Logical Reasoning - Statement and Conclusion - Discussion
Discussion Forum : Statement and Conclusion - Section 2 (Q.No. 11)
Directions to Solve
In each of the following questions, a statement/group of statements is given followed by some conclusions. Without resolving anything yourself choose the conclusion which logically follows from the given statements).
11.
Every man should have his identity card with him. That card should mention his blood group, complete address and telephone number for contact, in case, some serious accident takes place.
Discussion:
37 comments Page 1 of 4.
Mansvi said:
1 decade ago
Can you please explain this more. !
Asad said:
1 decade ago
Even I cant get this according to me B is the right choice.
Meet said:
1 decade ago
Please explain.
Ankur said:
1 decade ago
This isn't right. The correct option should be B.
Gaurav Periwal said:
1 decade ago
I agree with asad. B should be the right choice because after an accident a person in certain circumstances can forget phone number.
Rohit said:
1 decade ago
According to me B seems to be the appropriate answer because it logically suits the statement and all other statement forces to take some assumption before asnswering the question, which is not allowed in the question. So, the answer might be B or the question is wrong and there should be one more option i.e. none of the above.
Dexter said:
1 decade ago
I wonder how option D is correct? If its an fatal injury like Head injuries, the person will become unconscious then how can you ask him his phone number? I feel Option B would be much appropriate.
Andrew said:
1 decade ago
Option D is not convicing according to the statement. I strongly believe that option B is the best answer.
Ankit said:
1 decade ago
I don't think so "D" is the correct answer.
How can a person remember his or her number if he is in unconscious stage!
"B" is the correct answer for this question.
How can a person remember his or her number if he is in unconscious stage!
"B" is the correct answer for this question.
Ninja_chick said:
1 decade ago
D is the correct option.
Just in case an accident occurs, then the police might need to know a person's details. Suppose a person has a concussion suddenly on the road, it isn't an accident and not exactly fatal either. Still, the police have to inform his family members so they would require an ID.
So, we can't exactly say that an ID card is necessary only when the accident is fatal. That rules out option B.
The reasoning of Option C is too retarded! (I mean who'd forget his own address unless he's an amnesiac?!) Also, we can't generalize it to everyone (in a logical sense).
Similarly, we can also rule out Options A and E since they talk about specific situations. They are true, however. Not ALL the time (like I mentioned in the concussion case, the person might not necessarily have to lose blood).
Hence, the only option left is D. And trust me, it makes the most sense as well.
Just in case an accident occurs, then the police might need to know a person's details. Suppose a person has a concussion suddenly on the road, it isn't an accident and not exactly fatal either. Still, the police have to inform his family members so they would require an ID.
So, we can't exactly say that an ID card is necessary only when the accident is fatal. That rules out option B.
The reasoning of Option C is too retarded! (I mean who'd forget his own address unless he's an amnesiac?!) Also, we can't generalize it to everyone (in a logical sense).
Similarly, we can also rule out Options A and E since they talk about specific situations. They are true, however. Not ALL the time (like I mentioned in the concussion case, the person might not necessarily have to lose blood).
Hence, the only option left is D. And trust me, it makes the most sense as well.
Post your comments here:
Quick links
Quantitative Aptitude
Verbal (English)
Reasoning
Programming
Interview
Placement Papers