rahul said:   1 decade ago
Here length of both the trains moving opposite are same. The slower train first come across the driver of fast train. And then slow train cover its own distance to cross the driver. Now the slow train still has to cross the entire fast train.

That's why in this question we take distance as 500m i.e. length of slow train itself.

Durgesh said:   1 decade ago
Consider the driver as a pole is best one method to understand this Question. Answer is right.

Veerappan said:   1 decade ago
I accept @Durgesh, because he said well.

Faster train driver can be considered as an object like standing pole on station, slower train to pass a faster train driver is 500/75*5/18.


Post your comments here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.