Verbal Reasoning - Blood Relation Test - Discussion
Discussion Forum : Blood Relation Test - Blood Relation 1 (Q.No. 8)
8.
If D is the brother of B, how B is related to C? To answer this question which of the statements is/are necessary?
- The son of D is the grandson of C.
- B is the sister of D.
Answer: Option
Explanation:
Given: D is the brother of B.
From statement 1, we can detect that D is son of C (son of D is the grandson of C).
From statement 2, we can detect that B is 'Female' (sister of D).
Therefore, B is daughter of C.
Discussion:
39 comments Page 2 of 4.
Rhea said:
3 years ago
No, I think it should be only 2. We need to find the relation between B and C. From 2, we come to know that B is a girl. It is sufficient to say B will be a daughter of C, irrespective of the gender of C.
(5)
Rimjhim mishra said:
3 years ago
The given answer is correct.
Because we find the relation between B and C.
So, the relation between B and C is brother and sister.
Therefore both statement is required.
Because we find the relation between B and C.
So, the relation between B and C is brother and sister.
Therefore both statement is required.
(1)
H. Bhole said:
4 years ago
The given answer is correct.
Because we find the relation between B and C.
So the relation between B and C is brother and sister.
Therefore both statement is required.
Because we find the relation between B and C.
So the relation between B and C is brother and sister.
Therefore both statement is required.
Nanda Kumar said:
4 years ago
@All.
Both statements are required for us. Without a second statement. We can't know the gender of B. Without knowing the gender. How can we related to C?
Both statements are required for us. Without a second statement. We can't know the gender of B. Without knowing the gender. How can we related to C?
(1)
Suma said:
6 years ago
How can we say like that B is the sister of D (there is no mentioning the sex of B) then how it is possible?
I think option one is the right answer.
I think option one is the right answer.
Raja ravi varma said:
7 years ago
@All.
No answer is correct. Here, it is Neither mentioned grandmother or grandfather also not mentioned maternal or paternal grandparents.
No answer is correct. Here, it is Neither mentioned grandmother or grandfather also not mentioned maternal or paternal grandparents.
Dr.satya said:
1 decade ago
Ya ya I too agree with Mr. Sundar. We must find relation between B and C.
So, the second statement also required to solve this problem.
So, the second statement also required to solve this problem.
Arvind singh said:
1 decade ago
The son of D is the grandson of C.
So, D may be son in law of C.
In this case, B is not the daughter of C.
Please reply my query.
So, D may be son in law of C.
In this case, B is not the daughter of C.
Please reply my query.
Abdul said:
9 years ago
According to me, the Correct answer is Option B.
Only 2 (B is the sister of D. ). This is required to find that B is daughter of C.
Only 2 (B is the sister of D. ). This is required to find that B is daughter of C.
Gkgs said:
9 years ago
Here B is not specified in the question, whether it is female or male. So, I think statement-2 is not necessary.
Is it right?
Is it right?
Post your comments here:
Quick links
Quantitative Aptitude
Verbal (English)
Reasoning
Programming
Interview
Placement Papers