Aptitude - Pipes and Cistern - Discussion

Discussion Forum : Pipes and Cistern - General Questions (Q.No. 11)
11.
One pipe can fill a tank three times as fast as another pipe. If together the two pipes can fill the tank in 36 minutes, then the slower pipe alone will be able to fill the tank in:
81 min.
108 min.
144 min.
192 min.
Answer: Option
Explanation:

Let the slower pipe alone fill the tank in x minutes.

Then, faster pipe will fill it in x minutes.
3

1 + 3 = 1
x x 36

4 = 1
x 36

x = 144 min.

Discussion:
67 comments Page 3 of 7.

Hafee said:   1 decade ago
Let it be 3x, 1x.

So, 4x = 1/36.

Then x = 144.

Prakash said:   1 decade ago
Let A be faster pipe & B be slower pipe.

We know that [b] Capacity = Work/Time [/b].

Assume the capacity of A as 3 unit/min (i.e. A pipe can fill three times more capacity than B as given in the question).

Then the capacity of B is 1 unit/min.

Total capacity (A+B) = 3+1= 4 unit/min.

If the pipes together (A+B) fill the tank in 36 min, then net work = capacity*time.

i.e Net work = 4*36 = 144 units.

Now the time taken by slower pipe B = Network/Capacity of B.

Time (B) = 144/1 = 144 min.

Similarly for A pipe = 144/3 = 48 min.

Ans: 144 min.

Suman chabri said:   1 decade ago
Thanks now I am understood.

Pranav Kumar said:   1 decade ago
I didn't understand the problem could you explain once.

Prashi said:   1 decade ago
Assume A = Fast pipe.

B = Slow pipe.

A takes x time. And B takes 3x time.

So, in 1 min 1/x + 1/3x = 1/36.

By solving 4x/3x^2 = 1/36.

Finally x = 4*36/3.

x = 48.

Time taken by slow pipe = 3x = 3*48 = 144 min.

Shan said:   1 decade ago
I am getting a different answer,

Two pipe fills the tank in 36 min.

Let's take slower one = A.

Faster one as B.

So, B = A*3.

If B+A = 36.

Then B = 27 and A = 9.

If B alone has to fill the tank then it will fill in.

27min (of B) + 9/3 of A = 27+3 = 30 min.

And if go like this and A alone has to fill the tank then it would be:

30*3 = 90 min.

Why I this is not right someone Please explain?

Pavan said:   9 years ago
Actually A=3B because A pipe fill d tank 3 times fast as B pipe.
So A=3B but in time.

Then B = A/3
Let, A= x-----(1) assume i.e B=x/3---------(2)

Formula 1/A+1/B=1/36 substitute both in
1/x+1/x/3 = 1/36,
1/x+3/x = 1/36,
4/x = 1/36.
=>x=4*36 =>144.

Jayaprakash said:   9 years ago
Great @Indrajit.

Khagendra said:   9 years ago
Most effective solution, Thanks @Laxman.

Pranathi said:   9 years ago
Thank you @Reshma.


Post your comments here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.