# Verbal Reasoning - Data Sufficiency - Discussion

### Discussion :: Data Sufficiency - Section 1 (Q.No.10)

In each of the questions below consists of a question and two statements numbered I and II given below it. You have to decide whether the data provided in the statements are sufficient to answer the question. Read both the statements and

• (A) If the data in statement I alone are sufficient to answer the question, while the data in statement II alone are not sufficient to answer the question
• (B) If the data in statement II alone are sufficient to answer the question, while the data in statement I alone are not sufficient to answer the question
• (C) If the data either in statement I alone or in statement II alone are sufficient to answer the question
• (D) If the data given in both statements I and II together are not sufficient to answer the question and
• (E) If the data in both statements I and II together are necessary to answer the question.

10.

Question: How is X related to Y ?

Statements:

1. Y and Z are children of D who is wife of X.
2. R's sister X is married to Ys father.

 [A]. I alone is sufficient while II alone is not sufficient [B]. II alone is sufficient while I alone is not sufficient [C]. Either I or II is sufficient [D]. Neither I nor II is sufficient [E]. Both I and II are sufficient

Explanation:

From I, we conclude that Y is the child of D who is wife of X i.e. X is Y's father.

From II, X is married to Y's father. This implies that X is Y's mother.

 Goutam Mishra said: (Sep 22, 2011) From 1st statement only we find that X is father of y but as per 2nd statement indicates X as mother of Y. This is a contradiction. How to analyze this anomaly?

 Shekhar Ghate said: (Oct 20, 2011) The correct answer is not expected only the data are sufficient or not to arrive at the answer is required. Hence doesn't matter the relation is different.

 Anuradha Chauhan said: (May 11, 2012) I statement shows that x is male person and 2 statement indicates that x is R'S SISTER means female how it can be possible.

 Anuradha Chauhan said: (May 11, 2012) Option c is correct because statement 1 is alone sufficient to specify relation and 2 statement is also sufficient alone. No matter they are indicating the different relations. or. BOTH STATEMENTS ARE SUFFICIENT INDEPENDENTLY TO GIVE ANSWER TO WHAT IS ASKED.

 Sunny said: (Apr 12, 2013) Yes, both are true, either 1 or 2 can be used, (consider both statements as separate and non relational statements) then Option C is correct.

 Janardhan said: (Dec 18, 2013) If they are considered non relational then how Y and Z are born?

 Chandra Sekar said: (Jul 22, 2014) x is father of y means what about D?

 Trishul said: (Jul 7, 2015) Is it sufficient to only find out that Y is the child of X rather than Y being son or daughter of X?

 Nit said: (Jan 7, 2017) Both defines a different relationship. Can't conclude it!

 Aravind Sai said: (Oct 24, 2020) Option D is correct because they haven't mentioned Y's gender. So, Y can be either son or daughter.