Verbal Reasoning - Venn Diagrams - Discussion
Discussion Forum : Venn Diagrams - Venn Diagram 1 (Q.No. 19)
Directions to Solve
Each of these questions given below contains three elements. These elements may or may not have some inter linkage. Each group of elements may fit into one of these diagrams at (A), (B), (C), (D) and/or (E). You have to indicate the group of elements which correctly fits into the diagrams.
19.
Which of the following diagrams indicates the best relation between Boys, Girls and Students ?
Answer: Option
Explanation:
Discussion:
27 comments Page 1 of 3.
Ashish Mishra said:
4 years ago
@All.
If you look closely in option C, the two inner circles are overlapping each other. So even if the bigger circle was drawn to indicate "Students" then only if they were not crossing each other, then that diagram would've been apposite.
But since the two inner circles cross each other it means that some boys are girls and some girls are boys but since no boy is a girl and no girl is a boy C is rejected and the right one is D option.
If you look closely in option C, the two inner circles are overlapping each other. So even if the bigger circle was drawn to indicate "Students" then only if they were not crossing each other, then that diagram would've been apposite.
But since the two inner circles cross each other it means that some boys are girls and some girls are boys but since no boy is a girl and no girl is a boy C is rejected and the right one is D option.
(2)
Mahish Jasrotia said:
8 years ago
As per the question, only D option fits right as no other option is true.
And those who are confused with the mid circle, The mid one is a set of students, so when we draw a relation between boys and students, it fits right. Secondly, when we talk about girl we just draw relationship b/w students and girls only neglecting the third circle as boys are contained in the set of students, we don't need to draw seperate set.
Hope that clarify.
And those who are confused with the mid circle, The mid one is a set of students, so when we draw a relation between boys and students, it fits right. Secondly, when we talk about girl we just draw relationship b/w students and girls only neglecting the third circle as boys are contained in the set of students, we don't need to draw seperate set.
Hope that clarify.
Rajneesh Kumar Thakur said:
1 decade ago
I think the answer will be D but I am not fully satisfied with the above mentioned answer figures.
Here (Students) is the Super set and (Boys) and (Girls) are sub-sets.
Both these sub-sets will be encircled inside the super set separately (Students) because (Girls) and (Boys) both are students but (Girls) cannot be (Boys) and (Boys) cannot be girls.
Here (Students) is the Super set and (Boys) and (Girls) are sub-sets.
Both these sub-sets will be encircled inside the super set separately (Students) because (Girls) and (Boys) both are students but (Girls) cannot be (Boys) and (Boys) cannot be girls.
Pramit said:
9 months ago
I think no options correctly showing the relationship between boys, girls & Student.
Because in the D option there is some part in a middle circle (student) which not fall in Boys & Girls means. There may be some students which are neither boys nor girls.
How is it possible?
Anyone please clarify this in detail.
Because in the D option there is some part in a middle circle (student) which not fall in Boys & Girls means. There may be some students which are neither boys nor girls.
How is it possible?
Anyone please clarify this in detail.
(2)
Sourav Gaonkar said:
5 years ago
D is the right answer because some boys are illiterate and some are students, similarly, some girls are illiterate and some are students, and let's face it, if no one wants to type it in here I'll do it, not all students are boys or girls.
D is probably the most accurate you could get.
D is probably the most accurate you could get.
(1)
Persia said:
7 years ago
@All.
The option C cannot be the right answer because both the circles inside the big circle intersect each others. Which means that there is some relation between boy and a girl but it's not A correct answer. So option D is the right option. Thanks.
The option C cannot be the right answer because both the circles inside the big circle intersect each others. Which means that there is some relation between boy and a girl but it's not A correct answer. So option D is the right option. Thanks.
(1)
Debu232 said:
1 decade ago
The option D is correct. Because, students refers as boys or girls, but not all the boys or girls are students.
E.g - illiterate boy or girl who never go to school or institution due to poverty.
E.g - illiterate boy or girl who never go to school or institution due to poverty.
Ankit Sethi said:
9 years ago
Hello All,
D can't be the answer.
As per my logic, the answer will be with one big Circle and inside that 2 circle which are not intersected to each other.
D can't be the answer.
As per my logic, the answer will be with one big Circle and inside that 2 circle which are not intersected to each other.
Wondergirl said:
1 decade ago
I would like to ask Mr. Sandipan what you will call a student who is neither a boy nor a girl. I don't understand how is that possible?
Krishn Ashish said:
1 decade ago
I do not agree with any option.
Option (D) seems to be most appropriate but what about the student who is neither Boys or Nor Girls.
Option (D) seems to be most appropriate but what about the student who is neither Boys or Nor Girls.
Post your comments here:
Quick links
Quantitative Aptitude
Verbal (English)
Reasoning
Programming
Interview
Placement Papers