Verbal Reasoning - Syllogism - Discussion
Discussion Forum : Syllogism - Syllogism 3 (Q.No. 9)
Directions to Solve
In each of the following questions there are three statements. Which are followed by three or four conclusions. Choose the conclusions which logically follow from the given statements.
9.
Statements: Some cars are jeeps. All the boxes are jeeps. All the pens are cars.
Conclusions:
- Some cars are boxes.
- No pen is jeep.
- Some boxes are cars.
Answer: Option
Explanation:
Discussion:
39 comments Page 3 of 4.
Pranitha said:
9 years ago
Definitely option C correct. Even from the Venn diagram, it is evident that option C is correct. Rest is all misleading.
Bhargav said:
9 years ago
According to me, the conclusion only correct.
Aakanksha said:
9 years ago
Is this a rule that the negative conclusion should be false every time?
Raghwendra said:
9 years ago
Guys, Is it true that we should see the minimum overlapping Venn diagram for a given question? i.e. is the 1st Venn diagram over here.
Rama Krishna Sambari said:
10 years ago
The answer is A.
If you consider first diagram then your answer will be 2nd conclusion and it is not given in the options.
But if you consider the second diagram and derive conclusions you will get answer as C.
The answer is A, because we have to apply the conclusions on both (all the possible diagrams) diagrams.
So, if we consider first diagram we will get 2nd conclusion satisfied, then apply the second conclusion on second diagram there it fails. Hence no conclusion satisfies. Therefore Answer is A.
If you consider first diagram then your answer will be 2nd conclusion and it is not given in the options.
But if you consider the second diagram and derive conclusions you will get answer as C.
The answer is A, because we have to apply the conclusions on both (all the possible diagrams) diagrams.
So, if we consider first diagram we will get 2nd conclusion satisfied, then apply the second conclusion on second diagram there it fails. Hence no conclusion satisfies. Therefore Answer is A.
Anil sunetra said:
10 years ago
From second figure the second option is also false. So A is the only answer.
Abc said:
1 decade ago
Only option 2 is correct. No pen is jeep holds true.
Dinesh kumar said:
1 decade ago
Yeah I'm going with @Ramakhanna. Only conclusion 2 is right. But the option is not there.
Surie said:
1 decade ago
All jeeps being cars is a possibility.
All jeeps being boxes are cars is a possibility.
All jeeps being boxes are cars is a possibility.
Sonali said:
1 decade ago
Hello ajay...as you are asking,(all Y are Z)?
It is not possible...
But (some y is z )can be a possibility..ok
Try it by drawing venn diagram... you will get it
It is not possible...
But (some y is z )can be a possibility..ok
Try it by drawing venn diagram... you will get it
Post your comments here:
Quick links
Quantitative Aptitude
Verbal (English)
Reasoning
Programming
Interview
Placement Papers