Multinational Corporations: Are they Devils in Disguise?
Points to remember before you participate in this discussion:
- Assume you are one of the members of a real group discussion.
- Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.
- Contribute your positive thoughts towards providing the solution.
- Post your thoughts here.
Discussion:
124 comments Page 2 of 13.
Parag tadhani said:
1 decade ago
Hello friends,
In my point of view every coin has two sides.
Today's scenario in our country rich person get more rich, poor person still poor and middle level person is struggling for better future.
And another thing is in our country every year passed many of doctors and engineers. So, it is not possible all of get job in government organization.
Positive aspects,
- It provide better employment with handsome salaries.
- Provide better infrastructure.
- Provide better technology.
- Increase economy of the country.
- Provide better quality product at lower rate.
Negative aspects,
- MNC'S always thinking about their profit.
- It effect on employees health because of tension, completion of work before deadline.
- Prize of our rupee is decrease.
But negative aspects is reduce if government makes a rules for MNC.
Like.
- Employee do a work in MNC for particular decided hours.
- MNC also support our social work and also in charities.
Thank you.
In my point of view every coin has two sides.
Today's scenario in our country rich person get more rich, poor person still poor and middle level person is struggling for better future.
And another thing is in our country every year passed many of doctors and engineers. So, it is not possible all of get job in government organization.
Positive aspects,
- It provide better employment with handsome salaries.
- Provide better infrastructure.
- Provide better technology.
- Increase economy of the country.
- Provide better quality product at lower rate.
Negative aspects,
- MNC'S always thinking about their profit.
- It effect on employees health because of tension, completion of work before deadline.
- Prize of our rupee is decrease.
But negative aspects is reduce if government makes a rules for MNC.
Like.
- Employee do a work in MNC for particular decided hours.
- MNC also support our social work and also in charities.
Thank you.
(69)
Hitesh Sharma said:
9 years ago
Hello, everyone.
Well, I don't think at all that MNCs even closely resembles devils. The devil is our point of view when we see them as threats. They come with their share of negative but who doesn't. Everything present is this system has its merits and demerits. As someone pointed out can you imagine our nation without google, Microsoft, apple, BMW, Audi They bring in technologies our people can only dream of.
We may be ahead of them in other sectors but technology wise, we are way behind them.
For instance, assume that you only have access to products made of Indian companies. Can companies like Micromax, lava or Intex has ever offered the product which can compete with global standard products like apple iPhone has Wipro, TCS ever made an Operating System which can compete with Windows, Android or Ubuntu ?
I am not against any Indian MNCs, all I am saying is that they have a lot to learn from foreign MNCs.
So instead of thinking them as devils, they should work with them.
That's all.
Thanks.
Well, I don't think at all that MNCs even closely resembles devils. The devil is our point of view when we see them as threats. They come with their share of negative but who doesn't. Everything present is this system has its merits and demerits. As someone pointed out can you imagine our nation without google, Microsoft, apple, BMW, Audi They bring in technologies our people can only dream of.
We may be ahead of them in other sectors but technology wise, we are way behind them.
For instance, assume that you only have access to products made of Indian companies. Can companies like Micromax, lava or Intex has ever offered the product which can compete with global standard products like apple iPhone has Wipro, TCS ever made an Operating System which can compete with Windows, Android or Ubuntu ?
I am not against any Indian MNCs, all I am saying is that they have a lot to learn from foreign MNCs.
So instead of thinking them as devils, they should work with them.
That's all.
Thanks.
(69)
Rahul said:
9 years ago
Hello, friend.
India is a developed country but meanwhile, India is a most corrupted country. Also, India is a world 2nd largest population where youth is 60%. From 60% of youth, more than 30% are jobless. It's not because they are uneducated. It's because of In government job, opportunity and job vacancy are less. Also in government sector, there is reservation quota and therefore the deserved candidate did not get a job and reserved candidate gets a job.
So my dear friend MNC is good for India because MNC company gives the job to the unemployed people and also MNC company also do the project for government sector. If we work on MNC company we will learn and gain the experience and then after we can switch and we can create our own company and we will give the job opportunity to the Indian people.
"Soch Badlo, Desh Badlega".
Thankyou.
India is a developed country but meanwhile, India is a most corrupted country. Also, India is a world 2nd largest population where youth is 60%. From 60% of youth, more than 30% are jobless. It's not because they are uneducated. It's because of In government job, opportunity and job vacancy are less. Also in government sector, there is reservation quota and therefore the deserved candidate did not get a job and reserved candidate gets a job.
So my dear friend MNC is good for India because MNC company gives the job to the unemployed people and also MNC company also do the project for government sector. If we work on MNC company we will learn and gain the experience and then after we can switch and we can create our own company and we will give the job opportunity to the Indian people.
"Soch Badlo, Desh Badlega".
Thankyou.
(66)
Saurav said:
9 years ago
Hello, everyone.
First of all, we have to know that two third of our nation's software business run with countries like USA, China, Japan etc. This means that these MNC surely earn profit in a disguised manner.
According to Bill Gates if they stop taking employee from India then a new MICROSOFT will be developed in INDIA.
This means what we all Indians have that much of potentials that we can run our business of our own. We should focus that our revenue should go to our domestic market, not to other countries.
Thank you all for reading!
First of all, we have to know that two third of our nation's software business run with countries like USA, China, Japan etc. This means that these MNC surely earn profit in a disguised manner.
According to Bill Gates if they stop taking employee from India then a new MICROSOFT will be developed in INDIA.
This means what we all Indians have that much of potentials that we can run our business of our own. We should focus that our revenue should go to our domestic market, not to other countries.
Thank you all for reading!
(64)
Mukesh said:
9 years ago
Hi, friends.
I would like to add my point, MNCs are actually backbone of our country, imagine India without Amazon: the e-commerce giant, Apple, Microsoft, and many more which help in advancing our lifestyle and economy of our country although we have such giant like TCS, Flipkart, Wipro and many more but we should know how they get their start in India is only due to these MNC.
Our Indian firms have learned so many things from these MNCs and still learning in every field to speed up the profits, stability and also in technology transfer.
When Amazon entered the Indian market only then the growth of e -commerce market of Flipkart came to full flow.
Take the example of mobile markets how it grew in India in last two years, although I was only possible due to the campaign launch by Mr. Modi Goverment "MAKE IN INDIA " but some what's MNCs like Lenovo, Redime, Apple helped lots to achieve this fit of the mobile market in India.
If you go to research about our PSU company of India, you would find the lots of MNCs are working together with different PSU to overcome the different current engineering issue. Take the example of setting of the new plant of NTPC, most of the equipment is provided by MNCs firms only.
Lots of defense precise instruments are supplied to the giant's manufacturers like HAL independently my Indian micro industries and MNCs only.
I would like to add my point, MNCs are actually backbone of our country, imagine India without Amazon: the e-commerce giant, Apple, Microsoft, and many more which help in advancing our lifestyle and economy of our country although we have such giant like TCS, Flipkart, Wipro and many more but we should know how they get their start in India is only due to these MNC.
Our Indian firms have learned so many things from these MNCs and still learning in every field to speed up the profits, stability and also in technology transfer.
When Amazon entered the Indian market only then the growth of e -commerce market of Flipkart came to full flow.
Take the example of mobile markets how it grew in India in last two years, although I was only possible due to the campaign launch by Mr. Modi Goverment "MAKE IN INDIA " but some what's MNCs like Lenovo, Redime, Apple helped lots to achieve this fit of the mobile market in India.
If you go to research about our PSU company of India, you would find the lots of MNCs are working together with different PSU to overcome the different current engineering issue. Take the example of setting of the new plant of NTPC, most of the equipment is provided by MNCs firms only.
Lots of defense precise instruments are supplied to the giant's manufacturers like HAL independently my Indian micro industries and MNCs only.
(62)
Deepti dhyani said:
1 decade ago
I completely disagree with the topic. No MNC are not at all Devils. Rather they are like a hope of ray in dark night. Seeing the cut throat competition across the nation only those who get their education from big institutions are able to Crack those government jobs exams where the vacancies are very less so people getting employed at these posts get their dreams but what about other people.
Haven't they completed their GRADUATION? Aren't they capable for the job? The answer is no. Yes they are capable of doing all these things but what they don't get is the opportunity so for these students the MNC come up like a ray of hope and provide them with good job and awesome salary package. Although it's true that in MNC they make us work for huge hours but it's well said 'no pain no gain' so the more effort we put up, the more we get admired and thus get promoted same way.
One should not forget that although British Empire came into India and ruled over us but it's because of them only that we can see the huge changes in our county be it the great India museum of Kolkata, the big big building in Mumbai, metro etc were introduced by them and to them we are thankful even today. So it's not at all unfair to use manpower for work unless we are not being paid for what we are doing. So MNC are doing a great job in developing a nation regardless of its economy or where it stands.
Thank you.
Haven't they completed their GRADUATION? Aren't they capable for the job? The answer is no. Yes they are capable of doing all these things but what they don't get is the opportunity so for these students the MNC come up like a ray of hope and provide them with good job and awesome salary package. Although it's true that in MNC they make us work for huge hours but it's well said 'no pain no gain' so the more effort we put up, the more we get admired and thus get promoted same way.
One should not forget that although British Empire came into India and ruled over us but it's because of them only that we can see the huge changes in our county be it the great India museum of Kolkata, the big big building in Mumbai, metro etc were introduced by them and to them we are thankful even today. So it's not at all unfair to use manpower for work unless we are not being paid for what we are doing. So MNC are doing a great job in developing a nation regardless of its economy or where it stands.
Thank you.
(60)
Mahalakshmi said:
10 years ago
Hello everyone,
Due to globalization, economy is growing faster. MNCs are part of globalization. They invest their money and use resources of host country and make profits out of them. Those profits are taken over by MNCs to their parent countries. In the due course the host country is benefited in several ways such as employment opportunities, availability of good and services which are otherwise not available at such fair rate and quality, government getting taxes, etc.
And we should reap the benefits benefits instead of avoiding it. In order to get benefited, there should be some repatriation restrictions of profits earned by MNCs. If we are against to MNCs and FDI, we are definitely going to lose more, rupee will depreciate further, adverse balance of trade, etc.
Due to globalization, economy is growing faster. MNCs are part of globalization. They invest their money and use resources of host country and make profits out of them. Those profits are taken over by MNCs to their parent countries. In the due course the host country is benefited in several ways such as employment opportunities, availability of good and services which are otherwise not available at such fair rate and quality, government getting taxes, etc.
And we should reap the benefits benefits instead of avoiding it. In order to get benefited, there should be some repatriation restrictions of profits earned by MNCs. If we are against to MNCs and FDI, we are definitely going to lose more, rupee will depreciate further, adverse balance of trade, etc.
(57)
Shantanu Ghosal said:
1 decade ago
Hi Friends.
Firms which have presence in many nations can be roughly termed as MNC's.
These are usually big corporations with vast area of work. They usually provide high salary to their employs, better living standard and a better shot at constantly improving in their life.
However they are often blamed for extracting too much work at all costs, violating human rights, spreading western culture and blah blah.
But still the horde of people to enter into MNC's is not decreasing rather increasing. This trend itself speaks that people are very much dissatisfied with the domestic companies which treat their employees even worse and pay lesser salaries with narrower growth prospects. So before blaming the MNC's we must look into our own economy and industries.
A foreign company when enters a country set up its working rules according to the laws and regulation of the government and also by gauging the mood of the society. And we Indians are from the very onset of our school education are over-worked. Being over-worked has become a part and parcel of Indian society and the MNC's just try to cash on our very tradition. And yet we think that they are the culprits.
Firms which have presence in many nations can be roughly termed as MNC's.
These are usually big corporations with vast area of work. They usually provide high salary to their employs, better living standard and a better shot at constantly improving in their life.
However they are often blamed for extracting too much work at all costs, violating human rights, spreading western culture and blah blah.
But still the horde of people to enter into MNC's is not decreasing rather increasing. This trend itself speaks that people are very much dissatisfied with the domestic companies which treat their employees even worse and pay lesser salaries with narrower growth prospects. So before blaming the MNC's we must look into our own economy and industries.
A foreign company when enters a country set up its working rules according to the laws and regulation of the government and also by gauging the mood of the society. And we Indians are from the very onset of our school education are over-worked. Being over-worked has become a part and parcel of Indian society and the MNC's just try to cash on our very tradition. And yet we think that they are the culprits.
(56)
Hari said:
9 years ago
MNC's are not Devils in Disguise.
Advantages:
1) By having MNC's in a country, can have more international exposure and to the technology.
2) After working in MNC's many gain experience and establishes startups.
3) Due to mnc's a countries economy can be improved through fdi.
Disadvantages:
1) Skilled workers are more interested working in MNC's.
2) MNC's are threat to the local business of the same type.
Advantages:
1) By having MNC's in a country, can have more international exposure and to the technology.
2) After working in MNC's many gain experience and establishes startups.
3) Due to mnc's a countries economy can be improved through fdi.
Disadvantages:
1) Skilled workers are more interested working in MNC's.
2) MNC's are threat to the local business of the same type.
(55)
Akanksha Nigam said:
9 years ago
Hello,
I believe that MNC's are doing a great job for the Indians when it comes to a point of employment. No doubt these companies are providing employment to many our Indian youths by which so many people in our country are employed and I believe that we should be thankful to them as because they are providing a great environment to work for an employee as well. We all know that when it comes to professionalism MNC's companies have a good platform to learn it which we Indian must learn to grow. Not only we are employed also we are encouraged by them but also many of our Indians are in a very good designation because of their talent. When it comes to talent Indians always prove their best.
I also believe that many of the small-scale industries are affected because of these MNC's but I wanted to say that to avoid this fact; we need to support Indians products too. Why we can't make in India and why we won't support Indian products when they are making in India. I've seen many people want foreign products to be used as they believe that only foreign products can provide the society status.
Indian always prove their talent Internationally not only in this era also if we go back we can see that we Indians are very talented in every aspect and foreign countries understand and appreciate us. We all have business mind but we didn't get support from us in India only.
I'm sorry to say that Indians are not recognized and also not valued by Indians only when it comes to believing the talent and quality and that is the main reason small scale industries didn't get recognition and not standing in front of MNC's.
I want to say that if we really want to be a developed country we not only to be an entrepreneur but also we trust each other quality and talent and our qualities should be recognized internationally.
To clear it I wanted to say an example of "iPhone" we all wants an iPhone due to the quality of it why we Indian can't make such quality product and a brand which should be recognized internationally and get benefits of it. To answer this the question I must say our Indians are that much talented that they can make more good and best product which can become International brand but where we are losing is that we don't get recognition by us that is the reason our Indian small scale companies are lacking and somehow Indian company are not standing to the International market.
I did a research and find that to grow every individual needs to have his its own business but when it comes to many Indian I'm sorry to say we just wanted to work for an MNC's by which we would be recognized in the society. Do we really need to have such kind of recognition?
I believe that we should take a step and grow through our own thought. We've history that there are many people in past who think different and grow in India with their talent and business mind.
We should be a business minded and not to be stuck at a single company with the A.C. rooms to the rest of their life. I believe that sweat needs to come out from every individual and I want to request to everyone that please believe on Indians product and make them a huge brand.
Thank you for reading this.
I hope and wish that one day we will be able to stand our business to other country and provide employments to their country people.
I believe that MNC's are doing a great job for the Indians when it comes to a point of employment. No doubt these companies are providing employment to many our Indian youths by which so many people in our country are employed and I believe that we should be thankful to them as because they are providing a great environment to work for an employee as well. We all know that when it comes to professionalism MNC's companies have a good platform to learn it which we Indian must learn to grow. Not only we are employed also we are encouraged by them but also many of our Indians are in a very good designation because of their talent. When it comes to talent Indians always prove their best.
I also believe that many of the small-scale industries are affected because of these MNC's but I wanted to say that to avoid this fact; we need to support Indians products too. Why we can't make in India and why we won't support Indian products when they are making in India. I've seen many people want foreign products to be used as they believe that only foreign products can provide the society status.
Indian always prove their talent Internationally not only in this era also if we go back we can see that we Indians are very talented in every aspect and foreign countries understand and appreciate us. We all have business mind but we didn't get support from us in India only.
I'm sorry to say that Indians are not recognized and also not valued by Indians only when it comes to believing the talent and quality and that is the main reason small scale industries didn't get recognition and not standing in front of MNC's.
I want to say that if we really want to be a developed country we not only to be an entrepreneur but also we trust each other quality and talent and our qualities should be recognized internationally.
To clear it I wanted to say an example of "iPhone" we all wants an iPhone due to the quality of it why we Indian can't make such quality product and a brand which should be recognized internationally and get benefits of it. To answer this the question I must say our Indians are that much talented that they can make more good and best product which can become International brand but where we are losing is that we don't get recognition by us that is the reason our Indian small scale companies are lacking and somehow Indian company are not standing to the International market.
I did a research and find that to grow every individual needs to have his its own business but when it comes to many Indian I'm sorry to say we just wanted to work for an MNC's by which we would be recognized in the society. Do we really need to have such kind of recognition?
I believe that we should take a step and grow through our own thought. We've history that there are many people in past who think different and grow in India with their talent and business mind.
We should be a business minded and not to be stuck at a single company with the A.C. rooms to the rest of their life. I believe that sweat needs to come out from every individual and I want to request to everyone that please believe on Indians product and make them a huge brand.
Thank you for reading this.
I hope and wish that one day we will be able to stand our business to other country and provide employments to their country people.
(53)
Post your thoughts here:
Quick links
Quantitative Aptitude
Verbal (English)
Reasoning
Programming
Interview
Placement Papers