Mechanical Engineering - Thermodynamics - Discussion

Discussion Forum : Thermodynamics - Section 1 (Q.No. 17)
17.
The efficiency of Diesel cycle approaches to Otto cycle efficiency when
cut-off is increased
cut-off is decreased
cut-off is zero
cut-off is constant
Answer: Option
Explanation:
No answer description is available. Let's discuss.
Discussion:
41 comments Page 1 of 5.

N V Katariya said:   1 year ago
The correct answer is: cut-off is decreased.

The Diesel cycle and Otto cycle are both idealized thermodynamic cycles used to model internal combustion engines. The main difference between them is the way heat is added to the system.

As the cut-off ratio (the ratio of the volume at the end of combustion to the volume at the beginning of combustion) in a Diesel cycle decreases, the cycle approaches the Otto cycle. This is because a smaller cut-off ratio means that the combustion process is more similar to the constant-volume heat addition process in the Otto cycle.

In contrast, a large cut-off ratio means that the combustion process is more similar to the constant-pressure heat addition process in the Diesel cycle. A cut-off ratio of zero would mean no heat addition and a constant cut-off ratio would not change the fundamental characteristics of the cycle.
(1)

Trulli said:   5 years ago
If you all compare both the cycle in one PV diagram. The Otto cycle highest temp meet to diesel cycle highest temp when cut off is zero. So the given answer is right.
(1)

Jithin said:   5 years ago
When cut-off is zero OR in other words cut-off ratio is one (i.e. When heat is being added at constant volume), diesel cycle approaches to Otto cycle.
(1)

Vinay said:   5 years ago
The answer is right.

Because here (Cut-off) is mention so, when cut-off will be zero then the efficiency of diesel cycle approaches to the efficiency of otto.

Where CUT-OFF and CUT-OFF RATIO both are different, If cut-off ratio is unity then the efficiency of the diesel cycle will approach to efficiency of otto cycle.

By L-HOSPITAL rule, you can prove, but for cut-off ratio.
(1)

Srikanth said:   8 years ago
In the options, they said cutoff(vol after combustion-vol before) not cutoff ratio (vol after combustion/vol before combustion).

Therefore as cutoff reaches zero it becomes constant volume process.

Ajj said:   8 years ago
If Cut off ratio equal to one.
Then efficiency diesel cycle equal to the efficiency of otto cycle.

Parmesh said:   8 years ago
It is ratios of two constant volume of decrease and increases the cp and CF or acrobatics process.

Saurabh said:   8 years ago
Answer is B.

When cutoff is decreased, diesel cycle efficiency approaches (not equal) to the otto cycle efficiency.

Subhasis Roy said:   8 years ago
No,

Here the term used "approached". Not used equal to. Understand the key.

The Answer must be cut off ratio is 0.

Many guys can think, it can be 1 then also it can be right. But, when cut off ratio is 1, the cycle will be comprised of 3 processes, which is impossible. Along with that, it will reach in the limit of 0/0 form.

Here, the Correct answer must be: When cut-off ratio is 0, the diesel cycle approached to Otto cycle.

Pradeep gk said:   8 years ago
It is ratio of volume after heat addition to volume before heat addition in diesel cycle at constant pressure.

V2/V1.


Post your comments here:

Your comments will be displayed after verification.